Magdi Jacobs Profile picture
Jul 10, 2024 20 tweets 8 min read Read on X
I will put this plainly, w/o hyperbole: If the U.S. leaves NATO, we will be looking down the barrell at a level of European warfare we haven't seen since WWII. Putin will invade more countries. Europe, for the 1st time in 80 years, will go it alone, w/o the U.S.
Look at a map. Consider a captured Ukraine, which is very possible if Trump wins. Romania, Moldova, Lithuania, Latvia, Estonia, & Poland have all said they are prepared for greater warfare. France, Germany, & Britain are preparing to defend them. Image
From this year:
-"Russia preparing for military confrontation with West, says Estonia"
-"Latvia prepares for Russian aggression amid concern war will spread beyond Ukraine"
-"We need to be ready for war with Putin, Romania’s top general says"

Image
Image
Image
Then, this, today from Poland, after Trump made his comments about abandoning NATO:
"Poland must prepare army for full-scale conflict, army chief says."
reuters.com/world/europe/p…
What happens when the threat of the US military is removed? European war. The Baltic States & Eastern EU are most threatened. Meanwhile, France, Germany, & the UK will be tasked to defend them. Italy's Meloni is cold on Putin. Why? It's an 11-hour drive from Ukraine to Venice. Image
Meanwhile, Western EU is preparing to defend the East, as the East prepares to defend itself
-New joint defense agreements btwn France/Germany/ Poland
-UK puts its defense industry on "wartime footing"
-UK starts the most intense military exercises in Poland since the 1980s

Image
Image
Image
I was raised by a military historian & part of my early ed was to avoid hyperbole. To do so, I said we're looking at "European Warfare." I didn't say WWIII. WWII was truly a *world* war. So let's take a moment to look at a broader map of EU, w/in the world. What do you see? Image
I see Iran, allied w/ Russia. I see Turkey, an opportunistic ally to both NATO & RU. An ally who might turn-coat if the threat of US force is eliminated. I see Syria, allied w/ Russia. I see Iraq, always in flux. I also see North Africa. I remember: Putin is fighting for influence in Africa.Image
So I look at the map. I ask myself, are these North African countries areas where Putin is specifically seeking influence? I find:
"Russia, Algeria 'tighten' strategic ties"
"Russia’s foreign minister tours North Africa as anger toward the West swells across the region"
Image
Image
I find, also, that North African states that have been traditionally "Western" allies, like Tunisia, are turning more towards Russia. I also find this: -Increased Russian military activity in Tunisia & Libya -Strengthened bilateral relations between Morocco & the Kremlin.

Image
Image
Image
Russia may even be intending to build a naval base in Libya. Please look at a map & consider what a "naval base" in Libya means in the context of European warfare. Image
If we take into account China & Taiwan, plus the Middle East, where Putin has power in Iran & Syria, plus North Africa, where Putin is forming alliances & also increasing a military presence, what do we have? World War III. This is not hyperbole. It's what Europe is preparing for
Without the US, can the UK, France, Germany, & Poland defend all of EU against Russia? Maybe. But can they also defend against attacks from North Africa? Can they defend Taiwan while doing so? What about the ME? Russia has been building alliances, incl. w/ Hamas, throughout
Meanwhile, Russia is also sowing domestic discord, weakening all of Europe, just like it does w/ the U.S., from within. Russia's targets are always domestic discord. They pick at Western fissures like picking at a scab. Image
This is what could happen if Trump is elected & decides to leave NATO. The International Post-WWII Era will be over. No more deterrence from the US entails aggression everywhere. From a man--Putin--who is planning to aggress. Meanwhile, the press treats this as a "nothing story."
From today, in @politico "NATO plans, Trump laughs." NATO vs Trump. It makes Trump look so strong. When really, what we're talking about, is a US abdication of its anti-war responsibilities, while the rest of the world *scrambles* to adjust to this possible New World Order. Image
The defense strategy--NATO--that prevents broader warfare is in danger if Trump is reelected. The American press alternately ignores this issue, obfuscates, or presents it as a power-move from Trump. Replace "Nato" with "All of Europe" in this headline. Image
-Given Putin's war in Ukraine
-Given Putin's influence campaigns across continents
-Given Putin's military presence in the ME & NA.
-Given Trump's stance on NATO & other alliances (Taiwan)
-We, as a world, will be closer to WWIII than we have ever been since the end of WWII.
That's a story worth taking very seriously.
I didn't even mention that Trump loves dictators & tried to use "defense" to extort the Ukrainian President, who is now reliant on US defense to defend his country. Best case scenario under Trump is that the U.S. takes the side of no one. Worst case is. . . .

