Trump seeks to end the independence of the Federal Reserve. No advanced western democracy does this. The reason is simple: when politicians mess with monetary policy they do so for political reasons. It usually results in massive inflation. brookings.edu/articles/feder…
Harris, by contrast, is proposing economic ideas that are meeting the challenges of the moment.
@Noahpinion wrote a great explainer for Harris's housing policies and how they would alleviate the housing shortage. noahpinion.blog/p/harris-has-t…
Harris is also expanding upon a good idea for medicine already started by the Biden-Harris admin and used by most developed countries: have the government negotiate with big pharma for better prices.
If you or a loved one have diabetes or heart problems, you benefit.
2) Abortion.
This is treated as a culture war issue. It is bizarre to me that a medical issue is. It became extremely personal earlier this year when my wife learned at 13 weeks that our baby's heart had stopped and her body would not pass the fetus itself.
I am not a medical expert nor an expert on all of the abortion bans that Republicans have implemented at the state level around the country.
What I can tell you is that it is painful to learn a baby you wanted and planned for has no heart beat and your wife needs an abortion.
Grieving and having to make medical decisions rapidly is hard enough. Doing so while the government is meddling in your medical care is unacceptable.
If there is ever a Senate majority for securing abortion rights nationally, Harris will sign it.
Trump won't.
3) Presidents have the most unilateral power when it comes to foreign policy. They can deploy the most powerful military on earth. They can pursue diplomacy to strengthen America.
It is not a power to be taken lightly.
There were two world wars within decades of each other that took tens of millions of lives on every continent on this planet.
There have not been any since. That's not a coincidence. That's a result of the global architecture America built after being dragged into war twice.
The pillars of that global architecture are NATO and military alliances in Asia which constrain rogue powers like Russia and China. They promote respect for land borders.
Coupled with free trade, it has produced more prosperity and far smaller wars than what came before.
Trump seeks to abandon NATO. He seeks to force Ukraine into an unfair peace with a Russia that starts land wars in Europe, a direct cause of previous world wars.
We will not be able to avoid getting dragged into those wars anymore than we avoided WW1 and WW2.
How we can avoid that outcome is by upholding the American alliance system. By arming Ukraine to beat back the Russians and uphold the norms about borders not being decided through conquest.
3A) A foreign policy issue of high personal importance is Israel. While anti-Israel activists win a lot of headlines, there are millions of Americans like me who believe America's relationship with Israel is in our national interest.
Trump, while paying lip service to Israel, prioritizes his support for Iran's closest ally, Russia.
A stronger Russia will result in a stronger Iran.
The same Iran that funds, arms, and trains Hezbollah and the Hamas 10/7 butchers.
Iran is currently supplying Russia with missiles and drones for its genocidal war in Ukraine. The same one Trump wishes to see Putin win.
Russia collaborates with Iran in propping up a Syrian gov that allows Iran to establish a land bridge to Hezbollah to provide them arms.
Trump's support for Russia doesn't just tacitly benefit Iran.
The last time Trump was in office he leaked Israeli intelligence from Syria to the Russians. Which they promptly shared with Iran. timesofisrael.com/horrified-isra…
Trump's running mate Vance openly puts daylight between the U.S. and Israel. He would abandon Israel in the event of a more open war with Iran. timesofisrael.com/vance-us-and-i…
While 80,000 Israelis in northern Israel have been displaced and many have been maimed and killed as a result of Hezbollah's unjustified year-long bombing of northern Israel, Trump campaigns in Michigan to end the "suffering" of *Lebanon.*
Harris is not abandoning her principles to win votes in Michigan. Whatever disagreements you may have with her Israel policy, what you see is what you get.
Nobody can truthfully say the same for Trump.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
The Columbus shenanigans remind me that one of the most frustrating things about the "who is a Jew" question, particularly when discussing historical figures, is how often the debate is informed by ideas that are alien to Judaism.
Judaism is an ancient and deeply communal religion. It predates concepts of race, DNA, and individualism.
If you are born Jewish and you convert to another religion, you are not simply welcomed back into the fold if you're famous. It's not your decision. Judaism is a communal religion.
Some thoughts on the situation regionally in light of the confirmation that Nasrallah is dead, a thread.
1) The performance of the IDF and Israeli intelligence in dealing with Hezbollah is markedly better than their engagement with Hamas.
That's not a weird quirk. It reflects the strategic read of Israel about which war they anticipated and prepared for before 10/7.
2) We know that when Hezbollah began bombing Israel on 10/8 that the Israeli military was advocating for action then. Biden and Netanyahu were both opposed. Now we know why the IDF was so confident about action against Hezbollah.
For no particular reason, a thread of American politicians the Turkish government has tried to influence lawfully and covertly.
1) Eliot Engel, Jamaal Bowman's predecessor, was a vocal critic of Turkey’s policies, particularly on issues like the Armenian Genocide and Turkey’s conduct in Syria's civil war.
Bowman wasn't. Turkish affiliated groups donated tens of thousands of dollars to him.
2) A critic of the Turkish President Erdogan's government resides in the U.S. Erdogan wanted him extradited. Turkey sought to plant evidence on said critic and sent unregistered agents to the U.S., to do it. Some have been arrested.
1) For the unfamiliar, Edelstein was a prominent otkaznik ("refusenik") from Soviet Ukraine. For the crime of being a Jew who wanted to reclaim his culture and his ties to the Jewish people, he was sent to the Gulag.
2) Among the prominent otkazniki who ended up in Israel, Edelstein is the only one left who is still relevant in electoral politics.
Others are in the periphery of the political sphere, getting political appointments to non-political agencies, writing books, or are retired.
It's very difficult to parse the debate about the Philadelphi corridor. It's clear Hamas wants Israel out so they can renew smuggling weapons into the strip. It's also clear Israel's public and security establishment don't trust Netanyahu to negotiate for the hostages.
The messaging coming out of Israel's security establishment is that Netanyahu included Philadelphi in the negotiations to stall the talks. Probably has truth to it.
What I struggle with is their claim, repeated by Gallant in multiple forums, that they can simply return.
I remain a skeptic that Israel can simply return to Philadelphi. First of all, they paid in blood to take it in the first place. It will come with similar costs in blood to do so.
Secondly, it's not clear that Israel will have the diplomatic room to do so.
How I am thinking about the hostages Hamas executed, the politics around it, and where we go from here. This thread will probably not be short.
A preface: I am hearing from friends who knew the murdered hostages. I am seeing the posts from hostage families.
I will do my best to think critically, but I am no more detached than anyone else in the Jewish world. I may come to view things differently with more time.
1) In moments of tragedy, there is an instinct to start trading blame. It is natural, it is human.
Yet we must remember responsibility for people who are murdered first and foremost lies with those who murdered them.