Culture Critic Profile picture
Apr 25 18 tweets 6 min read Read on X
How much human knowledge has been lost to history?

Well, this ancient wonder was razed by the Mongols in 1258 — it's said the Tigris River ran black with ink.

Here's what was inside... (thread) 🧵 Image
1,200 years ago, the world's largest city was Baghdad (modern-day Iraq) — 1.5 million lived there at its peak. The Round City, a masterpiece of urban planning, contained one of history's greatest libraries. Image
Baghdad was then an intellectual capital of the world. Scholars came from all across the Islamic empire, and the ruling Caliphs were eager to collect their knowledge under one roof: The House of Wisdom. Image
When the city was sacked after 500 years, the Islamic Golden Age came to an end — alongside a devastating loss of knowledge.

But what was actually in there? How significant was the loss? Image
The House of Wisdom was foremost a place where knowledge was transferred. Many classical texts by that point were lost in Europe, because after the Roman Empire collapsed, copies of texts weren't often being made.Image
Texts were translated into Arabic from Persian, Syriac and Greek, including some of the rarest Greek materials in existence: Plato, Aristotle, Euclid, etc.

Some were so precious that Caliphs paid translators their weight in gold to translate them. Image
We know works of philosophy, medicine, astronomy, optics and mathematics were copied — but original research also flourished. Foundational work was done in algebra, and in the pioneering of medical techniques.
Image
Image
So much knowledge was stored there by the 13th century that the Tigris apparently ran black with ink when the Mongols sacked it. One source says:

"So many books were thrown into the river that they formed a bridge that would support a man on horseback." Image
We don't know how much was lost, but c.400,000 manuscripts were evacuated before the siege. Given the numbers involved, losses might have been as significant as at the Library of Alexandria — where estimates range in the hundreds of thousands. Image
It's obviously impossible to know what was lost in the great libraries — so put it this way:

All of our knowledge of the Greco-Roman world comes from some 500 volumes. 700,000 scrolls were potentially lost at Alexandra alone. Image
Catastrophes of this kind might seem like they set humans back centuries with a single blow. The truth is, cultures usually die much earlier... Image
When the House of Wisdom burned, it was already in rapid decline under the reign of new Caliphs. A literal interpretation of the Quran was being embraced, scientific rationalism abandoned, and Greek philosophy seen as anti-Islamic.
Same in Alexandria: by the time the library was burned down (in part) by Caesar's men in 48 BC, it was already in disuse and decay. Image
Texts through history were lost not because of fires, but because they weren't copied in the first place — cultures need a reason to preserve them.

Many survived because they were in school curricula for centuries. That's why so many copies of Virgil, Homer and Aristotle exist.
Image
Image
When the Round City fell, the spirit that inspired the translation movement was long gone. Perhaps as much knowledge was lost by what wasn't translated in those final years, than during the eventual destruction. Image
Cultures aren't simply lost at the hands of ransacking barbarians. They're lost because they die first from something much worse: indifference... Image
If threads like this interest you, you NEED my free newsletter!

Art, history and culture: 36,000 others read it 👇
culturecritic.beehiiv.com/subscribe
Conclusion: Preserving knowledge (and culture) requires more than a good set of barbarian defenses.

It requires a constant state of tending and diligence... Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Culture Critic

Culture Critic Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Culture_Crit

Jun 21
What did Jesus of Nazareth look like?

The 6th century Christ Pantocrator is the most recognized image of Jesus — but what about before then?

Well, that's where things get weird... (thread) 🧵 Image
There are no physical descriptions of Christ in the Gospels. The first Christians were wary of idolatry and wanted to focus on his words and teachings.

But what do the earliest artistic depictions show us? Image
This is the Christ Pantocrator, a Byzantine icon kept in a small Mount Sinai monastery since the 6th century.

Its style (right hand raised, Bible in the left) became repeated around the world, and established his conventional appearance: bearded and long-haired. Image
Read 20 tweets
Jun 19
Why do American cities feel less "alive" than their European counterparts?

It's because of something called the "missing middle".

A century ago, American cities looked completely different... (thread) 🧵 Image
Millions make pilgrimages to Europe's centers every year. Architectural beauty is one thing, but they simply feel more vibrant and "alive" than American cities.

But why is that?Image
In the early 20th century, American cities were much like European ones. They had smaller footprints relative to population, and people lived centrally enough to walk or take elegant streetcars to work.

What happened? The "missing middle" was decimated... Image
Read 19 tweets
Jun 18
You might recognize this as a movie set — it's actually a real place near Paris.

In the 1970s, one man had enough of modern architecture and did something radical.

He went back to Ancient Greece for inspiration... (thread) 🧵 Image
It's called Les Espaces d'Abraxas, and it's unlike anything you've seen before.

It's a housing project built in the 1980s as a backlash against the dreary modernist blocks of the day... Image
After WW2, cheap, rectangular housing blocks addressed the need to build rapidly across Europe.

Modernism was the dominant style and most new Parisian suburbs were like this: tower blocks built with seemingly little regard for what it's like to live in them. Image
Read 16 tweets
Jun 17
Before you can enter Heaven, you must climb Mount Purgatory.

It has 7 levels, and you must conquer different sins at each one.

This 700-year-old poem guides you up — and it's the greatest self-help manual ever written... (thread) 🧵 Image
In 1321, Alighieri Dante imagined a journey through Hell, Purgatory and Paradise. It's one of the most imaginative stories ever told.

He first travels right to the bottom of Hell and describes each of its 9 levels along the way... Image
Why make this journey?

Because to journey upward, you must first descend into the depths of your own soul — and confront what you find there.

At the very bottom, the bitterly cold point furthest from God's grace, Dante finds Satan. Image
Read 18 tweets
Jun 13
In 1685, someone painted this "3D" fresco in Rome — a masterpiece of Baroque art.

But what was the point of decorating buildings so lavishly?

It wasn't just to show off. It was believed that people could be transported by images... (thread) 🧵Image
In the 15th century, the printing press put translated copies of the Bible into people's hands across Europe.

Those who had previously relied on the Catholic Church to interpret it for them now argued the Church had taken too much liberty with the original text. Image
Martin Luther and John Calvin argued against things like the sale of indulgences, deciding it was time to get back to the text itself.

Religious art — of Jesus, Mary and the saints — became seen as unnecessary and idolatrous.
Image
Image
Read 19 tweets
Jun 12
A thread of religious architectural wonders that most people haven't heard of... 🧵

1. Church of the Transfiguration: an entirely wooden, 22-dome church built without a single nail... Image
Part of the Kizhi Pogost, Russia — the world's tallest wooden structure. Built to gather Christians in the remote Karelia region.

The current, restored church used metal nails, but the 18th century original didn't. Instead, it used horizontal logs that interlock in the corners. Image
2. Cathedral of Christ the Saviour

Another of the wondrous, Byzantine-influenced domes of the Russian Empire (modern-day Kharkiv, Ukraine).

But this one was demolished by Stalin on his anti-religious campaign that razed thousands of churches. Image
Read 14 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(