Mike Hoerger, PhD MSCR MBA Profile picture
Sep 10, 2024 7 tweets 4 min read Read on X
PMC COVID-19 Forecasting Model, Sept 9, 2024
🧵1/7

Nationally, we appear to have passed the peak of our late-summer wave, and it's not pretty.

At peak:
🔹>1.3 million daily infections
🔹2.8% (1 in 36) actively infectious
🔹Transmission higher than 90.5% of the pandemic

We are showing a peak around Aug 10, but as you look closely at the graph and in later Tweets, you'll see it was bimodal, with near-identical transmission on Aug 10 and Aug 24.

The CDC consistently corrects historical data, so in hindsight, we might expect the official peak date to flip to the 24th, or for the stats on the 10th to jump higher.

We had expected that Friday's data release might show this was the largest summer peak all-time (by the slimmest of margins), but the prior week's data were retroactively corrected downward by about 5%.

This is a common occurrence, which is why it's important to focus on the big-picture forecast (very bad transmission the remainder of 2024) as opposed to minute details.

Let's walk through the details in this Thread....Figure shows the 9 waves of the U.S. COVID-19 pandemic. We are in the 5th-largest wave, and the 2nd largest summer wave. The statistics in the Tweet summarize the peak of the current wave.
PMC COVID-19 Forecasting Model, Sept 9, 2024
🧵2/7

The current year-over-year graph on Covid transmission is troubling. We just had the worst August of Covid transmission in the U.S.

We are likely to have our worst September, worst October, and potentially worst November of transmission.

We expect to bottom out around 850,000 daily infections in early November, before the winter surge picks up.

These new monthly records for Covid transmission are the consequence of #LaissezFairePublicHealth, especially the 1-day isolation policy, but more generally that public health officials are not describing transmission frankly and the need for multi-layered mitigation.Graph of year-over-year transmission. The current surge appears to have peaked, just under the daily peak of the 2022 summer wave, and is setting the stage for four months of monthly records in transmission, based on year-over-year monthly comparisons.
PMC COVID-19 Forecasting Model, Sept 9, 2024
🧵3/7

Zooming in, see the forest for the trees: About 74 days in a row with 1 million daily infections.

The peak date is somewhat arbitrary, and either Aug 10 or 24 may be estimated the peak in hindsight.Graph shows the prior year of transmission and 1-month forecast. Daily infections will remain >1 million for nearly another month, and are projected to reach 74 days in total.   Once below 1 million, only expect daily infections to get down to about 850,000/day in early November, then get much worse.
PMC COVID-19 Forecasting Model, Sept 9, 2024
🧵4/7

Statistics to reinforce the significance of the ongoing pandemic:
🔹1.1 million daily infections on average the next month
🔹2.2% (1 in 45) actively infectious any given day of the next month
🔹High-risk in classroom-sized settings
🔹>1.5 million resulting Long COVID cases from infections derived during the next monthCurrent Levels for Sep 9, 2024 % of the Population Infectious 2.4% (1 in 41) New Daily Infections 1,157,000  New Weekly Infections 8,099,000  Resulting Weekly Long COVID Cases 405,000 to 1,620,000  Monthly Forecast Average % of the Population Infectious 2.2% (1 in 45) Average New Daily Infections 1,061,933 New Infections During the Next Month 31,858,000 Resulting Monthly Long COVID Cases 1,593,000 to 6,372,000  Running Totals Infections Nationwide in 2024 199,788,000 Average Number of Infections Per Person All-Time, U.S. 3.38  How Does Risk Increase with More Social Contacts? Number of peop...
PMC COVID-19 Forecasting Model, Sept 9, 2024
🧵5/7

This is the current heat map for Covid transmission. We released this Friday, given the ongoing debate about the CDC coloring their map in cool blue using the same data.

PMC COVID-19 Forecasting Model, Sept 9, 2024
🧵6/7

Here are regional estimates of transmission. Note that you can estimate the percent of your state actively infectious by looking up the CDC Level on their website and multiplying it by 0.330.

These are approximate estimates and higher quality in states with more and longer-standing wastewater sites.

Go here, select a state from the drop-down:


For example, in Louisiana the most recently-reported CDC Level is 8.31.

