GemsOfINDOLOGY Profile picture
Apr 11, 2024 15 tweets 11 min read Read on X
Closed, endogamous communities have a rich history in Southern Asia. Throughout the past millennium, they have been referred to as 'jati' in Sanskrit, 'qaum' in Arabic, 'zat' in Persian, among other terms.

Interestingly, there is no direct equivalent for "caste" in any Indian or Asian language, despite its pervasive use today in Indian public and policy discussions.

The term was originally introduced as 'casta' by Iberians – Portuguese and Spanish – first in the Iberian peninsula and later in Asia and the Americas. However, the precise ways in which this term was utilized – descriptively, administratively, and sociologically – remain less explored.

There have been classification in most parts of the world based on their status, color, hierarchy etc.

Lets delve

#Bookmark this #thread on Caste system in the ancient world

1/Closed, endogamous communities have a rich history in Southern Asia. Throughout the past millennium, they have been referred to as 'jati' in Sanskrit, 'qaum' in Arabic, 'zat' in Persian, among other terms.   Interestingly, there is no direct equivalent for "caste" in any Indian or Asian language, despite its pervasive use today in Indian public and policy discussions.   The term was originally introduced as 'casta' by Iberians – Portuguese and Spanish – first in the Iberian peninsula and later in Asia and the Americas. However, the precise ways in which this term was utilized – de...
The term "caste" has a rich history. Originally derived from Spanish and Portuguese, it referred to lineage or tribe. The word took on its modern sense when Portuguese colonizers encountered the Indian social groups in 1498, where it described endogamous social divisions.

The term "caste" was first used in English in 1613 in the context of India. In Latin America, "caste" is also used to refer to a racial classification system based on ancestry. Despite the linguistic link between the Latin American and South Asian systems, the comparability of the two remains a subject of debate.

Historically, European societies were stratified into closed social systems like nobility, clergy, bourgeoisie, and peasants. Each group had distinct privileges and rights that were inherited and not based on wealth or citizenship. Inter-caste marriage often led to loss of privileges. Some countries gave titles to these groups with their own codes of behavior and dress. These closed social classes were sometimes referred to as estates in parts of Europe.

In European society, below the recognized estates, a large group of serfs served those with status. Serfs endured into the mid-19th century, with limited rights and restricted mobility. Marriage and living arrangements were controlled by State, Church, landowners, and local custom.

2/The term "caste" has a rich history. Originally derived from Spanish and Portuguese, it referred to lineage or tribe. The word took on its modern sense when Portuguese colonizers encountered the Indian social groups in 1498, where it described endogamous social divisions.  The term "caste" was first used in English in 1613 in the context of India. In Latin America, "caste" is also used to refer to a racial classification system based on ancestry. Despite the linguistic link between the Latin American and South Asian systems, the comparability of the two remains...
The Sistema de Castas in colonial New Spain classified people by race, with Spaniard as the most desirable and Negro as the least. Blacks were marginalized, while some of African descent achieved elevated status within the system.

1. Peninsulares: Spaniards born in Spain, held highest status in colonies.

2. Criollos: Spaniards born in Americas, seen as inferior, faced discrimination.

3. Mestizos: Mixed European and Indigenous ancestry, middle hierarchy position.

4. Mulattos: Mixed European and African ancestry, faced discrimination.

5. Zambos: Mixed Indigenous and African ancestry, marginalized.

6. Indigenous peoples: Native Americans, subjected to forced labor and discrimination.

7. Africans: Enslaved, at the bottom of social hierarchy.

3/The Sistema de Castas in colonial New Spain classified people by race, with Spaniard as the most desirable and Negro as the least. Blacks were marginalized, while some of African descent achieved elevated status within the system.  1. Peninsulares: Spaniards born in Spain, held highest status in colonies.  2. Criollos: Spaniards born in Americas, seen as inferior, faced discrimination.  3. Mestizos: Mixed European and Indigenous ancestry, middle hierarchy position.  4. Mulattos: Mixed European and African ancestry, faced discrimination.  5. Zambos: Mixed Indigenous and African ancestry, mar...
In ancient Japan, there were social classes that influenced people's lives and opportunities.

1. **Emperor and Imperial Family**: The divine rulers with political power.

2. **Samurai**: Warrior-administrators following bushido.

