Lewis Goodall Profile picture
Jul 5 • 20 tweets • 6 min read • Read on X
IF YOU'RE JUST WAKING UP 🧵

LABOUR LANDSLIDE.

THE WORST TORY DEFEAT IN HISTORY. COLLAPSE EVERYWHERE

LIB DEMS REVIVE BEST RESULT FOR THIRD PARTY SINCE 1923

SNP IMPLOSION. LABOUR DOMINANT IN SCOTLAND AGAIN.

MUSLIM VOTE FOR LABOUR COLLAPSES

INDEPENDENTS ELECTED IN SAFE SEATS
Labour first

Keir Starmer is a huge election winner. Becomes only the fourth Labour leader to win a majority for his party.

Will be just shy of the 97 victory..

Party result the northern wall in its entirety, in Wales and in Scotland and won dozens of new seats in the south.
Labour will be dominant in the next parliament. Starmer will be the most powerful prime minister we've seen since Blair in 2001-05.

The vote was perfectly distributed across the country. Labour is the biggest party in England, Scotland and Wales.

But the vote was thin. Starmer may come to office on the smallest share of the vote of any winning party in history- less than 35%.
They pulled it off by having a highly efficient vote distribution. They got the right votes in the right places (as opposed to piling votes up in the same places, a la Corbyn in 17)

In many places Conservative vote collapsed and Reform was the beneficiary. Labour didn't necessarily gain that much but came through the middle.
In fact Labour barely put on any vote share at all. It's up by 1-2% from Jeremy Corbyn in 2019. This is a story about Conservative collapse.

Nigel Farage made it into Parliament. But Reform is in second place in 98 seats, many of which in northern England to Labour. That is going to be Farage's focus and it's going to change politics and spook those Labour MPs. Immigration is going to become an even bigger issue.
But it's not just Reform. Labour has lost a clutch of safe seats to independent candidates in heavily Muslim seats. They ran in opposition to Labour's policy on Gaza. And they've triumphed in safe seats like Leicester South (prev maj 22000), Birmingham Perry Bar (15000), Blackburn (18000) and more besides.

They ran Labour very close in Birmingham Ladywood (Shabana Mahmood), Birmingham Yardley (Jess Phillips) and more besides. They did, however, win back Rochdale from Galloway.

Labour's relationship with many Muslim voters is in tatters.
Corbyn also retained Islington. And Labour lost Bristol Central to the Greens.

Labour's victory is broad but potentially fragile. It is going to require profound political skill to keep this coalition together when the adhesive of being the anti-dote to the Tories is taken away. Starmer is going to have to look in multiple directions with different opponents in second seats in different places. It's a deeply fragmented political picture and political geography.
Rishi Sunak meanwhile becomes the biggest loser in British political history. He has lost more Tory seats in one election than any election in history, more even than the Liberal landslide of 1906.

The Tory vote share is easily the lowest in history at 24%. That's down 20%pp since 2019. It's lower than Major's 30% of 97.

His decision to fight the election now, with the strategy he chose was catastrophic.
Conservatives will have

0 seats in Wales
1 seat in the North East
1 seat in the North West

Four of the five of the Tories' Prime Ministers' seats of the last 14 years have been lost (Witney, Maidenhead, Uxbridge and South West Norfolk).

The Conservatives have never been so marginal or unimportant to British politics as they are right now.
What has happened in the south of England to the Tories is a reconfiguration of our electoral geography is way beyond anything we saw in the red wall. Demographic change has punished the Tories.

There is no easy way back. A bloody war for the soul of the party comes next. Most likely candidates who have survived are from the right: Badenoch, Braverman, Jenrick. Atkins and Tugendhat have survived too and will give it a go from one nation wing but I suspect will get nowhere.

Feels to me inconceivable that stung from defeat, with Reform splitting the vote in so many places, and the Tory membership moving to the right in recent years, the members won't choose the most right wing candidate available.

Btw will only take about 20 MPs to trigger a leadership contest on these numbers. Good luck to the new chair of the 22.
The Lib Dems have had their best night in history. They've won dozens of new seats. They've returned in their old south west heartlands. They've won new seats in teh south east, including in Tory fortresses like Oxfordshire.

Ed Davey is the most successful Liberal leader since Asquith.
But like Labour, the Lib Dems have achieved it on a slim share of the vote. They've won about 12% vote share. That's up less than 1% on 2019. But again, the Conservatives have collapsed in so many places PLUS Lib Dems have put on votes where it matters. Clear beneficiaries of v efficient tactical voting.

Either way the Lib Dems are back as a serious force in British politics. They'll have more than half of the Tory seat number. We'll be seeing much more of Ed Davey, and not always on a bungee jump.
The SNP have had their worst election result for over a decade. They have largely dominated in each and every election they've contested in Scotland since 2015. No longer. Labour has had their best performance anywhere in teh country in Scotland. SNP are exiled back to their historic heartlands. They will be irrelevant in Westminster.

They will of course still be in office in Holyrood. A 2026 election there against a potentially unpopular Labour govt in Westminster will be to their advantage. Independence is also still polling well and Labour, for the first time, will have to navigate having a significant number of Yes voters in their coalition. But this is the biggest setback for independence, in the short term, for a long time.
In Northern Ireland Sinn Fein will be the biggest party for the first time (of course, they don't take their seats).

Is Sinn FĂ©in's third electoral victory in two years in NI.

