1/ Last night's highly successful Ukrainian attack against a drydock in Sevastopol appears to have caused significant damage to a Kilo-class submarine, the Rostov-on-Don (B-237), as well as to a Ropucha-class landing ship.
2/ Ian Matveev has written a useful thread explaining why this is so significant and why the submarine may have been the principal intended target. Translation follows below. ⬇️
By @ian_matveev:
Which submarine was attacked in Sevastopol?
3/ It is reported to be the Rostov-on-Don, Project 636.3 "Varshavyanka", a multipurpose diesel submarine with Kalibr missiles. Let me tell you more about it in a short thread.
4/ Project 636 "Varshavyanka", known as 'Improved Kilo' according to NATO classification, is the export version of Project 877 "Paltus" [the original Soviet designation for the Kilo-class vessels – Project 636.3 is a further improvement from the mid-2010s]. (Pic by @CovertShores)
5/ Together they make up the Russian Navy's fleet of 20 diesel multipurpose submarines. There are 7 such boats in the Black Sea Fleet.
6/ One of them was spotted in a dry dock next to a Project 775 landing ship – which was attacked this night and badly damaged. Perhaps the real target was the submarine – I will explain why below. (Photo published by @DefMon3)
7/ As the name suggests, the Varshavyankas [named after a Polish revolutionary song, 'Warszawianka'] were built for the Warsaw Pact countries, but then something happened. Some of them went to China, the rest stayed at home and are still being built.
8/ Despite their age (the project began in the late 1970s), the boats look very competitive and strong in their class.
9/ They provide the same 20 knots (40 km/h) underwater speed as the German 214 and Chinese 041, but have a much larger underwater displacement of almost 4,000 tons. However, the endurance of the German submarine is half as much - 45 days against more than 80.
10/ But for local theatres like the Black Sea, endurance does not play a significant role. On the other hand, Varshavyankas are considered to be extremely undetectable, due to special engine operating modes. Among the major operators are China, India and Vietnam.
11/ The armanent is the standard torpedo tubes of 533 mm calibre and 18 torpedoes. But in addition to that, which is much more important now, they carry Kalibr missiles, which are launched from the same torpedo tubes.
12/ These photos show the process of loading Kalibr-PL missiles onto a submarine through torpedo tubes. An important point is the possibility of launching from an underwater position. The missiles can be both anti-ship and anti-submarine, and 3M14(E) - for attacking land targets.
13/ Project 636.3 submarines have already launched Kalibrs at Ukrainian territory. The country's authorities suspect that the 14 July strike on Vinnitsa was launched from a submarine. This video shows one of the submarine launches in the Black Sea.
14/ Here is another video – also apparently with an underwater launch.
15/ Therefore, the most likely target of today's strike was the cruise missile carrier. The submarine was conveniently docked, where it was easier to cause damage, although it was impossible to sink.
16/ However, I think even a serious fire and damage to the hull will lead to a long repair or even total disablement.
17/ We can assume that the Ukrainian military has begun a full-fledged hunt for the Kalibr naval carriers; they also wrote about an attempt to use naval kamikaze drones to attack surface missile-carrying ships.
18/ One more fact about the Varshavyanka class submarine. It is the one depicted in the film "72 Metres" - the B-471 "Magnitogorsk" of the Northern Fleet and the B-871 "Alrosa" of the Black Sea Fleet were used for filming. By the way, the Alrosa could also be docked today. /end
1/ Systemic discrimination against people from Russia's regions – affecting not just ethnic minorities, but ethnic Russians as well – is to blame for the disproportionate numbers of war casualties among the country's minority groups, according to the author of a study. ⬇️
2/ Maria Vyushkova, the co-author (with Yevgeny Sherkhonov) of a study on Russian ethnic minority casualty rates in the Ukraine war, has explained their findings in an interview with Azatliq, Radio Liberty's Tatar service. brill.com/view/journals/…
3/ Vyushkova and Sherkhonov were able to confirm widespread reports that ethnic minorities have experienced a disproportionate percentage of casualties compared with the percentage of their population in Russia.
1/ One of Russia's richest women is allegedly rueing Yevgeny Prigozhin's demise: she will no longer be able to join wealthy convicts and organised crime bosses in paying a large bribe to 'enlist' with the Wagner Group, stay somewhere safe and get a pardon after six months. ⬇️
2/ The VChK-OGPU Telegram channel reports that Prigozhin's death has "buried the market for buying parole from prison under the guise of criminals' participation in the war." They were kept safe in Wagner-run hospitals before returning to freedom with a pardon from Putin.
3/ According to the VChK-OGPU's sources, Prigozhin's plane crash came at a particularly bad time for Olga Mirimskaya, who was allegedly negotiating a $5 million fee to become – notionally at least – Wagner's first female mercenary.
1/ A Russian nationalist symbol has become the latest target of paranoia about anything that looks even slightly like the flag of Ukraine. The police were called after a wreath in blue, yellow and red was left at a Moscow memorial. ⬇️
2/ The wreath was in the colours of the flag of the Rostov region and the short-lived Don Cossack Republic rather than the blue and yellow of the Ukrainian flag, but a local resident reportedly overlooked the red colour and thought it was a pro-Ukrainian wreath.
3/ It had been laid at the equestrian statue to Cossack ataman (leader) Matvei Platov in Moscow's Lefortovo Park. The wreath was presumably left to mark the anniversary of Platov's birth on 19 August 1753. He commanded the Don Cossacks in the Napoleonic wars.
1/ A senior Russian officer has been arrested and charged with embezzlement and taking bribes for the demilitarisation of old tanks and infantry fighting vehicles. Colonel Ilya Timofeev is accused of taking bribes worth millions of rubles and plundering military funds. ⬇️
2/ The Russian newspaper Kommersant reports on the arrest of Colonel Timofeev, the head of the Recycling Service of the Main Armored Directorate (GABTU) of the Russian Ministry of Defence. He has been placed in a pre-trial detention centre to prevent him fleeing Russia.
3/ The colonel was investigated by the FSB's Military Counterintelligence Department (DVKR) and the military investigation branch of the Investigative Committee, roughly Russia's equivalent of the FBI. He was arrested at the end of August 2023.
1/ A study shows that there are large differences in pay and mortality rates for Russian soldiers from different parts of the country. Men from Moscow and St Petersburg are paid far more and have a lower chance of dying than those from poor regions like Chuvashia or Buryatia. ⬇️
2/ The independent Russian news outlet Govorit NeMoskva has reviewed military pay, benefits and mortality rates across Russia. It has found that St Petersburg – Vladimir Putin's home town – is by far the most generous, paying six times more than the lowest-paying regions.
3/ At the same time, soldiers from Moscow and St Petersburg have significantly lower mortality rates that those from Buryatia, Tuva and North Ossetia – all three of which are among Russia's poorest regions.
1/ Will the real Vakhtin stand up? SOTA highlights an absurd situation in Russia's regional elections – a ballot paper on which six candidates of the same surname are listed, in an apparent effort to bury the real challenger to the United Russia candidate. ⬇️
2/ The ballot paper above is from the elections to the Council of People's Deputies of the Semiluksky District in the Voronezh region. It lists Alexey Viktorovich, Anatoly Anatolyevich, Anton Valentinovich, Viktor Anatolievich, Vladimir Ivanovich and Evgeniy Anatolyevich Vakhtin.
3/ The real Vakhtin – the candidate for the Rodina party – is Vladimir Ivanovich. Notably, the Vakhtins' names are not listed alphabetically, burying him in the middle of a swarm of fake Vakhtins. The other five Vakhtins are all self-nominated candidates.