The thing that really winds me up about the global obsession with Palestine is the moral superiority some claim, while indisputably engaging in a clearly racist motivated obsession with anything that involves Jews.
/1
Coming from a family myself that are refugees from *actual* ethnic cleansing (rather than the Palestinian version which is essentially trying to ethnically cleanse someone and failing spectacularly), I perhaps have a bit less empathy than most.
/2
I have, after all, managed to get through my parents relocating thousands of miles with just a single suitcase *without* becoming a terrorist or a racist or celebrating people being raped or burned alive, buy hey, that's just me.
/3
But the horrific images of murdered Hindus coming out of Bangkadesh reminded me of one of dozens of examples of ridiculousness of the current global obsession with "the nakba" of 1948 and all that's occurred since.
/4
In the 70s, the Bangladesh genocide occurred. An actual genocide. The aggressor was Pakistani Muslims. People who, just a few years earlier had their own state formed on a fairly similar manner to the partition of British mandate Palestine.
/5
Anyway, during the Bangladeshi liberation, Muslim forces murdered up to THREE MILLION Hindus. Thats a maximum I admit, but think about that number. They moved through villages and specifically asked for places where Hindus lived before burning them down.
/6
Hindus were identified by checking circumcision or by demanding the recitation of Muslim prayers. Time reported it as follows, "It is the most incredible, calculated thing since the days of the Nazis in Poland"
/7
Being murdered like flies, and their villages being burned, 30 MILLION Hindus were displaced, 10 MILLION of whom managed to cross the border to India. They got no special UN aid agency.
/8
Pakistan's imams declared Hindu women to be "war booty” and fatwa were issued legitimizing Hindu women as spoils of war. 400,000 were captured and raped. Often by many men. Most of them died in captivity or committed suicide.
/9
Oh yes, and before anyone uses the excuse that people don't care because they west wasnt supporting it, you're dead wrong. Nixon refused to condemn it and provided weapons to the Muslims. So that excuse is pretty null. The ICJ did fuck all. Nor the UN.
/10
Let's stop pretending "the nakba" was a uniquely horrific event when reality is that it was a very minor displacement of people, a very short distance, during a war they started. Compared to the 30 million displaced in Bangladesh that nobody cares a fig about.
/11
Let's stop pretending that "genocide" is taking place when there's 40k casualties, probably mostly combatants in a war where clearly civilian death is carefully avoided. Unlike Bangladesh with 300x as many casualties that they literally went door to door to kill.
/12
Let's stop pretending that Jews have opressed Muslims when reality is that Muslims have opressed,raped and murdered millions of minorities and continue to today. And NOBODY suggests annihilating Pakistan or Bangladesh.
/13
Let's stop pretending UNRWA was needed because the Palestinian refugee situation was particularly serious, when it was not, it was just a politically motivated act to undermine the world's only Jewish state.
/14
And let's not pretend this is about your "tax dollars" being used for evil, because I can tell you now that your tax dollars have and are being used to fund eye curdling evil and always has been. Israel defending itself is not in that category.
/15
And the part that's almost funny? Those screaming the loudest about the evil of Israel are quite often themselves of Pakistani parents. Such as the MP for Gaza, Zarah Sultana or the ICJ Prosecutor who brought the case against Israel.
/16
Not to mention that Pakistan itself us still classified as in religious apartheid, and has one of the worst human rights records ON EARTH. Yet these people have the brass nuts to stand up and pretend their humanitarian rather than what they probably REALLY are.
/17
So my question to anyone who seeks to pretend Israel is not only "evil", but uniquely evil and deserving of annihilation, murder of it's people and racism towards its citizens around the globe, my question is...HOW DARE YOU?
/18
Those you judge as the most evil in history once condemned 6 million Jews to death based on the lie that they were uniquely evil and deserved it. You now do the same to the Jewish state and somehow think you are any better. Am Yisrael Chai and screw you.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
From 1750 to 1945 a heated debate endured in Western Europe, coined, "The Jewish Question", which pondered of Jewish emancipation- in simple terms a debate over whether they were entitled to equality.
1/5
For two hundred years, the question was asked. In the 19th century hundreds of articles and books were written on the subject, debating resettlement and deportation of Jews from Europe. Some argued they could only deserve equality if they gave up their religion.
2/5
Karl Marx argued that society could not be free from the oppression of capitalism without removing Jews from society entirely. Adolph Hitler agreed, and embarked on his own "solution" to the Jewish Question. The majority of Jews were subsequently wiped off the planet.
3/5
Religion was once fundamentally inseperable from politics and was very much a tool of power and control over populations, effectively inspiring obedience as well as shared community and values.
/1
That said, it was also once fairly pliable. It was not abnormal for new empires to conquer an area and amalgamate religions so people could carry on with the familiar. Eg: the Romans adopted the Egyptian goddess Isis into their pantheon when conquered Egypt.
/2
Many populations also accepted conquest, and even forced conversion, fairly passively as they didn't really care who ruled them or what religion they were and were more interested in who treated them better.
/3
I'm a middle eastern immigrant living in Britain, with two siblings married to Muslims (one gay) and for us, "multiculturalism" works great. But there's an essential component which is a shared value system and the honest truth is, this...
/1
Minorities are ONLY safe, protected and equal IF they live in a country where minorities are protected. For that to happen, you must have laws which offer that protection, but more importantly you must have a consensus that values equality and freedom.
/2
The fundamental principle of "freedom" is not a concept that is lauded universally. For some cultures, "freedom" is unimportant and / or, runs contrary to religious beliefs around which their value systems are based.
/3
A very large number of Muslims have popped into my mentions to tell me that zionism (self determination for Jews) is "genocidal". And there's something very, very interesting about this. Which is this..
/1
The all parliamentary group worked for two years on a working definition of "Islamophobia". The research came up with nine points to summarise what Muslims deeply felt to be "Islamophobia", and therefore unacceptable.
/2
Point 6 reads: "Denying Muslim populations the right to self-determination e.g., by claiming that the existence of an independent Palestine or Kashmir is a terrorist endeavour".
Here's the 2023 report from Amnesty on exactly what that "freedom" might look like in practice....
1)
LGBT RIGHTS?
Homosexuality is illegal in Gaza. UNRWA published guidance to staff regarding treating LGBTI people equally and the Hamas authorities accused them of promoting “deviance and moral decay”. There are 336000 homosexuals in Israel at the lowest estimate.
2)
WOMEN'S RIGHTS?
Women still did not have equal rights to men in personal status law, which is subject to religious law. According to the Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics, 59% of married women and girls experienced violence at the hands of their partner.
3)
What is happening in Gaza right now includes the following key factors.
1. There is a war, that was started by Gaza with a particularly brutal attack on Israeli civilians
2. The attacking "force" was Hamas, who carefully planned it - likely over years - and who have committed thousands of attacks previously. They have proven history of exploiting the "rules" of warfare with actions such as using juvenile combatants or even child suicide bombers.
3. They have very clearly stated their motivation is ethnically cleansing Israel of Jews and making it Arab / Muslim in entirety. They have not said, nor has any Palestinian committing a terror act EVER, that their goal is a two state solution or a multicultural state solution.