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Magdi Jacobs

Magdi Jacobs Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @magi_jay

Jan 31
I really want people to start realizing that societal dysfunction is the goal. It is a means to an end. I think this could apply to tariffs as well. Look at where the societal dysfunction of COVID brought us. Look at how much it helped Republicans. They learned a lesson.
Look also at the environments within which fascism can take true hold. The economy is not strong in such environments. Society is not functioning well in such environments. There is, rather, chaos & strife. You don't get good fascism w/ a Biden economy.
They fumbled into their COVID "response" to protect Trump. But they discovered much along the way. Chaos works for them. Pain works for them. Shredding vestiges of societal bonds works for them.
Read 6 tweets
Jan 7
In 2002, I was living in France during the election. The left split its votes and Jacques Chirac, a conservative, advanced to the second round against Jean-Marie Le Pen, a Holocaust denier. No political event apart from the Iraq War has ever influenced me to the same extent.
I have never seen so many people in such a state of shock as the French were when Le Pen recieved ~20% of the 1st Round Vote. Prior to the election, as a young American Leftist, I was inspired by the # of different political parties, many types of Left. But. . vote splitting.
When the results rolled in, Marie-France, the woman I was living with, literally screamed & flipped back in her chair, hands across her face, weeping. As a young American Leftist, I had paid very little attention to the right-wing, so I didn't quite know what was happening.
Read 4 tweets
Dec 3, 2024
This. I'll add that I am getting increasingly frustrated with some Democrats constantly criticizing other Democrats in their "Why didn't we win?" analyses without once questioning if maybe the fact that constant criticism of Democrats might be part of the answer.
95% of Dems on this site spent 2021-2024 criticizing Biden for Lofty Reasons & arguing with one another. No one is asking for absolute fealty, but if 95% of the people who are supposed to be Pro-Dem can't find anything but negativity for Dems, maybe we will recruit no new voters
We spent 20 years in Afghanistan precisely because we didn't want the Taliban to come back to power. But no one understood that, so Biden failed when he did what everyone wanted & the inevitable consequence of withdrawal became apparent.
Read 8 tweets
Nov 11, 2024
I think we are look at "mass deportation" incorrectly. There are two possibilities:
1. They are committed to this policy due to racism/ideology; do not understand the consequences
2. They are committed to this policy for the above reasons & welcome the consequences
It's an important distinction. In the case of #1, perhaps Trump's narcissism or some other factor could win out. In the case of #2, they will truly be trying to break America. Not just the economy, but the military, etc. Perhaps the deportations serve a greater purpose.
We simply don't know at this point. I believe any student of fascism should be highly attuned to #2 as a possibility. You break a people before you rule them so completely, if they're not already broken. Which, economically, we are not. The traditional military can be broken too
Read 6 tweets
Nov 11, 2024
I wish this wasn't happening to The New Yorker.
I really don't like criticizing the New Yorker. I take negative pleasure in it. But I don't know how you get from Jane Meyer's extensive investigations into dark money & right-wing politics & come out w/ "People are on the left think X is happening! But here's Kevin Roberts!" Image
Meyer dabbled in some false equivalencies between Biden & Trump that I took issue w/ this year. But her work on the conservative movement was really good. How do you go from valuing that level of depth towards this type of stuff? I don't understand it. Image
Read 5 tweets
Nov 9, 2024
This analysis is bad & we should generally ignore this type of thing. We've been through it before & we know it's wrong, cf. 2019-2020. Congrats to @agraybee, though for being so influential his twitter name is now a qualifier for a subtype of liberal. Image
If we engage too much as liberals in this type of argument it will become a bigger thing. Do we think this argument is worth having again? If yes, then engage. If you're as fatigued & bored & irritated w/ it as I am, I'd say we should direct our energies elsewhere.
We follow no gods nor any masters & we certainly don't need to let the least historically correct people frame our own discourse for us. Let's frame it ourselves. Maybe if they come up with something new or something that makes sense, they can come & respond to us for once.
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(