Brandon Beylo Profile picture
Jul 11, 2023 21 tweets 8 min read Read on X
The IEA just released its Critical Mineral Market Review 2023.

The report provides valuable insights into the large and rapidly growing Critical Minerals Market.

A MUST-READ for metals investors.

Here's a thread on the most important things I learned from the report ... 🧵
1/ Why You Should Care About Critical Minerals

• Green energy tech is propelling demand growth of critical minerals

• Critical Minerals market size has doubled over past 5yrs to $320B

• Success of green movement hinges on critical mineral supply

• Geopolitical importance
2/ Clean Energy Driving Demand Growth

Renewable energy technologies like Solar PV, Wind, and EVs are driving Critical Mineral Demand.

Check out the YoY demand growth expectations:

• Solar PV: +30%

• Wind: +70%

• EVs: +30%
3/ Green Energy Shifts Demand For Key Minerals

One interesting aspect of green energy is that it creates more demand on top of a metal's existing demand function.

For example, in 2017, only 30% of lithium demand went to clean energy.

By 2022, it was 56%.

Other metals 👇
4/ Clean Energy Expands Mineral Markets

The market size for energy transition minerals doubled over the past five years (2017-2022):

• Copper: 1.5x

• Lithium: 6.5x

• Nickel: 3.1x

• Cobalt: 1.9x

• Rare Earths (REEs): 2.5x

This is just the beginning.
5/ Metals Prices: Higher For Longer

Metals prices went ballistic in 2021-2022. This year, they're pulling back hard, and mining stocks are down 50-80%+.

However, thanks to energy transition demand, metals prices should stay higher for longer.

New normals > prior ranges.
6/ Capital Is Starting To Flow Into Metals

Critical Mineral Mining Investment rose by 30% in 2022.

The investments spread across:

• Diversified majors (like $GLEN, $TECK, $BHP)

• Focused players ($CODELCO, $SCCO)

• Lithium ($SQM, $PLS)

This is a good sign!
7/ Mining Majors Still More Conservative

Diversified Majors still have PTSD from the past metals cycle.

They're reinvesting at a ~25% rate, which most of the reinvestment coming from cash from operations (versus debt/equity).

Majors still favor dividends/buybacks over capex.
8/ Exploration Budgets Trending Higher

Exploration budgets increased by ~$1B from 2021 and ended at ~$6B in 2022.

~$3B of that exploration was spent on #Copper.

Unfortunately, increased exploration has yielded little (if any) major discoveries at high grades.
9/ Copper Dominates M&A Activity

M&A activity is down to ~$22B in 2022 versus ~$37B in 2021.

$20B of the $22B M&A in 2022 went to #copper deals.

In other words, the big players know what's coming in copper, and they see the impending supply/demand crunch.
10/ Consumers Want Bigger EVs

Consumers want larger EVs, which require larger EV batteries.

This consumer preference increases metals requirement in both the EV and the EV battery.

People want EV SUVs.
11/ EV Manufacturers Are Securing Upstream Supply

We're seeing a large increase in EV manufacturer JVs and long-term offtake agreements.

Whether it's $TSLA trying to buy $SGML or Stellantis investing in copper mines.

The signal: Metals are scarce, we want to secure them.
12/ Production Trends For Copper & Lithium

We saw a 4% growth in mined copper production in 2022 and a 3% expected increase for 2023.

Refined #copper production also increased by 3%.

Lithium production increased by 38% with an expected 32% production increase in 2023.
13/ Production Trends For Nickel & Cobalt

Mined #nickel increased by 18% in 2022 with a 14% increase expected in 2023.

Mined #cobalt increased by 23% in 2022 and is expected to increase by 17% in 2023.

Indonesia is now the world's leading nickel producer.

DRC leads cobalt.
14/ Production Trends For Graphite & Rare Earths

Natural graphite production increased by 11% in 2022.

Mined Magnet REE production increased by 11% in 2022.

China is the global leader in both graphite and REE production.

This WILL become a geopolitical issue.
15/ Critical Mineral Demand Set To Explode

If we get anywhere close to Net Zero by 2050, critical mineral demand will explode higher than we can imagine.

The obvious reality is that supply cannot keep up with demand growth due to:

• Grades
• ESG
• Permitting
• Water

16/ Anticipated Primary Production By 2030

Look at the gaps between "Anticipated Supply" and "Net Zero Emissions."

It is not even close for #Copper, #Lithium, #Nickel, and #Cobalt.

Only problem w/ Lithium is that there's so much gov't spending there = more competitive
17/ We Need To Diversify Processing & Extraction

We're entering Metallic Nationalism where countries stockpile valuable resources to produce higher value finished goods.

China dominates Graphite/REE production and nearly ALL Critical Mineral Processing.

Could get wild.
18/ Where To Learn More

Interested in learning more?

There are a few ways you can learn more about Critical Minerals/Metals.

• Follow me on Twitter!

• Listen to my podcast:

• Read the original report: https://t.co/WG5iu9Gejdtinyurl.com/5n6d6hcc
tinyurl.com/43eda5fk
19/ Conclusion

I hope you enjoyed this thread on the IEA Critical Minerals Review 2023.

