Just BeCause Profile picture
Nov 5 25 tweets 7 min read Read on X
1/ As stated by the media, only 30% of the shells Russia is currently using are manufactured domestically. If this is accurate, Russian Soviet-era ammo arsenals should be empty by now. To prove or refute this claim, I’ve reviewed Russian arsenals, and here are my observations. Image
2/ Reported Russian shell usage ranged from 50,000 to 10,000 per day in Spring 2024. Given the numerous ammo dumps destroyed in 2022 following the deployment of HIMARS, the sheer number of shells used is enormous, which should have strained the Soviet-era ammunition supply.
3/ According to The Insider, Russia has been refurbishing and producing 1.7 million shells annually since 2014, totaling at least 13.6 million shells, along with an unknown quantity of older shells that needed refurbishing due to their age by 2022. theins.ru/politika/254514
4/ So, by 2024, Russian arsenals should theoretically be depleted, with the remaining shells or rockets likely used up by now. The best way to confirm this—yes, you guessed it—is via satellite imagery.
5/ We don’t have fresh imagery for every arsenal, but for the largest ones, the trend is visible. Let’s go through them.
6/ The first is the 1819th artillery munition base, which stores (obviously) artillery munitions. By September 2024, it’s nearly empty, with only junk piles scattered. Some ammo remains, but I’d estimate 90% is gone, and the rest is questionable.
7/ Some comments about the 1819th base. Image
8/ The 2719th Artillery Ammunition Base didn’t hold much to begin with, but by September 2024, it was completely empty.
9/ As shown in the pictures, this base was primarily used for ammo disposal. Image
Image
Image
10/ 1215th Central Artillery Ammunition Base. Same story here. I’m unsure what’s in those white boxes, but I doubt there’s anything usable at this stage (“What’s in the box?!”).
11/ MLRS ammo at the 1215th base. Image
12/ 73rd Arsenal GRAU: Primarily underground bunkers, but the outdoor storage sections are nearly empty by September 2024. It looks like they’re clearing the area, perhaps for more bunkers. A train there appears to be loaded with 3m slim boxes, likely MLRS rockets.
13/ Some comments about the 73rd arsenal. Image
Image
14/ The 100th arsenal is almost empty, with large cleared areas around it.
15/ For the 7th arsenal, we don’t have recent satellite imagery, but by autumn 2022, significant depletion was already evident, with entire sections gone.
16/ The 51st arsenal, in September 2024, showed much less activity compared to October 2022. Sections near the train station are empty, likely due to either reduced shipments or an effort to keep everything inside bunkers for protection. It seems an incident occurred there.
17/ These observations from the arsenals storing ammo outside indicate little Soviet-era ammunition remains available.
18/ Arsenals closer to the Ukrainian border serve as logistics hubs for recently produced and North Korean-provided shells. Some were destroyed recently as you can't store ammunition 2000 km away from the front lines, so these logistics points must stay closer.
19/ Regarding artillery from storage, Highmarsed, Jompy, and Covet Cabal have reported that Russians have taken over 8K SPGs and towed guns (without mortars) from storage. If they average 20K shells used per day, Russia would have used over 18 million shells by mid-2024. Image
Image
20/ Given a gun barrel loses accuracy after around 3,000 shells, it suggests that over 6,000 barrels may have worn out. However, some of these reported shells are mortar shells, and storage guns also replace destroyed ones. So, the estimate of 8,000 "used" artillery pieces fits.
21/ More about towed guns in storage here:
22/ Key points of this thread:

- Russia has indeed depleted its Soviet-era shell reserves.
23/

- The role and contribution of North Korea are underestimated. According to media reports, Russia now produces between 3 and 4.3 million shells per year—8,000-12,000 per day, but it isn’t enough to maintain the 2022-2023 usage pace. North Korean support is crucial.
24/

- Russia’s artillery reserves are still substantial, likely enough for another 2+ years. Training with North Korean artillery has already been reported though. You might disagree, but they’ve had more artillery guns in storage than tanks and BMPs combined.
25/ That’s it for now! If you enjoyed my work, consider supporting me on Buy Me a Coffee, with Patreon and PayPal links in my bio.



