Saul Sadka Profile picture
Apr 11, 2024 • 9 tweets • 3 min read • Read on X
What does the death of Ismail Haniyeh's 3 sons in Gaza City tell us about the state of the war, about Israel's achievements thus far, and what the plan appears to be? (my 1st ever🧵)

While underground infrastructure is found throughout the Strip, it is dense in 2 places: (1/9) Image
Two reasons:

Firstly, these areas, under Gaza City and Khan Yunis/Rafah, are the two large urban aeras, it is easiest and most critical to have such infrastructure.

Second, only in those areas is the water table deep enough to make the basic Hamas tunnels sustainable. (2/9) Image
Apart from Rafah, Israel occupied all the areas where the tunnel network was densest (and was never more than 1km from any urban location). It cleared all these areas, building by building.

(The water table issue is why Israel's initial push was up the beach.) (3/9) Image
With its underground infrastructure destroyed, stripped of its weapons caches and hideouts, Hamas outside Rafah is just another above-ground insurgency, and one much weaker than before, with at least half its trained fighters dead or injured. (4/9)
This is confirmed by Haniyeh's three sons—the ultimate Gaza VIP's, billionaires and terrorist—being forced to travel above ground, in daytime, with the constant buzzing of Israeli drones overhead waiting to send them to paradise.
If they travel above ground, everyone does.(5/9) Image
The withdrawal of Israeli troops to the buffer zones and the corridor now starts to make sense.

The USA demanded a plan for the inevitable Rafah attack, and this withdrawal is stage 1. Northern and central Gaza are being repopulated, aid is flowing. Rafah is emptying. (6/9)
Once Rafah and its surrounds are no longer crammed with displaced people, the IDF will have the ability to remove the terror infrastructure there too, as it has done in the rest of the Strip.

This will not end the war but Hamas will then be a mere above ground insurgency. (7/9) Image
With Hamas cut off from resupply, forced above ground, under constant surveillance, and with a impenetrable buffer between them and Israel, they will not pose a threat.

Israel can let them run out of ammo or move back in to fight a regular urban war against an enemy they already defeated once in 4D battle.
(8/9)
At some point Israel will hold an election.

If that election is held with Sinwar alive, 100+ hostages in tunnels and Hamas still sitting pretty in Gaza, the winner of that election will be whoever can disclaim responsibly and promises to smash Hamas hardest.
Be careful what you wish for. (9/9)Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Saul Sadka

Saul Sadka Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Saul_Sadka

Apr 15
There's an easy way to know if someone has taken Qatari money: Have they said nice things about Qatar?

Qatar isn't Italy or Norway. It's just a little patch of sand with a few gaudy towers and 2,000,000 semi-slaves to serve its little theocratic tribal dictatorship with a population smaller than Lexington, Kentucky. So if you "like" Qatar, it's because they pay you.

Feel free to share examples of people saying nice things about Qatar in the comments.Image
So, if someone goes to Italy, and comes back gushing about how great the food is, they did not necessarily get paid to do this. However, if they have the same reaction to Qatar, they did. Image
Another example: if someone goes to California and reports that the climate was wonderful, he wasn't necessarily paid to say that. If he does the same in Qatar, he was. Image
Read 6 tweets
Apr 5
Why is Heinz Ketchup Called "Tomato Seasoning" in Israel—and How Trump's Tariffs could end up being great for Israelis.

The victims might be the monopolies, Netanyahu and the public might be the victors. This presents huge opportunities for the savvy. Here’s how: (1/8)Image
When Israel announced a few days ago that it was cancelling all tariffs on American goods, it was essentially bluffing.

There have been virtually no tariffs on American goods for over 30 years. The total amount collected annually was around $40 million — about 0.02% of the Israeli government’s budget. (2/8)Image
One of the major issues with Israel’s otherwise thriving economy is the high cost of goods, especially groceries, which are on average 50% more expensive than in other OECD countries.

