Sina Toossi Profile picture
Oct 20 23 tweets 9 min read Read on X
🧵A very important piece: an Israeli outlet reports severe morale loss and exhaustion among soldiers, with many now refusing to serve.

Based on interviews with soldiers and families across units, it's described as a "suppressed but growing phenomenon."

ha-makom.co.il/idf-droppings/Image
Image
2/ The piece opens with a striking anecdote:

In September, the Nahal Brigade began its 11th round of combat in Gaza, but out of a platoon of 30 soldiers, only 6 showed up—the rest claimed medical exemptions.

"I call it refusal and rebellion," says the mother of one soldier. Image
3/ The mother describes the sense of futility the soldiers feel:

"They keep going back to the same buildings they’ve already cleared, only to find them booby-trapped again. In the Zaytoun neighborhood alone, they've been there three times. They understand it’s pointless." Image
4/ One IDF soldier explains that the growing shortage of manpower means missions are "done halfway."

He adds, "The platoons are empty; those who aren’t dead or physically wounded are mentally broken. Very few come back to fight, and even they aren’t fully okay." Image
5/ The soldier notes that all of this was happening before the escalation in Lebanon and the current ground incursion.

He says, "I don't know with what army they think they'll enter Lebanon, because there is no army. I'm not going back to the battalion." Image
6/ The article states that this a suppressed but growing phenomenon of soldiers refusing to fight. The unity and sense of mission that once drove them has faded. "They fought until their last ounce of strength, but reached a point where they just couldn’t continue." Image
7/ Many parents say the soldiers' morale began to break down in April, as the war dragged on, and their sense of purpose started to fade.

"When they had to return to places we’d already been, like Jabalia, Zeitoun, and Shuja'iyya, it broke them," one parent explained. Image
8/ "What’s killing them are the conditions and the prolonged fighting without any end in sight," says on parent. "Not to mention the loss and the horrific scenes they witness in Gaza." Image
9/ One soldier says, "We’re sitting ducks in a shooting range. We don’t understand what we’re doing here...The hostages aren’t coming back, and it just feels never-ending—soldiers are getting injured and dying along the way. It all seems pointless." Image
10/ The article states that most of these soldiers refusing to serve (under medical exemptions) aren’t being sent to jail, and the whole situation is being kept quiet. Image
11/ It adds that after 12 straight months of a war that feels directionless, soldiers describe themselves as “black”—military slang for feeling depressed, exhausted, and drained of motivation.

"Today the motivation is zero." Image
12/ The article describes the situation Israeli soldiers face in Gaza: the only "music" they hear is the sound of air force bombs, and the air reeks of death and decay. They feel abandoned by the army, treated like mere tools on the path to "absolute victory." Image
13/ One Israeli soldier says: At a certain point, we were all exhausted & couldn’t see the purpose in going back to places we’d already been...Eventually, I stopped feeling anything. I lost faith in the system & no longer believed in what we were doing. Image
14/ The Israeli soldier recalls, "I was mentally exhausted, having anxiety attacks so severe that when they told us we were done maneuvering, I thought I’d get a break. I broke down, crying on a lawn, saying I couldn’t take it anymore. I was completely finished mentally." Image
15/ The soldier says his commander accusing him of "abandoning the country" & reprimanding him before the platoon.

But "the day," another "soldier came up to me and asked how I did it. He wanted to, but didn’t have the courage."

The next day, he left too. Image
16/ The shortage of soldiers has forced those who need mental health treatment to fight.

"My son went to his company commander & said, 'I feel like my alertness has dropped so much that I’m not only putting myself at risk, but also those around me. I’m not as sharp as I was." Image
17/ One father says, "The only way to stop this downward spiral or get some rest is to say, 'I refuse,' and then you're instantly treated like the most humiliated person on earth...It doesn’t matter what you’ve sacrificed, what you’ve been through, or what you’ve done." Image
18/ On the other hand, those who do manage to get mental health leave face emotional blackmail.

One soldier’s brother explains that when his sibling returned home, he couldn’t sleep in his room, barely ate, & was in severe mental distress--but still was forced to go back. Image
19/ Cultural differences among Israeli soldiers from different nationalities also complicate addressing morale issues.

One commander told his subordinates, "I come from a Polish family, where we don’t talk about feelings—that’s how I was raised, and that’s my way." Image
20/ A similar situation is unfolding with soldiers entering Lebanon. Exhausted, hundreds of paratroopers recently united to fight for "their rights", expressing anger, frustration, and distress over the lack of understanding about their urgent need for rest at home. Image
21/ Stunningly, these paratroopers entering Lebanon are being threatened with fines for military equipment lost or destroyed on October 7 or during the fighting and are denied new equipment until they sign that they are responsible for the loss. Image
22/ The piece ends with a powerful statement from an Israeli soldier: "If the treatment doesn’t improve soon, the little wind left in our sails will also disappear." Image
23/23 This isn’t the only Israeli report highlighting faltering morale and manpower shortages in the country's military.

