Aizenberg Profile picture
Dec 18 12 tweets 4 min read Twitter logo Read on Twitter
🧵IDF soldiers broke protocols tragically killing hostages with white flags. Key question is why soldiers may have thought they were a threat? Because of at least TEN Hamas war crimes which greatly impact IDF actions, especially in Shejaiya where this occurred. Here they are: 1/
ONE: Hamas dresses as civilians. If Hamas wore uniforms as required by international law, IDF would never have thought civilians might be combatants. The hostages would still be alive. Hamas violates Geneva Protocol I.44.3 2/ Image
TWO: Hamas regularly violates “Prohibition of perfidy” by feigning civilian status, a key factor in tragic hostage incident. Hamas acts like civilians, enters homes set up with arms, exits as civilian, enters another pre-set attack position. A core Hamas battle strategy 3/ Image
THREE: Hamas uses human shields. Not just hiding among & under civilians which is also war crime. But sending civilians as spotters or to disrupt IDF actions as reported in Jabaliya in just one case from story below. Hamas violates Protocol I.51.7 risking lives of civilians. 4/ Image
FOUR: Hamas illegally booby traps bodies, certain civilian sites, even children’s backpack (see news story) & lures troops using things like baby recordings. This has killed IDF soldiers. War crimes under Protocol on Prohibitions & Restrictions on Use of Mines, Booby-Traps. 5/ Image
FIVE: Hamas violates Protocol I.58 as they have an affirmative duty to avoid locating military objectives from "densely population areas" – like Shejaiya neighborhood where hostages killed. This is the core Hamas war crime: embedding within civilian areas. 6/ Image
SIX: Hamas regularly violates Geneva Protocol I.53 by using mosques for weapons storage, attacks, tunnels etc. Many documented examples. While not directly related to killing of hostages, this & other war crimes speak to IDF troops knowing that NOTHING is too low for Hamas. 7/ Image
SEVEN: Further in the category of NOTHING being too low for Hamas: rape on 10/7 and sexual violence against hostages (10 hostages reported this) is a unique war crime. 8/ Image
EIGHT: Hamas tortured and caused physical suffering to hostages. From placing burn marks on children to identify them if they escaped to just murdering hostages they violate Geneva IV.32. Nothing is too low & depraved for Hamas. IDF has internalized this. 9/ Image
NINE: Hamas use of hospitals for its military actions is now well documented, from hostage taking at Rantisi & Shifa hospitals, tunnels, Hamas firing positions, weapons inside incubators. Nothing too low for Hamas. Nothing can be trusted. Several laws broken like this one: 10/ Image
TEN: Finally of course: taking hostages is a war crime per Geneva IV.34. If Hamas had not taken hostages in the first place they’d still be alive today. Their death – and every civilian death in this war – is ultimately for the account of Hamas. 11/ Image
Another 10 war crimes could easily be listed (e.g. rockets). It is dishonest & willfully ignorant to assess killing of hostages by IDF without taking into account these massive Hamas war crimes IDF soldiers deal with daily. UN & Fake NGOs of course pretend they don't know. END

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Aizenberg

Aizenberg Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Aizenberg55

Dec 19
🧵@hrw piece claiming Israel intends to starve Gazans for war is propaganda masking as scholarship but covered by NY Times. Like all HRW "reports" on Israel it is filled with lies, errors, misrepresentations & omissions. Here is a detailed breakdown: 1/

