#1 Production, Information Costs, and Economic Organization with Harold Demsetz
- Chosen as one of AER's Top 20 articles in its first 100 years.
- Anyone interested in IO, contract theory, or entrepreneurship needs to grapple with this paper. josephmahoney.web.illinois.edu/BA549_Fall%202…
The big question: Why do firms exist?
The fundamental problem that Alchian and Demsetz point to is Hayekian. Information isn't free!
With team production, paying each worker their marginal product isnt straightforward. People will specialize in monitoring and metering workers
#2 Vertical Integration, Appropriable Rents, and the Competitive Contracting Process with Klein and Crawford
Haggling is destructive. So workers and firms have the incentive to find contractual workarounds.
The more investments are specific to a particular trading partner, the more likely we will see contracts tying the two sides more tightly together.
Bob Gibbons calls Klein, Crawford, and Alchian one of four formalizable theories of the firm. Every mechanism design course covers the models on the left.
#3 Uncertainty, Evolution, and Economic Theory Do firms maximize profits?
That's not a well-posed question with uncertainty.
In fact, in many ways, it doesn't matter what people try to do. The profit system selects for firms that make positive profits jstor.org/stable/1827159
From here, we can impose assumptions on costs that make sense.
For example, all else equal, executing the same task in less time is more costly. I summarized this paper in a newsletter a while back economicforces.xyz/p/costs-and-ou…
#4 Information Costs, Pricing, and Resource Unemployment
This 1969 paper was groundbreaking in applying information economics to the labor market, especially search theories.
Money arises not just to overcome double coincidence of wants, but due to information costs in assessing goods' attributes. Money has low costs. jstor.org/stable/1992014
Using money plus experts in goods reduces costs of assessing quality. Experts become specialist middlemen due to reputability. Explains unemployment too.
Again, microfounded (search) macro.
And just in terms of general badassness as an economist, no one surpasses Alchian.
To no one's surprise, the Nobel Prize goes to Claudia Goldin
Here are 3 things from her to start your dive into her work:
One of the things that makes it difficult to jump into Claudia's work is that there really isn't ONE paper. It's a body of work built over decades.
Contrast this with last year's prize, which was literally for one model of bank runs.
I would start with "The Power of the Pill."
The paper traces the profound influence of oral contraceptives on women's life choices, especially around work. By granting reproductive autonomy, the pill gave educational and career freedoms for women. dash.harvard.edu/bitstream/hand…
We've known @linakhanFTC wanted to rewrite US antitrust since she first took office. (Actually, since she was in law school). So far, she's struck out.
Today's new draft FTC/DOJ guidelines reveal her vision on mergers.
If taken seriously, they will set antitrust back decades 🧵
First, what are the merger guidelines?
The rule of law requires that people know beforehand whether something is legal or not. A speed-limit sign tells drivers the rules of the road. 🚦
The merger guidelines give a signal to businesses what the FTC/DOJ will challenge in court.
Since 1968, the merger guidelines have become more explicit and more grounded in economics and the "CONSUMER WELFARE STANDARD"
I won't say consumers are out the picture now, but they have taken a backseat to a hodgepodge of things thrown at the wall to see what can block mergers
The NYT ran a piece that blames the failure to enforce the Robinson-Patman Act for rising food prices.
Anytime you see a piece connecting antitrust to inflation, you know it's going to be a stretch 🧵
Before we get to the RPA, the op-ed starts with "To understand why grocery prices are way up, we need to look past the headlines about inflation." I agree.
But we should look at some DATA, not just stories about 1 grocery store that would be bad for nearby people if it closed.
Are food prices rising fast? Since when?
It's not exactly clear when things went wrong in the author's mind. Sometimes it seems 1960 was the golden era.