If you want to understand how Hamas propaganda is created on here and spreads, let me show a perfect example.
21 year old Mia Schem was taken hostage by Hamas on 10/7. She had her arm blown off. She was released as part of the ceasefire exchange.
While she was still in Hamas captivity, they had her film a hostage video in October.
Then, right before her release, they had her film another video under gunpoint where she said she was treated “very good” and people in Gaza were “very kind” to her.
The main anti-Israel propaganda accounts on here then promoted that video for millions of views suggesting Hamas was treating the hostages very well.
And then you had certain people with media platforms, like Briahna Joy Gray, use such propaganda to dismiss the possibility of rape andclaim that the hostages faced “humane treatment”
All of that leaves a lasting false impression. Then we get to now when she has had a chance to recover and is sharing the real story on how she was treated, which is the complete opposite of humane.
Here Mia talks specifically about the video cited above by propagandists on here that Hamas made her record.
“Just before heading home, a Hamas terrorist with a camera confronts you and tells me, say that the people of Gaza are nice. Say kind things”
Mia explains that she was treated like a zoo animal. She says that she believes the only reason that the man from the family who watched her 24/7 prior to being taken to the tunnels didn’t rape her was that his wife was always outside the door w the kids.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
A perfect example of how ignorant reporters create false narratives that get exploited in this media environment.
Yesterday there was a lot of outrage over a CNN report from @NatashaBertrand which claimed almost a majority of the bombs Israel was using in Gaza were “dumb bombs”
The implication of most of the article, which was widely cited to support the idea that Israel was doing something irresponsible, was that Israel’s choice of unguided munitions was similar 2 indiscriminate targeting.
Although they did add 1 paragraph that undermined the premise
But what Bertrand failed to do was add any context as to whether that rate of “dumb bombs” was appropriate or consistent with other military actions.
When ABC News looked at that, they found it was a “historically high level of precision weapons” being used.
The most insightful thing you can read about the current coverage of this conflict was actually written back in 2014 by former AP reporter and editor Matti Friedman. Almost everything he wrote is still reflected in what you see today and I would urge everyone to read it.
I’m going to highlight a few of the key points in this thread.
“The key to understanding the strange nature of the response is thus to be found in the practice of journalism, and specifically in a severe malfunction that is occurring in that profession—my profession—here in Israel."
This is key and why news organizations almost completely ignored the Palestinian poll from last weekend:
“If you follow mainstream coverage, you will find nearly no real analysis of Palestinian society or ideologies, profiles of armed Palestinian groups, or investigation of Palestinian government. Palestinians are not taken seriously as agents of their own fate.”
Please watch this video of one of the music festival survivors recounting part of what she saw that day. I've seen dozens of these interviews with survivors.
Keep that in mind in the context of watching despicable people on here constantly try to deny or diminish what Hamas did that day.
Here is another survivor describing the hell he and his friends went through. They actually managed to take out some of the terrorists with their jeep as they tried to escape.
Here is another survivor who was shot in the arm and the leg describing what he witnessed.
You will notice they all tell the same story. Just Hamas terrorists murdering everyone they could find.
Outside the obvious, let me give an example of why it is irresponsible for news networks to use death totals from Hamas & how this choice isn't new:
Back in 2022, during the Second Intifada with a wave of terrorism, Israel tracked many of the attacks to the Jenin refugee camp.
Israel decided they had no choice but to go into the camp, which militants had boob-trapped and prepared for a battle. Israel went in on April 2nd. By April 7th, Palestinians were claiming over 500 dead. In the next week, they would raise that number to thousands.
CNN reported the Palestinian claims of 900+ dead. So did BBC. There were claims of a massacre, bodies being hidden etc. that dominated the press.
The Israeli operation ended on April 11th. Human rights groups and the UN then went in.
The actual casualty total based on those groups, which weren't exactly friendly with Israel, was 53 Palestinians. That includes militants and some civilians.
We now have video of the scene showing the explosion is from the parking lot and the buildings are in tact. There is no crater, no building demolished. This is inconsistent with the type of bomb many were suggesting yesterday.
There is drone footage from before and after that shows the same as above. Also inconsistent with an airstrike.
The IDF has released a phone call allegedly between 2 Hamas operatives where one informs the other that the Islamic Jihad missile was launched from a cemetery near the hospital and the shrapnel is consistent with one of their missiles.