hrw.org/news/2023/12/1…
Image
The core lie is presented upfront claiming that for 2 months Israel has deprived Gaza with GOAL of starving Gaza incredibly omitting ANY detail on the many 1000s of trucks that have entered Gaza. Food & aid has been at ~90% of pre-war levels and FAR more recently. 2/ Image
From Oct 21-early Dec truckloads of aid were 3,499 or about 90% of pre-war 2022 levels. Israel opened Keren Shalom to move truckloads up further to ~190/day. HRW does not mention any of this in their “report” – not one number or statistic to evidence their claims! 3/ Image
Read 19 tweets
Dec 13
🧵HAMAS FAKE CASUALTY UPDATE: Hamas now reports the opposite of last 6 week trend: only male deaths in last 4 days. Perhaps they read analysis showing women & children deaths kept rising in impossible ways. This only deepens dubiousness of Hamas numbers. Here are the details: 1/ Image
UN reports daily Hamas stats. Each day UN adds this note about total fatalities: “about 70 per cent of whom are said to be women and children.” It's another way of saying: we have no idea & neither does Hamas but we’ll report them anyway so media & NGOs can say “the UN says.” 2/ Image
As a recap, on many days in Oct Nov & early Dec of total fatalities added less than 5% were men. Women & children killed soared (see chart). For example: Oct 31 only 6 of 216 new fatalities were men; 4 of 306 on Nov 7; 44 of 929 on Dec 7. Many similar anomalies on other days. 3/ Image
Read 8 tweets
Dec 11
🧵Claims that Israel is "indiscriminately" bombing or causing disproportionate civilian deaths in Gaza can be easily proven false based on actions & statistics. Here are SEVEN items of evidence that debunk claims of war crimes, genocide, unprecedented civilian deaths, etc. 1/
ONE: Casualty ratios. Israel states 5,000-7,000 Hamas killed. Civilian combatant ratio is ~2:1. Battle of Mosul against ISIS was >3:1. Former Commander of UK forces in Afghanistan says ratio there 3:1-5:1. Israel is doing better than Western armies. 2/
TWO: Gaza has ~2.3mm people vs ~10,000 Civilians killed after 60+ days of what is described as massive bombing. If so incredibly massive & random (this is what indiscriminate means) in dense area how can it be only ~0.005 killed? Not even 1% after 2 months of random bombing? 3/ Image
Read 9 tweets
Dec 9
🧵Compilation #2 of evidence: Hamas using homes mosques schools for military. NGO industrial complex will soon issue reports blaming Israel for unjustified destruction of infrastructure but totally ignore how Hamas rigged Gaza for combat. See below for 20 documented examples: 1/ Image
Jebaliya, residential home: IDF filmed gun battle against two Hamas firing from residence. Video shows kitchen & rooms, ends with images of killed men. 2/ Image
School in Shejaya: Hamas cell in gun battle with IDF, filmed. Tunnel within school found leading to mosque. Best place to find Hamas assets: schools, mosques & hospitals. 3/ Image
Read 21 tweets
Dec 7
🧵IMPORTANT UPDATE to Hamas casualty count falsification thread. MORE falsifications proven based on review of December numbers with a massive jump in claimed percentage of women & children killed; Men killed DROPS dramatically! Also a response to a main criticism. 1/ Image
Hamas' recent Dec 5 casualty report vs Dec 2 shows +1,041 new fatalities. But remarkably, new women & children killed jump by +1,353 over this same period, 312 more than total new fatalities! Again, no men seem to have died in several days of fighting. (My math in blue). 2/ Image
We can look at it another way to show absurd numbers. According to Hamas and cited by the UN & media of course, men killed have DECLINED by 312 over these days. See detailed calculations below. Despite reports of many dozens to hundreds of Hamas killed in recent battles. 3/ Image
Read 10 tweets
Dec 4
🧵Critical Thread. Close review of Gaza casualty figures reported by UN OCHA based on daily Hamas “Ministry of Health” numbers proves they are FALSIFIED. Women & children are grossly inflated. This is easily proven but media ignores. See detailed expose below: 1/
UN OCHA publishes a daily “flash update” since Oct 8 and cites detailed Gaza casualty figures provided by Hamas. The website and data is available to the public here: Sometime in October the UN provided the data in graphic form, here is the latest. 2/ ochaopt.org/crisis
Image
It is immediately obvious that Hamas does not report ANY combatant deaths & the numbers amazingly seem to indicate that IDF bombs & bullets disproportionately hit women, children & elderly. They IDF CANNOT seem to hit too many fighting age men. But the numbers are faked. 3/
Read 10 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(