Andy Boreham 安柏然 Profile picture
Mar 10 26 tweets 9 min read Read on X
This is French reporters Justine Jankowski & Marine Zambrano. Yesterday, they both blocked me.

But why?

They recently did an "undercover investigation" in China that claimed Chinese factories use child & forced labor.

The only problem: they are lying.

And I have proof. 🧵⬇️ Image
Last summer, these two reporters from popular French show "Cash Investigation" snuck into clothing factories in China trying to prove forced labor.

They found no evidence, but banked on their audience not understanding the Chinese language.

Unluckily for them, I do. Image
So what were their claims?

1⃣ To have found child labor in a Chinese factory;
2⃣ To have found forced labor in a Chinese factory;
3⃣ To have found a factory using Xinjiang cotton in a Chinese factory.

Their 3 claims are all blatant lies.

Let's go through them one by one.
Last summer, Justine @JustineJankows1 and Marine @Marinezamb lied their way into some clothing factories in China's Shandong Province.

They wore hidden cameras and claimed they needed to use the toilet. The friendly security guards took their word for it and let them in. Image
Once inside, Marine went about trying to get evidence for her preconceived plot: forced labor.

Of course, she found nothing of the sort. In fact, the factory looked clean, orderly and relaxed.

But then she hit the fake news jackpot! Image
A 12-year-old girl was sitting next to her mother, who is employed at the factory.

Marine couldn't believe her luck! If she could prove child labor, they'd have an amazing exposé!

She asked the girl if she worked there.

"No, I just come here to wait for my mom," she said. Image
Not the bombshell Marine was looking for, so she asked the girl to sit at a work station and pretend to work.

The girl obliged, as Marine coaxed her on. "You are a diligent worker!" the reporter laughed.

"Thanks," the girl replied as her mom stood by. Image
And with that, Marine's trap for her hungry viewers on French TV was successful, and the piece was aired there as evidence of child labor.

A French NGO called Disclose worked with the TV show to make a report at the same time.

Check out what they wrote in the next tweet! 🤬
'Her tiny fingers are doing up a Decathlon navy blue polo shirt under the vigilant gaze of her mother ...

“I’m 12,” the girl replies when asked how old she is. She looks particularly small as the huge production lines of the factory where she works illegally are almost empty.' Image
Decathlon is the name of a massive French clothing brand which uses that factory in China to produce some of their clothes.

Our two French reporters want to prove the company is using forced labor in China in order to damage the brand. Image
And it worked. 'Cos of the allegations (2 of which I will tell you about shortly), the company panicked and the factory was shut down for an investigation.

The mom of the girl plead for help from the reporters for lost income (below image from Chinese TV).

They ignored her. Image
The next big lie is perhaps the most blatant.

One of the French reporters, Marine, speaks a little Chinese. But her skills are pretty average, so she mistranslated a key Chinese quote used to prove her claim of forced labor in a Chinese factory.
They found a recruitment video from the company on China's TikTok, and claimed it showed an employee saying: "We welcome workers from Xinjiang and North Korea here."

This would be a problem, because the U.S. claims workers from those places are forced to work illegally. Image
It's not true, of course, but a company like Decathlon using workers from Xinjiang, for example, would face sanctions from the U.S. government. Not good.

That's because the U.S. passed a law, called the Uyghur Forced Labor Prevention Act, which stops int'l companies hiring Xinjiang workers based on the "forced labor" lie.

Instead of using the internationally recognized legal concept of "innocent until proven guilty," the U.S. has decided that EVERY person in, or even FROM, Xinjiang who is employed, is doing so under forced labor.

This effectively stops even Chinese factories from hiring people from their own country if they happen to be from Xinjiang, for fear of being accused of forced labor, which would mean international companies like Decathlon wouldn't be willing to have clothes made there.

U.S. laws can pressure companies around the world and force them to obey, for fear of losing valuable markets.

So China, despite knowing full well that there is no forced labor in China, has to discriminate against it's own people and refuse to hire them, all based on a U.S. law.Image
So claiming the video they found on China's TikTok calls for Xinjiang workers would be a massive problem for Decathlon.