Alla prossima!buymeacoffee.com/justbecauseosi…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Just BeCause

Just BeCause Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @a_from_s

Nov 11
1/ And I’m back with another thread. If you’re following research on Russian losses and storage bases, this one is probably one of the most important, as I see a lot of misconceptions people have. So let’s roll. Image
2/ "Did Russia run out of things? Will they? When? Why hasn’t Russia run out yet?" — these are the most common questions, and I’ll try to answer them.
3/ First, a quick recap. The Russian invasion stalled in the North in 2022, followed by two successful Ukrainian counteroffensives and a failed Russian offensive by 2023, resulting in major Russian equipment losses. Image
Read 23 tweets
Oct 30
1/ Russian BMP refurbishment rate has peaked and is now slowing down. In today’s thread, we’ll explore repair plants and major BMP storage bases to uncover some trends. Image
2/ First, let’s look at how many BMPs were taken from storage. Referring to Jompy’s spreadsheet on BMP-1/2/3: by mid-2024, 2,565 vehicles were taken from storage. docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d…
3/ These 2.5K units include almost all BMP-2/3s that were in storage and the best of the BMP-1s. Around 3,744 remain, with approximately 400 being PRPs and around 3.3K BMP-1s.
Read 24 tweets
Oct 25
1/ From storage base to battlefield: Part 2. Back with another thread on T-80s tanks in Russian storage. This time, I’ll dig deeper into what’s been missed and what’s been scrapped. Grab a coffe before reading! :) Image
2/ The main question is: how many T-80s were actually in storage? You might’ve heard about 3,000 T-80s stored, but let’s dig deeper to find them. I recommend reading part one of the research before continuing here.
Image
3/ Tracking T-80s wasn’t easy due to changes between 2009-2015. Initially, they cut their military and essentially said, “Forget T-80s; we’re sticking with T-72s and T-90s.” But by 2013-2014, with Ukraine’s revolution, T-80s returned to service as new units formed for an invasion Image
Read 25 tweets
Oct 17
1/ From storage base to the battlefield - I’m back with a big research/investigation on Russian T-80 tanks. I’ve tracked the movement of these tanks and am going to uncover refurbishment rates and look closely at storage bases for more insights. Grab a coffee before we start :) Image
2/ I’ll start with refurbishment at the Omsktransmash plant in chronological order to understand what’s been going on there. So, in the summer of 2022, Russian cowboy moves in northern Ukraine didn’t go as planned, and it became clear that the sprint had turned into a marathon.
3/ So, they started preparing for mass refurbishment of old equipment. There are two repair plants specializing in T-80s - 61 BTRZ and Omsktransmash. The 61st was actually the main T-80 refurbishment facility and had a lot of T-80s in its own storage… Image
Read 44 tweets
Oct 12
It’s time for another thread! Today, we’re exploring spare SPG and towed gun barrels in Russian storage bases and looking into what’s been happening there since the beginning of the war. I would like to share with you my observations. Image
To start, Russian storage bases became flooded with equipment after military reforms in the 2010s. Vehicles had to be stored and organized. During this period, many SPGs and towed guns were disassembled for spare parts that remained in storage bases.
Here’s a quick 2010-2021 time-lapse of the 94th Arsenal to show how it took a while before things became organized. This is true for every base I’ll cover in this thread.
Read 22 tweets
Oct 9
A thread on a German storage base and facility for dismantling tanks and IFVs. Has anything changed since the beginning of the war in Ukraine? Let’s find out!

Disclaimer: this thread contains sensitive content for German vatniks.

1/12 Image
Let’s start with what this is all about. The Koch Battle Tank Dismantling firm is located in the village of Rockensußra. The company specializes in dismantling battle tanks and armored vehicles from the German armed forces and others.

2/12 Image
Image
Image
For years, tanks and infantry fighting vehicles came here to die... But no more! New satellite imagery shows that things have changed.

3/12 Image
Image
Read 13 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(