Using corn to make fuel increases the price of food.
This is not disputed.
Yet some Republicans are insisting on keeping costly ethanol provisions of the Democrat “green new deal” in the Republican budget reconciliation plan.
This is not disputed.
Yet some Republicans are insisting on keeping costly ethanol provisions of the Democrat “green new deal” in the Republican budget reconciliation plan.
I asked Grok if ethanol subsidies and mandates increase food prices. Here’s Grok’s answer:
Ethanol mandates and subsidies can indeed push up food prices, and here’s how it plays out. In the U.S., the Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) requires blending ethanol—mostly made from corn—into gasoline. Subsidies, like tax credits or direct payments to producers, sweeten the deal for ethanol makers. This jacks up demand for corn, a staple crop for both fuel and food. When more corn gets diverted to ethanol refineries, less is left for livestock feed, processed foods, or export markets. Basic supply and demand kicks in: reduced corn supply for food purposes means higher prices for corn-based products.
Look at the numbers. In 2022, about 40% of U.S. corn production—roughly 5.3 billion bushels—went to ethanol, according to the USDA. That’s a massive chunk of a crop that also feeds cattle, pigs, and chickens. When corn prices rise—say, from $3 a bushel to $7, like they did between 2020 and 2022—feed costs for livestock climb too. That ripples through to higher prices for beef, pork, eggs, and dairy at the grocery store. A 2011 National Academy of Sciences study pegged the RFS as bumping corn prices by 20-40% in tight supply years. More recent analyses, like from Iowa State’s CARD in 2023, suggest ethanol policies still add about 10-15% to corn prices annually, depending on harvest yields and global demand.
It’s not just corn, either. Land that could grow wheat, soy, or other crops gets planted with corn instead because ethanol keeps corn profitable—subsidies have historically pushed corn’s return per acre above other grains. The USDA says cropland devoted to corn hit 92 million acres in 2023, crowding out alternatives. Less wheat or soy means tighter supplies and higher prices for bread, cooking oil, and tofu too.
On the flip side, ethanol backers argue it’s not the mandates alone—global factors like weather, oil prices, and trade wars mess with food costs too. They’re not wrong; the 2022 Ukraine invasion spiked grain prices worldwide, ethanol or not. Plus, ethanol coproducts like distillers’ grains get fed back to livestock, offsetting some feed cost hikes. A 2021 Renewable Fuels Association report claimed this keeps the food price impact under 5%. But that’s a tough sell when corn prices drive so much of the ag economy—USDA data shows a $1 increase in corn per bushel adds about $0.40 to a pound of retail beef over time.
Globally, it’s messier. In poorer countries, where people spend 30-50% of income on food (vs. 10% in the U.S.), ethanol-driven grain price jumps hit harder. The 2007-2008 food crisis partly blamed U.S. ethanol policies for spiking corn and tortilla prices in Mexico—FAO estimated a 10-15% food price bump there tied to biofuels.
So, yeah, ethanol mandates and subsidies generally nudge food prices up—how much depends on harvests, markets, and policy tweaks. Without them, corn might stay cheaper, but gas prices could climb unless oil steps in. It’s a trade-off: fuel security vs. food affordability. What’s your take on balancing those?
Ethanol mandates and subsidies can indeed push up food prices, and here’s how it plays out. In the U.S., the Renewable Fuel Standard (RFS) requires blending ethanol—mostly made from corn—into gasoline. Subsidies, like tax credits or direct payments to producers, sweeten the deal for ethanol makers. This jacks up demand for corn, a staple crop for both fuel and food. When more corn gets diverted to ethanol refineries, less is left for livestock feed, processed foods, or export markets. Basic supply and demand kicks in: reduced corn supply for food purposes means higher prices for corn-based products.
Look at the numbers. In 2022, about 40% of U.S. corn production—roughly 5.3 billion bushels—went to ethanol, according to the USDA. That’s a massive chunk of a crop that also feeds cattle, pigs, and chickens. When corn prices rise—say, from $3 a bushel to $7, like they did between 2020 and 2022—feed costs for livestock climb too. That ripples through to higher prices for beef, pork, eggs, and dairy at the grocery store. A 2011 National Academy of Sciences study pegged the RFS as bumping corn prices by 20-40% in tight supply years. More recent analyses, like from Iowa State’s CARD in 2023, suggest ethanol policies still add about 10-15% to corn prices annually, depending on harvest yields and global demand.
It’s not just corn, either. Land that could grow wheat, soy, or other crops gets planted with corn instead because ethanol keeps corn profitable—subsidies have historically pushed corn’s return per acre above other grains. The USDA says cropland devoted to corn hit 92 million acres in 2023, crowding out alternatives. Less wheat or soy means tighter supplies and higher prices for bread, cooking oil, and tofu too.
On the flip side, ethanol backers argue it’s not the mandates alone—global factors like weather, oil prices, and trade wars mess with food costs too. They’re not wrong; the 2022 Ukraine invasion spiked grain prices worldwide, ethanol or not. Plus, ethanol coproducts like distillers’ grains get fed back to livestock, offsetting some feed cost hikes. A 2021 Renewable Fuels Association report claimed this keeps the food price impact under 5%. But that’s a tough sell when corn prices drive so much of the ag economy—USDA data shows a $1 increase in corn per bushel adds about $0.40 to a pound of retail beef over time.
Globally, it’s messier. In poorer countries, where people spend 30-50% of income on food (vs. 10% in the U.S.), ethanol-driven grain price jumps hit harder. The 2007-2008 food crisis partly blamed U.S. ethanol policies for spiking corn and tortilla prices in Mexico—FAO estimated a 10-15% food price bump there tied to biofuels.
So, yeah, ethanol mandates and subsidies generally nudge food prices up—how much depends on harvests, markets, and policy tweaks. Without them, corn might stay cheaper, but gas prices could climb unless oil steps in. It’s a trade-off: fuel security vs. food affordability. What’s your take on balancing those?
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
