Did you know The Last Samurai is based on a true story?
A thread on the incredible life & adventures of the real “Last Samurai;” Jules Brunet.
Jules Brunet was born in Alsace, France in 1838. His father was a veterinary doctor in the army. Jules followed in his father’s footsteps & joined the French Army in 1855, attending the prestigious Saint-Cyr & École Polytechnique.
Although a middling student, Jules excelled at his training as an artilleryman, graduating fourth in his class. Soon after graduating from his artillery course in 1861 he was sent to the war in Mexico. Jules served with distinction as a sub-Lieutenant in the mounted artillery.
Jules fought with valor at the Siege of Puebla & was recognized with the Cross of the Légion d’honneur. In 1866, France resolved to send advisors to the Shogun to modernize his army. Jules was an obvious choice as the artillery advisor with his impressive academic & combat record
Jules expressed his “most great desire” to participate & at 28 was the mission’s youngest officer. Jules & the French Mission arrived in January 1867 & spent a year training the Japanese military. Japan only recently reopened to the world after centuries of self-imposed isolation
The army that welcomed Jules was still dominated by the Samurai. Although muskets now prevailed, the Shogunate’s equipment was seriously antiquated. Katanas were still ubiquitous & matchlocks, even pikes and bows, were not unheard of among the more traditional groups of warriors.
The French quickly began training an elite force for the Shogun. This was called the Denshūtai & was composed of 800 men in French-style uniforms & equipped with state-of-the-art equipment. This formation was intended to train & augment the Shogun’s less-modernized troops.
Western arms were flooding into Japan as clans & rivals jockeyed for power & Western governments vied for influence. Breech-loading artillery, modern rifles, & Gatling Guns soon made their way into the arsenals of Japanese warbands & the Imperial Army.
Jules’ knowledge of artillery gained the trust & confidence of the Shogun’s men. Jules himself became attached to the Samurai & their Bushido code. After a year with the Samurai, Jules felt bound to his new brothers in arms, especially as power struggles reached a fever pitch.
Japan’s forced entry into the modern world wasn’t easy. Many groups saw modernization as a way to grab more power, while others saw the changes as a threat to their way of life & political control. The struggle between the now-symbolic emperor & Shogun concentrated these forces.
Tension broke into open warfare in January 1868 when the 15 year old Emperor Meiji, supported by Choshu & Satsuma forces, declared his restoration to full power & resignation of the Shogun; Tokugawa Yoshinobi. Skirmishes broke out in & around Tokyo.
Jules marched with the Shogun’s army to Kyoto, where they planned to protest the Shogun & his supporters’ fall from power. They were met near Toba & Fushimi by the forces of Choshu & Satsuma. The Shogun’s 15,000 men outnumbered the opposing forces 3:1.
However, the Choshu & Satsuma forces had modern weapons; many of the Shogun’s men still used muskets & even the traditional katanas & pikes of the Samurai. As the battle progressed, the Shogun’s forces were devastated by the accurate rifle & artillery fire of the imperials.
Defections also hampered the Shogun’s forces, and although casualties were fairly light, the Shogun’s retreat convinced many to throw in their lot with the Emperor. Jules & the men he trained were present at the battle & he followed the Shogun’s admiral, Enomoto, to Tokyo.
The Imperial forces surrounded Tokyo & crushed the forces of the Shogun, who surrendered & retired in disgrace. The Emperor ordered the French military advisors to leave the country, due to their role in training the Shogun’s men. Jules refused & resigned from the French military
Knowing his actions would be deemed treasonous or insane he wrote to Emperor Napoleon III, “A revolution is forcing the Military Mission to return...The Daimyos of the North have offered me to be its soul. I have accepted… I can direct the 50,000 men of the confederation.”
Jules went to Sendai where their forces were regrouping. The army here was more numerous than their imperial foes but woefully under-equipped. The fighting was fierce & the Shogunate fought desperately; building wood & rope cannons to fire stone projectiles.
In the end, the mechanical efficiency of modern weaponry proved too strong & Sendai fell.
Jules, ever-faithful, went with the shattered remnants of the army to Hokkaido. Led by Enomoto, the Shogunate forces formed a government, the Republic of Ezo, on the island.
Ezo was based off the American model & Japan’s only republic in its storied history. Jules took the role of its Foreign Minister & second-in-command of its army. Jules made contact with foreign governments, seeking recognition & aid. Ezo’s army had been divided into four brigades
Each were commanded by a Frenchman. Two others, Collache & Nichol, were in charge of fortifying southern Hokkaido & the Navy. By Spring 1869, Imperial naval forces had defeated the Ezo’s depleted navy and landed 7,000 soldiers on Hokkaido to oppose Ezo’s 3,000 men.
