Saul Sadka Profile picture
Sep 23, 2024 12 tweets 5 min read Read on X
I almost feel bad for Hezbollah. They’ve spent the 18 years since the Second Lebanon War preparing for this day.

They dug bunkers and tunnels, turned bedrooms into missile silos, and mosques into fortifications. (1/8)
They concealed firing positions under bushes across Lebanon's hills and in the Bekaa Valley. They carefully distributed their weapons.

But in those 18 years, Israel has been working too, and the technological advances in that time have vastly increased Israel's edge. (2/8) Image
What the IDF has now confirmed in this video was obvious: there’s no doubt they have centimeter-level 3D models of every building in Lebanon. On lidar maps, the entrances to all of Hezbollah's "secret" hideouts would light up like Christmas trees. (3/8) Image
It’s trivial to track changes in these maps: when a farmhouse is extended, when new tracks appear in a wood, the changes show up bright.

Like the French in the 1930s, Hezbollah prepared for the last war. It turns out they’ve built a modern Maginot Line. They’re cooked. (4/8)Image
As their civilian human shields head north, leaving them exposed, Hezbollah's fighters will now be scrambling through the brush and across the hills, unable to safely use roads and with no way to contact each other. They’ll desperately try to reach whatever rockets they can, only to ineffectually fire back at Israel.

But they’ll be tracked by Israel's endless eyes in the sky and eliminated along with their rockets. (5/8)Image
The question is: Can Israel sufficiently reduce the Hezbollah threat with targeted airstrikes alone and avoid a ground incursion?

In the past, this would have been impossible, even with carpet bombing.

However, with the new technology available and complete air superiority, Israel may be able to keep their enemy pinned down from the air, slowly degrading them into dust. (6/8)
If the Israelis do need to go in, it might be sufficient to cut off Hezbollah's heartland in the south from the Bekaa Valley, and thus from resupply from Iran, just as was done to Hamas at Rafah, sealing their demise. It might even be possible to achieve this from the air alone.

Lebanon's geography makes this feasible, as it is split north-south by mountains and east-west by around 12 large canyons. There are no more than seven bridges across each canyon, and there are minimal passes through the mountains.

(7/8)Image
Israel would just need to pick a river and make it impassable for Hezbollah with a few bombs. With careful monitoring, Hezbollah's southern activities would dry up and fizzle out.

The Litani River probably isn’t far enough north, as it bisects Hezbollah's Shia heartlands, and parts of it are less than 10 km from Israel.

Don’t be surprised if the bridges on the Awali or Damour rivers go kaboom at some point.

If the Israelis do go in, it might simply be to take up positions on the very lightly populated (mostly Druze) western reaches of Mount Hermon (highlighted). Occupying those heights, with one of the valleys made impassable, would force Hezbollah's communications over a single mountain road—essentially turning it into a shooting gallery.

(8/8)Image
Based on the number of major ammo cookoffs that people are posting, the IDF claim to have destoryed 50% of Hezbollah's stocks doesn't look implausible. The IDF are unlikely to let up now that even the minority of civilians who remained have fled the battlefield.



Looks like a Hezbollah cruise missile cooking off somewhere in the Bekaa Valley at around 6 pm local time. Dramatic.
@GAZAWOOD1 thank you

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Saul Sadka

Saul Sadka Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Saul_Sadka

Feb 23
These are the 24 hostages still held in Gaza who will not be among the four released on Thursday. The remains of 34 others, who have been declared dead by the IDF, are also being held.🧵

From top left:

1. Eitan Horn
2. Segev Kalfon
3. Bipin Joshi
4. Guy Gilboa-Dalal
5. Avinatan Or
6.  Yosef Haim Ohana
7.  Nimrod Cohen
8.  Rom Braslavski
9. Evyatar David
10. David Cunio
11. Tamir Nimrodi
12.  Bar Kupershtein
13.  Gali Berman
14.  Eitan Mor
15.  Edan Alexander
16.  Pinta Nattapong
17. Omri Miran
18. Elkana Buchbut
19. Alon Ohel
20. Matan Zangauker
21.  Ziv Berman
22.  Ariel Cunio
23.  Maxim Herkin
24.  Matan AngrestImage
1. Eitan Horn (37) was captured alongside his brother Iair, there are serious concerns for his heath. Image
2. Segev Kalfon (26) was kidnaped from the Nova festival. His family recently received a 'sign of life'. Image
Read 26 tweets
Feb 12
Walls. What are they good for? And why Jordan should beg Israel to annex the Jordan Valley—and why it probably will soon.

