1/ I have seen the Israeli military and political machine falter before, on the verge of being forced to end past wars. I believe this is what is happening now. Israel is putting on a show meant mostly for domestic consumption. --->
2/ Netanyahu and his cronies and accessories, particularly those with military experience (Gantz and Eisenkot), want to tell the Israeli Jewish public (that overwhelmingly supports the "war") that Israel has "operated" in Rafah. There is nowhere else to go in the Gaza strip. --->
3/ Israel can thus claim it has "exhausted" all military options before it capitualtes to the pressure applied by the US, Saudi Arabia and just about everyone else. I don't think conspiracy is afoot to occupy Gaza. The religious right is interested but no one else is. --->
4/ I don't think Israel is interested in slaughtering as many Palestinians as possible. I think, and this shames me deeply, that Israel sheds Palestinian blood with no thought at all. Palestinians have been completely dehumanized by Israelis. We simply don't care. --->
5/ And so I believe what we are seeing in Rafah is a last attempt at appearing competent and full of conviction, defying the world to enhance Israeli security. That is, of course, a sham. I base my assessment also on the minimal resistance Israel has encountered in Rafah. --->
6/ Hamas has no reason to fight, having made its strategic decision. Hamas has opted for a deal. It controls the narrative, forcing Israel to "react". Hamas has nothing to gain from fighting so it doesn't fight. No fixation on the murder of Jews; just common sense. --->
7/ In its own mind, Israel cannot appear "weak", as acceptance of a deal has been spun as "surrendering" here by the PM and his government. Had Israel initiated a deal earlier it may have been less painful now. So Israel will buck and shudder but awareness is seeping in. --->
8/ All sorts of things suddenly make the Israeli headlines now, most prominently issues of personal appointments and official reviews of the war. This is to be expected when the end is in sight. Remember also that Israel will be celebrating Independence Day next Tuesday. --->
9/ Netanyahu wants to appear valiant and focused. Because he is who he is, because Israel is what it is, he is procrastinating, bobbing and weaving. He knows it shows. He knows his pants are on fire. There is plenty of damage to do and blood to shed, but the war is lost.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/ I cannot praise the US for stopping arms shipments to Israel. The Biden administration has taken its time and its hands are stained with innocent Palestinian blood. Still, this is the first time Israel has heard a negative reaponse from Washington. --->
2/ Israel's case for using 1 ton bombs in Rafah is as morally decrepit as it was for Gaza. Is Israel executing a plan to kill all the Palestinians and take over Gaza? I doubt it. Such a plan may exist in the devious minds of settler leaders. Most Israelis just don't care. --->
3/ Yesterday, for the first time in seven months, relatives of hostages protesting outside IDF HQ in Tel Aviv called for an end to the war. The Israeli left has called for an end to the war since it began, but the Israeli left possesses no political relevance. --->
2/ אני עוזב לשניה את העובדה שמדובר ברצף של שקרים (זו לא אותה תורה, חמאס לא נאצים, ״הם״ לא אותם ״הם״ כמו ש-״אנחנו״ לא אותם ״אנחנו״). אני מבקש להשאר רק במשמעות שנגזרת מתוך התועבה הזו לגבי המשמעות והאחריות של מדינת ישראל בעשור השמיני לקיומה. --->
3/ כי מה עושה הטקסט הזה? הוא מקבע במסמרות את העובדה ש-״אנחנו״, היהודים (ולא סתם ״אנחנו״ נחרזים עם ״ילדים״), לא אחראים לשום דבר שנעשה לנו. בהשלכה, אנחנו גם לא אחראים לשום דבר שאנחנו עושים. אנחנו ילדים. ״הם״ עושים הכל, שונאים ושורפים ורוצחים (מצורפת אילוסטרציה). --->
1/ Why has Israel lost the "war", despite destroying Gaza and the Gazans? There are several answers. They all begin with the same discrepancy: Israel and Hamas were not fighting the same war. You cannot win a war on parallel planes. Victory requires a defree of consensus. --->
2/ Hamas put all it had into one strike against Israel. Even if it declared its intention to destroy Israel, it physically could not. Hamas wanted to wreak havoc, to shock Israel and to kill as many Israelis as possible, to sow fear and reveal weakness. Hamas succeeded. --->
3/ Israel began with an all consuming desire for revenge driven by fear and humiliation. Then Israel set out to fight a war for the longer term, meant to create a future "without Hamas". Israel actually fought both wars simultaneously, destroying and dismantling. --->
1/ Historical truths may be established this evening. As things stand, Israel is refusing to stop the war. That is the main demand Hamas is making, a demand accepted by Egypt and the US and legitimized by the reality on the ground. Gaza is no more; Israel has lost the war. --->
2/ Continuing the "war" practically meanins perpetrating a genocide on the people of Gaza. Israel has made it clear, through action and statement, that it has no plan of stopping the geocide (Hamas infrastructure!) and that it does not believe there are bystanders in Gaza. --->
3/ If this is the decision ultimately reached and the "world", led by the Unites States, does not do all it can to stop Israel, then that world is complicit in the host of crimes committed by Israel. Any attempt to justify Israel's crimes by recourse to "security" is a lie. --->
1/ It doesn't matter how supportive Israeli Jews might be towards a hostage deal. It doesn't matter how opposed Israeli Jews might be to Binyamin Netanyahu. Ultimately, Israeli Jews continue to support the "destruction" of Hamas, which means continuing the "war". --->
2/ The "debate" about campus protests in the US serves the American culture wars. It also serves Israel's hectic campign to establish itself as eternally singular. The references to Germany in the 1930s, ridiculous and shameful, have not been made accidentally. --->
3/ Israel is using everything in its arsenal to make itself seem both perennial and fragile, immutable and frail. Israeli government ministers can speak publicly about the divinely inspired annihilation of Gaza. Why? "Nobody takes him seriously"; "no orders to that effect". --->
1/ the most disturbing thing about the Israeli obsession with "operating" in Rafah (as though Israel has not been bombing Rafah and killing civilians by the dozen on a daily basis) is the fact that all of it has to do with domestic Israeli concerns. Palestinians are absent. --->
2/ The Israeli military leadership is clamoring for an operation. That is not surprising. This "war" has been an abject failure in military terms. Not only has Hamas remained viable and its senior leaders alive, Israeli security is at an all-time low with 100000 DPs. --->
3/ This is an important point for understanding Israel's mindset as well as a basic lesson in genocide studies. Most supporters of genocide derive no joy from its success. Genocide is treated as a necessity, meant to ensure the survival of the perpetrators and no more. --->