Mark Krutov Profile picture
Feb 21 20 tweets 6 min read Read on X
🧵With my colleagues, we analyzed the Russian Main Military Medical Directorate's database on 166,000 hospitalizations in Russian MoD facilities (Jan 2022–June 2024). It's incomplete but offers insights into the Russian army's dynamics. svoboda.org/a/tysyach-rane…
First things first: THIS DATABASE SHOULD NOT BE USED TO ESTIMATE TOTALS. It doesn't have those hospitalized to civilian hospitals, very limited number of wounded in 'DNR' and 'LNR' hospitals, etc. Thanks to @MassDara and @Mortis_Banned for their comments on the data we studied.
Also, A LOT of soldiers stay for a day or 2 in a field hospital before being sent back to front. They DO NOT MAKE IT TO THIS DATABASE.
Database include personal information, unit assignments, injury specifics, and treatment outcomes of the personnel. Important caveat: not ALL people in the database have ALL this information mentioned.
The database also includes those hospitalized with non-war-related injuries or even the flu. However, they are a small minority, and we assume their numbers remain relatively constant each year, so they don't significantly affect the overall dynamics.
This is a rare case where I can name the source of the leak: Alexey Zhilyaev, a Russian medic from the 144th Guards Motor Rifle Division, who defected to France in 2024. Read his interview with @severrealii here: severreal.org/a/ya-ni-o-chyo…
The database is compiled from data sent by hospitals to the Military Medical Directorate, which is then forwarded back to military units as one list to allow them to track their wounded.
We verified the database, of course, confirming that dozens of people from it fought for Russia. Some were mentioned in the press, while others were not (exhibit: a GUR Spetsnaz fighter from Dagestan and a random guy from Kazan). Image
Image
Now, a few examples. Analysis shows a decrease in the proportion of officers among the wounded as the war progressed—communications issues were being resolved, allowing Russia to pull them back; HIMARS was introduced, etc. Image
Many in the database have their wound severity mentioned. Notably, the share of severely wounded stayed +/- the same despite Russian force growth. According to our source, MEDIVAC capacities remained the same, and military hospital limits became evident too. Image
Overall shares of severely/moderately/lightly wounded (note: some 'lightly wounded' were non-war sick patients). There's also a trend of lowering wound severity in hospitals to get people back to their units faster. Image
As the military medic who provided this database says, the only injury that guarantees you won't be sent back to war is the amputation of an arm or leg. At the same time, nearly all who make it to the hospitals survive. The problem, again, lies with the MEDIVAC capacities.
Here's one of the oldest amputees in the database, 60-year-old Artur Egorov, who played saxophone in Moscow clubs before the war. Image
Image
The database shows that Russia hasn’t fully tapped into the youngest yet, with the average age of the wounded rising by 30% as mobiks and convicts were introduced—from 28 years in February 2022 to 36 in June 2023. The same issue applies to the Ukrainian army, to be honest. Image
The database also allows us to see which hospital treated the most wounded. Here's the top 8, with Rostov Military Hospital leading by a significant margin over second place. Image
The database also contains limited data on the wounded treated in Belarus (mainly Homel) during the early months of the war. Among 800 entries from Belarusian civilian hospitals, you'll find mostly National Guard troops, the 64th 'Bucha' brigade, and others. Image
We parsed the data of soldiers with both hospitalization and discharge dates to calculate the average time spent in the hospital for lightly, moderately, and severely wounded. This doesn’t include time in a field hospital, initial evacuation site, or rehabilitation. Image
As the largest part of the Russian force, motor-rifle brigades suffered most of the non-lethal losses during the period of Feb. 22 - June 24. Image
For more insights, like GRU Spetsnaz and VDV non-lethal losses or injury types by month, check the article—I'll share the link again: . This is just a starter kit; we had limited time and will share more (like SSO wounded losses) in future investigations.svoboda.org/a/tysyach-rane…
This and future investigations based on the database won't be possible without the enormous effort of @Mike_Eckel @CarlSchreck @pustota @riinaljas @disconnect and many others. Stay tuned!