Here are the key points:

• Clean energy requires tons of Critical Minerals

• Supply cannot match demand growth

• China dominates production/processing

• REE demand will explode

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Brandon Beylo

Brandon Beylo Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @marketplunger1

Feb 13, 2024
Peter Cundill is one of the most consistent value investors ever.

His Value Fund generated a 15% CAGR over 33 years. Turning $100 into $10,000.

He followed in Ben Graham's footsteps but carved his own path.

Here are six of Cundill's most important investing lessons ... 🧵 Image
Lesson 1: Be A Global Investor

Cundill was Canadian but invested globally.

He believed, like Peter Lynch, that whomever turns over the most rocks will win the game.

The wider you cast your net, the greater the odds of finding extreme value.

That is very true today.
Lesson 2: Buy Hidden Asset Plays

Cundill demanded a strong balance sheet with high asset values.

He also loved hidden assets.

For example, he bought Tiffany's in '74 because it held its diamonds and real estate at historical cost. Which vastly understated its current value.Image
Read 8 tweets
Jan 19, 2024
Allan Mecham is one of the best value investors out there.

He's generated a ~37% CAGR since 2008 while operating as a one-man shop above a taco store.

I read all his shareholder letters to find the Five Key Lessons from Mecham's philosophy.

Enjoy 👇
macro-ops.com/five-invaluabl…
Lesson 1: Less (Not More) Information is Better

Edge is found in clear thinking/uncluttered mind.

Our brains only have so much decision making power capacity each day.

The less information you consume the more time you have to ponder the few critical bits that really matter.Image
Lesson 2: Selling Great Biz Is Almost Always A Mistake

It's tough to find a great business.

It's even more difficult to not sell that great business once you find it.

Mecham found Autozone $AZO & made it 18% of his fund. Yet he still sold it.

Lesson? It was a mistake.Image
Read 7 tweets
Sep 14, 2023
One of the best ways to learn about the Copper Industry is by studying the Top 10 Global Producers.

I read each of the Top 10 #Copper Producer Q2 2023 reports so you don't have to.

Here's a thread on the most important data and themes from the world's largest players ... 🧵 Image
1/ Codelco $CODELCO

• Copper Production DOWN 12.6% to 685kt

• Cash Costs UP 42% to $2.13/lb

• Reasons for Product Decline: Weather, lower grades, reduced mineral processing

• Reasons for High Cash Costs: Lower production, higher opex (labor + energy) Image
2/ Freeport-McMoran $FCX

• Copper Production DOWN 5% to 1,029Mlbs

• Cash Costs UP 4% to $1.47

• Reasons for Product Decline: Lower grades/production, weather

• Reasons for High Cash Costs: Lower production, increase in operating costs (labor, fuel, etc.) Image
Read 14 tweets
Aug 17, 2023
Goehring & Rozencwajg Investor Letters are a MUST-READ for any Natural Resource Investor.

They cover everything from oil to natural gas, base and precious metals, and agriculture.

Here's a thread on the most important insights from their Q2 2023 Investor Letter ... 🧵 Image
1/ Upcoming Gold Bull Market: How High Will It Go?

G&R believe gold is radically undervalued today.

"Gold, relative to the size of the Fed’s balance sheet, is more undervalued today than in the
late 1960s or 1990s."

How high could gold go?

G&R see $14,000-$32,000/oz!
Image
Image
2/ The Uranium Bull: Defying Trends & Redefining Energy Markets

Over the past 12M, every energy commodity has declined EXCEPT for Uranium.

"Our models suggest Uranium's strong performance has just started."

G&R explain why Uranium is entering its fifth "Bull Period." Cont... Image
Read 15 tweets
Jul 5, 2023
The Value Hive Podcast Energy / Oil Thread

I've spent most of this year studying Energy and Oil.

Part of that process was interviewing some of the smartest people in the industry to pick their brains.

Here's a thread on every Energy & Oil Value Hive Podcast this year ... 👇 https://t.co/7H1fhofmPYtwitter.com/i/web/status/1…
January 27: Oil & Gas Crash Course w/ @Rory_Johnston

We discussed:

• Oil's volatile history

• Shale oil history

• Oilfied services

• Inventories, supply curves, and futures curves

Listen here: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/ror…
February 17: Busting ESG Myths w/ @BrianGitt

Brian was a fantastic guest. He busted myths of ESG investing and energy practices.

We also discussed:

• Why we shouldn't demonize fossil fuels

• Energy and national security

• Uranium

Listen here: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/bri…
Read 13 tweets
May 25, 2023
In 2021 Citi created a new framework for analyzing Copper balances/prices.

Enter: The Call on Scrap Model

The Model focuses on the required scrap to balance the Cu market.

It has strong positive correlation w/ Cu prices!

Here's a thread on the model and how to use it ... 🧵 Image
1/ The Math Behind The Model

Let's start with the mathematical model.

Equilibrium is: D = mS + eolsS

Where:

• D = Demand

• mS = Mine Supply

• eolsS = End of Life Scrap

We can rewrite the equation so that: D - mS = eolsS (aka Call on Scrap)

Thus ...

CoS = eolsS Image
2/ Key Observations From "Call On Scrap" Pricing Dynamics

• When consumption increases relative to mine supply, PRICE needs to rise up the EoL scrap cost curve to incentivize scrap supply response.

• When Call on Scrap > Scrap Supply, market is in deficit & needs higher price Image
Read 13 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(