.@KirstieMAllsopp I'm astounded by this comment. One of the gender ideologues' favourite slogans is 'no debate'. Opponents have been attacked, vilified, subject to discipline at work, had their lives overturned and lost their careers, all for the crime of wanting a debate. 1/13
Sonia Appleby, an experienced psychotherapist working at the now discredited Tavistock clinic, was monstered for raising concerns. A tribunal found that her professional reputation had been damaged and 'prevented her from proper work on safeguarding'. 2/13 bbc.co.uk/news/uk-584532…
Sue Evans, a nurse who also worked at the Tavistock and was extremely worried that children were being harmed, tried to raise the alarm. She took concerns to management but was 'alienated' and subsequently left for the sake of her own mental health. 3/13crowdjustice.com/case/protect-c…
Dr David Bell, a distinguished psychiatrist who shared Evan's and Appleby's concerns, submitted a report detailing whistle-blowers' claims, and the trust's response was to attempt to open an investigation into him. 4/13 theguardian.com/society/2021/m…
James Esses, who was doing a Masters Degree in psychotherapy, was expelled from his course for speaking out about the impact of gender ideology on child safeguarding. 5/13 dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1…
In Canada, Kenneth Zucker, former head of the Child Youth and Family Gender Identity Clinic, was fired for questioning whether automatic affirmation of children in their trans identities was the best treatment model. 6/13 juliebindel.substack.com/p/a-fascinatin…
In the US, trans man Scott Newgent (@NotScottNewgent) has made it his life's mission to raise the alarm about the dangers of transitioning children. He's lost his career for speaking out. 7/13
@NotScottNewgent Jo Phoenix, professor of criminology at the Open University, was harassed and bullied because of her opposition to gender identity ideology, severely impacting her career and health. 8/13 crowdjustice.com/case/harassed-…
Allison Bailey, the lesbian KC who dared challenge gender identity ideology's impact on lesbians, was targeted by Stonewall, subject to horrendous abuse and effectively lost her career. 9/13 allisonbailey.co.uk
Philosophy professor Kathleen Stock was hounded out of her position at the University of Sussex, shunned by colleagues and targeted by students, all for the crime of being critical of gender identity ideology. 10/13 telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/05/2…
Detransitioners are subject to horrendous abuse from their 'community' online, because they speak out about the negative impact hormones and surgery have had on their lives. We've all watched them being jeered at, even told to kill themselves, after sharing their stories. 11/13
These individuals are the tip of the iceberg. I know, because I've received innumerable letters and emails from other people in medical and related professions who've been bullied and harassed for wanting a debate on gender identity ideology and the affirmation model. 12/13
People like you who now claim there's never been any attempt to stifle debate are part of the reason this mess happened in the first place. If you want to remain in a state of blithe unconcern, fine, but don't tell those in the trenches they're making a fuss about nothing. 13/X
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Judge Alexander Kemp, who presided over the Sandie Peggie tribunal, 'has been urged... to withdraw his findings and consider his position after it emerged that his ruling was “riddled” with errors and inaccuracies.'
Kemp used at least one completely bogus quote in his ruling. It's also being suggested, per the Times, that he 'used AI to research other cases.'
But there's worse. Kemp misrepresents a Swedish study that looked at the pattern of criminality among trans-identified men.
2/4
The Swedish study found that trans-identified men have the same pattern of criminality as other men regarding violence and sexual offending. However, Kemp claims these men are no more likely to be violent or predatory than women.
'Some sources suggested that the reluctance to push ahead with broader [gender change] reform was down to a desire to protect relations with the United States.' So Trump succeeded where a multitude of British women, including lifelong leftists, failed. 1/4 thetimes.com/uk/politics/ar…
However, in spite of the puberty blockers ban, 'separate moves for a transgender-inclusive ban on “conversion therapy” are understood to be going ahead.' This means therapists will be banned from fully exploring why a child wants to transition. 2/4 thetimes.com/uk/politics/ar…
We know that children who are autistic, same-sex attracted and those who've experienced sexual abuse are overrepresented at gender clinics. We also know, from multiple studies, that the vast majority of children grow out of gender dysphoria if allowed to go through puberty. 3/4
This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not to keep these people ignorant of what they were doing, but to prevent them from equating it with their old, ‘normal’ knowledge.' 1/5 bmcmedethics.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.11…
We're all used to the obfuscatory language gender activist medics and their cheerleader, insist upon. 'Gender affirming care/treatment' is so much nicer sounding than 'sterilisation, surgical mutilation and provision of toxic drugs to troubled minors'. 2/5
But this paper breaks new ground. It acknowledges that by the usual medical standards ('old normal knowledge') transitioning minors has not been found to be the unqualified success many have claimed. The proposed solution? Jettison the old knowledge. Redefine success. 3/5
The UK Charity Commission has directed that Mermaids - the single most influential activist group regarding child transition in the UK - must "have regard to the findings, conclusions and recommendations of the Cass Review.” 1/6
Cass found "the rationale for early puberty suppression remains unclear, with weak evidence regarding the impact on gender dysphoria, mental or psychosocial health. The effect on cognitive and psychosexual development remains unknown."
Mermaids disagreed: 2/6
Mermaids also sent out breast binders without parental consent. A 2015 study found that 97% of female users "reported at least one of 28 negative outcomes attributed to binding." Mermaids has now been told to follow Cass Review findings re: binders. 3/6 tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.108…
Roz Adams has been awarded £35k for the harassment she suffered at Edinburgh Rape Crisis. She was subject to a ‘Kafkaesque’ ordeal for believing the centre should be allowed to discuss the natal sex of support workers with rape survivors. 1/12 telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/10/1…
As Roz says: 'I don’t know how any organisation can claim to have women only spaces or services while not defining what a woman is or what female means.'
In 2023, Sandy Brindley, CEO of RCS, said 'work was underway' on a definition of women. 2/12
.thetimes.com/uk/scotland/ar…
One year on and Brindley still hasn't produced her definition. You might think the CEO of a service that claims to offer woman-only support would be able to say what a woman is, but Brindley is one of those whose ideology forbids any definition of women that excludes men. 3/12
While you've been in charge at Rape Crisis Scotland, a man now serving time in prison for multiple sexual assaults was 'treated' at the Edinburgh centre.
The man in charge of the Edinburgh centre called rape survivors who wanted single sex services 'bigots.' 1/9
Under your leadership, multiple women self-excluded from the Edinburgh centre because of the male CEO you defended and praised.
On your watch, a 14-year-old girl who'd been raped felt unable to access support because she wasn't guaranteed a single sex space. 2/9
You claim I misrepresented what happened at the meeting at which rape survivors were harangued by your trans activist partner, who shouldn't have been there at all. Here's the survivors' own account of what happened. 3/9 parliament.scot/-/media/files/…