3. **Nobility**: Courtiers, daimyo, and aristocrats holding land and power.

4. **Peasants and Farmers**: Majority of the population providing essential resources.

5. **Artisans and Merchants**: Despite being looked down upon by samurai and nobility for their focus on trade, artisans and merchants were another class.

6. **Outcasts**: Outcast communities like eta (associated with impure tasks) and hinin (street performers and beggars) faced discrimination.

4/In ancient Japan, there were social classes that influenced people's lives and opportunities.  1. **Emperor and Imperial Family**: The divine rulers with political power.  2. **Samurai**: Warrior-administrators following bushido.  3. **Nobility**: Courtiers, daimyo, and aristocrats holding land and power.  4. **Peasants and Farmers**: Majority of the population providing essential resources.  5. **Artisans and Merchants**: Despite being looked down upon by samurai and nobility for their focus on trade, artisans and merchants were another class.  6. **Outcasts**: Outcast communities like eta...
In ancient Korea, the social structure was primarily based on Confucian principles and the influence of the ruling class.

1. **Yangban**: Top social class - scholars, bureaucrats, and land-owning aristocrats with political power.

2. **Commoners**: Farmers, artisans, merchants - lower social status compared to yangban.

3. **Chungin**: Middle class - professionals like doctors, teachers, minor officials, below yangban in status.

4. **Sangmin**: Lowest class - laborers, servants, limited rights.

5. **Cheonmin**: Sub-class of sangmin - slaves, few rights.

Similar to Bhartiya Varna system, it was possible for individuals to move between classes through education, achievement, or royal decree. Additionally, certain professions were hereditary within families, contributing to the preservation of social distinctions over generations.

Commoners in the Joseon dynasty wore straw hats and shoes. Their clothing was made of hemp. They were only allowed to have thatch roofs. People of the yangban social class and above were entitled to build ceramic roofs.

5/In ancient Korea, the social structure was primarily based on Confucian principles and the influence of the ruling class.  1. **Yangban**: Top social class - scholars, bureaucrats, and land-owning aristocrats with political power.  2. **Commoners**: Farmers, artisans, merchants - lower social status compared to yangban.  3. **Chungin**: Middle class - professionals like doctors, teachers, minor officials, below yangban in status.  4. **Sangmin**: Lowest class - laborers, servants, limited rights.  5. **Cheonmin**: Sub-class of sangmin - slaves, few rights.  Similar to Bhartiya Varna system,...
Image
In ancient China, there was a social hierarchy based on Confucian principles and influenced by the feudal system. This social structure had distinct classes with limited social mobility.
1. **Scholars and Officials (Shi)**: Educated in Confucianism, held government positions, highly respected for knowledge and moral integrity.

2. **Farmers (Nong)**: Backbone of society, respected for agricultural contributions.

3. **Artisans (Gong)**: Skilled workers producing goods like pottery, textiles, and metalwork; had some social status below scholars and farmers.

4. **Merchants (Shang)**: Engaged in trade and commerce, viewed with suspicion due to perceived exploitation.

5. **Military (Shi)**: Included soldiers and officials, respected for defense role but lower in status.

6. **Slaves and Servants**: Bottom of hierarchy, had few rights, considered property.

Ancient China had limited social mobility, emphasizing stability within classes. Some rose through education, military success, or favor from elites, but overall, the social hierarchy remained stable, reinforcing divisions.

6/In ancient China, there was a social hierarchy based on Confucian principles and influenced by the feudal system. This social structure had distinct classes with limited social mobility. 1. **Scholars and Officials (Shi)**: Educated in Confucianism, held government positions, highly respected for knowledge and moral integrity.  2. **Farmers (Nong)**: Backbone of society, respected for agricultural contributions.  3. **Artisans (Gong)**: Skilled workers producing goods like pottery, textiles, and metalwork; had some social status below scholars and farmers. 4. **Merchants (Shang)**: Engaged ...
In ancient Russia, society was structured hierarchically based on social classes and feudal relationships.
1. **Nobility (Boyars)**: The ruling class with political, military, and administrative power.

2. **Clergy**: Orthodox Church leaders with spiritual authority, land, and wealth.

3. **Peasants (Serfs)**: Majority of population tied to nobility or church lands, with limited rights.

4. **Merchants and Artisans**: Middle class in medieval Russia involved in trade, crafts, and economic activities.