8.31 * 0.330 = 2.74, signifying that 2.74% of the state is estimated to be actively infectious with Covid.

Take 100 divided by that number to get the "1 in ____" statistic. For example, 100/2.74 = 36.45, signifying that 1 in 36 people in Louisiana are estimated to be actively infectious.

Watch your decimals, and remember these formulas can't just be thrown at any random wastewater tracker.cdc.gov/nwss/rv/COVID1…Estimated Percentage Actively Infectious  PMC Model (carries forward to Sept 9) | Raw CDC Data (uses most recent data from the CDC website on Aug 31)  National	2.4% (1 in 41)		2.6% (1 in 39) Northeast	1.7% (1 in 57)		1.8% (1 in 54) Midwest	2.7% (1 in 38)		2.8% (1 in 35) South	2.6% (1 in 38)		2.8% (1 in 36) West	2.9% (1 in 35)		3.0% (1 in 33)
PMC COVID-19 Forecasting Model, Sept 9, 2024
🧵7/7

Here's the complete dashboard. Use, crop, improve, and share as desired across other platforms and the web. Tag me if helpful.

Read the full report and technical appendix online:
pmc19.com/dataDashboard had six areas, summarized in each of the preceding Tweets

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Mike Hoerger, PhD MSCR MBA

Mike Hoerger, PhD MSCR MBA Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @michael_hoerger

Jan 25
During this 12th COVlD wave, the CDC reports 1-in-3 states have "High" or "Very High" levels.

PMC estimates the proportion of residents actively infectious (prevalence):
◾️USA: 1 in 67
◾️IA: 1 in 27
◾️MI: 1 in 25
◾️IN & CT: 1 in 23
◾️ME: 1 in 21
◾️OK & SD: 1 in 17

🧵1/ Heat map using CDC data. National PMC prevalence estimate noted; estimated incidence of 732,000 new daily infections.
On average, Americans have have 5.0 cumulative SARS-CoV-2 infections.

This week's infections are expected to result in 1/4 to 1 million new #LongCOVID conditions and ≈2,000 excess deaths.
🧵2/ Column 1: Table of state-level prevalence estimates. Highest estimates noted in the thread text.  Column 2:  Proportion Actively Infectious										1 in 67 (1.5%) New Daily Infections										 732,000  Infections the Past Week										 5,220,000  Infections in 2026										 24,000,000  Cumulative Infections per Person										 5.04  										 Long COVID										 Long COVID Cases Resulting								37,000 to 146,000		   from New Daily Infections										 Long COVID Cases Resulting								261,000 to 1,040,000		   from New Weekly Infections										 										 Excess Deaths										 Ex...
The wave peak is now estimated >10% higher than last week at 1.2 million new daily infections, nearly double the Delta wave.

We expect sustained high transmission (≈600,000 to 750,000 new daily infections) the next few weeks as COVlD circulates through schools/families.
🧵3/ Fig 1: Graph of 12 waves  Fig 2: "Barometer" showing above average transmission  Fig 3: Year-over-year graph, which informs the analytic forecast  Fig 4: Forecast described in post
Read 4 tweets
Jan 17
Based on today's CDC & Biobot data, we estimate the following for the week of Jan 19:

🔸1 in 52 people in the U.S. actively infectious
🔸25% chance of exposure in a room of 15 ppl
🔸Nearly 1 million new daily infections
🔸5 cumulative infections per person all-time (avg)
🧵1/5 Heat map from CDC data with PMC estimates. Description of "Very High" states in next post
Transmission estimates have been marginally corrected upward.

11 states have Very High COVlD levels:

🔸PA: 1 in 25 estimated actively infectious
🔸MI: 1 in 23
🔸OH & KY: 1 in 22
🔸SD: 1 in 20
🔸NE & IA: 1 in 18
🔸IL & ME: 1 in 17
🔸IN: 1 in 16
🔸WV: 1 in 11
🧵2/5 Proportion Actively Infectious										1 in 52 (1.9%) New Daily Infections										 941,000  Infections the Past Week										 6,020,000  Infections in 2026										 18,000,000  Cumulative Infections per Person										 5.01  										 Long COVID										 Long COVID Cases Resulting								47,000 to 188,000		   from New Daily Infections										 Long COVID Cases Resulting								301,000 to 1,200,000		   from New Weekly Infections										 										 Excess Deaths										 Excess Deaths Resulting 									270 to 450	   from New Daily Infections										 Excess Deaths Resulting 				...
We're in the middle of a 12th COVlD wave.

