🧵IMPORTANT UPDATE to Hamas casualty count falsification thread. MORE falsifications proven based on review of December numbers with a massive jump in claimed percentage of women & children killed; Men killed DROPS dramatically! Also a response to a main criticism. 1/
Hamas' recent Dec 5 casualty report vs Dec 2 shows +1,041 new fatalities. But remarkably, new women & children killed jump by +1,353 over this same period, 312 more than total new fatalities! Again, no men seem to have died in several days of fighting. (My math in blue). 2/
We can look at it another way to show absurd numbers. According to Hamas and cited by the UN & media of course, men killed have DECLINED by 312 over these days. See detailed calculations below. Despite reports of many dozens to hundreds of Hamas killed in recent battles. 3/
Hamas keeps upping the percentage of women & children killed, with a dramatic jump in December. See the chart below for how these percentages have moved over time. In line with fewer men mysteriously reported killed. It's not a margin of error but deliberate falsification. 4/
Despite civilian evacuations, slowdown in bombing especially compared to initial bombing prior to evacuations, reliance on more ground troops, the percentage of women & children killed keeps rising. IDF CANNOT seem to hit many men & their “aim” worsens as the war progresses. 5/
Some desperate critics claim numbers simply reflect identification time lag from pulling bodies from rubble. But this means that on MANY days literally 100s of bodies identified as men were really women & children and NEVER the reverse. The trend shows this reason is false. 6/
Israeli media reports that officials believe ~15,000 deaths is within accurate range, however they also say ~6,000 are Hamas members. After factoring in civilian men killed, the percentage of women & children killed is dramatically less than the 73.8% reported by Hamas. 7/
Also to consider: (1) child soldiers, as it is well documented teens are involved with Pal terrorist groups (2) 471 greatly exaggerated deaths from Al-Ahli Hospital fire caused by PIJ rocket remains in casualty count (3) 1000s of rockets fell inside Gaza likely killing many. 8/
Let’s be clear. There is TRAGIC death of 1000s of civilians including many children in Gaza. But Israel has no choice; Hamas cannot and does not enjoy permanent immunity because it embeds within and under 2 million civilians. A strategy it admits to so tragedy is their fault. 9/
It seems the big jump in last few days of percentage of women & children killed reflects Hamas' desperate hopes of more world pressure for ceasefire and UN is playing along. Expect even more hysterical humanitarian crisis claims from Hamas, UN & fake NGOs in coming weeks. END
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
🧵Critical Thread. Close review of Gaza casualty figures reported by UN OCHA based on daily Hamas “Ministry of Health” numbers proves they are FALSIFIED. Women & children are grossly inflated. This is easily proven but media ignores. See detailed expose below: 1/
UN OCHA publishes a daily “flash update” since Oct 8 and cites detailed Gaza casualty figures provided by Hamas. The website and data is available to the public here: Sometime in October the UN provided the data in graphic form, here is the latest. 2/ ochaopt.org/crisis
It is immediately obvious that Hamas does not report ANY combatant deaths & the numbers amazingly seem to indicate that IDF bombs & bullets disproportionately hit women, children & elderly. They IDF CANNOT seem to hit too many fighting age men. But the numbers are faked. 3/
🧵+972 magazine article making rounds, widely cited by likes of @ilhanMN @kenroth & others, yet another version of (1) Israel is a war criminal deliberately targeting civilians (2) Israeli is bloodthirsty not caring about killing kids. Long thread which tears article apart: 1/
972 claims war crimes throughout article; below are two examples of many, this is core contention of the article. The key evidence? Unnamed IDF sources (literally not one verified or named source), testimony of Gazan civilians, (fake) statements from IDF and Amnesty Int'l. 2/
Here 972 effectively claims bloodthirst: Israel kills children and does not care. 972 won't accept Israel has to destroy Hamas after 1,200 Israelis butchered & vows more and thus IDF has TERRIBLE choices. They won't accept that no IDF commander relishes death of children. 3/
🧵Claimed words by IDF spokesman Hagari: “The emphasis is on damage and not on accuracy” have been falsely quoted worldwide as proof that Israel bombs Gaza indiscriminately, part of a campaign to claim genocidal intent. HonestReporting investigated; read for detail: 1/
This 9 word snippet, offered without any context, like all Israeli “quotes” claiming to prove war crimes, were widely reported, often with extra unproven embellishment (“abandons precision bombing”) further misrepresenting what Hagari actually said and meant. 2/
Washington Post later used quote as its centerpiece evidence of the same charge, that Israel is not really trying to minimize civilian casualties. WP links to the same Oct 10 Guardian article that does not cite a source. @ishaantharoor did not bother to check its accuracy. 3/
🧵Media falsely claim 500 trucks/day entered Gaza before war but now 140 during truce & less prior. But it's all grossly misrepresented to imply a humanitarian crisis. In fact, number of truckloads of food medicine & humanitarian items are similar to before war. Here's truth: 1/
UN publishes truckload entries into Gaza via Israel & Egypt. In 2021 106,000 truckloads entered and 79,000 though Aug 2023, was on pace for 118,000. Here is the chart for the last 15 years. So that's 290/day in 2022 and 323/day in 2023 NOT 500. 2/ ochaopt.org/data/crossings…
Notably, media are now inflating truckloads that entered Gaza prior to war; before this the constant importation of goods into Gaza via Egypt & Israel was obfuscated to pretend Gaza was suffering with not enough food & water -- all lies. 3/
🧵A long thread worth your time to debunk Israel genocide in Gaza. Claims of genocide often rely on analysis by Raz Segal as an "expert” on genocide. Analysis of his work and a group of recycled quotes by Israeli officials, now used by the media, shows it's all fabrication. 1/
Notably, Segal published his claim on Oct 13 only days after Hamas atrocities with <2,000 Gazan deaths. Segal already decided he was going to charge Israel with genocide before the bodies were all pulled from Be'eri. His arguments are easily debunked. 2/ jewishcurrents.org/a-textbook-cas…
On Nov 20 Segal spoke with Owen Jones making the same case for "textbook" genocide but ALL his "evidence" of genocidal intent by Israel is falsified or misrepresented, blatant academic dishonestly. Both the article & video interview will be debunked. 3/
🧵Here is a compilation of evidence showing Hamas using mosques, schools, homes etc. for military use. All Hamas war crimes. This is why there is wide destruction & collateral damage in Gaza. Only defense Hamas apologists have left is to claim these are all fake. 20 examples: 1/
Mosque in Zeitoun neighborhood: Tunnel, weapons and drone lab. 2/
Al-Karmel Secondary Boys School: Weapons and Hamas equipment. Here’s an image of the school in better times. 3/