5. **Cossacks**: Skilled warriors along borders with semi-independent status.

6. **Outcasts and Marginalized Groups**: Criminals, vagrants, and foreigners faced social stigma in medieval Russia.

While these social groups existed and interacted within Russian society, Social mobility could occur through various means, including military service, education, or economic success, although the opportunities were often limited based on one's birth and social status.

7/Image
Ancient Britain, particularly during the medieval period, society was stratified based on social classes and feudal relationships, similar to many European societies of that time.

1. **Nobility and Aristocracy**: Land-owning elites at the top of society who held power and often served as knights or lords.

2. **Clergy**: Religious leaders with significant influence associated with the Church.

3. **Knights and Vassals**: Warriors who served nobility for land, protection, or privileges in the feudal system.
4. **Merchants and Tradespeople**: Middle-class included merchants, traders, and skilled craftsmen contributing to the economy and urban development.

5. **Peasants and Serfs**: Majority were peasants or serfs working land owned by nobility or Church, with limited rights tied to feudal obligations.

6. **Outlaws and Marginalized Groups**: Included outlaws, beggars, and marginalized groups facing social stigma or discrimination.

Social mobility in medieval Britain was possible but often limited by birth, status, and opportunities available within one's social class. Education, military service, or economic success could sometimes enable individuals to move up the social ladder, but the structure of feudal society generally maintained social divisions and hierarchies.

8/Ancient Britain, particularly during the medieval period, society was stratified based on social classes and feudal relationships, similar to many European societies of that time. 1. **Nobility and Aristocracy**: Land-owning elites at the top of society who held power and often served as knights or lords.  2. **Clergy**: Religious leaders with significant influence associated with the Church.  3. **Knights and Vassals**: Warriors who served nobility for land, protection, or privileges in the feudal system. 4. **Merchants and Tradespeople**: Middle-class included merchants, traders, and skil...
In ancient Ireland, society was organized along distinct social classes and hierarchies based on various factors such as land ownership, wealth, and political power.
1. **Kings and Nobility**: Held political power, controlled land and resources.

2. **Freemen (Aos Dána)**: Skilled craftsmen, poets, scholars contributing culturally and economically.

3. **Semi-Free and Tenant Farmers**: Worked the land with some independence and rights.

4. **Clients and Dependents**: Some individuals served noble landowners in exchange for benefits.

5. **Slaves and Servants**: Slavery in ancient Ireland was not widespread; slaves were often captives or debtors, with limited rights.

6. **Outcasts and Marginalized Groups**: Groups like criminals, foreigners, or people with disabilities may have faced social exclusion.

Social mobility in ancient Ireland was possible, especially through skills, achievements, or alliances with powerful individuals or families. The importance of kinship ties, clan affiliations, and honor played a significant role in shaping social relationships and status within the community.

9/Image
Ancient Egypt society was hierarchically structured with different social classes and roles.

1. **Pharaoh and Royalty**: Pharaoh was divine ruler with absolute authority. Royal family and queen held high status.

2. **Priests and Nobles**: Below pharaoh, priests and nobles managed temples, conducted rituals, and had political influence.

3. **Scribes and Officials**: Scribes were educated individuals in bureaucratic roles, responsible for record-keeping and government tasks.

4. **Craftsmen and Artisans**: Skilled workers made pottery, jewelry, textiles, and buildings, boosting the economy.

5. **Farmers and Laborers**: Most people farmed and did manual labor like construction.

6. **Slaves and Servants**: Some worked as servants, laborers, or soldiers under ownership, less rigidly than in other societies.

Social mobility in ancient Egypt was limited, mainly based on skills and contributions. Social status was usually inherited or linked to occupation and social groups. The hierarchy was connected to religious beliefs, political power, and economic roles.

10/Ancient Egypt society was hierarchically structured with different social classes and roles.  1. **Pharaoh and Royalty**: Pharaoh was divine ruler with absolute authority. Royal family and queen held high status.  2. **Priests and Nobles**: Below pharaoh, priests and nobles managed temples, conducted rituals, and had political influence.  3. **Scribes and Officials**: Scribes were educated individuals in bureaucratic roles, responsible for record-keeping and government tasks.  4. **Craftsmen and Artisans**: Skilled workers made pottery, jewelry, textiles, and buildings, boosting the economy...
While in most part of the world, the caste system is abolished by law or by the society. In ancient India, people were born as Shudra and earned their varna through their activities

There was no Slavery and caste system in India as noted by Magathenese during 3rd century BCE.