They played the video on the French TV show, and subtitled it to fit their narrative.

Problem? That's not AT ALL what the woman in the video says! Image
In the video, the factory manager doesn't say "Xinjiang," she says "man qin jiang," which means 'full attendance bonus."

And she doesn't say "North Korea" (Chaoxian in Mandarin), she says "chao tian shu jiang," which describes bonuses for working extra days.

And guess what? Image
The French NGO, Disclose, repeated the lie.

Check out what they wrote: Image
They even showed the video to anti-China conspiracy theorist Adrian Zenz, who claims to be a respected academic who can speak Mandarin Chinese.

He watches the video and can't tell the Chinese is wrong, then says this is "incontrovertible evidence" of forced labor! 🤣 Image
The final lie Justine Jankowski and Marine Zambrano tell their French viewers is that they found evidence another factory uses Xinjiang cotton.

Why would that be a problem? Well, that U.S. law forbids int'l companies using Xinjiang products, because they claim forced labor. Image
Marine asks a factory worker: "Is all your cotton produced in Shandong?"

Worker: "Not necessarily."

Marine: "I heard Xinjiang has lots of cotton."

Worker: "I heard that, too."

That's it, and they used THAT to "prove" the factory uses Xinjiang cotton! Image
That's it, y'all!

All three of the claims made in the video are easily proven as false, but @cashinvestigati still aired the show, which ultimately led to the factories involved being shut down and workers losing valuable income.

All because two French idiots want to lie!
Yesterday I posted a video explaining their lies on my show, Reports on China, which led both reporters to blocking me here on X.

But they shouldn't be allowed to get away with this.

They need to be held accountable, and shamed, for their blatant, evil actions. Image
You can help by sharing this post, and by spreading the word. I really appreciate it – let's get some justice for the harm caused by their two, vile humans.

If you want, you can watch my video report at the tweet below:
If you want to help me share this thread, please click on the first tweet (below) and reshare that one.

Thanks so much!

UPDATE: The host of the show is @EliseLucet, and it was aired on @FranceTV & @Francetele. Any comments?

The NGO, Disclose, who published the report based on complete lies can be found here: @Disclose_ngo
@EliseLucet @FranceTV @Francetele @Disclose_ngo UPDATE: Disclose, the French NGO that collab’d with Cash Investigations to produce these lies, and who wrote a written report to release at the same time, is funded by George Soros’ Open Society Foundation.

Soros is an ardent and decades-long China hater.

Follow the money! Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Andy Boreham 安柏然

Andy Boreham 安柏然 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @AndyBxxx

May 9
I had a bit of an accident on my electric scooter here in Shanghai. 🏍️

The police suggested I go for a hospital checkup, but I was worried it would take forever.

30 minutes later and I was done, including an X-Ray!

What was the process and cost? A short 🧵 Image
Firstly, I’m totally fine! They wanted to X-ray my ankle, since it was a bit battered under my bike. No problems! The rest was just fairly surface scratching.

A whole group of scooter riders went through a red light, and while trying to stop I ended up on the ground. Image
I think I hit my head pretty hard, so please wear your helmets folks! (I was.)

The police came and told me to go to the nearest hospital for a checkup.

Being from NZ, I had in my mind that it would take hours upon hours.

I was done in 30 minutes! Image
Read 7 tweets
Apr 5
Just had to translate for an elderly French couple who came back to the Shanghai restaurant I was eating at to find a wallet they left behind.

They were totally shocked.

But why? Even I didn’t understand to begin with…

🧵
The shop’s manager, as soon as she saw the couple enter, jumped up and gave them their wallet that was stored behind the counter.

The French couple were so surprised and relieved that they almost hugged the manager.

Then they started talking to her in broken English.
Of course, the manager couldn’t understand so she turned to me and asked in Mandarin: “What are they saying?”

Basically, they had left the wallet and thought it was as good as gone.

They were so happy to get it back, that they wanted to buy more from the restaurant as thanks.
Read 6 tweets
Mar 28
Anyone saying Speed was paid by the "CCP"* or worked with the "CCP"* for his recent live streams in China is just showing how little they understand this country.

