Clément Molin Profile picture
Aug 30, 2024 20 tweets 7 min read Read on X
In may 2024, Russian 🇷🇺 armed forces created the "North" corps aimed at putting pressure into Sumy and Kharkiv oblasts 🇺🇦.

4 months after, all eyes are on Kursk, while Kharkiv attritional fight continues, which is not a russian defeat.

🧵THREAD🧵1/20 ⬇️ Image
This is (was) the city of Vovchansk in Kharkiv oblast. In may 2024, a ~50k army crossed the border north of the city of Kharkiv but was stopped in central Vovchansk. Image
Since that time, around 12 ukrainian brigades and various battalions, worth ~20 or 30k men took position to defend the two axis of progression.

The first one is going to Lyptsi and the second one to Vovchansk. Image
The initial russian advance surprised many, but no me because there were no fortifications directly on the border.
Since I worked on the ukrainian fortification program, I understood there was no defenses directly on the border like it is the case everywhere, too dangerous. Image
As you can see on my map, there are, in fact, some fortifications on the border (which are old russian positions).
But Ukraine-Russia border is hundreds kilometers long, you can't keep men in every position.
So the main defensive line is located 5 to 10km from the border. Image
Thus the ukrainian armed forces couldn't hold the initial russian advance and abadnonned many positions. It was an error.
In fact, there were a few errors : the main line wasn't completed and positions were not occupied by soldiers.
But then, many people said russian objective was to capture Kharkiv city, or at least, to threaten it.

When videos came out, we only saw an infantry force with few to no armoured vehicles and tanks. Image
Northern corps, named "Sever" is badly equiped. MTLB, T62 and mainly infantry.

So we are here with people lying and assuming big objectives for this corps, like advancing on Kharkiv city or threatening the rear of Kupiansk front.
Then, when russian progress was halted, these same people claimed it was a clear russian defeat to advance to Kharkiv city.

They said Ukraine managed to stop the advance and were showing counterattacks in Vovchansk and Hlyboke.
This narrative is false.

Firstly, the russian corps did not even aimed at reaching Kharkiv. It was created and poorely equiped for one mission : DIVERSION.

Just look at videos, they are advancing with loafs and vans... Image
I believe they attacked these two places for one main reason : defensive advantage.

Rivers would be used as stop lines while forrest are good covering positions for infantry.
The city of Vochansk is also ideal to settle and hide, while the Ukrainians are trying to take it back. Image
The other direction is also perfect for defense : high ground, some forests, rivers and lakes, villages and positions facing south because they were dug by the russian army. Image
Both direction have the same advantage, high ground on the russian side. The next step was to build defenses. Ukraine targeted a few escavators but the work was done : Image
Image
I mapped some of these new russian trenches :

They are used to hide and to advance to the "meat grinder", Vovchansk. Image
I told you, this city is disputed since may 2024.

Here is the current frontline. Ukrainian forces regained territory after succesful counter-attacks, but the russians are stil trying to push them out of the northern part of the city. Image
Russian FABs are raining on small towns and forest plantations around Vovchansk. They can fire these tens of kilometers from there, inside Russia without risking there air assets. Image
On this front, Russia managed to attract at least 10 brigades from the Donbass and elsewhere, in a place where ukraine is loosing men against poorely trained and equiped russian soldiers.

Vovchansk is an ukrainian forces magnet.
Just look at all the videos @UAControlMap volounteers located in Vovchansk et Hlyboke : it shows how the attritional fight is ongoing there. Image
Image
With a 50k army, Russia managed to open a new front, attracted a few ukrainian brigades (which would have been useful in the Donbass) and opened the condition for an endless fight in Vovchansk city.

I believe this was the plan and it was successful.
However, Kursk offensive may have changed some things.
Most of the russian reinforcements are coming from Kharkiv front, this could allow ukrainian forces to use less troops into this direction or to try to take back territory all the way the recognized border.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Clément Molin

Clément Molin Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @clement_molin

Feb 16
L'Ethiopie 🇪🇹 se rapproche de plus en plus de la guerre civile généralisée

La mobilisation massive de l'armée éthiopienne dans le nord, son retrait de larges zones de l'Amhara⚫️, vers le Tigré 🟡 et les tensions frontalières font craindre un conflit majeur.

🧵THREAD🧵1/24⬇️ Image
L'Ethiopie, 2ème pays le plus peuplé d'Afrique est très régulièrement surnommée la "Yougoslavie d'Afrique", car elle est en réalité une fédération ethnique.

