Ori Goldberg Profile picture
Sep 1 9 tweets 2 min read Read on X
1/ Things are shifting here. The Palestinians are still far from anyone's mind. Very few are calling for an end to the genocide or even an end to "the war". Palestinian lives and deaths are meaningless to us in our murderous solipsism. But our own deaths are something else. --->
2/ The six hostages found dead today drove home a point that has eluded us so far. It isn't that Hamas is an existential threat; we suddenly understand that we are our own existential threat. The coin has dropped that our behavior pver the past 11 months is lethal for us. --->
3/ Three of the six who died could have been released in the deal that Israel has obstructed for months. They likely died because Israeli forces were attacking with the knowledge that hostages were nearby. They were not old "kibbutzniks" but young people of all persuasions. --->
4/ They died minutes before the IDF arrived, proving that "military pressure" was killing the hostages and not saving them. And they died after 11 months of implosion, on the first day of school, when it suddenly seemed unreal to realize that things were only getting worse. --->
5/ The chief of our national confederacy of unions has announced a general strike for tomorrow. He stated that "a hostage deal" is being delayed for "political reasons" and this must be protested. This is a big deal because he is known for his timidity. --->
6/ He is a bellweather for the broad Israeli consensus, much broader than the leaders of the protests against Netanyahu. This is the first national institution to take sides against the government's policy. The government seems to be committed. No one knows. --->
7/ Things to remember:
1. This is still all about us. The shared illusion is that we are within our rights to continue the slaughter in Gaza and in the West Bank.
2. Regardless, many of us previously full of righteous indignation are now full of fear. --->
8/ We realize that we are the ones killing ourselves. That is where our darkness has been pierced.
3. This is not about redemption. We have long lost any moral standing we may have thought we had. We carry out and support a genocide. We remain alone in our world. --->
9/ We may be beginning to realize we cannot do this forever with impunity. We have gotten a glimpse of our own finitude. I can only pray that this brings hope to our victims, a breath of life to countermand our death.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Ori Goldberg

Ori Goldberg Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ori_goldberg

Sep 2
1/ What is happening in Israel today? We should begin with what is not happening. Very few are calling for an end to the genocidal campaign in Gaza that is spilling over into the West Bank. We don't care about the Palestinians and fail to connect their plight to ours. --->
2/ Israel declared this war as having two goals: Destroying Hamas (all sorts of qualifications were added later as Hamas failed to be destroyed) and the return of the hostages. Most of us believed these goals to be commensurate, perhaps even complementary. --->
3/ The illusion of complementarity snapped yesterday, with the discovery of 6 dead hostages in a Rafah tunnel. Assuming they had been killed by Hamas, they were shot minutes before an IDF force raiding the tunnel arrived on the scene. Our offensive was killing the hostages. --->
Read 11 tweets
Aug 31
1/ Israel has lost control of its genocide. We are out of control in Gaza, where humanitarian conditions are deteriorating , dozens of Gazans are killed every day by Israeli bombings and even humanitarian workers are not immune to Israeli bullets. --->
2/ Israel has lost control of its genocide in the West Bank, destroying refugee camps, besieging medical facilities, shutting the down the Ibrahimi mosque in Hebron and killing more and more Palestinians each day as part of its "anti-terrorism operation". --->
3/ It is seemingly self-explanatory to see the mounting death and destruction as a decades-long plan unfolding in real time. The majority of Israelis support "the war". At best, they call for a "hostage deal" because we need to "bring them home now". Will the "war" end? --->
Read 12 tweets
Aug 29
1/ I would like to consider Israel's "operation" in the West Bank not as the next step in Israel's plan to ethnically cleanse the Palestinians and rob their land but as a sign of desperation and destabilization, not just of Israel but of a global paradigm of power. --->
2/ It is logical to see a plan in Israel's demeanor. It behooves us to think that evil is meticulously planned. If it is then we can tell evil apart from good through careful observation. We can then take active measures to refrain from evil and ultimately defeat it. --->
3/ I don't think Israel has a plan. Did Israelis plan in advance to ethnically cleanse the Palestinians in 1948? They did, and at the very least they capitalized on opportunities to do so. What is happening in Gaza and the WB is worse, I think, because there is no plan. --->
Read 14 tweets
Aug 28
1/ Languishing in Gaza and in Lebanon, Israel is turning to the West Bank. Of course, Israel has been on a rampage in the West Bank for several years, even under the PMship of Lapid and Bennett. Now there is talk of an Iranian-funded terrorism surge that "must" be stopped. --->
2/ The "Iranian threat" is a wondrous tool that lets Israel off all and any hooks. If everything bad that happens to Israel (it always happens to us) is Iran's fault then Israel is not responsible for the consequences of its actions. Our hands are tied. What would you do? --->
3/ It isn't really about Iran. For Smotrich it may be about annexation. For the generals and the former generals it may be about maintaining a semblance of functionality after the abysmal failures in Gaza and Lebanon. Israel uses all its military might but to no avail. --->
Read 12 tweets
Aug 27
1/ I'm in analogous state of mind. Today I keep thinking of Israel as the country-sized version of Harvey Weinstein. There is brilliance there, but it is so profoundly intertwined with abuse of power, with prowling for the kill, with isolating the weakest and pouncing. --->
2/ There is the knowledge and the silence, the enabling. So many people gain from letting Israel/Harvey do whatever the hell they want... The money keeps rolling in. Every project leads to the next, each grounded in more abuse and more violation. And in silence. --->
3/ There is the self-perpetuating illusion of normalcy. This has been going on for so long that it simply is the epitome of the normal. Women are ushered up to the Weinstein suite and everyone involved knows to back away and come back after the deed is done. --->
Read 8 tweets
Aug 26
1/ Many smart, good people here believe Israel has a plan. It wants to take over and settle Gaza, or it wants to kill as many Palestinians as possible, or it is angling for a regional war motivated by debauchery at a national and ideological level. I beg to differ. --->
2/ I would like to propose that the best position from which a nation can defend an outlook of murderous solipsism (we are the only real people in the world and we'll kill anyone who suggests otherwise) is the middle ground. A point of origin or a destination are obstacles. --->
3/ Think of Schrodinger's cat. There is no creature more solitary than that cat when he is in a sealed box, neither and both alive and/or dead. That is our goal and that is why we are eager to defend intermediate solutions that get us nowhere in particular. --->
Read 13 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(