These reports raise serious questions about the feasibility of Netanyahu prolonging the Gaza war or escalating conflicts with Lebanon and Iran.

/end🧵

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Sina Toossi

Sina Toossi Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @SinaToossi

Oct 13
🚨🧵Today, Hezbollah launched its most devastating attack on Israel since the war began, targeting the elite Golani Brigade base south of Haifa, causing over 70 casualties.

Exact numbers of dead & wounded are unclear due to Israel's strict censorship on reporting such attacks.


2/ Israeli media reported that a drone struck the base undetected, with no sirens sounding before it hit the dining hall, where soldiers & officers were reportedly present.

Initial reports suggested Chief of Staff Herzi Halevi was there, but Israeli sources have denied this. Image
3/ @ynetnews: According to the Arabic Sky News network, the drone was launched under the cover of a rocket barrage targeting the Galilee. The Saudi channel Al-Hadath, citing anonymous sources, reported that the drone "fired a missile" before exploding.

ynet.co.il/news/article/h…
Read 10 tweets
Oct 10
🧵Fmr Israeli General Itzhak Brik gives a scathing critique of Israel's war strategy, warning that Netanyahu is leading Israel to "collapse."

He says Israel is stuck in unwinnable wars of attrition, & calls for diplomatic solutions w/ Hezbollah & Hamas.

maariv.co.il/journalists/op…
2/ Brik warns, "Even conquering territories in Lebanon won't stop the war of attrition, as the IDF will eventually withdraw. Hezbollah will continue launching missiles at Israel from even greater distances than the areas we capture." Image
Image
3/ Brik calls for a "measured" response to Iran's missile attack, coordinated with the US to avoid escalation.

He warns that while Iran can survive strikes on its oil wells, a hit on Israel's energy infrastructure could be devastating: "Who can guarantee we would survive?" Image
Image
Read 7 tweets
Oct 8
🧵We need an English-language exposé on Reza Pahlavi's monarchist movement.

He's like an Ahmed Chalabi on steroids, serving Netanyahu's agenda.

With little organic support, he's boosted by social media manipulation as vocal opposition against him grows daily, even in diaspora.
2/@thomasjuneau rightly calls out Reza Pahlavi's idea that there "won't be a power vacuum when the Islamic Republic falls" as delusional.

Pahlavi, son of the overthrown Shah, clearly hopes Israel will magically topple the Iranian govt, & he will take over
@thomasjuneau 3/ Reza Pahlavi & his supporters aggressively tried to hijack the Iranian opposition movement following the 2022 Women, Life, Freedom protests, despite being irrelevant to the protests themselves.
Read 20 tweets
Oct 1
🧵 on the rapid developments after Iran's missile attack on Israel.

The coming hours & days will be crucial in determining if a regional war erupts.

Iranian missiles reportedly hit several military targets, including Tel Nof Airbase south of Tel Aviv, as seen in this video.
2/ Netanyahu, in his first statement regarding the Iranian attack: "Iran made a big mistake this evening and will pay the price. The Iranian regime does not understand our insistence on defending ourselves and responding to our enemies. We will strike back."
3/ Iran's Defense Minister Brigadier General Nasirzadeh:

"A variety of our missile products were used in this operation.

"Our targets were solely military and intelligence-related, fully legitimate.

"If the Zionist regime responds, they will receive a much harsher response.

This operation was simply a countermeasure, but if they retaliate, we will launch the next wave."
Read 10 tweets
Sep 25
🧵on the latest in the Israel-Lebanon conflict from today:

This graphic from an Israeli analyst shows Hezbollah's increasing missile range into Israel.

Today also saw a reported Hezbollah strike on a target in Tel Aviv for the first time.

>>>

2/ Hezbollah announced it fired a Qadir-1 ballistic missile at Mossad HQ on the outskirts of Tel Aviv at 6:30 AM local time.

This clip from Israel's Channel 13 captures the moment sirens blared across Tel Aviv.

Image
3/ Hezbollah confirmed today that Ebrahim al-Qubaisi, the commander of its missile unit, was killed in an Israeli missile strike on Beirut yesterday. This marks another significant blow to the organization. Image
Read 10 tweets
Sep 22
🧵Hezbollah has escalated its attacks, targeting the strategic port city of Haifa & expanding its missile range across northern Israel.

This surge, significant in terms of number & kinds of missiles fired & damage caused, follows a week of Israeli airstrikes & assassinations.





2/ As hundreds of thousands take shelter and the region shuts down, a local official in Haifa district warned: "I feel the equation is shifting. It would be a serious escalation if we end up in the same situation as the north."

ynet.co.il/news/article/r…
3/ Haifa Mayor Yona Yahav: "No one from the government or even the military has been here. We are handling everything on our own with the residents. It's not possible to continue like this. We will deplete our public budget, and what will we do next?"

ynet.co.il/news/article/r…
Read 24 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(