Ori Goldberg Profile picture
Mar 28 8 tweets 2 min read Read on X
1/ A personal note. I am an Israeli Jew. I have been consistently critical of my country's policies and actions with regard to its occupation of Palestinian territories and its punitive war in Gaza. Doing so, I remain an Israeli Jew. I have no other country or place. --->
2/ I don't call for or believe in the dissolution of Israel. I realize that ongoing violent suppression is a prominent element of Israel's core. I will do all I can to change this. I think it can be changed. The initial requirement for me is acknowledgement by Israelis. --->
3/ I have written extensively about the historical and current evils of the occupation. I have criticized the Israeli offensive on Gaza from day one. I believe Israel has spiraled out of control and is showing some of its true colors as a result. This breaks my heart. --->
4/ I believe this can change. I believe it, I suppose, because this is my home. Accepting criticism regarding the foundations of my home does not amount to calling for its demolition as far as I am concerned. Israel will change, or it will drive itself into expiration. --->
5/ I believe in restoring Palestinian rights, including the right of return. I also believe in respectful, equitable cooperation as the only way to make this happen. I understand the inevitable violence of the struggle on both sides. I oppose this violence. --->
6/ This is, for me, a remarkably difficult time. My difficulties pale before the suffering of the Gazans and Palestinians in general. The immediate evils of this "war" must stop - the starvation, the bombings, the inhuman treatment. I know and say this as an Israeli Jew. --->
7/ I post to share the lessons I learn about the zombification of my society in real time. I post to reflect on the truths I am learning about my Israeliness, truths I have engaged with before but was privileged enough not to have seared into my mind. Now they are seared . --->
8/ I would like to thank everyone who reads and responds. I welcome your thoughts and am happy to talk and think. I appreciate your time and consideration. This "war" must end. Palestine must be free. Israel must take responsibility for its actions in order to change profoundly.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Ori Goldberg

Ori Goldberg Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ori_goldberg

Mar 26
1/ The level of cognitive detachment in Israel continues to boggle my mind. While the religious right is happy to embrace the chaos of the end times, the great majority of Jewish Israelis are retreating into two fortresses of denial. --->
2/ The first hails "the real picture". From the walls of this fortress, the war im Gaza is the frontline in a global battle between "moderates" and "extremists". Israel has taken one on the chin for the moderate team having to kill so many civilians in Gaza. --->
3/ Still, there is moderate team without Israel. The other members, committed to war against everything from Communism to Fundamentalism, just need some explaining from a new Israeli PM and all manners of things will be well. The second fortress celebrates responsibility. --->
Read 6 tweets
Mar 23
1/ Tens of thousands of Israelis are demonstrating in support of a prisoner deal. Three words are missing from their cries and signs: "stop the war". They know there will be no deal without, at the very least, a prolonged ceasefire. Still, they will not call for one. --->
2/ Why? Two reasons come to mind. First, Israel has severed the bond between cause and effect Second, many Israelis see war as the ultimate distinction between good and evil. These Israelis are desparate to remain good. The end of the war will deny them their goodness. --->
3/ The massacre of October 7th has, on the one hand, affirmed the power of causality. Israel, in its own eyes, is allowed to annhilate Gaza and the Gazans for all eternity because Hamas atrocities can never be redeemed and can never happen again. --->
Read 12 tweets
Mar 22
1/ The sad, sobering truth about curent Israeli discourse is that there are very few distinctions between left and right. Both are converging, becoming a troubling, solipsistic (and thus violent towards those not included) monologue, signifying nothing but death. --->
2/ on the right, particularly the religious right, this is all quite blunt and straightforward. After the "Economist" published a cover captioned "Israel Alone", one of our more extreme government ministers, Amichai Eliyahu ("Nuke Gaza!") summarized it succinctly. --->
3/ "We are not alone," he tweeted. "God is with us". Straight and to the point. God promised us the land and God fights our wars and God ensures our victory, regardless of our foes or allies. We don't need allies. We are, in every way, right in everything we do. --->
Read 12 tweets
Mar 20
1/ Over the last several days, Israel has carried out assasinations ("targeted killings") of Hamas personnel in Rafah and killed a senior Hamas police commander during a raid on Shifa hospital in Gaza. We can learn something about Israeli reasoning from these killings. --->
2/ all the men killed dealt with logistics and coordination. The senior police officer oversaw the distribution of the humanitarian aid allowed into Gaza. The men killed in Rafah were liaison officers between Hamas' government and mainly non-military units in the field. --->
3/ Why did Israel kill these men? Because, in principle, they represent Hamas attempts to "govern". In Israeli eyes, Hamas is always and entirely a terrorist entity. Enhancing the ability of Hamas to distribute aid or to enforce public order is akin to promoting terrorism. --->
Read 8 tweets
Mar 20
1/ מלה על גל החיסולים של הימים האחרונים, ברפיח ובביה״ח שיפא בעיקר. צה״ל הורג את אנשי חמאס שאחראים על התיאום הלוגיסטי בין דרגי השטח השונים. מה האינטרס הצה״לי? למנוע מחמאס לחזור להיות הגורם שמנהל את השטח. את פאא׳ק מבחוח, ״ראש מנהלת המבצעים״ שחוסל בשיפא, הוצג כטרוריסט בכיר. --->
2/ הוא היה שוטר, פקיד שהיה אמון על תיאום חלוקת משלוחי המזון להם התירה ישראל להכנס לעזה. המחוסלים הטריים ברפיח הוצגו עפ״י הגרסה הרשמית בישראל כאנשי תיאום. למה זה מענין? כי זה מדגים יפה את האופן בו המלחמה הזו מבוססת על שקר. מהו השקר? שאפשר להפריד בין הריסת חמאס להחרבת עזה. --->
3/ כשישראל הורגת את האנשים הללו היא ״מונעת מחמאס לפעול כשלטון״. בעת ובעונה אחת היא מגבירה משמעותית את התוהו ובוהו ברצועה, במיוחד סביב חלוקת המזון שכבר הובילה למותם של מאות מאש צה״ל. אין ברצועה כרגע גורם שיכול לנהל את חלוקת המזון. ישראל לא מעוניינת. אנשי חמאס מסוגלים. --->
Read 6 tweets
Mar 19
1/ Run of the mill Israelis don't talk about the starvation of Gaza. There is a lot of chatter about how Hamas is responsible for the Gazans' plight. There is no mercy for the Gazans who die in the daily bombings and bombardments. Even acknowledgement is rare. --->
2/ "Hamas must be destroyed" is accepted as sufficient reasoning for everything from indiscriminate slaughter to "errors in judgment" made by Israeli field commanders (for example, the destruction of Al-Israa university by Brigadier General Barak Hiram). --->
3/ Presented with such an all-encompassing goal, the "collateral damage" of Gazan deaths is a price Israelis are willing to pay, like Lord Farquad in "Shrek". As long as the narrative can be contained within a military framework Israelis can accept is as "professional". --->
Read 9 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(