A quick 🧵:

*CPC Image
QUICK BACKGROUND:
YouTuber iSpeedShow has over 37 million followers on the app, and recently streamed from Shanghai and Beijing.

His two streams gained around 10M views, and were heralded as a massive boon for China, showing his young fans a more fair and realistic view.Image
CRITICISM:
Some claimed Speed was paid by the "CCP" for his streams in China, especially after he was praised by China's embassy in the US for helping "bridge gaps."

This is an ill-informed criticism, since the CPC doesn't work directly with any foreign celebrities etc.Image
Read 11 tweets
Mar 21
LOL:

Canada has updated its travel advice for China, warning Canadians that they may be subject to the law in China if they try to smuggle in drugs etc. 🇨🇦💉💊

But why?

A short 🧵⬇️ Image
Canada is mad that China didn’t listen to Justin Trudeau when he ordered Beijing not to execute four Chinese nationals for smuggling drugs into China, because they also hold Canadian passports.

But wait! Image
In China, it’s illegal for Chinese to hold dual citizenship — they need to renounce their Chinese citizenship in order to become Canadian. They didn’t.

They entered China using Chinese passports and carrying drugs.

They were executed as Chinese nationals.
Read 5 tweets
Mar 15
🤖Grok VS DeepSeek🖲️

I asked Grok, X's AI model, and famous Chinese AI model DeepSeek a simple question:

▶️ Who is Andy Boreham?

One had an amazing reply, the other was almost completely wrong.

Decide who you think won before scrolling down to read both replies. ⬇️ Image
Before we move on, this is Yumi Ishikawa, a Japanese activist who one of the AI models thinks is my wife... Image
GROK’S REPLY:
Andy Boreham is a New Zealand-born journalist and media professional based in Shanghai, China. He works as a columnist, video producer, and journalist for Shanghai Daily, a Chinese state-affiliated English-language newspaper, and its associated platform, SHINE.cn.

Boreham has lived in China for several years, initially moving there as an exchange student to study Mandarin during his undergraduate years at Victoria University of Wellington.

He later pursued a master’s degree in Chinese Language and Culture at Fudan University in Shanghai, funded by a Prime Minister’s Scholarship for Asia awarded by former New Zealand Prime Minister John Key.

After completing his studies, he began working full-time for Shanghai Daily.

Boreham is known for his coverage of China-related topics, often presenting perspectives that align with or defend the Chinese government’s narrative.

His work includes writing columns, producing vlogs and short documentaries, and conducting interviews on topics such as Chinese culture, politics, and international relations.

He has gained attention for his criticism of Western media’s portrayal of China, arguing that it is often biased and unfair. Boreham hosts and created Reports on China, a platform where he discusses issues related to China and counters what he describes as anti-China propaganda.

He has been labeled as "China state-affiliated media" by Twitter (now X), a designation he has described as a "badge of honour," reflecting his belief that he is providing a counter-narrative to Western media.

This label has made him a controversial figure, with critics accusing him of acting as a propagandist for the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), a claim he denies, asserting that his views are his own and based on his experiences and understanding of China.

Boreham’s background also includes a diverse range of experiences in New Zealand, where he worked in media, politics, and graphic design before moving to China. He holds a triple major undergraduate degree in Media Studies, Political Science, and Chinese, and has experience in film production, having graduated from film school.

He is also involved with the New Zealand China Friendship Society, aiming to foster understanding between the two nations.

His work has garnered both praise and criticism. Supporters commend his investigative efforts, such as exposing alleged inaccuracies in Western reporting about China, while detractors view him as a mouthpiece for the CCP, pointing to his employment with state media and his defense of Chinese policies as evidence of bias.

Regardless of perspective, Boreham remains a notable figure in discussions about China’s image in global media.

DeepSeek's reply in the next tweet:
Read 6 tweets
Mar 12
China made some massive achievements last year.

Here are 10 of them. 🧵

1⃣ China's GDP hit 5% in 2024. Image
2⃣ China produced 13 million new energy vehicles in 2024, more than any other country. Image
3⃣ The Consumer Price Index rose 0.2% in China last year. Image
Read 11 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(