Saul Sadka Profile picture
Apr 11, 2024 • 9 tweets • 3 min read • Read on X
What does the death of Ismail Haniyeh's 3 sons in Gaza City tell us about the state of the war, about Israel's achievements thus far, and what the plan appears to be? (my 1st ever🧵)

While underground infrastructure is found throughout the Strip, it is dense in 2 places: (1/9) Image
Two reasons:

Firstly, these areas, under Gaza City and Khan Yunis/Rafah, are the two large urban aeras, it is easiest and most critical to have such infrastructure.

Second, only in those areas is the water table deep enough to make the basic Hamas tunnels sustainable. (2/9) Image
Apart from Rafah, Israel occupied all the areas where the tunnel network was densest (and was never more than 1km from any urban location). It cleared all these areas, building by building.

(The water table issue is why Israel's initial push was up the beach.) (3/9) Image
With its underground infrastructure destroyed, stripped of its weapons caches and hideouts, Hamas outside Rafah is just another above-ground insurgency, and one much weaker than before, with at least half its trained fighters dead or injured. (4/9)
This is confirmed by Haniyeh's three sons—the ultimate Gaza VIP's, billionaires and terrorist—being forced to travel above ground, in daytime, with the constant buzzing of Israeli drones overhead waiting to send them to paradise.
If they travel above ground, everyone does.(5/9) Image
The withdrawal of Israeli troops to the buffer zones and the corridor now starts to make sense.

The USA demanded a plan for the inevitable Rafah attack, and this withdrawal is stage 1. Northern and central Gaza are being repopulated, aid is flowing. Rafah is emptying. (6/9)
Once Rafah and its surrounds are no longer crammed with displaced people, the IDF will have the ability to remove the terror infrastructure there too, as it has done in the rest of the Strip.

This will not end the war but Hamas will then be a mere above ground insurgency. (7/9) Image
With Hamas cut off from resupply, forced above ground, under constant surveillance, and with a impenetrable buffer between them and Israel, they will not pose a threat.

Israel can let them run out of ammo or move back in to fight a regular urban war against an enemy they already defeated once in 4D battle.
(8/9)
At some point Israel will hold an election.

If that election is held with Sinwar alive, 100+ hostages in tunnels and Hamas still sitting pretty in Gaza, the winner of that election will be whoever can disclaim responsibly and promises to smash Hamas hardest.
Be careful what you wish for. (9/9)Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
怀

Keep Current with Saul Sadka

Saul Sadka Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Saul_Sadka

Nov 19
While the Israeli successes in the Middle East over the last 2 years are astonishing, how has Israel done meeting its war goals in the Gaza Strip?

1. Destroy and disarm Hamas
2. Free the hostages
3. Ensure Gaza no longer threatens Israel

What will be happening in Gaza? (1/8) Image
1. Destroy and disarm Hamas (ā‰ˆ90% achieved)

Hamas has lost around 55% of its territory and about 90% of its initial trained fighting force of 35,000 through death, capture, or defection. While they may have recruited some new men, these recruits are low-quality, and the real bottleneck is arms. They have been hermetically sealed off from resupply for two years. They have lost almost all their heavy weapons and are reduced to IEDs and light arms, using ammunition very sparingly.

Their only real weapons are the Gazan people—more on that below. (2/8)Image
2. Free the hostages (ā‰ˆ99% achieved)

These are the only three hostages still held in Gaza, and all are confirmed dead: Dror Or, Ran Gvili, and Sudthisak Rinthalak. On October 6, 2023—and for many years prior—there were four Israelis held in Gaza, two of them alive. Israel did not go to war for the four; it will not go to war for the three.

So if Israel lacks sufficient motivation to disarm the dregs of Hamas, and the oppressed population lacks the ability, who will? Answer: nobody. So what’s the plan? (3/8)Image
Read 8 tweets
Oct 27
Trump doesn’t get Europe. Trillions spent on windmills that need subsidies, raise electricity prices for everyone, and place an undue burden on the poorest—that’s money well spent, as it allows Europe to restore the landscapes that inspired so many artists like Constable… (1/6) Image
Sicne they also only provide occasional power, you still need all the coal plants, sitting and waiting to be used. But Van Gogh's classic, The Starry Night, is so much better in the original, with the turbines. (2/6) Image
People say that these windmills—sorry, turbines—are hideous and pointless, but who can argue that Da Vinci's masterpiece isn't improved by them? What could possibly make Tuscany more beautiful than more of these? (3/6) Image
Read 6 tweets
Oct 22
Bill Nye thinks the Holocaust could have been avoided if Jews had made more effort to get to know their neighbours.

Zionism means Jews no longer have to stay and die, beg for their lives on bended knee, and can fight back when attacked. That’s why all Jew-haters hate Zionism.
Not all Jews are Zionists, but all Jew-haters are anti-Zionists.
So, aparantly, this clip is ten years old, someone sent it me, and @kahntra posted it recently. It's hard to tell as @billmaher doesn't age.

But so what? The lesson stands. Im fact, even more, since this is before these defamation clowns has the "genocide" or "famine" libels as cover.
Read 4 tweets
Oct 2
As promised, they globalized the intifada again today, this time in Manchester on Yom Kippur, and life for Jews in the UK will never be the same. It might even be the beginning of Jewish life in the UK. It is a black day.(1/9) Image
For decades, British Jews have lived under the threat of Jihadi terror, the vast bulk of the nearly 50,000 UK residents on terror watchlists are Jew-hating Jihadis. For every six Jews, the UK has one suspected Jew-hating terrorist. (2/9) Image
Jewish organizations beg the police and the CPS to pursue cases against people openly inciting hate against Jews, but the police refuse even the most blatant cases.

The Jewish community knows why: There are certain groups the authorities are appeasing at their expense. (3/9) Image
Read 12 tweets
Sep 17
Operation Grim Beeper was the turning point of the war.

A year ago today at this hour, the entire Hezbollah organisation built up over 40 years and at the cost of hundreds of billions was neutered by a mere 50 kilograms of explosives. It precipitated a new Middle East. (1/10)
In seconds it was transformed from the most fearsome terror army the world has ever seen into a rehabilitation charity, with thousands of living anti-martyrs, who will be rolling, castrated examples of what Allah does to people who plan Jihad against Jews into the 22nd century.

So much changed, everything was flipped upside down, and so many things had to line up for this all to occur. (2/10)Image
Hezbollah had been forced, against its will and against the will of its sponsor Iran, to come to the symbolic aid of Hamas, who had failed to understand the plan: wait for an Iranian nuke and only then attack in tandem under a nuclear umbrella.

Sinwar jumped the gun, and from that moment the fate of the entire axis was sealed—just so long as Israel could hold a coherent strategic line. The Biden administration, by holding Israel back and restarting the pace of the main effort in Gaza, accidentally made this all possible. (3/10)Image
Read 10 tweets
Sep 9
HUGE: Israel has struck Hamas leadership in Doha, Qatar! Rumors suggest Khalil al-Haya is among those targeted.

Hamas will be eradicated—its leaders will be hunted down no matter where they are, and no matter how much money their protectors have. Bold stuff from Israel.
I didn't believe Israel would dare attack the Hamas leaders in Qatar, even though they obviously easily could. Qatar alone is defenceless.

I doubt they would have done this without the tacit approval of the Trump admin, and perhaps this was a hint:

How things can change in one day: Yesterday and today. Hamas on the left, IRGC on the right.

Didn't the Hamas guys learn from the 12-day war? All surviving Iranian officials are Israeli spies. Image
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(