Thread by @SteB777

The @guardian should be thoroughly ashamed for publishing this steaming pile of sophistry. It's why I regard it as having a troublesome position. Yes, it has better climate crisis coverage, but that is because the rest are dire, it's just less dire.

1/🧵theguardian.com/commentisfree/…

The premise of the argument is that whilst the sentences given to @RogerHallamCS21 et al, are harsh, that @JustStop_Oil are using the wrong tactics, because they are inconveniencing ordinary road users. This is such an ignorant argument, from a position of privilege.
2/

Firstly, the elephant in the room, and this is why this argument, is sophistry, about traffic delays, people missing appointments, is it tacitly implies, that without @JustStop_Oil protests, the traffic would flow freely.
3/

This is just laughable, in its crass intellectual dishonesty, stupidity and ignorance. Traffic flow through the London area is notoriously congested, often with gridlocks, traffic jams, and huge delays, to travel, which have nothing to do with @JustStop_Oil.
4/

The average journey speed through central London is 8.7-7.1 mph, and pretty slow even in outer London. Remember, these are averages, and there are considerable delays on many days.

5/london.gov.uk/who-we-are/wha…

Protests by @JustStop_Oil etc, are very brief and temporary. So whilst they could cause temporary delays, those delays are often similar or worse in the 365 day yearly cycle, when JSO are not protesting. The elephant in the room is being ignored.
6/

The reason for this congestion, and delays, are the holier than thou car drivers getting riled by @JustStop_Oil protests, cyclists etc. They rarely acknowledge, that driving a car in the London area, causes these delays, far worse than JSO. Lock 'em all up. Tongue-in-cheek.
7/

For clarity, and before going on, let me make it clear that I am not saying @JustStop_Oil tactics are perfect, but I will also defend them to the death, because no other tactics are working to change the globally suicidal course we are on.
8/

Currently, we are heading towards civilization collapse, and mass starvation, driven by the climate crisis, and the overall ecological crisis. This is not an extremist position. Read this by Sir David King, former UK Chief Scientist.

9/theguardian.com/commentisfree/…

Believe it or not, civilization collapse, and mass starvation will disrupt people's lives far more than a few small protests by @JustStop_Oil. This is the absurdity of these arguments.
10/

All these arguments that @JustStop_Oil are using the wrong tactics. Well, please tell me what the right tactics are? Our leaders promised to address the climate crisis, but according to the UN Secretary General @antonioguterres, they're liars.

11/press.un.org/en/2022/sgsm21…

Personally, I'm not involved with @JustStop_Oil and I have my own views on what is necessary to prevent this crisis turning into global suicide. But I refuse to criticize any activists or tactics, when so far nothing has worked. They might be right in their choice of tactics.
12/

This is why that Observer/Guardian article, is so crass, stupid, ignorant and is outright false argument.

None of these criticisms of @JustStop_Oil acknowledge that we are currently in a climate crisis heading towards globally suicidal civilization collapse.
13/

I make no excuse for my "alarmism". If you're not alarmed by the climate crisis, it's because you're uninformed, ignorant, & are in some sort of serious denial.

I've not suddenly become a fanatic, it is our leadership who are the dangerous fanatics.

14/

https://x.com/antonioguterres/status/1511294073474367488?lang=en

The previous excuse was that our leadership, weren't going to let the climate crisis get out of hand, because they had plans to address it. But as @antonioguterres says, there is a litany of broke climate promises, and our leaders are liars.

15/

Even with the most ambitious Net Zero plans, we are actually heading towards 3-4C of warming, because as Professor Kevin Anderson @KevinClimate says, these plans are Not Zero. They are not actually Net Zero, but pretend Net Zero.

16/

The climate and ecological crisis is a strange state of affairs. It has always been a preventable catastrophe, and 32 years ago at the 1992 Rio Earth Summit, our leaders promised to address the crisis. The problem is, they've done nothing since.

17/un.org/en/conferences…

Our leaders have squandered all the time they had to organize a credible response, by promising action, and then doing nothing. This is why it is a real emergency, and this is not exaggerated alarmism.
18/

Anyone attacking the tactics of @JustStop_Oil is engaging in a classic, ignoring the massive elephant in the room fallacy, of being in total denial about the actual situation, which is infinitely worse than any "alarmist" climate activists, could describe.
19/

@threadreaderapp unroll