So why hasn't anyone taken advantage of the obvious arbitrage opportunity? If there are no tariffs on American goods, wouldn’t enterprising individuals flood the Israeli market with American products, bringing prices down to U.S. levels (plus shipping and local distribution)? (3/8)Image
Read 11 tweets
Mar 26
We can learn some critical facts from the current clan-based protests in Gaza:🧵

1. The Gazans know they leaders failed.
2. How Israel has infiltrated the Hams command.
3. Why the clans are critical to the present and future.
4. How you can defeat ideas, actually. (1/5)Image
1. The people of Gaza fully understand that their Jihadi leaders have lost the war, and that their suffering continues only because they—and their children—are the final weapons in the arsenal.

This realization is crucial, as it is essential for both sides that the Gazan population—brainwashed into Jihad over decades—can never again be manipulated into believing that self-destructive attacks on their neighbors might somehow bring them joy. (2/5)Image
2. If hundreds are willing to protest publicly—despite the known predilection of their tormentors to execute all dissenters—we can be sure that thousands have betrayed they privately to the IDF. This would explain the sudden uptick in Israel's ability to pinpoint enemy leadership in the Strip. (3/5)Image
Read 7 tweets
Feb 24
Ehud Olmert has revealed publicly for the first time the map of the peace offer that Mahmoud Abbas rejected in 2008 (the picture on the right is Abbas' sketch of it.

Abbas rejected this ridiculously generous offer and now there will never be a Palestinian state in any borders. Image
Image
The best hope for the Arabs of the southern Levant is something modeled on the UAE, but demilitarized. Perhaps the "United Sheikhdoms of Palestine."

Each of the major cities (Gaza, Khan Yunis, Hebron, Bethlehem, Ramallah, Kalkilya, Nablus, Tulkarem, Jenin, Jericho), along with their hinterland villages, will decide how to run their own lives, and can federate to whatever extend they chose.

But the Israeli public is not going to be ready for anything more than that for a very very long time, and they have a veto.
I like how the comments are split between those accusing Olmert of being a foreign agent and those accusing Abbas of being a Mossad agent.
Read 4 tweets
Feb 23
These are the 24 hostages still held in Gaza who will not be among the four released on Thursday. The remains of 34 others, who have been declared dead by the IDF, are also being held.🧵

From top left:

1. Eitan Horn
2. Segev Kalfon
3. Bipin Joshi
4. Guy Gilboa-Dalal
5. Avinatan Or
6.  Yosef Haim Ohana
7.  Nimrod Cohen
8.  Rom Braslavski
9. Evyatar David
10. David Cunio
11. Tamir Nimrodi
12.  Bar Kupershtein
13.  Gali Berman
14.  Eitan Mor
15.  Edan Alexander
16.  Pinta Nattapong
17. Omri Miran
18. Elkana Buchbut
19. Alon Ohel
20. Matan Zangauker
21.  Ziv Berman
22.  Ariel Cunio
23.  Maxim Herkin
24.  Matan AngrestImage
1. Eitan Horn (37) was captured alongside his brother Iair, there are serious concerns for his heath. Image
2. Segev Kalfon (26) was kidnaped from the Nova festival. His family recently received a 'sign of life'. Image
Read 26 tweets
Feb 12
Walls. What are they good for? And why Jordan should beg Israel to annex the Jordan Valley—and why it probably will soon.

Israel built two walls. One a complete success; the other a total failure. The Israel–Egypt border fence succeed while the Israel–Gaza one failed? (1/12)Image
Image
Faced with an endless wave of drug smuggling and human trafficking from Africa toward Israel across the lawless Sinai desert, and increasing public unrest about the approximately 80,000 illegal immigrants (about 1% of Israel’s population at the time) who had arrived in previous years, Israel built a 150‑mile barrier along the border with Egypt in 2010.

It cost about $3 million per mile and took three years to complete across the mostly mountainous, arid terrain. (2/12)Image
Before this, the border had been marked by a bare‑metal fence that was easily skipped over and had mostly collapsed or disintegrated into the sand. The new barrier reduced smuggling and human trafficking to a trickle.

But an even more sophisticated barrier between Gaza and Israel failed completely, resulting in a war that has been ongoing for a year and a half with no end in sight. Why did one fail and one succeed? (3/12)Image
Read 13 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(