Saul Sadka Profile picture
Sep 23 12 tweets 5 min read Read on X
I almost feel bad for Hezbollah. They’ve spent the 18 years since the Second Lebanon War preparing for this day.

They dug bunkers and tunnels, turned bedrooms into missile silos, and mosques into fortifications. (1/8)
They concealed firing positions under bushes across Lebanon's hills and in the Bekaa Valley. They carefully distributed their weapons.

But in those 18 years, Israel has been working too, and the technological advances in that time have vastly increased Israel's edge. (2/8) Image
What the IDF has now confirmed in this video was obvious: there’s no doubt they have centimeter-level 3D models of every building in Lebanon. On lidar maps, the entrances to all of Hezbollah's "secret" hideouts would light up like Christmas trees. (3/8) Image
It’s trivial to track changes in these maps: when a farmhouse is extended, when new tracks appear in a wood, the changes show up bright.

Like the French in the 1930s, Hezbollah prepared for the last war. It turns out they’ve built a modern Maginot Line. They’re cooked. (4/8)Image
As their civilian human shields head north, leaving them exposed, Hezbollah's fighters will now be scrambling through the brush and across the hills, unable to safely use roads and with no way to contact each other. They’ll desperately try to reach whatever rockets they can, only to ineffectually fire back at Israel.

But they’ll be tracked by Israel's endless eyes in the sky and eliminated along with their rockets. (5/8)Image
The question is: Can Israel sufficiently reduce the Hezbollah threat with targeted airstrikes alone and avoid a ground incursion?

In the past, this would have been impossible, even with carpet bombing.

However, with the new technology available and complete air superiority, Israel may be able to keep their enemy pinned down from the air, slowly degrading them into dust. (6/8)
If the Israelis do need to go in, it might be sufficient to cut off Hezbollah's heartland in the south from the Bekaa Valley, and thus from resupply from Iran, just as was done to Hamas at Rafah, sealing their demise. It might even be possible to achieve this from the air alone.

Lebanon's geography makes this feasible, as it is split north-south by mountains and east-west by around 12 large canyons. There are no more than seven bridges across each canyon, and there are minimal passes through the mountains.

(7/8)Image
Israel would just need to pick a river and make it impassable for Hezbollah with a few bombs. With careful monitoring, Hezbollah's southern activities would dry up and fizzle out.

The Litani River probably isn’t far enough north, as it bisects Hezbollah's Shia heartlands, and parts of it are less than 10 km from Israel.

Don’t be surprised if the bridges on the Awali or Damour rivers go kaboom at some point.

If the Israelis do go in, it might simply be to take up positions on the very lightly populated (mostly Druze) western reaches of Mount Hermon (highlighted). Occupying those heights, with one of the valleys made impassable, would force Hezbollah's communications over a single mountain road—essentially turning it into a shooting gallery.

(8/8)Image
Based on the number of major ammo cookoffs that people are posting, the IDF claim to have destoryed 50% of Hezbollah's stocks doesn't look implausible. The IDF are unlikely to let up now that even the minority of civilians who remained have fled the battlefield.



Looks like a Hezbollah cruise missile cooking off somewhere in the Bekaa Valley at around 6 pm local time. Dramatic.
@GAZAWOOD1 thank you

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Saul Sadka

Saul Sadka Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Saul_Sadka

Sep 9
Hamas Qatar & Iran meticulously executed a hybrid warfare strategy—the goal being to sacrifice its own people just to shower Israel with bad press.

Israel's dismal, disjointed reply is best encapsulated by the firing of its 2 most talented spox for petty personal reasons. (1/4)Image
Sinwar's goal wasn't military, they are not stupid.

They knew they couldn't conquer Israel's 10 million people with 3,000 men.

Their plan was to draw Israel into a war, and then use their carefully built PR operation to isolate Israel, and fracture it internally. (2/4)Image
This failed, but only by luck.

If they had killed just 100 people and taken just 50 hostages it would have worked.

But their overachievement (due to unfathomable IDF complacency) reduced their prospects of isolating Israel, and united Israel, rather than fracturing it. (3/4)Image
Read 4 tweets
Aug 21
In March, after analysing satelite maps and speaking to friends who had been in Gaza, I predicted the IDF plan, which has finally come to fruition today. Israeli tanks are now busy taking control of the port of Khan Younis (red dot) having vacated and cleared the third corridor at Gaza's narrowest point at Kisufim.

Alongside the ever widening Rafah corridor that hermetically cuts Hamas off from resupply, and the now 6km wide Netzarim corridor with its 5 fortified bases that separates Gaza City from the rest of the Strip, Gaza is now cut into three. The humanitarian zone is now also cut in two by the new corridor.

Expect this new corridor to be fortified with bases. I would not be surprised if the IDF decided to form two additional corridors (yellow lines) to separate Beit Hanoun from Gaza City and to separate Rafah from Khan Younis.

The 1km buffer zone along the border looks to also be almost entirely cleared.

There are also a number of other military roads that have had large areas around the cleared of obstacles meaning that the IDF can sit back in their bases but be at any point in Strip with 5 minutes and via unpredictable routes. The point is to make the Gaza Strip strategically controllable by a minimal IDF force.

