Playfra Profile picture
Apr 1, 2025 15 tweets 11 min read Read on X
How #Ukraine 🇺🇦 is planning to stop #Russia 🇷🇺 in #Donetsk Oblast', once and for all.

A strategical frontline and fortification works assessment for the month of March 2025.

🧵Thread 🧵1/15⬇️Image
Image
2/🧵

After extremely tough fighting, and tactical counterattacks and disruptions, the Ukrainians were able to finally mostly stabilize the contact line along most of the Donets'k's front and extinguish the most dangerous Russian offensives for the Pokrovs'k - Myrnohrad agglomeration.
Seeing this, Russia decided to shift its focus elsewhere, especially concentrating on the Uspenivka - Rozlyv axis.Image
3/🧵

Russia coupled the shift in their area of activity with the utilization of the armor they have likely been stockpiling for some time (Russia is suffering from a serious lack of armor all along the frontlines), and broke through on a mechanized assault to Bohdanivka. They were denied consolidation only thanks to massive efforts by the involved brigades.Image
4/🧵

The situation on the Bahatyr axis is also hot: while the Ukrainians are still clinging on to Andriivka and Kostyantynopil', the Russians shifted again their attention further south at Rozlyv. For the past week they have been running into the village and gaining footholds in basements, before flooding into even more and this way capturing the village. After those 3 villages, Russia will immediately attack Bahatyr from the south and south-east, this way cutting the Bahatyr - Velyka Novosilka road, and try to gain a foothold on the heights north of Oleksiivka. This way they will trap the Ukrainians in the valley between Bahatyr and Oleksiivka, just like near Andriivka.Image
5/🧵

About the Kotlyne salient.
The Uspenivka sector remains highly dynamic. The Russians are trying to capture it, but they're denied this by constant Ukrainian counterattacks. As of now they're trying the "alternative" way of bypassing it from the south. At the moment the Ukrainians are trying fiercely to dislodge the Russians that have gained a foothold in Novooleksandrivka. Fighting is ongoing.
About Udachne, the Russians sometimes try to advance from the VPS-1 mine westwards, but they're denied access to Udachne's residential area.
In Kotlyne, the situation is as dynamic in the VPS-2 mine as is in the part of the village south of the railway. Fighting continues.
Same for Pishchane. Intense fighting is ongoing for the VPS-3 mine and Pishchane itself. The Russians are also trying to bypass the settlement by attacking Zvirove and a trench system behind Pishchane.
In Shevchenko, the Russians were able to recapture everything but the north-easternmost outskirts, where a Ukrainian presence is still registered.
Russian offensives with unknown levels of successes are also reported near Novoukrayinka further east.as itImage
6/🧵

Let's speak numbers.
Despite heightened numbers of Russian attacks every day, their gains continue to decrease every month. In March, Russia captured only 133 km^2 according to DeepState, compared to the 730 km^2 captured in November 2024. Moreover, for every hour that Russia does not make progress near the agglomeration, Ukraine has more time to strengthen its defenses there, which we will analyze in depth in this thread.Image
Image
7/🧵

Let's look at the area from another point of view.
Every blue line represents a solid defensive line that could've been used by Ukraine to delay Russia by weeks. Can you see where I'm going with this? Many, many exceptionally good lines were lost in the past year, often without fighting. Now Ukraine is forced to fortify itself on worse lines, often in the middle of random fields, which causes many unnecessary casualties. That is, the Ukrainians could've made command reforms much, much earlier, and by now Russia would've probably still been stuck at the Selydove - Novohrodivka - Hrodivka line.
As you can see, though, there are still a lot of tough nuts that Russia will have to crack if it wants to capture the agglomeration.
Now, the interesting part. Let's see how the Ukrainians adapted these lines and dug on them.Image
8/🧵

Dark blue: trenches dug in March
Red: trenches dug before March

This month, the Ukrainians decided to "get serious" in terms of trenches. We arrived at the conclusion that the Ukrainians have completely switched to digging smaller, but more numerous and better equipped Slovyanka-styled trenches. This is happening all along Ukraine. In particular, in this direction we can easily see that the most active areas were Mezhova and Demuryne. In both areas we can see that the Ukrainians dug a lot of new trench systems. East of Novopidhorodne, for example, there are tens of systems on every single treeline for kilometers, while the Demuryne - Havrylivka line was incredibly upgraded, with dozens of new systems stretching all the way from Mykolaivka to Havrylivka.Image
Image
9/🧵

Orange: anti-tank ditches dug in March
Yellow: anti-tank ditches dug before March

In front of the trench systems belonging to the Demuryne line, Ukraine has dug a massive anti tank ditch stretching the same distance as the trench systems. Moreover, Novopavlivka is in the process of being encircled by a ditch, while many, many more anti-tank ditches are being dug north of Pokrovs'k at the Hryshyne line. Serious activity is also registered west of Kostyantynivka. This is to correlate with the Russian threats of capturing ground west of the city from the Vozdvyzhenka and Torets'k salients.Image
Image
10/🧵

