THREAD: There have been a number of important developments over the weekend.
Three US soldiers were killed, and several dozen wounded, in a drone attack on a US military/intelligence base known as Tower 22 in northeastern Jordan, the region where the borders of Jordan, Syria, and Iraq meet.
The Jordanian authorities continue to insist that the attack was in fact directed at the US base in Tanf in southeastern Syria rather than Tower 22, because it does not want to draw unnecessary attention to the highly unpopular US military presence on Jordanian territory.
The US deployment is regulated by the 2022 US-Jordan Memorandum of Understanding on Strategic Partnership, which gives Washington virtually unlimited rights to use Jordanian territory for US military purposes, and the Jordanian treasury USD 1.45 billion per year for seven years.
The attack is significant for a number of reasons. Although there have been numerous attacks on US bases and forces in the Middle East since 7 October 2023, including in Iraq, Syria, in the Red Sea off Yemen, and according to unconfirmed reports Israel as well,
these are the first confirmed killings of US soldiers in the region since that date. (Two Navy SEALS died off Yemen’s coast recently, but it was reported as an accident). It is also the first confirmed attack on or from Jordanian territory since 7 October.
Responsibility for the attack was claimed by the Islamic Resistance in Iraq, a coalition of groups aligned with the Axis of Resistance, itself a coalition of states and movements in the region opposed to US-Israeli hegemony in the Middle East.
According to the statement of responsibility the attack, apparently launched from Syrian rather than Iraqi territory, is intended to raise the cost of Israel’s genocidal onslaught on the Gaza Strip and US support for Israel’s mass killings.
“If the US keeps supporting Israel, there will be escalations. All US interests in the region are legitimate targets and we don’t care about US threats to respond.” The expulsion of US forces from Iraq and Syria is an additional, unspoken objective.
In his own statement about the incident, US President Joe Biden blamed “radical Iran-backed militant groups operating in Syria and Iraq”.
White House spokesperson John Kirby will probably be trotted out to deny any connection whatsoever between developments in Jordan and Gaza, much as he has done in relation to attacks by Ansar Allah off Yemen’s coast, which even more explicitly reference the Gaza Strip.
Given US casualties, Washington is virtually certain to respond to this escalation with a significant escalation of its own. This in turn brings direct conflict between the US and Iran one big step closer, from plausible but unlikely to plausible and possible.
Powerful forces in both the US and Israel have been agitating for such a scenario since 7 October, and will now see a new opportunity to make this a reality.
The broader significance is that US forces are now dying in defense of Israel. Throughout this war Washington has had a clear choice: put an end to Israel’s genocidal onslaught on the Gaza Strip, or engage in conflict with regional forces determined to do so themselves.
Given Israel’s extraordinary level of military and political dependence on the US, so visibly demonstrated these past several months, it would take only a brief phone call to achieve the former. But the Biden administration has consistently chosen for the latter.
In the words of @asadabukhalil : “The US does not want a cease-fire in Gaza and objects to the regional repercussions of its rejection of the ceasefire.”
@asadabukhalil That’s not how the US-Israeli relationship is supposed to work. Israel is the designated proxy, assigned to defend Western interests in the Middle East. A “stationary aircraft carrier”, in the words of former US Secretary of State Alexander Haig.
@asadabukhalil Instead, the US is functioning as Israel’s proxy, now fighting on multiple fronts, its soldiers dying to defend Israel and protect its ability to continue fighting in the Gaza Strip. This is because for more than 100 days, Israel’s longest war since 1948-1949,
@asadabukhalil it has proven incapable of defeating Hamas, a second-order guerilla movement that doesn’t possess a single aircraft, tank, warship, or anti-aircraft defense system. Its long-range missiles basically need to make a direct impact on an individual’s forehead to achieve a kill.
@asadabukhalil As previously argued, Israel’s military incompetence and mediocre performance will have long-lasting consequences for its strategic relationship with its Western sponsors.
@asadabukhalil To put it simply, t-shirts emblazoned with an Israeli fighter jet and the slogan “Don’t Worry America, Israeli is Behind You!” used to popular among visiting tourists. I suspect they can now be obtained at a steep discount.