The only urban areas that the IDF have yet to enter in force (though they are already starting) are the towns in the central portion, Deir al Balah and Nuseirat. Only there can the Hamas infrastructure still be anything like its pre-war level.

It is almost certain that most of the remaining Hamas leaders, including Yahya Sinwar, are hiding out there, as are most of the most remaining hostages. They are now surrounded on four sides, with no hope of resupply, totally enemy surveillance as if they were in a fish tank.

The IDF has played this really well. They played the slow game, perhaps against their will and under US pressure, but managed to reduce Hamas from a dug in mighty army able to fire 1,000 rockets at hour to a insurgent rabble who can only fire a rocket on special occasions.

Hamas are contained and almost totally defeated. Israel did this at a cost of 330 heroes while eliminating 17,000 enemies, taking 5,000 POWs, and taking many 1,000s more out of the fight via injury.Image
In the meantime, the Hamas T-gram groups I follow are ignoring this harbinger of their defeat and instead are laughing about a guy who had to run out of his rocket struck house in a towel in the Golan this morning.

Whatever helps them cope. Image
The purple areas are the two central corridors, and they surround a rectangle of land about 3km by 10km where we can expect the final major engagements to be fought. Image
Read 8 tweets
Aug 11
I read the New York Times hit-job on Bari Weiss, so you don't have to.

She's a heretic. A witch. Did you know she is a Jew? Her friends are Jews. She is a witch. Actually, she does Jewish stuff. She loves money. Oh, she is rich... and a Jew. Heretic. Burn. The. Witch... JEW. Image
Some selections. The rare gentile to get a mention is as you would expect going to quoted with a snide remark.

Honestly, it's quite balsy on the NYT to print such a catty article about someone that was bullied out of her job at their own paper...


Image
Image
Image
Image
To sum up: "She is a heretic...and even worse, she is just doing it for the money."
Read 4 tweets
Aug 6
People ask: Why does the UK's Sky News seem to hate Israel, even more than Al Jazeera?

The story begins in 2005, when two things happened:

1. Israel withdrew from Gaza, allowing Hamas, supported by Qatari money, to start a 19 year process of turning the Strip into the most complex battlefield in history.

2. Qatar started sponsoring Sky News, via the hourly weather forecast, to start a 19 year process of capturing the UK news narrative.

Incredibly, Sky News and Hamas are just two Qatar funded operations. No wonder they seem to get along.

(1/6)Image
While reminding potential tourists about your country in the context of "weather" when you have the most appalling climate on the planet, might seem odd (they need to cool pools otherwise they would be giant hot tubs), Qatar's goal wasn't tourism, but influence.

Sky News is a loss making venture, and by becoming its most consistent and lucrative sponsor, the tiny petro-kleptocracy slave-state of Qatar can buy easy influence for a pittance. (2/6)Image
It is how, for example, Kay Burley made Eylon Levy very very famous with that "Eyebrows moment."

The hidden premise of her question was basically, "Since, as we know, Juice are evil..."

It took 19 years of Qatari patronage, and new ownership—from Murdoch's News Corp to Comcast—to become Al Jazeera+. (3/6)
Read 7 tweets
Aug 4
How is Israel able to act in Iran, assassinating scientists and terror chiefs at will?

How fragile is Iran? (tldr: very.)

One map and one chart explain this and more:

Iran is a patchwork of ethnicities, with 52% of its population being non-Persian. Each of the other groups would rather be self governing, or even part of other states. (1/6)Image
Conveniently for these ethnic groups, there are effectively open borders that link them with their ethnic kin.

The loyalties of Kurds, Arabs, Azeris, Balochs, Pashtuns and a dozen others, are to their clan and ethnicity much more than they are to any Persian religious fanatics who have brought them to ruinous poverty.

The Azeris border their homeland of Azerbaijan, an Israeli ally, and are 30% of the population. They have oil, and want to be free; and Israeli-ally Azerbaijan (which unlike Iran, has a real military) is surely waiting for the opportunity to help them. (2/6)Image
Look at this chart: Fully 45% are openly secular, irreligious, atheist or agnostic. Another 8% are Zoroastrians, the original Persian religion that pre-dates the Islamic conquest.

Only 32% profess the same Shiite religion of the oppressive, millenarian cult, that has ruined the lives of 3 generations now. And certainly a large portion of them are Shiites, but have no interest in the loopy theology of the Mullahs. (3/6)Image
Read 8 tweets
Jul 31
For 2,000 years Jews were pillaged and slaughtered, they couldn't do much. They packed up what remained and moved on to the next place. But this is a new world now, with new rules.

When Ismail Haniyeh grinned as he watched the gore of the Oct 7 pogrom that he orchestrated from Qatar, he didn't imagine his days were numbered, but they were—299 days to be precise.
Condolences are due to many many people in the West, not least his dear friend, the former MP George Galloway, who has been losing a lot of friends lately.

All Haniyeh wanted was the genocide of all Juice, is that so unreasonable?

Here they are in happier times:Image
Here is Israel's current progress through the top of it's "playing cards list": Here are the face cards. Khaled Mashal probably wants to find a nice loose fitting Burqa and try to get back to Qatar... Image
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(