GIDs did not cooperate with #CassReview attempt to survey practice.
The state of its medical notes is shocking, and not in line with @gmcuk guidance. #Page137
The NHS adult clinics also fefused to cooperate with the data-matching needed for long-term follow-up study for gender-distressed children. This is an outrageous failure.
#CassReview sometimes uses terminology which is inaccurate, unscientific and confusing - cisgender, assigned at birth, “trans females”. But that does not detract from the many important points she makes.
#CassReview says guidelines drawn up by the Endocrine Society and #WPATH which influenced NHS are based entirely on low-quality sources. The standard of care for gender-distressed children has fallen far short of what this vulnerable population needs and deserves.
#CassReview refutes the suicide myth - there is no evidence that prescribing puberty blockers or cross-sex hormones reduce suicide risk.
#CassReview demolishes the case for a legal ban on so-called “conversion practices”. Calls for medical leaders to come together to “provide leadership and guidance on the clinical management of this population taking account of the findings of this report”.
#CassReview raises serious safeguarding issues: Risks issues are overshadowed when gender becomes the focus.
There was “lack of apparent professional curiosity” at GIDS.
Giving children new NHS numbers makes records of children at risk untraceable.
#CassReview recommends a transitional service for 18 to 25 year olds.
This is a vulnerable point where mental health worsens. Brain maturation continues until age 25. She acknowledges and promotes the need for specialist services for detransitioners.
#CassReview says that what happens in school is important. Her work gives @GillianKeegan all the evidence to drive gender-identity ideology out of the classroom and @educationgovuk the evidence they need to say “no” to social transition.
This review makes clear that those who have led NHS child and adult gender services have serious questions to answer.
If not now, soon, there will have to be an inquiry into what went wrong, with a view to holding those responsible to account.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
- Promote human rights where they relate to biological sex
- Advance education about sex and the law
- Promote the sound administration of the law in relation to sex and equality in the law.
On Monday, I went to an event at University College London, together with Shelley Charlesworth from Transgender Trend. Professor Davina Cooper was presenting on the findings of the Future of Legal Gender research project…
…which received £750,000 in public funding from the Economic and Social Research Council.
Cooper talked about how the project had set out with big ambitions to influence government policy to “decertify” sex and gender, but by the time it ended she was framing it somewhat despondently in terms of envisioning “utopias”.
Now @DHSCgovuk claims '@NHSEngland moved away from WPATH guidelines more than 5 years ago"
@NHSEngland said: "While we are aware of WPATH standards... these do not determine NHS policy."
Scottish Government says @NHSScotland do not have a working relationship with WPATH
WPATH’s influence is all over the NHS
- 2013 govt guide to gender dysphoria services informed by WPATH SOC
- Bernadette Wren, Director at the Tavi told parliament treatment protocols are based on WPATH "almost universally observed in Europe.”
- NHS’s Contract for GIDS repeatedly refers to WPATH SOC up to 2024
- Sandyford clinic in Scotland tells adult patients: “Your treatment will be monitored & run in accordance w WPATH SOC ”
- @gmcuk @TheBMA @rcpsych informed by WPATH standards
-Gendered Intelligence, Mermaids, Stonewall and GIRES promote WPATH as the only acceptable approach.
Polling has shown that a third of people are confused about what “trans woman” means, so it was helpful and appropriate of Webb to explain. If this is not allowed, people will be confused and potentially misled by BBC news stories.
Most media reports in the past fortnight of the conviction and then sentencing of murderer Scarlet Blake referred to Blake as a woman, many without pointing out that he was male or even that he was transgender.
This morning I gave a talk to the sixth form at Verulam School in St Albans. This is the second talk I have given at a school (the first one was to South Hampstead High School in London).
Honestly, these are some of the most nerve-wracking things that I have done. Where do you start telling a story about employment tribunals to children for whom this is all part of the alien world of work? And how many think I am a bigot before I even walk in?
I tell them the story of how a mum from St Albans ended up setting a legal precedent that protects everybody’s rights, about why freedom of speech and pluralism matter, and why the concept of “worthy of respect in a democratic society” is so important. Democracy is about the ability to disagree and to talk about it.