Chung-Tzu Profile picture
Nov 23, 2023 29 tweets 18 min read Read on X
(1/25) Let's talk about Grad. Image
(2/25) While the M-13 ('Katyusha') and M-31 had proved successful during the war, the Soviets were impressed with German spin-stabilised rockets, particularly the 21 cm Nebelwerfer 42, which had superior accuracy and twice the range of the M-31.


Image
Image
Image
Image
(3/25) The next generation of Soviet MRLs would switch to spin-stabilised rocket projectiles (турбореактивный снаряд), resulting in the M-14 and M-24 systems. The M-14 became the standard MRL of Soviet combined arms divisions in the 1950s.
kpopov.ru/military/padik…



Image
Image
Image
Image
(4/25) In 1959, the GAU issued its requirements for the M-14's successor, 'Grad' ('Hail'). 'Grad' was required to have 20-km range (over double the M-14), and carry 30 100–125-mm rockets, as well as a blast-frag effect no worse than the M-14 or a 152-mm shell.

Image
Image
Image
(5/25) Work was led by the one-eyed Aleksandr Ganichev, chief designer of what is today NPO Splav, known as NII-74 back then. Ganichev was responsible for Grad, Uragan, and Smerch over his career, leading to him being known as the father of Soviet MRLs.
missilery.info/article/ganich…

Image
Image
(5/25) Spin-stabilisation carries a cost, in that energy (fuel) has to be used up spinning the rocket, reducing range. To meet the range requirement for the 'Grad', Ganichev and his team came up with a hybrid fin/spin stabilisation system.

Image
Image
Image
(6/25) The 'Grad field rocket system' (2B5 launcher, 9M22 rockets, and 9F37 racks for carrying rockets) was accepted into service in 1963. At some point it was given the GRAU index 9K51 and the launcher and rockets got named BM-21 and M-21OF.
missilery.info/gallery/kopiya…

Image
Image
(7/25) The original Grad's 2B5 (BM-21) launcher is based on the Ural-375D 6x6 truck. In 1986, this was switched to the 2B17 (BM-21-1), which is based on the Ural-4320. The latter has a YaMZ diesel engine replacing the 375D's fuel-hungry ZIL-375 engine.


Image
Image
Image
Image
(8/25) Each 2B5/2B17 carries 40 rockets ready to fire. The launcher can be elevated to 55° and traversed 102° left or 70° right. In order to fire over the cab (34° left/right) the launcher must be elevated to 11°.


Image
Image
Image
Image
(9/25) A full salvo of 40 rockets can be fired in 20 s. It is also possible to fire smaller salvos or individual rockets.
(10/25) The primary rocket fired by the Grad is the M-21OF. There are several types that fall under the 'M-21OF' name depending on the fuse and propellant charge used, but all carry the same HE-Frag warhead with 6.4 kg explosive. Max range is 20.4 km.
Image
Image
(11/25) A Grad battery (6 BM-21s) can launch 240 rockets in 20 s, delivering ~1.5 t of explosive. To do the same with 122-mm D-30 howitzers in 2 min would require an entire artillery regiment of 36 guns.

Image
Image
Image
(12/25) Conversely, Grad is not in any sense a 'precision' weapon, with the dispersal area of a full Grad salvo being 35x that of a D-30 at 15 km. Even when firing small salvos with ranging, 'precise' is probably only relative.
Image
Image
(13/25) It is as an area bombardment system that the Grad excels.

(14/25) Aiming the Grad is a more primitive affair than on a HIMARS or Smerch, which is to be expected from an early 1960s weapon.
(15/25) Another Grad rocket type occasionally seen in Ukraine is the MZ-21 (9M22S) incendiary rocket. The 9N510 warhead carries 180 thermite incendiary elements in a hexagonal magnesium alloy casing.
en.missilery.info/missile/grad/m…



Image
Image
Image
Image
(16/25) The MZ-21 has a slightly lower range (19.89 km) and scatters the incendiary elements over a 6,400 m² area. It is primarily intended to ignite dry vegetation and other combustible materials. Each element burns for a minimum of 2 s.
(17/25) There are many other types that can be fired from the Grad system. These include the 9M28 family, which are lighter 15 km rockets developed for the down-sized Grad-1 (9K55) system intended for motor rifle and naval infantry regiments.

Image
Image
Image
(18/25) Unlike Uragan and Smerch, Grad does not have a dedicated transloader. The rockets were simply carried in 9F37 racks on trucks. In fact, a dedicated Grad rocket transporter, 9T254, did not appear until 2001. The loading process is done manually to this day.