The peak has likely passed, but with students headed back to school, transmission is expected to remain high for at least the next several weeks.

🧵3/5 1) Graph of 12 waves 2) Barometer showing above-average transmission 3) Year over year graph 4) Forecast for transmission to decline and then percolate at high levels
Read 5 tweets
Jan 10
The size of the winter COVlD wave has been revised upward as post-holiday data come in.

We estimated 1 in 55 people in the U.S. are actively infectious.

🔥WV: 1 in 14
🔥IN: 1 in 15
🔥MI & OH: 1 in 21
🔥MO: 1 in 22
🔥CT: 1 in 24
🔥KS: 1 in 25
🔥MA & IL: 1 in 27

Quick 🧵 1/4 Heat map and PMC estimates, 1 in 55 infectious and 892,000 new daily infections for Jan 12.  We expedited the report to release it two days early.
Nationally, we are seeing an estimated 892,000 new daily SARS-CoV-2 infections, meaning a 1 in 4 chance of exposure in a room of 15 people. Risk varies considerably by state.

We are approaching an average of 5 infections per person since pandemic onset.
🧵 2/4 Alabama	Moderate Alaska	Very Low Arizona	Very Low Arkansas	High* California	Very Low Colorado	Low Connecticut	Very High Delaware	Moderate District of Columbia	Very Low Florida	Very Low Georgia	Very Low Guam	Very Low Hawaii	Very Low Idaho	Very Low Illinois	Very High Indiana	Very High Iowa	High Kansas	Very High Kentucky	Moderate Louisiana	Moderate Maine	High Maryland	High Massachusetts	Very High Michigan	Very High* Minnesota	Moderate Mississippi	Low* Missouri	Very High* Montana	High Nebraska	High Nevada	Very Low New Hampshire	Moderate New Jersey	Low New Mexico	Moderate New York	High* North Ca...
We are in the 12th COVlD wave of the U.S.

Current transmission is higher than 68% of all days since the pandemic onset in 2020.
🧵 3/4 12 waves of COVlD  Pandemic barometer: Higher than 88% of the past 100 days, 73% of the past year, 68% of the entire pandemic.  Year over year graph  Forecast of slowly declining transmission.
Read 4 tweets
Jan 8
You might not have heard, but the northeastern U.S. is in a COVlD surge.

We use wastewater levels to derive estimates of the proportion of people actively infectious in each state (prevalence), e.g., 1 in 24 people in Connecticut.

Let me walk you through it...

🧵1/8 Colors show CDC levels PMC prevalence estimates noted: -Maine 1 in 38 actively infectious with COVlD -New Hampshire 1 in 35 (limited data) -Vermont 1 in 75 -New York 1 in 44 (limited data) -Pennsylvania 1 in 44 -Massachusetts 1 in 36 -Connecticut 1 in 24 -Rhode Island 1 in 41 -New Jersey 1 in 82
Notice that #Connecticut has excellent SARS-CoV-2 wastewater surveillance. It's "Very High" across much of the state, per CDC.

Based on wastewater levels, we estimate 1 in 24 residents are actively infectious w/COVlD. That's a 66% exposure risk in a room of 25 people.

🧵2/8 Colors show CDC levels PMC estimate of prevalence
The CDC reports "Very High" levels in #Massachusetts.

The surveillance is less robust, but we estimate 1 in 26 residents are actively infectious, similar to our estimate in CT where coverage is better.

In a room of 25 people, that's a 62% chance of an exposure.

🧵3/8 Colors show CDC levels PMC prevalence estimates provided
Read 8 tweets
Jan 8
We're in the middle of a 12th COVlD wave in the U.S., with transmission particularly high in the Midwest and Northeast.

The CDC announced this week that COVlD continues to kill more Americans than breast and prostate cancer combined.

Get boosted & #MaskUp 💉💪😷
1/4🧵 Heat map of CDC data with PMC prevalence estimate
Levels are "Moderate" to "Very High" in 26 states.