@asadabukhalil Related to this, a rally was held in Jerusalem today to promote the expulsion of Palestinians from the Gaza Strip and renewal of Israeli settlements in that occupied territory. It was attended by no less than 12 of Israel’s 37 government ministers (almost a third),
@asadabukhalil including several leaders of parties represented in that state’s genocidal coalition. Two of Israel’s most senior leaders, Minister of National Security Itamar Ben-Gvir and Minister of Finance Bezalel Smotrich, addressed the raucous and adoring crowd of several thousand.
@asadabukhalil Ben-Gvir leads Otzma Yehudit (“Jewish Power”), a Kahanist party that is Israel’s equivalent of Germany’s Nazis. Bezalel Smotrich is the leader of Tkuma (Religious Zionist Party), also Israel’s equivalent of Germany’s Nazis.
@asadabukhalil One thing that distinguishes these parties (and a few others) from others in Israel is their insistence that Israel is sufficiently powerful to act unilaterally and do as it pleases, and sufficiently independent to give the world, including Israel’s sponsors in the US and Europe,
@asadabukhalil the middle finger. That’s why they convened this meeting within 48 hours of the International Court of Justice session indicating that Israel has plausibly been accused of genocide.
@asadabukhalil The above notwithstanding Ben-Gvir and Smotrich have the mannerisms of spoiled children more than seasoned gangsters. Insufferable kids who feel free to grab or break anything they want at the store because they know Mummy and Daddy are there to take care of things,
@asadabukhalil and clean up any resulting mess. In other words, they talk big but know they can only do so because Biden and Brussels have their back. And on this score they’re right.
@asadabukhalil Which brings me to UNRWA. Several of Israel’s sponsors, including the US and UK, have suspended their funding of the UN refugee agency for Palestine refugees in response to unproven allegations that several of its employees participated in the attacks on Israel on 7 October.
@asadabukhalil It’s a bit like cutting off aid to a foreign country because a dozen of its civil servants have been charged (but not yet tried) for participation in criminal activity.
@asadabukhalil There’s much going on here, including a long-term campaign to liquidate the Palestinian refugee question, in which UNRWA serves as a primary surrogate for US-Israeli hysteria. And a history of previous Israeli allegations against UNRWA subsequently exposed as fraudulent.
@asadabukhalil (For example, a 2014 drone video released by Israel of two UNRWA medics purportedly using an ambulance to transport Hamas missiles was later revealed to be two UNRWA medics transporting a stretcher into an ambulance.)
@asadabukhalil But when it comes to UNRWA, a rush to judgement is obligatory, the agency is guilty until proven innocent, and then still guilty.
@asadabukhalil The Israeli allegations were transparently released to divert from the ICJ ruling. The response of multiple Western governments should also be seen as a response to the ICJ.
@asadabukhalil In their rules-based international order, it is a violation of international law to apply international law to Israel or Western states.
@asadabukhalil South Africa dares to hold Israel accountable for genocide? Let’s see what it thinks when we deliberately intensify hunger and famine in the Gaza Strip.
@asadabukhalil I’ll conclude by citing the comment of @sarahleah1, former head of MENA at Human Rights Watch and currently Executive Director of Democracy for the Arab World Now (DAWN):
@asadabukhalil @sarahleah1 “It took Blinken about 3 seconds to suspend UNRWA aid based on mere allegations that 12 employees linked to Hamas attack,
@asadabukhalil @sarahleah1 but despite evidence that IDF has indiscriminately & deliberately massacred tens of thousands of Palestinians – plausibly a genocide ICJ said – zero suspension of military aid”. END
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
THREAD: In a post yesterday I argued that AI assistants like Grok are unreliable for resolving questions which require judgement and interpretation, and can be useful only when the question posed to such assistants concerns matters of settled fact that have one, and only one, correct answer. I gave the example of “In what year did Napoleon invade Russia?” versus “Why did Napoleon invade Russia?” to illustrate my point.
That, at least, was my view until several people responded with examples in which Grok is unreliable even with respect to matters of settled fact, because it provided multiple, contradictory, and incompatible responses to what are essentially “yes or no” questions. So I stand corrected.
Returning to my initial point about AI assistants being unreliable for questions where interpretation is required, I experienced a relevant and telling example today.
THREAD (also available as a single text on my substack mouinrabbani.substack.com): Now that France and Britain, both members of the United Nations Security Council and G7, have indicated they are prepared to recognize the State of Palestine, the dam has burst. Today Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney indicated his government too intends to recognize Palestine during the upcoming session of the UN General Assembly in New York, and a growing number of Western states are adopting or preparing similar positions.
