Perspective: Israel only emerged as a cohesive state, eschewing an intra-Jewish civil war, only because in '48 one faction moved very quickly, and pretty brutally, to concentrate weapons in its own hands and monopolize "legitimate violence"...
defeating/coopting other militias and instituting some of the world's toughest gun laws (even police trade unions are banned bc they would amount to armed orgs independent of the state!) Nine months into the war, this equilibrium is out of the window, owing to three factors - -
a) Unprecedented numbers of mobilised continually armed reservists b) a 800% rise in gun licenses issued by Itamar Ben Gvir, convicted terrorist and now police minister c)exhausted, underpaid, already problematic & violent police getting explicitly, factionally politicised by BG
What we saw yest was a tiny, tiny preview that got successfully deescalated, partly by sheer luck. Expect this x10 next time soldiers are arrested (even for protection from the Hague), and potensh x20 if IDF leave Gaza before "total victory" "finishing the job." I still think...
that getting rid of Netanyahu will be a huge step toward national and regional stabilisation. But we're close to a point where it might not be enough: his catastrophic, narcissistic mismanagement of the war and the country evidently armed time bombs that will long outlive him.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
So. Having excavated my jaw from a crater in the floor, here's my take on Haniyeh assassination. Three ways to read Netanyahu's thinking:
a. He WANTS a regional war
b. He calculated this WON'T spark a regional war
c. The semi-official Israeli narrative, which is bullshit.
Reading A: Netanyahu wants regional war. Pro: It's not going great for him rn. Britain dropped objection to his arrest warrant & is about to impose at least a partial arms embargo, Kamala is signaling she'd be tougher on him than Biden, Trump is on the backfoot; IDF is cracking.
What to do? Kick the table over. Unite the nation in an epic WW2 style effort. Start a regional war with stakes so high the West will HAVE to abandon its quibbles, and join in on Israel's side - or risk losing its main strategic asset in the Middle East. But...
Well, fuck. Civilian protesters have now broken into the compound and are currently surrounding the building where Gazan detainees are held. Per Haaretz, police are "standing aside". We could be on the verge of something exceptionally brutal - and game-changing.
Soldier to Haaretz: "Some military police are trying to keep people apart. That's it. No organic forces. Soldiers are just looking on. No officer is in command of the incident. They've lost control." Police are staying outside the base.
MPs including Nissim Vaturi, Amihai Eliyahu and Tzvi Succot are there, reportedly just chanting "death to terrorists" with the lynch mob. Hey @tzvisuccot, we all know you're a troll - but are you actually going to personally kill unarmed prisoners now? With your own bare hands?
There's currently a "confrontation" going on between Sde Teiman soldiers / camp guards and the military police who've come in to arrest one for them for torture. I don't recall last time there was an actual physical tussle between two groups of Israeli soldiers - do you?
The suspected torturers have barricaded themselves at the base, and attacked police with pepper spray. They're apparently uploading footage on social media calling for Israelis to come out to the streets in their support 🍿
Ben Gvir - national police minister, mind you - is voicing support for the torturers resisting arrest, saying it's shameful to arrest Israel's true heroes, bla bla bla. I'll be surprised if he actually does something about it, though.
🚨🧵The official IDF investigation is out, and and the crux pretty much confirms the leak to Haaretz on Tuesday: Forces “identified” a gunman on an unrelated truck, and then, although they never got another visual, ASSUMED that hypothetical gunman was on one of the WCK vehicles.
The new info: 1. “The forces did not identify the vehicles in question as being associated with WCK.” Even if we assume they didn’t use high-res surveillance cameras to hit the first car right in the WCK logo...
...this suggests that the very detailed comms between IDF and the convoy before the attack either didn’t get to the drone operators or were deliberately ignored by them.
🚨Absolutely stunning new investigation by @yuval_abraham of @972mag. TLDR: In Oct, IDF expanded kill lists from "top commanders" to "everyone Hamas"—37k ppl.
Via a slap-up AI bot.
And it increased quota of permitted collateral damage from "zero" to "20" civilians per target.
Soldiers and officers were told to treat the AI bot decision's as direct orders and not to double-check its decisions despite the only check ever run on it via a random sample showed only 9 in 10 names it picked out had even tangential connections to Hamas.
Crucially, the IDF also gave sweeping permission - and what sounds like encouragement - to bomb these targets IN THEIR HOMES rather than on the move or combat situations. This is how you got hundreds dozens of families wiped out day in, day out, throughout the war. Via a bot.
The IDF's early explanation re the killing of the World Central Kitchen team is in - per "security sources" speaking to Haaretz. Before we get to the putative pretext for the attack, they also disclose a harrowing detail - the drone bombed the convoy THREE TIMES in succession..
because team survived one hit and tried taking cover in another vehicle, and then survivors moved to a third - and were finished off there. Deliberate, repeated targeting of convoy, making sure no one was left alive.
And this actually doesn't stack up w the alleged pretext:
"According to sources acquainted with the details of the incident, the Operation Room in charge of securing the route identified an armed person on the truck and suspected this was a terrorist. By the time preparations were made for the attack, the truck arrived....