This fall has been grim for Ukraine. According to our assessment, between 1 September and 30 November, the Russians captured over 1600 km2 in Ukraine, and retook roughly 500 km2 in Kursk. The rate of advance accelerated every month, despite the Russians suffering heavy losses. 1/
Already at the end of the summer, the situation seemed to be developing in a worrying direction. Especially in August, the Russian gains were relatively large, and it did not seem like the Ukrainian offensive in Kursk would significantly slow down the Russians. 2/
During the fall, while making progress in Ukraine, Russia also conducted several counterattacks in Kursk. Ukraine lost the western flank of the salient, while also losing positions in the east. Between September and November, Ukraine didn’t advance significantly in the area. 3/
Main focus of the Russian offensive this fall has been the area of Pokrovsk and Kurakhove. In November, after the loss of Vuhledar, Russians also advanced quickly to Velyka Novosilka. Currently, most of the changes on the frontline are happening on a 140 km section. 4/
Russians are pressuring elsewhere too, but have not gained much in the big picture. Ukrainians held the Toretsk-Chasiv Yar-Siversk direction well, denying Russians of any greater progress in northern Donetsk. The front in Zaporizhzhia didn’t see much change during this fall. 5/
In Kupiansk, the Russians managed to advance to the Oskil river, cutting the Ukrainian presence there in half. However, this can be considered a secondary front without very significant opportunities for the Russians, regardless of whether they are on the river or not. 6/
What can we expect from the rest of the year? Based on the current trends, the Russians can likely continue their offensive in the Pokrovsk-Velyka Novosilka direction. It can be expected that additional 500-700 km2 of Ukrainian land will be occupied. 7/
Russia will likely try to continue advancing in Kursk too, but concentrating very heavy forces there wouldn’t be the best usage of their troops. However, the same applies to Ukraine. Reserves would be needed elsewhere, as the eastern front has had constant setbacks for months. 8/
I’ve been posting a bit less recently, as I’ve been very busy with work. Various articles, reports, lectures, presentations, interviews, TV appearances, a podcast series and my upcoming non-fiction book military history have taken most of my time. 9/
However, we at @Black_BirdGroup still follow the situation closely. You can also find me and us from the other place with bluer skies, if that’s your preferred platform nowadays.10/10
Russia is advancing, but it’s also spending significant amounts of men and material in the process.
In this thread I’ll take a look on two important directions: Kurakhove and the concerning developments there, and the politically motivated Kursk counteroffensive. 1/
In Kurakhove, the Russians are closing in from almost all directions. They have entered the eastern part of the town, and it seems a couple of large Ukrainian fortified strongpoints have already fallen. Some troops also entered the village of Dalne. 2/
The latest advances are threatening the Ukrainian positions between Uspenivka and Yelyzavetivka. It’s unclear how firmly the Russians have been able to establish a presence in Dalne, but the fact that they’re getting there at all so quickly, is already an issue. 3/
The Russians recently launched a large offensive in eastern and southern Donetsk, on a 70 kilometers wide front.
The attack has breached Ukrainian defences in just a few days in many areas, and there can be some dangerous developments ahead, which I’ll discuss in this thread. 1/
The operation has two main focus areas, the Selydove-Kurakhivka area and the southern direction, where the enemy is currently advancing in the area between Shakhtarske and Bohoyavlenka. Both directions have their own problems and threats. 2/
In a short timeframe, Ukraine has very likely lost Selydove (over 21 000 pre-invasion residents), which is the largest city Russia has captured since the fall of Avdiivka. Simultaneously Russians also captured Hirnyk (10 000 pre-invasion residents). 3/
Recently, it has been said that North Korean troops in Ukraine are a sign of Russia’s weakness.
While this arrangement naturally proves once again that the war isn’t going as Russia initially wanted, I view this as a practical solution rather than just simple weakness. 1/
Russia's problems shouldn't, of course, be downplayed.
You don’t have to be Clausewitz to understand that the quick operation to subjugate Ukraine isn’t going very well, when you hear the words “North Korean troops will likely soon arrive in Kursk to help Russia”. 2/
However, this isn’t a relevant way to approach the matter. From Russia’s perspective, there are many benefits in cooperating with the North Koreans.
North Korea has already had a significant impact on Russia’s capabilities by selling them millions of artillery shells. 3/
In the last few days, the Russians have continued successful attacks against the western flank of the Ukrainian-controlled area in Kursk. The Ukrainian defences were breached and Russian troops were able to push relatively deep. 1/
Let’s take a brief look at the recent developments.
Russians have carried out multiple counterattacks in Kursk in September and October. The first major success was opening the land route between Glushkovo and Korenevo. For Ukraine, this was a problematic setback. 2/
From the Russian perspective, it was a pragmatic move, which was likely to happen at some point. It reduced the risk of Ukrainians cutting off and capturing Glushkovo and the area south of Seym river, as the supply didn’t solely depend on temporary bridges anymore. 3/
Vuhledar has now most likely fallen to the Russians.
Some Ukrainian sources are still reporting of resistance inside the city, but because of recent geolocations, I believe the Russians are now de facto controlling the town. The fighting continues in the surrounding fields. 1/
There can of course be some small pockets of Ukrainian defenders inside the town, and they may even have a foothold on the northeastern corner of Vuhledar. However, it can't be said that the Ukrainians would be in control of Vuhledar anymore. 2/
Capturing Vuhledar doesn't give the Russians any immediate benefits or avenues of approach towards Kurakhove.
The battles will likely soon shift to Novoukrainka and Bohoiavlenka. Between Vuhledar and Kurakhove, there's a distance of over 20 km and many fortifications. 3/
During September, Russians have made significant gains in the Vuhledar area.
The situation on a previously stable front has quickly deteriorated, and the Russians are less than five kilometers from the main supply road. 1/
Vuhledar has withstood many attacks during the years.
One of the most famous incidents was the defense against the Russian winter offensive in early 2023. The Russians attacked with a lot of armored support, but suffered very heavy losses while achieving very little. 2/
However, the battle of Vuhledar may be nearing its end soon, as the most recent developments are very concerning for the Ukrainians. There are not many fields the Russians need to capture in order to force the Ukrainians to retreat from the city. 3/