1/This is a graph of the number of non-disease* deaths per month above or below expected based on 2013-2019 baseline
It's a great example of the phenomena of reporting lag & how lag is used to manipulate public perception of the pandemic
(*accidents, suicide, homicide, etc.)
2/Note the area in the pink circle here
Suddenly, starting in February of 2023 it looks like people just stopped dying from accidents, from suicides, from drug overdoses, etc
Did they?
No, of course they didn't. What you are seeing here is reporting lag
3/You have to go all the way back to JANUARY OF 2023 (sorry for shouting) when the reported number of deaths from accidents matches the trend of previous months
I downloaded the data in this graph from the CDC yesterday
The data is only accurate to January 2023
Nine months ago
4/So when a public health official, an academic, a media columnist or a politician says "Excess deaths have been below normal for months now!"
You know you're being gaslighted
You know you're being bullshitted
You've been Leonhardt-ed. @DLeonhardt @charles_gaba @RichardWWard1
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Do pictures like this make you wish a BSL-3 superpathogen developed in a bioweapons laboratory would just GO AWAY?
Are you the prime minister or the president of a major western power?
Have no fear!
At Travis Confounders(TM) our heavy lifting equipment can MOVE YOUR BASELINE
Why compute excess deaths off of "old" years when, for a modest sum, we here at TC will put that junk in the trunk and move you into the bright endemic future?
How does it work?
We replace our old, empty, baseline years with new modern years that come pre-charged with disease.
That way whenever you compare what it's like today, you compare it to a steaming pile of shit from just yesterday!
1/The CDC stopped publishing its COVID / Excess deaths reports last week. I'm preparing a replacement now and thought a quick primer on excess deaths would be welcome
* What are "excess deaths?"
* Why do we care about excess deaths?
* How do you calculate excess deaths?
2/Excess deaths are simply the number of deaths in a given population in excess of the number of deaths expected in that population
Population is usually defined both by a given geographic area as well as demographics such as age, race, income, education, etc.
3/We care about excess deaths because it is nearly impossible to determine "why" a person died
This is because our likelihood of dying from ANYTHING increases with age
By the time we get around to actually dying it's because a whole lot of things all came together to kill us