Saul Sadka Profile picture
Apr 11, 2024 9 tweets 3 min read Read on X
What does the death of Ismail Haniyeh's 3 sons in Gaza City tell us about the state of the war, about Israel's achievements thus far, and what the plan appears to be? (my 1st ever🧵)

While underground infrastructure is found throughout the Strip, it is dense in 2 places: (1/9) Image
Two reasons:

Firstly, these areas, under Gaza City and Khan Yunis/Rafah, are the two large urban aeras, it is easiest and most critical to have such infrastructure.

Second, only in those areas is the water table deep enough to make the basic Hamas tunnels sustainable. (2/9) Image
Apart from Rafah, Israel occupied all the areas where the tunnel network was densest (and was never more than 1km from any urban location). It cleared all these areas, building by building.

(The water table issue is why Israel's initial push was up the beach.) (3/9) Image
With its underground infrastructure destroyed, stripped of its weapons caches and hideouts, Hamas outside Rafah is just another above-ground insurgency, and one much weaker than before, with at least half its trained fighters dead or injured. (4/9)
This is confirmed by Haniyeh's three sons—the ultimate Gaza VIP's, billionaires and terrorist—being forced to travel above ground, in daytime, with the constant buzzing of Israeli drones overhead waiting to send them to paradise.
If they travel above ground, everyone does.(5/9) Image
The withdrawal of Israeli troops to the buffer zones and the corridor now starts to make sense.

The USA demanded a plan for the inevitable Rafah attack, and this withdrawal is stage 1. Northern and central Gaza are being repopulated, aid is flowing. Rafah is emptying. (6/9)
Once Rafah and its surrounds are no longer crammed with displaced people, the IDF will have the ability to remove the terror infrastructure there too, as it has done in the rest of the Strip.

This will not end the war but Hamas will then be a mere above ground insurgency. (7/9) Image
With Hamas cut off from resupply, forced above ground, under constant surveillance, and with a impenetrable buffer between them and Israel, they will not pose a threat.

Israel can let them run out of ammo or move back in to fight a regular urban war against an enemy they already defeated once in 4D battle.
(8/9)
At some point Israel will hold an election.

If that election is held with Sinwar alive, 100+ hostages in tunnels and Hamas still sitting pretty in Gaza, the winner of that election will be whoever can disclaim responsibly and promises to smash Hamas hardest.
Be careful what you wish for. (9/9)Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Saul Sadka

Saul Sadka Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Saul_Sadka

Jul 27
There’s a special place in hell for the editors & journalists who took Hamas’ photos of children with congenital conditions (and parents with double chins) and broadcast them to their already radicalized audience with the message, ‘Look what the Jews did.’

Remember their names.Image
One of the many consolations of the demise of the newspaper industry is that this is the last generation of journalists.
This was a coordinated, Qatar-run campaign designed to help Hamas in its bargaining efforts. By spreading these libels, they not only harmed Israel and the hostages, betrayed Trump, and endangered Jews worldwide—they also guaranteed more suffering for the people of Gaza.

It incentivized further immiseration of the Gazans by Hamas.

No forgiveness for anyone involved.
Read 6 tweets
Jul 24
America's new Hitler Youth. Well done everybody.

This is not entirely without precedent: Image
Looks like a large cohort of American youth needs denazification. Shocking.
Read 6 tweets
Jul 22
This insane and completely baseless "Protocols of the Elders of Zion"-level conspiracy wasn’t just broadcast on LBC—the producers liked it so much, they clipped it and shared it across all their social media platforms. If any other minority were slandered like this, the UK police would be knocking on doors and making arrests.

Historically, spreading lies about how Juice crave gentile blood was always, always, a preamble to their murder. This time will be no different, and LBC and all the rest will share in the blood-guilt.Image
We can only assume that the originator of the conspiracy knows so little about Judaism that they assume that since Christians have "Sunday School" to learn about their faith, Jews would have "Shabbat School." Evil and stupid stuff from LBC.

Why, one might ask, would anyone believe such nonsense? Such a stupid lie so easily disproven? And then broadcast it to millions?
Read 4 tweets
Jul 20
The 15,000,000 Jews alive today are the product of 40 generations of people who said "no," often at great cost. Evolutionary selection pressures made them countercultural contratians.

They aren't "chosen"—that's a misunderstanding of the theology. They are the "choosers." (1/3) Image
Image
And this—not any extra level of innate intelligence (some Asian groups are smarter on average), nor in-group clannishness (many cultural groups are far more nepotistic)—is the reason Jews have had an outsized impact on so many fields of human endeavour. (2/3) Image
The many agreeable Jews willing to go along with the crowd—follow Jesus & his disciples, or Muhammad & his—are not the ancestors of modern Jews. If you're a Jew today, it's because there is a 40-generation-long chain of contrarians baked into every cell of your body. (3/3) Image
Read 6 tweets
Jul 4
As Francesca Albanese tries to revive BDS—just as Arab states clamour for peace & trade with Israel—few have noticed that next week (July 9) marks 20 years since the BDS movement set out to defeat Israel by isolating & boycotting it. 🧵

So let’s review the results: (1/8)
Over that period, Israel has overtaken all the major European nations in terms of GDP per capita and now boasts the sixth highest GDP per capita in the world, of all nations with 10 million population or more. (2/8) Image
Far from being isolated, the Israeli passport is now one of the most powerful in the world: Israelis enjoy visa-free or visa-on-arrival access to 170 countries, ranking 19th globally, and that is set to expand along with the Abraham Accords. (3/8) Image
Read 10 tweets
Jul 2
There are three goals for the war. Forcing Israel to end the war prematurely means you can only pick two:

1. Bring home the last 20 hostages (and the 30 bodies being held as bargaining chips).

2. Ensure Hamas can never again pose a strategic threat to Israel.

3. Free the two million Gazans from Hamas— a prerequisite for any form of meaningful rebuilding.

Israel has already achieved point 2. Hamas is now permanently boxed in behind a large buffer zone, and even a small IDF presence with close surveillance ensures they can never rearm or threaten Israelis again.

So, from a purely cynical Israeli perspective, a deal that ends the hostage situation in return for allowing Hamas to remain in some form of power might be acceptable. True, they won't be able to claim "Total Victory" while Hamas still rules the rubble and terrorizes its own people—but Total Victory would have come with Total Responsibility, and a new set of risks. For most Israelis, “We reduced them to a harmless (to us) rabble” is victory enough.

The people who have been clamoring for a ceasefire since 2023 always supported Hamas. They never cared a jot for the Gazans, whom they saw only as useful tools. If they had even an ounce of humanity—or even common sense—they would recognize that Hamas is now only a threat to the Gazans themselves, and that a Total Israeli Victory is what they should be calling for too.Image
Article from the Jewish Chronicle:

thejc.com/opinion/if-a-c…
Note that this would be the same policy Israel took in Lebanon and Iran. Bringing about regime change immediately via military force is neither easy nor desirable. Better, reduce the enemy threat to you to something manageable in the long term, and let the locals fight it out.
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(