It is far from certain whether any of these governments will actually follow through on their statements of intent, and by attaching various conditions to their plans they have already provided themselves with an escape clause should they find it necessary to use it.
Given that a two-state settlement has been the official position of every one of these governments for several decades, and that a majority of states already recognized Palestine years if not decades ago, the question arises as to why these Western states have waited so long to recognize the state without which their proclaimed strategic objective is an impossibility.
THREAD (also available as a single text on my substack mouinrabbani.substack.com): When US president Harry Truman addressed a group of US diplomats stationed in the Middle East in late 1945, after they had urged him to withhold support for the Zionist objective of statehood in Palestine because it would lead to protracted conflict in the Middle East and undermine their efforts to promote US interests, he spoke the following words:
"I'm sorry, gentlemen, but I have to answer to hundreds of thousands who are anxious for the success of Zionism: I do not have hundreds of thousands of Arabs among my constituents."
The idea that it was Truman’s electoral calculations that determined US policy towards Palestine and produced the almost immediate US recognition of Israel in 1948, which was also a US presidential election year, has become accepted conventional wisdom, Yet it is hardly the entire story and also somewhat simplistic.
THREAD (Also posted on my Substack: ): The former president of Nigeria Muhammadu Buhari has died in London at age 82.mouinrabbani.substack.com
Buhari served three terms as the country’s head of state. In his first stint, he was installed in the top job in 1983 after participating in a military coup, then ousted in a further putsch two years later. More recently he was elected to the presidency in 2015, serving two terms until 2023.
For those otherwise unfamiliar with Nigeria and its politics, Buhari ’s time as military dictator during the mid-1980s is best remembered for an incident that his obituary on the Bibi Si’s website’s chose to omit, presumably at the direction of its chief censor on Israel reporting, Raffi Berg. It was known as the Dikko Affair.
THREAD (ALSO POSTED AS A SINGLE TEXT ON MY SUBSTACK): Taqiyya. Prior to the 9/11 terrorist attacks in New York and Washington, and the tsunami of Islamophobia it unleashed, I’d never heard of taqiyya. Nor had any of the Muslims or those identified as Muslims I had encountered before that time. More precisely, the topic never came up. Not once.
As explained by Islamophobes, and Israel flunkies in particular, taqiyya means not only “liar” but much, much more. In their telling, taqiyya not only permits but positively requires Muslims to lie and conceal, about anything and everything, in order to achieve their collective objective of global domination, transforming the entire planet into an Islamic caliphate. Through subterfuge, of course. It is a divine license, directed provided by Allah, to fabricate and dissemble at will. It is the primary religious obligation of every Muslim, whether religious or not, far exceeding the Shahada and the other pillars of the Muslim faith.
It also means that anything a Muslim, or one identified as such, says or writes or does can be dismissed with a single word: taqiyya. A Muslim (or for that matter a Christian Arab or Sikh wearing a turban) states s/he doesn’t want to kill all the Jews? Taqiyya. A Muslim swears allegiance to the US constitution? Taqiyya. A Muslim claims not be an active-duty Jihadi? Taqiyya. And so on. The pinnacle of taqiyya consists of assertions about Israel: occupation, apartheid, genocide? It’s all taqiyya. The very existence of the Palestinian people is, needless to say, the ultimate expression of taqiyya.
THREAD (ALSO POSTED AS SINGLE TEXT ON MY SUBSTACK): During the Gaza Genocide Israel flunkies have become obsessed with the proposition that Palestinians do not exist and never have existed. In their telling, those who call themselves Palestinians are, if anything, just generic Arabs from the Arabian Peninsula, or Egyptians and Jordanians in disguise. They come from virtually everywhere, except Palestine. The surnames of some, which reference foreign cities or countries, prove it, just like Tom Holland and Jools Holland are indisputably Dutch, and the Russian-British scholar Isaiah Berlin was German.
Just as importantly, these ideological fanatics insist that there is not and cannot be such a thing as a Palestinian people. In their telling this political collective is a fabrication, and anyone claiming to be part of it a fraud.
It is the perfect alibi. If the victim does not exist, there cannot have been a crime.