Bharat had profession based democratic system. This system existed untill 18th century AD as noted by Adams in his research


11/
jstor.org/stable/3632125
None of the pics are mine
Src Internet.

Expect a continuous update


12/jhiblog.org/2018/05/30/wha…
French Untouchables : "Cagots"

Cagots were usually segregated into separate quarters, known as crestianies in the past and cagoteries from the 16th century onwards. These hamlets were often located on the outskirts of villages. In Béarn, for instance, Cagots, many of whom were carpenters, were distributed similarly to other craftsmen, who were mainly concentrated in the piedmont region.

Cagots were forbidden to marry outside their community, resulting in enforced endogamy. However, in certain regions during later centuries, like Béarn, they were permitted to marry non-Cagots, but the non-Cagot spouse would then be considered a Cagot. Additionally, they were prohibited from entering taverns or using public fountains.

13/Image
Untouchables in China : Tankas

The Tankas are a sinicised ethnic group in Southern China traditionally living on boats along the coast. Some still fish from boats, preserving native traditions not found in Han culture.

They were once considered outcasts and called "sea gypsies." Tankas' origins trace back to the Baiyue ethnic minorities of southern China. Some Tankas also live in parts of Vietnam as a subgroup of the Ngái ethnicity.

14/Image
Untouchables in Yemen : Al Muhamashin

The Al-Muhamashīn, also known as the marginalized ones (Arabic: المهمشين), were previously referred to as al-Akhdām, Akhdām, or Achdām (Arabic: الأخدام) which translates to "the servants" in Arabic. They are an Arabic-speaking ethnic group residing in Yemen. While they are Arabic-speaking Muslims like most other Yemenis, the Muhamashīn are placed at the bottom of the caste system which was supposedly abolished. They face social segregation from other Yemenis and are mainly employed in menial jobs in the country's major cities. Unofficial estimates suggest that the Muhamashīn population ranges from 500,000 to 3,500,000 individuals.

Origins

The exact origins of the Akhdam are unclear, with some speculating that they are descendants of African slaves or soldiers from the Kingdom of Aksum in the 6th century. There is a popular belief that they are the offspring of Ethiopian Aksumites who settled in Yemen during the Ethiopian occupation of the region in pre-Islamic times. It is said that when these troops were driven out at the beginning of the Islamic era, some Ethiopian migrants decided to stay, giving rise to the Akhdam community.

15/Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with GemsOfINDOLOGY

GemsOfINDOLOGY Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @GemsOfINDOLOGY

Apr 5
1️⃣ The Vedas were not composed "somewhere in ancient India".

They name three rivers: Ganga, Yamuna, Saraswati. That confluence is today's Haryana belt.

This isn't ideology. This is internal geographic evidence the texts themselves provide.

So why does nobody mention the location? 🌊

#HaryanaFalse-color satellite map showing the Saraswati, Indus and other river channels across Rajasthan and Haryana, with cities Jaisalmer and Jodhpur labeled.
2️⃣ Now listen to the "Dehati" speech of Haryana.

"Tu kit ja sai"
"Tu ke kha sai"
"Tu ke pi sai"

These aren't translations of Sanskrit.
They ARE Sanskrit sentences after 3,000 years of phonetic erosion.

The rural tongue is the archive. Six Haryanavi/hariyanaka women in colorful salwar kameez stand beside a red agricultural seeder on a paved courtyard with green fields and trees behind them.
3️⃣ tvam kutra gacchasi → tu kit ja sai
tvam kim khādasi → tu ke kha sai

Same syntax. Same verb roots. Only endings simplified.

This is linguistic continuity, not borrowing. Not revival. Not reconstruction.

Just unbroken speech, wearing down naturally over millennia. Image
Image
Image
Read 7 tweets
Mar 3
1️⃣ A 10,000 BCE cave painting just cracked open India's migration mystery

Bhimbetka artists drew a two-horned rhino. The species never lived in central India.

But before we decode ancestral memory, let's talk about colonial amnesia.

Before 1800, approximately 20,000 rhinos roamed Bengal and Assam.