Here's a new, peculiar strategy adopted by Ukraine all along this sector of the country's frontlines: double and triple ditches and dragon's teeth lines.
Personally, I'm against this, as I see this as a failure by Ukraine to recognize changes in Russia's strategies. That is, excavators are being utilized to dig anti-vehicle ditches, but Russia is using vehicles less and less. Instead, I think trenches should be prioritized, especially in contrast to not only extensive ditch lines, but also to triple anti-tank ditches.
Perhaps, they have something else in plan. Time will tell.Image
Image
11/🧵

Dark blue: dragon's teeth placed in March
Light blue: dragon's teeth placed before March

The most notable changes in the dragon's teeth layer that I applied in March were, as expected after the trenches and the anti-tank ditches in front of Demuryne, a dragon's teeth line belonging to the same defensive line. Moreover, a line was placed just meters in front of the anti-tank ditch right on the Dnipropetrovs'k - Donets'k Oblast' borders, which is not a very common occurrence. Activity, as was for the ditches, is also registered north of Pokrovs'k, and, even more, west of Kostyantynivka.Image
Image
12/🧵

Black: barbed wire placed in March
Gray: barbed wire placed before March

These pictures nicely tell about the part of the Ukrainian military that recognized correctly the situation at the front and promptly adapted. To counter increased Russian infantry usage, Novopavlivka's southern entrance is now protected by a barbed wire line, the line of the Demuryne defense node was also enlarged, as well as the lines near Novooleksandrivka, west of Uspenivka. The Ukrainians also continue actively placing north of Pokrovs'k, exploiting gained time because of the Russian inability to secure Kotlyne and Udachne, important bridgeheads north of the Pokrovs'k - Mezhova railway.Image
Image
13/🧵

General view of the whole Pokrovs'k - Chasiv Yar section of the frontline. The pictures are high-resolution, zooming in is encouraged. Image
Image
14/🧵

In conclusion, we can conclude, analyzing the most prominent Ukrainian fortification efforts, that the Ukrainians, even if their counterattacks are constantly registered, are preparing for a retreat to the solid and stronger light blue line.
Ukraine has been able to adapt its strategies, not falling behind Russian dynamism, and, most importantly, to enact scaled reforms on their command structure. Furthermore, the Ukrainians exhausted Russian potential on some of their most strategically dangerous areas of advance and Russian stockpiles of armored equipment.
This is why I view, considered fully the current situation regarding available resources to Russia and the internal and military situation of Ukraine, impossible for Russian forces to capture the Pokrovs'k - Myrnohrad agglomeration up to the medium-term.Image
15/🧵

Here's the end of this thread! If you learned something new, consider reposting this analysis and following me on my Telegram channel (t.me/PlayfraOSINT), where I will also post some of my personal thoughts and, obviously, analyses.
Thanks for reading, and have a great rest of the day/night 🫡

You might've noticed that I "disappeared" for 2-3 weeks or so. This was unfortunately due to an increase in the load of material regarding my studies. I also exploited this time to take some kind of break, whilst still trying my best to update, at least, the trenchmap. But, as my "break" is over now, I have no more excuses! I will, as such, be much, much more active in the spring, and especially the summer months this year, when I will have a ton more free time. Stay tuned!

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Playfra

Playfra Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Playfra0

Mar 14
🧵The defense of Fortress Orikhiv 🇺🇦: everything you need to know about the city's future.

Analyzing natural obstacles and topography, fortifications, weak and strong spots, logistics, and urbanistics.

1/🧵Image
2/🧵

Orikhiv is a town in southeastern Ukraine with 14,000 pre-war inhabitants that covers about 10 km² (about 1/4 of Pokrovsk and 1/7 of Bakhmut).
This city has been no more than 7 km from the contact line since 2022 and has seen constant fighting ever since. Image
3/🧵

Together with Kamyanske, Huljajpole, and Velyka Novosilka, Orikhiv is part of the town line where the Ukrainians were able to stop the Russian advance in the first days of the war.
That same year it stood against a Russian encirclement attempt.
Then, it served as the main logistical, accumulation, and command hub of the Ukrainian 2023 southern counteroffensive, and after its failure, it continued to serve those purposes, significantly holding back Russian attempts to reactivate the Zaporizhzhia direction.Image
Image
Read 17 tweets
Mar 11
🧵 Southeastern front: Ukrainian 🇺🇦 and Russian 🇷🇺 forces continue clashing and fighting for the initiative, while Ukrainian engineers exploit this time to significantly enhance their fortifications.

🧵Thread 🧵1/⬇️ Image
2/🧵
In this thread, I will focus on:

- Describing the tactical-strategical situation in all directions of the southeastern front

- Describing the progress with Ukrainian fortifications

- Commenting on my opinions about each situation and giving my point of view on the general situation.