Over the course of several months the Imperials ground down Ezo’s defenses around Hakodate. Just before Enomoto offered his surrender, the French soldiers escaped the Imperial besiegers and boarded a French naval vessel in Hakodate Bay.
Ezo had lost close to half their men & most of their ships by the time they had surrendered on June 27th. The Japanese government demanded Jules & his comrades be punished; however, his actions had gained widespread approval in France & the request was denied.
Jules rejoined the French Army with a slight reduction in rank after a six month suspension. Jules went on to serve during the Franco-Prussian War with distinction & rose through the ranks of the French army in the following decades.
Jules’ friend, Enomoto later became the Minister of the Imperial Navy & through his influence Jules was rehabilitated in Japan & showered with awards.
Jules’ career of high adventure, bravery, & boldness are hardly captured by the Last Samurai. To see a Frenchman in his bright uniform commanding a battery of Samurai with their rope & wood cannons is a sight that goes to show history is stranger, more fascinating, than fiction.
“Three centuries before, it was the Goths who had been a turbulent unruly aristocracy, ruling a nation of serfs, and the Saracen had swept their monarchy off the face of the earth in two years. Now the Moslem had become even as his Gothic predecessor…
Luxurious, proud, untrue to his king, a hard master to the peasantry who paid him toll and tribute. Religious persecution was not rare, & Andalusia could count many martyrs; the accusation of having blasphemed the name of Mohammed always stirred the Moslem crowd to sudden cruelty
Victims of all ages and conditions, from an archbishop of Toledo down to obscure monks and trades folk, suffered on that charge.
Within a few years Islam seemed destined to absorb Iberia…
However, one holdout remained in the mountains of the North. The survival of Christian Iberia fell to a few warriors. Or, as the Muslims described them; “30 wild donkeys.”
In the preceding decades the armies of Islam had swept across North Africa meeting little resistance. The Amazigh population readily adopted this new faith, the Bedouin ethos meshing well with that of the hill tribes of the Atlas Mountains & herders of the scrublands.
Amazigh pirates had frequently raided the southern coast of Visigothic Iberia, now an ailing polity riven by civil war & suffering from decadence. The ever-expansionist armies of the Umayyads saw a rich land ripe for conquest.
The Byzantine Empire experienced both eddying heights & devastating catastrophes in the 11th century, what is the reason for this?
The inability to solve the security predicament of their geopolitical situation.
Was this rise & fall inevitable or could it have been prevented?
With the fading of Arab raids in the 10th century, the Byzantines conquered the Muslim Emirates near their borders. This was a strategic imperative to make the core of the empire safe & now possible with the breakdown of the Caliphate.
Early attempts were slow & produced mixed results until Nikephoros Phokas ramped up the professionalization of the military, making it more suited for offensive action. Results were immediate & Nikephoros swept aside all the remaining Emirates that had preyed on the Byzantines.
Some criticize the Byzantine Empire for failing to “Romanize” the lands it conquered from 934-1045 AD. However, there simply weren’t enough “Romans.” Arab depredations during the preceding 300 years had depopulated much of Anatolia.
People first came down from their troglodyte villages & resettled the productive plains. Some paleoenvironmental evidence is now emerging regarding this process in Cappadocia specifically. journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.117…
Armenians, their mountainous homelands unable to support them, moved thickly into Melitene & Cilicia. After Manzikert an Armenian Kingdom survived in the latter, a testimony to their numbers there.
A poignant excerpt from Toynbee; the haughty exploits of the conqueror often weaken his power & his bloody acts are repaid in kind by other peoples.
Toynbee mentions that many of those under the Assyrian yoke survived better than their erstwhile masters. Shelley’s Ozymandias really captures the desolate remains of this vanished empire.
…reached the stiff & menacing figure & sent it clattering & crashing down the moraine of ruined brickwork into the fosse below, they did not suspect that their terrible adversary was no longer a living man at the moment when they struck their daring, & apparently decisive, blow.
A generation after the disaster at Pliska, war again loomed over the Haemus Mountains.
During these preparations a secret embassy arrived in the capital, imploring Emperor Theophilos for his help.
The Emperor accepted & initiated one of the greatest rescue missions in history.
After crushing the Byzantines at Pliska, killing Emperor Nikephoros I, & famously turning his skull into a chalice, Khan Krum extended his Empire south into Byzantine territory. Integrating these Byzantines into the Bulgarian state was a key priority for the Khan.
Many of these populations & their leaders were allowed to maintain their posts & homes in the borderlands; however, Krum’s successors became uneasy with this arrangement. They felt these populations might serve as a fifth column for any Byzantine counterattacks.