1/ There is no real debate inside Israel regarding the genocidal campaign in Gaza. How do I know? Look to Jenin in the West Bank, where the IDF announced an "counter-terrorism operation" 2 days ago. The IDF reported "attacking dozens of terrorists" with "casualties". --->
2/ The Palestinians are reporting seven dead, including a physician hit by sniper fire on his way to work and a teen riding a bicycle. Why is this important? Because official Israel seems to be returning to "business as usual" with the citizenry appearing quite blasè. --->
3/ Israel is in full denial. Some days ago I had expressed the hope that this signifies the beginning of mourning. I believe I was wrong. Netanyahu was previously occupied with in-house political squabbles. He now seems to be betting on a solid Israeli Jewish consensus. --->
4/ That is a consensus supporting the "war" in Gaza and Israel's version of the "war on terror", waged both against the PA and with the latter's reluctant cooperation. The great majority of Israeli Jews also oppose the creation of an independent Palestinian state. --->
5/ When Israelis talk about their internal debates, they are often presented using terms like "messianic" and "liberal". That may be the case when it comes to the lives and welfare of Jews. When it comes to Palestinians, both "sides" embrace joint and total negativity. --->
6/ Netanyahu has no parliamentary opposition, not even when any politician worth her salt would identify an opportunity to break away from Netanyahu's choke hold and esabliah herself as an alternative. Israelis like to talk about Netanyahu's "magical" destructive abilities. --->
7/ This should no longer be presumed to be a credible explanation. Israelis have had countless chances to distance themselves from Netanyahu and his policies. The reason they have not done so is that while they may not like Netanyahu, they approve of his actions. --->
8/ The tolerance for this among Israel's allies is abominable. Palestinians continue to die in Rafah and Gaza and Jenin as the world conjures up creative gestures of dissatisfaction instead of stopping Israel in its tracks. Still, this makes political and historical sense. --->
9/ Allowing Israel to continue its dehumanizing occupation for long decades, supporting and arming it in fact, were all permissible under the illusion that Israeli hearts and minds were gradually being molded to accept a peaceful resolution. This was and is not the case. --->
10/ Israelis do not support peace. Israelis do not see Palestinians as partners, even for limited negotiations. Acknowledging the humanity of Palestinians is so egregious to Israelis that they are willing to combine Samson and Massada, both suicidal, to avoid it. --->
11/ Netanyahu is the quintessential Israeli. He knows. Continuing the war and defying the world make him more (not less) inevitable even to his greatest critics. He is Israel.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
1/ I am traveling in China this week and find myself repeatedly analyzing the situation in Gaza. The Chinese, bless their levelheaded heart, repeatedly ask a single question: what was the Israeli government's endgame when it began its punitive campaign against Gaza? --->
2/ Needing to think this through it is troubling to discover yet again the dysfuctional political genius of PM Netanyahu. The man demonstrates why the surprise of Israelis at the rushing tsunami of condemnation is so amusing. It could not have but come to this. --->
3/ The massacre of October 7th left Netanyahu depending on the political goodwill of two seemingly disparate groups. First, there were the settlers. The Hamas attack seemed like a direct sign from heaven. Israel could answer only with similar biblical flair. --->
1/ I must have been cast into the outer darkness because I find myself agreeing with my prime minister. As he rants, cartoonish in his purple hair and belabored table smacks, he makes one crucial point. This is not really about him. It is about the entire state of Israel. --->
2/ Of course, he makes this point for all the wrong reasons. He froths at the mouth as he calls Karim Khan an antisemite. He talks about the perennial persecution of Jews and tries to make Israel the current link an a neverending chain. That is, simply, a lie. --->
3/ Israel has not simply "fought a war". Israel fought two wars over the past seven months. It lost the first one, a one day war waged on October 7th. The massacre was horrific and atrocious, and it was a criminal act of war. It was an all-out attack and it succeedes. --->
1/ Israel is "astounded" that ICC prosecutor Karim Khan issued a request for arrest warrants against Netanyahu and Galant (and Sinwar) despite "Israel having been in contact with Khan"! The sheer arrogance is maddening. Israel is aghast at the "comparison" with Hamas. --->
2/ So is the US, but the Americans are pointedly not opposing the process or its outcomes. The US opposing the ICC is not surprising. The US focusing on language rather than substance is. Watch the Biden administration closely as this process develops. --->
3/ This is intentional language. Prosecutor Khan, considered almost criminally lenient by the rest of the world, has made an unthinkable gesture by "putting Israel and Hamas on the same list". Why so unthinkable? Becausr Israel, like the proverbial cheese, stands alone. --->
1/ Israeli soldiers returned the corpses of hostages from Rafah. All of them, just like every other hostage (except for the ones shot publicly by the IDF) whose death was announced over the past seven months, was said to have been "murdered on October 7th". --->
2/ Why is this significant? Because it gives a good indication of the rising role and importance of death in the function and evolution of Israeli society after 7 months of "war" turned genocide. Israel is besotted with death. Death is the only valid justification. --->
3/ consider Israel's version of temporal physics. There is no possibility that all the hostages who have dies over the past seven months were "murdered" on October 7th. This is a group of human beings. Some were old and infirm. Others had been injured while kidnapped. -->
1/ @LFC Jürgen Klopp will take his place at the Anfield touch line for the final time today. I will try to explain why this touches me deeply. Jürgen changed my life. I don't know him personally, of course. He didn't change my life by winning. He did by being himself. --->
2/ I did not grow up a football fan. I reached adulthood knowing that football was important to many and respecting that importance. I was never emotionally invested. I never thought football fandom could provide me with the means for self-expression and enhancement. --->
3/ My daughter, who was born in 2003, pulled me in when she was 15. She has ADHD and is neurodivergent. I was casually watching the World Cup in Russia when she realized for the first time in her life she can concentrate on something for 90 minutes. She wanted more. --->
1/ Listening to Israel argue before the ICJ is a disturbing experience. First time around I disagreed with everything said but could at least identify a consistent logic- "we are attempting to dismantle Hamas and that is our sole justification". That is no longer the case. --->
2/ Israel's advocates are fluctuating wildly between barefaced lies (Israel investigates mistakes) and chauvinistic claims boiling down to "we get to do whatever we want and you don't get to stop us". The body language runs the gamut from glowering to PTSD. --->
3/ The Israeli public is uninterested. Last time, our "heroes in robes" were treated like a national sports team sent to a global tournament. Nobody's watching this time. Why? First, we've been "assured" that the fighting will continue regardless of the pending decision. --->