La lutte de pouvoir qui opposent ces ethnies provoque des conflits meurtriers. Image
Ces dernières semaines et en particulier ces derniers jours, l'armée éthiopienne (ENDF) a déplacé des dizaines de milliers d'hommes vers le nord du pays.

La région visée, le Tigré était déjà au cœur d'un conflit meurtrier entre 2020 et 2022 qui avait fait 600 000 morts.
Read 24 tweets
Feb 15
Each day that passes gives Ukraine 🇺🇦 more time to prepare new fortifications that will ultimately slow down russian 🇷🇺 offensives.

The recent russian setbacks allowed Ukraine to largely reinforce its fortification strategy.

🧵THREAD🧵1/16 ⬇️ Image
Ukrainian fortifications are improving. The main defensive lines (yellow) are meant to protect Ukraine's rear.

Between these main lines, we can find multiple smaller ditches lines are barbed wire lines. This strategy is cutting the frontline : Image
We now have multiple squares and rectangles between main and secondary lines.

The frontline is literraly cut in pieces, the black ones are the finished/expected ones and the grey the larger ones, behind, that will be later cut in between. Image
Read 16 tweets
Feb 14
Contre-attaque victorieuse pour l'Ukraine 🇺🇦

Après plusieurs semaines de contre-attaques, l'armée ukrainienne a repris le contrôle de larges territoires disputés dont ~12 villages dans l'est de l'oblast de Zaporizhia.

L'armée russe 🇷🇺 a été repoussée.

🧵THREAD🧵1/18 ⬇️Image
Profitant de la suspension de Starling à l'armée russe (qui permettait de faire voler les drones russes et de communiquer) et de Telegram, l'armée ukrainienne a lancé une série de contre-attaques locales dans le secteur de Ternuvate et Pokrovsk'e, à l'est de Zaporizhia. Image
Les ukrainiens ont utilisé d'importants moyens mécanisés, une première depuis plusieurs mois, profitant notamment des mauvaises conditions météorologiques et de la suspension de Starlink qui empêchent les drones de voler.

Ces assauts ont eu lieu à l'ouest du côté de Ternuvate. Image
Read 21 tweets
Feb 12
I now managed to map 24 000 russian 🇷🇺 and ukrainian 🇺🇦 artillery strikes from the Dnipro to the russian border.

With this map, I'll show you exactly where Russia is putting its biggest offensive efforts and where Ukraine is counter-attacking.

🧵THREAD🧵1/20⬇️Image
With 12k artillery (and airstrikes) found last week, I now added 12k more, including 8k more in the same area as last week (Dnipro to Kostiantynivka).

This work is entirely volunteer and free, I mapped those 24 000 dots by myself.

You can support here : buymeacoffee.com/clement.molinImage
Most of the artillery strikes impacts are concentrated in 4 main areas :

-Hulialpole/Pokrovsk'e : 8 000 !
-Pokrovsk/Dobropilla : 7 000 !
-Siversk : 1 200
-Kupiansk : 1 200 Image
Read 20 tweets
Feb 10
Did Ukraine 🇺🇦 launch a counter-offensive in Zaporizhzhia oblast ?

Multiple accounts reported about this, but it is not really the truth.

Most of ukrainian progress happened in the grey zone, taking back villages which Russia 🇷🇺 was not controling.

🧵THREAD🧵1/12 ⬇️Image
The main question is where is the frontline. I already talked about it twice recently, especially with this analysis of shell impacts.

Take a close look on the Ternuvate direction, you can see barely no artillery/air strikes

Image
On these maps from @M0nstas, you can see the big difference on the definition of frontline from a pro-russian source and a pro-ukrainian source. Image
Image
Read 12 tweets
Feb 8
Le divorce entre l'Arabie Saoudite 🇸🇦 et les Emirats-Arabes-Unis 🇦🇪

Depuis plusieurs mois, les deux riches royaumes sont en pleine confrontation, voici un Etat des lieux :

Cliquez sur la carte et zoomez, analyse carte par carte dans les tweet suivants ⬇️

🧵THREAD🧵1/10 ⬇️Image
Commençons d'abord par la carte sans la légende, pour une vision globale d'un coup d'oeil.

Le sujet ici est l'éclatement au grand jour de la rivalité KSA-UAE au Moyen-Orient et en Afrique. L'objectif est de montrer l'ampleur de l'influence émiratie et ke retour saoudien. Image
Prendre connaissance de la légende est également important pour pouvoir comprendre la carte.

A la fin, j'ai ajouté un petit texte comprenant les sources et une explication de la méthodologie Image
Read 10 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(