However, data reporting is slow, and about 1/3 of states have low-quality data this week due to the holidays and illness.

2/4🧵 National estimates: Number of People		Chances Anyone is Infectious			 1				1.5%	 2				3.0%	 3				4.5%	 4				6.0%	 5				7.4%	 10				14.3%	 15				20.7%	 20				26.5%	 25				32.0%	 30				37.0%	 50				53.8%	 75				68.6%	 100				78.6%	 200				95.4%	 300				99.0%
Barometer: Higher transmission than 90 of the past 100 days (perhaps higher still, due to low data reporting quality)
State	CDC Level	Actively Infectious Alabama	Moderate	1 in 48 (2.1%) Alaska	Very Low	1 in 152 (0.7%) Arizona	Very Low	1 in 201 (0.5%) Arkansas	High*	1 in 36 (2.8%) California	Very Low	1 in 484 (0.2%) Colorado	Moderate	1 in 49 (2.0%) Connecticut	Very High	1 in 24 (4.2%) Delaware	Low*	1 in 70 (1.4%) District of Columbia	Very Low	1 in 5,835 (0.0%) Florida	Very Low	1 in 284 (0.4%) Georgia	Low	1 in 90 (1.1%) Guam	Very Low	1 in 687 (0.1%) Hawaii	Very Low	1 in 874 (0.1%) Idaho	Very Low	1 in 169 (0.6%) Illinois	Moderate*	1 in 56 (1.8%) Indiana	High*	1 in 34 (2.9%) Iowa	Moderate	1 in 41 (2.4%) Kansas...
State	CDC Level	Actively Infectious Missouri	Moderate*	1 in 42 (2.4%) Montana	High	1 in 34 (2.9%) Nebraska	Very High	1 in 26 (3.9%) Nevada	Very Low	1 in 138 (0.7%) New Hampshire	High*	1 in 35 (2.9%) New Jersey	Low	1 in 82 (1.2%) New Mexico	Low	1 in 87 (1.2%) New York	Moderate*	1 in 44 (2.3%) North Carolina	Low	1 in 82 (1.2%) North Dakota	High*	1 in 34 (3.0%) Ohio	Very High	1 in 27 (3.7%) Oklahoma	Moderate*	1 in 62 (1.6%) Oregon	Very Low	1 in 170 (0.6%) Pennsylvania	Moderate	1 in 44 (2.3%) Rhode Island	Moderate	1 in 41 (2.4%) South Carolina	Moderate	1 in 54 (1.9%) South Dakota	Very High	1 in...
If like years 1-4 of the pandemic, the winter wave has peaked. If like last year, we could hover near peak levels for a month.

Forecasting quality is low with 1/3 of states having data issues. Hopefully, we'll know a lot more in a few days.

3/4🧵 12 waves
Proportion Actively Infectious										1 in 65 (1.5%) New Daily Infections										 749,000  Infections the Past Week										 5,390,000  Infections in 2026										 3,000,000  Cumulative Infections per Person										 4.88  										 Long COVID										 Long COVID Cases Resulting								37,000 to 150,000		   from New Daily Infections										 Long COVID Cases Resulting								270,000 to 1,080,000		   from New Weekly Infections										 										 Excess Deaths										 Excess Deaths Resulting 									220 to 370	   from New Daily Infections										 Excess Deaths Resulting 					...
year over year graph
forecast
Read 4 tweets
Jan 5
We told you that 109,000-175,000 Americans would died of COVID (excess deaths) in 2025.

Today, the CDC estimates 101,000 deaths/year (flat from Oct 2022 to Sep 2024), and likely higher when considering more nebulous non-acute excess deaths (heart attack 6 months later).
1/5
The CDC estimates are actually higher than I would have guessed, given their methodology, which models estimates based on easily countable factors in healthcare and expert input on multiplier values. It lends credence to the PMC upper bound of excess deaths of 175,000/yr.
2/5
What's troubling is the CDC has annual mortality flat. My expectation based on mortality displacement and Swiss Re data is that it should be declining. If is stays flat, we're running on something like breast+prostate cancer or lung cancer deaths per year in perpetuity.
3/5
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(