By 1908? Barely 200. 🦏💰

#DecolonisationImage
2️⃣ British trophy hunting didn't just reduce numbers. It systematically erased a species from entire geographies.

Major-General Richard Carnac killed 30 rhinos in a single year near Purnea, Bihar, 1780s. Sport, they called it. Extinction engineering, more accurately.

Each horn fetched £100-150 in Victorian markets. Aphrodisiac myth met colonial greed.Image
3️⃣ The Bhimbetka paintings now make perfect sense.

Austroasiatic peoples migrated from Southeast Asia through Indonesia-Thailand-Myanmar around 10,000 years ago—the exact route Sumatran rhinos took. They carried ancestral memory of two-horned creatures, painted them centuries later at Bhimbetka.

January 2024: Tamil Nadu excavations at Molapalayam unearth 3,600-year-old rhino bones. First direct evidence of Indian one-horned rhinos in deep South.
Read 8 tweets
Feb 22
1/ Aryan Migration Theory has a math problem.

Not political. Not ideological. Mathematical.

If sophisticated Indo-Europeans brought decimal systems to India around 1500 BCE, show me their source culture's mathematics. 🔢

I'll wait. Image
2/ Reconstructed Proto-Indo-European:

Counting to 100 ✓
Basic addition/multiplication ✓
Systematic large numbers ✗
Decimal place value ✗
Zero as concept ✗
Cosmological calculations ✗

Pontic-Caspian steppe, 4000-2500 BCE.
No mathematical texts. No astronomical observatories.Image
3/ Compare what supposedly migrated TO India:

Greek: imported Egyptian geometry, Babylonian astronomy
Latin: borrowed Greek mathematics wholesale
German: million (Latin), Milliarde (French)
Slavic: миллион (million) - borrowed

Every Indo-European branch borrowed large number terms.Image
Read 10 tweets
Feb 17
THREAD 4
WHEN LAW REPLACED CUSTOM
(surnames, forms, the myth of timeless patriarchy)

1️⃣
This is where the break happens.

Not in ancient India.
Not in temples.
Not in epics.

But in files, registers, and forms. Image
2️⃣
Pre-modern India ran on custom.

Identity was local.
Lineage could be maternal.
Marriage could be flexible.

The system worked because society did not need every child tied to a named father.
3️⃣
Colonial administration could not function like that.

The state needed:
Land titles.
Tax rolls.
Census categories.
Inheritance clarity.

Custom was messy.
Plurality was inefficient.

So lineage had to be fixed.
Read 8 tweets
Feb 15
ASI calls it a "graceful threshold of history."

October 1502: 400 pilgrims locked in a ship and burned alive at sea by the man this arch honors.

This is what government curation looks like when it erases inconvenient details.

Thread on what ASI forgot to mention. 🧵

#GemsofASI MNI500A stone relief features a figure dressed as a viceroy, holding a sword, near a coat of arms and inscriptions, symbolizing colonial history.
Vasco da Gama's second voyage, October 1502:

Intercepted the pilgrim ship Miri near Madayi. 400+ passengers. 50 women and children.

Looted it. Locked them inside. Set it ablaze.

Eyewitnesses Thomé Lopes and Gaspar Correia documented mothers holding babies through portholes.

*ps pic AI generated
2/Image
Francisco da Gama built this arch in 1600 during his viceroyalty (1597-1600).

Historical record by then:

• 300 temples demolished in Bardez (1567)
• Goa Inquisition active (1560-1812, 16,000+ documented trials)
• Dec 4, 1567 decree: Hindu marriages, sacred threads, cremations banned

3/Image
Read 6 tweets
Feb 10
Thread 3

WHEN WOMEN WERE LINEAGE, NOT DEPENDENTS
(Travancore, matriliny, 1920s)

1️⃣
Here is the part most people don’t expect.

These systems did not vanish in antiquity.
They survived into the 20th century.

This is not rock art.
This is documentation. Image
2️⃣
In parts of Kerala and Travancore, lineage followed the woman.

Property.
Household identity.
Social continuity.

Children belonged to the mother’s line.
Not the father’s surname.

This was not chaos.
It was a functioning social order.
3️⃣
Relationships were recognised through custom, not sacrament.

Sambandham-type unions existed.
Women could enter and exit relationships.
Sexual exclusivity was not the foundation of legitimacy.

A child did not need a certified father to be socially valid.

That detail matters.
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(