Bad night for DUP. Ian Paisley Jr loses North Antrim to hardline TUV's Jim Allister.
BIG story of the night is turnout. The second lowest EVER at only 60%- about 7.5%pp down on the last election. Has driven all sorts of odd results. The public, in many cases, have either felt apathetic or disinclined to choose between what was put before them.
In sum. This was a deeply odd set of results. A triumph for Labour but on a low turnout and thinly spread. A Tory catastrophe. The Tory/Labour vote share at the lowest in history. 35% of the vote for Labour rewarded with 65% of the seats.

How robust is the coalition? Starmer is in Johnson's 19 position but x10. An odd patchwork of seats which does't necessarily cohere, where he will have to look left and right, liberal and conservative. It is gong to require some political magic to keep them together. . Starmer made few political arguments in teh campaign. He's going to have to make some now, in order to sustain his majority. And Labour has to deliver- because if if it doesn't it's easy to see this triumph quickly eroding.

Because if we've learned anything in recent years it has to be that there's no permanent settlements left in British electoral demography. The SNP hegemony- gone. The Tory hegemony- gone. The electorate is more volatile than ever. What they give, they can take away more quickly than ever.

Because with these results Britain is more marginal than ever. At the constituency level seats are tighter than any point since 1945. There is no such thing as a safe seat any more.
But all that is for another day and another election. Today the triumph is Keir Starmer's. No-one would have thought this were possible in 2019. It is the first change of party in government for 14 years. The first majority for a Labour govt in 19 years. He promised little but has complete power to do what he wants.

The question is, what will he do with it?

END AND SLEEP
Oh and btw- voter efficiency is everything in the British system. If you master that you win. And Labour did.
AND I'm all for talking about Reform. It's going to be a massive part of the next parliament. But we also need to talk in the same way about the Greens, who won the same number of seats and who also pose a long term threat to Lab and Tory.
Best way of understanding this result (in England and Wales). Labour may not be loved but the Conservatives, in many cases, were despised. And the voters were willing to vote for anyone best placed to remove them. All adding up to ruthless vote efficiency for Labour & Lib Dems.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Lewis Goodall

Lewis Goodall Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @lewis_goodall

May 22
Did someone say febrile
It seems very weird to allow rumours to build up and not clarify them before PMQs where the PM can be asked about them directly on the floor of the Commons. Not least when in news management terms you have a rare good day and decent story to tell on inflation…
Two scenarios at this point. He calls it today which given immigration figs tomorrow is, well, a big call. Or it’s been allowed to build for no reason, political journalist class annoyed and the rest of the week is dominated by “Sunak isn’t good at politics” narrative.
Read 4 tweets
Apr 28
NEW: Latest @TheNewsAgents Investigates - Britain’s hidden homeless children

Nearly 140,000 kids in Britain are now homeless, in so-called “temporary accommodation”. We went to a school where half of the kids don’t have a home to call their own.
podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/the…
It’s having a devastating effect on the educational outcomes of a big and growing group of working class kids. They’re almost forgotten, because they’re not on the streets. But their living conditions are Victorian, often sharing one room with their parents, siblings, shared bath.
Some of the kids come to school not having been able to wash in the mornings because there wasn’t an agailable bathroom in the temporary accomm. They’re embarrassed and have to wash at school. There are sometimes safeguarding issues because the kids are sharing bathrooms with strangers in the TA.
Read 7 tweets
Apr 3
NEW: Lib Dems call on the govt to suspend arms sales to Israel.

@EdwardJDavey: “Clearly, the thought that British-made arms could have been used in strikes such as these is completely unacceptable.

“The government must take swift action to suspend arms exports to Israel."
There's been (more or less) a fragile consensus between Conservative and Labour on policy towards Israel and the war. Pressure is going to increase on Starmer to move. Possibly (and more importantly) Sunak too...
Flick Drummond, Tory MP for Meon Valley has also said arms to Israel should cease.

“This has been concerning me for some time. What worries me is the prospect of UK arms being used in Israel’s actions in Gaza which I believe have broken international law.”
Read 4 tweets
Mar 6
NEW: Chancellor says that OBR forecasts that inflation is set to fall below 2% target in a few months.
NEW: Alcohol duty to be frozen until February 2025.
NEW: Fuel duty frozen again.

It's been temporarily frozen for 14 years now.
Read 22 tweets
Mar 1
What does the Galloway victory mean?

For the general election, very little. This was a unique by election and little is transferable. But it does change politics before the election and possibly tells us something about the shape of politics after it as well.

🧵
In the short term the result is highly embarrassing for Keir Starmer and for Labour. The Labour vote collapsed by over 40 % points. Labour will point to the fact that they withdrew support. But that reminds us that they had to withdraw support in a safe seat, itself a shambles.
Questions for the leadership as to why the by-election was held so quickly and why the selection process happened so quickly. As it is a safe Labour seat has been handed to one of the party's most implacable opponents.

Galloway will do what he always does...
Read 15 tweets
Feb 21
It’s not like the British Parliament makes everything about itself, no not remotely
Net result of all of this? Starmer has a lucky escape. Speaker is weaker. Commons is farcical. Nothing changes in Gaza. MPs don’t really get their vote. We continue not to scrutinise what matters (and even then not that much) , which is the government’s position and plan.
Btw attack the Speaker’s decisions or not, but the threat of violence against MPs is real. Speaker should be thinking about that. The fact we’ve just come to accept that as a kind of background to our politics is the grimmest thing of all.
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(