Image
Image
Image
Image
(19/25) The intended Soviet successor to Grad was the Prima system (9K59). Prima was a comprehensive modernisation of the Grad system, featuring a new 9A51 launcher, new 9F53 rockets with a detachable parachute HE-Frag warhead for optimal blast-frag effect, and a transloader.
Image
Image
(20/25) In the event, Prima entered service in ~1989, so it never came close to replacing Grad. The only country known to use it today is Kazakhstan. Image
(21/25) The Russian successor to Grad is Tornado-G (9K51M). Entering service in 2014, Tornado-G has a new launcher (2B17M) with automated fire control, which Prima had back in 1989, and GLONASS/GPS integration (note SMART antenna).
en.missilery.info/missile/tornad…
Image
(22/25) Both Ukraine and Russian continue to use Grads, where they serve much the same role as division-level MRLs that they did in Soviet times.
(23/25) According to Zhirokhov, Ukraine inherited at least 378 Grad/Grad-1 systems from the USSR. At least 70 were sold abroad, leaving about 300 in service in 2014.
web.archive.org/web/2018122417…


Image
Image
Image
(24/25) Since 2022, they have also been joined by their Czechoslovak cousin, the RM-70.
Image
Image
(25/25) In terms of longevity and number of users, Grad is indisputably the most successful MRL of the 20th century. Simple, cheap, and an effective area weapon, it is likely to continue to serve until well into the 21st century. Image
(26/25) Should at least mention the Zelenopillya shelling incident. There are two narratives behind this: one is from Philip Karber, who claimed it was done with Tornado-G. The other is by @AdrianBonenber1, who disputes this narrative:

Image
(27/25) To Karber, Zelenopillya (the U.S./western version) is the ultimate example of Russian lethality: advanced detection, electronic jamming, drone-integrated spotting, and long-range precision fires linked with advanced thermobaric munitions. Image
(28/25) @AdrianBonenber1 puts forward a more mundane narrative. It is for you to decide who is closer to the truth. Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Chung-Tzu

Chung-Tzu Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ChungTzuW

Dec 27, 2024
So generally fairly interesting observation of this newest version of Malva (2S43) in that it appears to be using the breech of the Giatsint-B Image
Image
As originally designed, Malva used the gun and breech assembly of the Msta-S, complete with the semi-automatic loading system for charges and projectiles. Some used Msta-B barrels without the fume extractor. Image
Image
Image
Image
Msta-B has a different breech design and ramming system, thus can be excluded at least based on the breech. Image
Read 7 tweets
Nov 7, 2024
I had no idea the PFUNR (UNR air force) had Zeppelin-Staakens lol Image
Image
Image
Interned in Romania 1919 @GHarward Image
Read 6 tweets
Sep 18, 2024
'Phantom Chariot of the East: The Mysterious Prototype Vehicle Hidden Behind Project 122 (Part 1)'


Image
Image
Image
Image



Image
Image
Image
Image

Image
Image
Read 4 tweets
Jun 22, 2024
Yuriy Kryuchkov, 'Submarines and their creators 1900–2000: Dramas of people, ships and ideas' (2010)

Image
Image
Image
Shaped charge torpedo scheme
Image
Image
Nuclear torpedo
Image
Image
Read 14 tweets
Apr 2, 2024
(1) If you have been kind enough to buy/download/borrow/acquire/pirate one of these books, I would like to take this opportunity to list any technical errors I made in them. If future editions are printed, they will be corrected, and if you notice any more feel free to tell me.
Image
Image
(2) Vol. 4 Page 4: The T-44 was not the first Soviet tank with planetary gear transmission: they originally still used friction clutches like the T-34. The T-54 was the first, and T-44s were later given them when upgraded to T-44M standard in the '60s.




Image
Image
Image
Image
(3) Vol. 4 Page 31: T-72s are not unique in this respect. All the Soviet MBTs of that generation have this layout (T-64B, upper), even the T-80U (lower). Don't ask me why they put it there (maybe no space?).

Image
Image
Image
Read 4 tweets
Mar 12, 2024
(1/24) Let's talk about the P-35 and Progress missiles. Image
(2) Let us go back to the beginning. In 8̶8̶2̶, R̶u̶r̶i̶k̶'s̶ s̶u̶c̶c̶e̶s̶s̶o̶r̶ P̶r̶i̶n̶c̶e̶ O̶l̶e̶g̶ 1954, Vladimir Chelomei's 'special design group' began work on the P-5 cruise missile. Previously, they worked on the 10Kh, the Soviet copy of the German Fi 103 aka V-1.
Image
Image
(3) Up to this point, cruise missiles had to be assembled on ramps before launch. These included the American Regulus submarine-launched strategic cruise missiles. The P-5 was similar in role, launched by submarines like the ungainly '655' (art by Hylajaponica (DA)).


Image
Image
Image
Image
Read 25 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(