Israel built two walls. One a complete success; the other a total failure. The Israel–Egypt border fence succeed while the Israel–Gaza one failed? (1/12)Image
Image
Faced with an endless wave of drug smuggling and human trafficking from Africa toward Israel across the lawless Sinai desert, and increasing public unrest about the approximately 80,000 illegal immigrants (about 1% of Israel’s population at the time) who had arrived in previous years, Israel built a 150‑mile barrier along the border with Egypt in 2010.

It cost about $3 million per mile and took three years to complete across the mostly mountainous, arid terrain. (2/12)Image
Before this, the border had been marked by a bare‑metal fence that was easily skipped over and had mostly collapsed or disintegrated into the sand. The new barrier reduced smuggling and human trafficking to a trickle.

But an even more sophisticated barrier between Gaza and Israel failed completely, resulting in a war that has been ongoing for a year and a half with no end in sight. Why did one fail and one succeed? (3/12)Image
Read 13 tweets
Jan 30
An intractable and revealing tension:

On the left, a hostage release the way Hamas likes it, portraying a picture of victory.

On the right, the setting for today's release of Arbel Yehoud, Agam Berger and Gadi Mozes—after some production notes from Qatar—featuring a devastated landscape, to present a picture of victimhood.

Both are lies. They are defeated, and they are not victims.Image
When you see images like this, of Palestinian flag bunting used as decoration for the celebration of war crimes aggaisnt Jews, can you blame Jews worldwide for seeing thst flag as a hate symbol? If Abbas was a leader he would protest this and tell Hamas to use their own flags.
Hamas and the UNRWA education system have made Gaza a very sick society.
Read 5 tweets
Jan 20
The year 2025 marks 20 years since the BDS movement set out to bring about the defeat of Israel by isolating it geopolitically and boycotting it economically. So let's review the results of their campaign: 🧵 Image
Over that period, Israel has overtaken all the major European nations in terms of GDP per capita and now boasts the 8th highest GDP per capita in the world, of all nations with 10 million population. Image
Image
Far from being isolated, the Israeli passport is now one of the most powerful in the world:

Israelis have visa-free or visa on arrival access to 170 countries, making the Israeli passport 19th in the world. Image
Read 9 tweets
Jan 15
Since Hamas are now celebrating their “great victory” over Israel, let's review their many achievements over the last 15 months in the light of their initial goals:

1. They failed to conquer Jerusalem.
2. They failed to drive the Jews into the sea.
3. They failed to split Israeli society—instead they united them.
4. They failed to isolate Israel internationally—even the Abraham Accords remain intact.
5. They failed to harm Israel’s economy, which continues to grow.
6. They failed to prove Israel was fragile—if anything, they demonstrated the opposite.
7. They failed to make the Jews “flee back to Europe,” as Israel’s population has increased by 2.5%.
8. They failed to crash Israel’s currency, which is now stronger.
9. They destroyed their own “axis of resistance.”
10. They derailed the geopolitical plans of their backers, Iran, leaving them completely exposed.
11. Their once-fertile land is now devastated, requiring a generation to rebuild.
12. Most of their homes, booby-trapped and used as weapon caches, are destroyed. Clearing the rubble alone will take decades.
13. Their tunnel network is gone.
14. They have alienated almost all their own people.
15. They have lost 99% of their rockets and have no means to rearm.
16. Their leaders are either in hell or in Qatar—or both.
17. Most of their fighters are dead.
18. Over 5,000 of their men will face trial for war crimes.
19. They lost their fighters at a 50:1 ratio compared to Israeli troops.
20. More than 10% of their population has fled, and perhaps another million have lost everything.
21. They caused destruction and losses among their allies in Lebanon.
22. They are now boxed in by the IDF, with no hope of resupply and no means of harming Israelis.
23. They tarnished the reputation of their UNRWA allies.
24. Israel has established a presence in their territory and will maintain constant surveillance.
25. They are being extirpated from the West Bank by their own Palestinian brothers.

What other “great Hamas victories” can you think of?Image
Happy Unvictory Day to Hamas!
The mad hatter appears to be wearing a hat saying 10/6. Hamas will dream of 10/6 forever. It was their last day.
Read 4 tweets
Jan 11
It's not a miracle. It's called "concrete." Image
To be honest, I don't really understand why people build beautiful new homes with timber adjacent to forests that combust at regular intervals. Concrete houses will still often get destroyed in fires, but not nearly as often. Particularly if the glazing holds up.

It can't really be to save money? On some of the most expensive building plots on the planet?
This is the before picture from about a year ago. The house on the left of the survivor might also not be wood, but as we can see, the survivor is brand new construction, while the one on the left is 25 years old plus. It's a matter a luck too. Image
Read 7 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(