Crémieux Profile picture
Aug 23 17 tweets 6 min read Twitter logo Read on Twitter
One of the best pieces every published in The Atlantic is this 97-year-old piece by "A Woman Resident in Russia".

In it, she described the chaos that resulted when Communists destroyed the institution of marriage.

Let's read about what happened when Soviets ruined marriage🧵
"To clear the family out of the accumulated dust of the ages we had to give it a good shakeup, and we did."

Russia boasted it had no illegitimate children. True. They eliminated the "illegitimate" category. Image
"Men took to changing wives" and 300,000 abandoned children resulted. Image
"It was not... unusual... for a boy of twenty to have had three or four wives, or for a girl of the same age to have had three or four abortions." Image
"I recall another victim of the breakdown of families ties.... She was divorced by her husband after their first child was born. He then married another woman, had a child by her, deserted both, and returned to his first wife, by whom he had a second child." Image
Not all women suffered from the breakdown. Some exploited it.

"Women of light behavior" would blackmail men into paying alimony. Image
Some men found ways to profit from this as well.

They would trick a woman into marriage, use her as an employee on the farm, and then divorce her when the season was through. Image
It wasn't just rural areas that buckled under the effects of marriage dissolution.

One group of students became indignant at accusations of licentiousness and declared that having sex was the only real amusement left, so they deserved free abortions. Image
Some chapters of the League of Communist Youth decried people who wouldn't do hook-ups and even organized circles to encourage free loving. Image
The Communists were ideologically committed to the idea that the state should rear the children.

This proved too expensive, so this "annoying test of Communist theories" could be given a failing grade. Image
The debates over a new, free-love abiding law took place in the Tsar's throneroom, with its gilded walls and vaulted ceilings, and the throne, replaced with a simple wooden platform. Image
The opposition to the law suggested it would abolish marriage, destroy the family, legalize polygamy, and ruin the peasantry.

Trotsky and Soltz offered contradictory explanations for their positions. Image
Smidovich and Kollontai provided their own opinions as well.

Kollontai wanted a social insurance scheme, like a sovereign fund for abandoned kids. Incidentally, she was the ambassador to Norway. Image
"If opinion on the proposed law is divided in the cities, the feeling in the villages, where eighty per cent of the Russians live, is overwhelmingly against it."

Here's what one peasant spokesman had to say: Image
"The... circulation of revolutionary ideas on the desirability of abolishing the family has not... eliminated old-fashioned passions of love and jealousy."

"Even Communist women have been known to commit suicide because their husbands' attentions were diverted elsewhere." Image
The Soviets eventually did crack down. Free love could not last, and this brief experiment in it led them to abandon attempts to bring it about.

The Communists simply couldn't uproot human nature.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Crémieux

Crémieux Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @cremieuxrecueil

Aug 12
This is what peak performance looks like

on various Wechsler IQ subtests, by age.

The medians here indicate the ages where the median person reaches their highest performance level in various cognitive tasks.

Here are some brief notes on cognitive aging. Image
For many tasks, performance declines kick in early and they happen gracefully across the adult lifespan. Image
Sometimes this sort of data is misleading, because age impacts sampling, so there do appear to be differences between longitudinal and cross-sectional results.

Though the differences aren't too large, they can help to explain old-age variance increases. Image
Read 8 tweets
Aug 3
Let's discuss the gender wage gap.

You may have heard that most of the gap is due to the "child penalty" women face after they give birth. Across the developed world, that is increasingly true.

Let's look at this with some great Austrian data.

First: the gap since the 1950s. Image
When mothers give birth, they suffer a large penalty to earnings and employment.

Some have suggested a way to reduce this penalty is to expand paid parental leave. If there's longer parental leave, what happens?

Well, not much. If anything, leave policies may worsen penalties. Image
What about when parental leave policies are changed from very little (2 months) to something substantial (12 months)?

Again, the effect is not very large relative to the initial child penalty itself and it may be harmful because it cuts into female labor supply. Image
Read 10 tweets
Jul 21
What's CNN talking about? I went to the source to find out.

This is the finding their story refers to: https://t.co/wG82dkFPJN
Image
The research was little more than correlating metropolitan statistical area (MSA) level variables with the # of mass shooting events (MSEs) that took place in them.

Here's their correlation matrix. What stands out?

Note: population size only correlated at 0.45 with # of MSEs. Image
The analysis culminated in a linear regression.

After their variable selection was completed, they were left with three predictors: Black percentage of MSA, an index of segregation, and the income Gini (inequality).

Only the Black percentage predicted the number of MSEs. Image
Read 5 tweets
Jul 18
Is American society irredeemably racist against Blacks?

One way to test this is to check if businesses are harmed when their owners are identified as Black people. If society is racist, they should lose clientele.

A new preprint used Yelp's Black-owned business label to test: Image
Businesses labeled as Black-owned received 36% more page views, 52% more website views, 71% more calls, 34% more orders, and 36% more revenue.

This effect was observed for

- Businesses that claimed they were Black-owned
- Businesses where reviewers noted they were Black-owned Image
This wasn't observed when the business was Black-owned but didn't identify as such: the effect was not driven by something that impacted all Black businesses regardless of label.

Comparing early and late adopters showed an effect on both. Time-varying effects aren't on the menu. Image
Read 10 tweets
Jul 17
Today marks four months of Twitter! Thanks to all 26,500 of you for following me.

Here's a thread of the last month's posts!
Residential housing does not seem to improve recidivism. This may be due to heterogeneous effects across types of crimes.

Gender dysphoria diagnoses have greatly increased over time, and as they have, the age of diagnosis has gotten younger. Also, girls have a younger age of diagnosis than boys.

Read 95 tweets
Jul 15
When We Get Back Home was a humorous Japanese occupation-era comic series depicting what American soldiers would do when they returned from their time in Japan.

The series is an excellent glimpse into how Americans viewed Japan.

Here's a thread of some of my favorite panels. https://t.co/haElba6prxtwitter.com/i/web/status/1…
Image
You have to start with the intro: the GI comes home and he speaks sayonara, wears geta on his feet, and carries a wagasa to avoid the sun and rain.

The author, Bill Hume, described this as "He has become definitely and deliriously Asiatic." Image
The wives just don't get it. Image
Read 33 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(