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Mark Krutov

Mark Krutov Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @kromark

Feb 11
🧵/ Link in the last post. How much information can one get from a single blurred-out police video with the help of OSINT? Let’s find out together. No BS – we're talking 'possible precursors to chemical weapons or nerve agents' here, destined for Russia and seized in Spain.
Back in October 2024, Spanish police reported the seizure of 13 tons of 'chemical products' in the port of Barcelona, destined for Russia. It was claimed to be the result of a two-year-long special operation. 4 people were arrested.
interior.gob.es/opencms/gl/det…
The operation was named 'Probirka' ('test tube' in Russian) and was carried out together with the European Anti-Fraud Office (OLAF) as part of the enforcement of EU sanctions against Russia.
anti-fraud.ec.europa.eu/media-corner/n…
Read 22 tweets
Jan 10
🧵Timur Praliev, arresred in the U.S. for illegally crossing the border from Mexico, received an official 'combat veteran ID' as a 'former Wagner fighter' less than a month ago, as we found together with @Mike_Eckel and @CarlSchreck. Image
A photo of Praliev receiving his veteran ID was posted on VK on Dec. 12th. The event took place in Bashkortostan: . We found Praliev's empty VK acc., which lists the same YOB as in the U.S. court docs (1993), and one of his friends confirmed that it is him.archive.is/jYw10
What puzzles me most about this story is the timing. On December 12th, Praliev receives his official Russian veteran ID as a 'former Wagner fighter.' By January 10th, Praliev is arrested with a drone in his backpack after crossing into the United States from Mexico. Insanely fast
Read 5 tweets
Dec 14, 2024
1/2 Comparison of Dec. 5 and Dec. 10 HR @Planet satellite images of the Russian airbase in Al-Jufra, Libya, shows an Il-76 loading/unloading, as well as newly appeared objects which I hesitate to ID (maybe radars?)
2/2 Exactly one year ago, in December 2023, the Al-Jufra base was attacked, resulting in damage to a Russian Il-76 plane.
Re: Al-Jufra Dec. 10th @planet image showing Il-76 unloading (see the thread 🔼) Image
Read 4 tweets
Dec 12, 2024
🧵/ Link in the last post. Remember the recent WaPo piece about Russia expanding its secret biological lab complex near Moscow? With @pustota, we proved that a Russian defense minister personally inspected it. We also found renders, images of the construction and inside the lab. Image
Image
The new biolabs are part of the 48th Central Scientific Research Institute of the Russian Ministry of Defense. First, we found this image of the new facility on the website of the construction company responsible for the finishing works. archive.is/3t3ppImage
Using this photo, we identified the company that produced and installed the windows in the new labs (). They had published renders of the entire project, which align with Google Earth satellite imagery. archive.is/q5ggv
Read 18 tweets
Dec 2, 2024
🧵/ link in the last post. Together with @Mike_Eckel and help from @C4ADS, we found that a Chinese company, which recently acquired a US plant in California and whose shares trade on the Swiss stock exchange, has shipped electronics to sanctioned Russian firms linked to military. Image
Not only were electronics produced by this company found in Russian guided aerial bombs in Ukraine, but some shipments were also made to the infamous FSB unit 34435, an employer of the 'poisoning squad' responsible for the 2020 poisoning of Russian dissident Alexey Navalny. Image
Image
This is not the first instance of this FSB military unit receiving shipments that bypass sanctions; the previous case was even more alarming.
Read 7 tweets
Nov 26, 2024
1/2 Not only did the Russian MoD acknowledge for the first time that ATACMS hit their targets, but also published photos of the rockets, one taken near the 'Pantsir' installed at Khalino air base in July and visible in a @planet satellite image from Nov. 2nd. Image
2/2 More photos of the ATACMS missile parts from the Russian MoD, taken in Khalino (t.me/mod_russia/462…) and Lotarevka (t.me/mod_russia/462…), where the S-400 missile system was hit. Image
Image
Image
Image
Bonus post: Just noticed that Yandex now started to blur out some Russian military facilities as well (Khalino air base in this case). Image
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(