Fortifications legend:
- Yellow: ditches
- Gray: barbed wire
- Blue: dragon's teeth

We will start from the west.
3/🧵

Stepnohirsk direction. In general, the situation remains stable and without significant changes.

In Prymorske and Stepnohirsk, Russian forces continue to infiltrate all over the settlements but are struck and often destroyed by tight control of Ukrainian FPVs.
Ukrainian forces continue to be present in both villages and sometimes conduct physical clearings.

Just east, Russians infiltrate along the indicated route to the solar farm and then attempt to reach Lukianivske, but they're struck by FPVs along the way, and the few who sometimes end up in the settlement are immediately cleared.

In my opinion, the main Russian objectives in this direction (photo #4) are:
- Getting as close as possible to Zaporizhzhia for it to eventually be in drone and artillery range.
- Pushing Ukrainian forces behind the Konka River.
- Pushing towards Orikhiv from the west, consolidating well their positions on the dominant heights, and placing drone teams there to critically endanger Ukrainian supplies into Orikhiv.

Photos #2 and #3 show the situation with the fortifications and topographic overlays.Image
Image
Image
Image
Read 14 tweets
Mar 2
1/🧵

Some personal considerations about the Ukrainian 🇺🇦 "counteroffensive" in the Oleksandrivka direction. Image
2/🧵

1. First of all, I disagree with figures citing massive Ukrainian gains of up to 400 (!) km².
According to my information, the total recaptured territory by the Ukrainians is around 20 km², and it is all concentrated at the Russian bridgehead over the Haichur River in the Ternuvate direction, which was almost completely liquidated except for Pryluky.
Here, a methodical clearing was conducted (not always without losses and with good organization and coordination), positions were taken and consolidated, and Russian forces do not have anymore the possibility to infiltrate like they did some weeks ago at all.Image
3/🧵

The bulk of the territory that goes in the incorrect 400 km² count is south of Verbove, in the Oleksandrivka direction. Here, first of all, the Ukrainians cleared remainders of old Russian infiltration attempts into Novooleksandrivka, Oleksiivka, and treelines south (the Russians never consolidated those positions, and the Russians had long given up on attempts to capture these settlements, almost totally focusing on Huljajpole: t.me/PlayfraOSINT/3…).Image
Read 8 tweets
Feb 6
1/ 🧵 Berdyansk sector: the most complete mapping ever made of Russian defenses (41,000 structures).
⚒️🇷🇺

Legend:
⬜️ Trenches
🟨 Ditches
🟦 Dragon's teeth

🗺️Interactive map:

Thread 1/⬇️ google.com/maps/d/u/1/vie…Image
2/🧵

After weeks of tedious mapping of every single trench, foxhole, emplacement, ditch, blockpost, dragon's teeth, and barbed wire line, I've finally finished the Berdyansk sector, one of the most heavily fortified pieces of territory in the whole of Ukraine.

The total count is as follows:
- 40,000 trenches, foxholes, emplacements, firing positions
- 450 separate anti-tank ditches
- 600 separate dragon's teeth lines
- 220 separate barbed wire lines

Let's look at the most interesting things I found along the way.
3/🧵

The area of the Ukrainian 2023 Velyka Novosilka counteroffensive.
De-facto, Russia's line "0.5". It was designed to absorb the first blow of Ukraine's counteroffensive and soften the Ukrainians for the first line of defense. Image
Image
Image
Read 15 tweets
Jan 30
1/🧵 The situation in and around fortress Kostyantynivka: is it in danger, what are the main problems, and what's next. Image
2/🧵

Kostyantynivka is a quite sizeable city in northern Donetsk Oblast, with a population of 67,000 as of 2022, and is part of Ukraine's formidable Kostyantynivka - Druzhkivka - Kramatorsk - Slovyansk defensive node, where Kostyantynivka is the southernmost city of the four.
These four cities are factually the last of their size still in Ukrainian-controlled Donbas.Image
3/🧵

Ever since 2023, up to this day, Kostyantynivka has served, and continues to serve, critically important purposes for Ukrainian forces in some of the hottest areas of eastern Ukraine, like the Bakhmut, Toretsk, Chasiv Yar, and Rusyn Yar sectors, being used, for example, as an accumulation hub, logistical base, and (probably) command point.Image
Image
Image
Image
Read 14 tweets
Jan 2
1/🧵

Pokrovsk - Dobropillia general update (26/12 - 01/01) Image
2/🧵

Pokrovsk industrial area. Russian soldiers move in waves of groups of 1-3 soldiers along the highway.
In the orange square, very frequent and large traffic of infantry is recorded.
From there, they cross the railway into the industrial zone along the indicated routes. Russian forces seem to still be unable to consolidate their positions there.Image
3/🧵

Just east of this area, Russian forces tend to move as shown in the picture, mostly following the urbanized area but also attempting infiltrations in the treelines just north of Pokrovsk. Image
Read 11 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(