Last year, the @USDOT released part of their 653 page report on a story we broke back in 2022. They found @lufthansa discriminated on the basis of religion and engaged in unfair business practices.
I spoke with multiple passengers today, who allege they, too, were unfairly targeted by Lufthansa in Prague.
In the end, Lufthansa allegedly went around the boarding area targeting only visibly Jewish passengers, while ignoring all other passengers present.
If you want Lufthansa to stop with this despicable behavior, like, comment, and share this tweet.
Full story below:
First of all. We receive reports on a near-daily basis from poorly treated passengers around the world. While we can’t investigate most of them, and we decline to write about many others after investigating, some make the cut for egregious behavior. This is one of those cases.
As in the 2022 incident, these passengers made a pilgrimage to visit the grave of Rabbi Yeshaya Steiner of Kerestir, known as Reb Shayala Kerestirer, on the 3 Iyar yahrtzeit (date of his passing) in 1925.
They then spent Shabbos in Israel before scrambling to rebook their Lufthansa flight to Frankfurt that was cancelled after a Houthi missile hit the grounds of Ben Gurion Airport.
5 visibly Hasidic Jews flew from Tel Aviv on Bluebird flight 462, which arrived in Prague at 12:36pm today. They were all booked separately.
Meyer Tauber and a friend went to an airport lounge, while others milled about the airport or waited at the gate.
When Mayer got to the gate shortly before boarding, he heard them page him and Herman Deutsch to come to the podium. They asked them if they were ok sitting in an exit row, to which they answered in the affirmative. The gate agent then told them they were going to have to check in their carry-on bags. Mayer asked why that would be, and the agent said it was oversized. When Mayer asked to put his bag in the sizer, he was able to fit it in, but the agent said you aren’t allowed to fit it in, it has to be able to be dropped in without touching it.
@meyertauber and a friend went to an airport lounge, while others milled about the airport or waited at the gate.. When Mayer said he was entitled to a personal item and carry-on, he was able to retrieve his Tefillin from his bag before it was checked.
Herman didn’t fare as well. The agent refused to allow him to touch the bag to retrieve his tefillin, and if he didn’t hand over the bag immediately, there would be an added fee. The agent was unwilling to explain what the added fee was for, but Herman complied.
The gate agent then systematically walked around the gate area and called the other 3 Hasidic Jews to go to the podium. Their bags were subject to a drop test, where the bag would only be allowed to pass through if it dropped right into the sizer, without the men being allowed to fit the bag into the sizer.
2 bags didn’t pass the absurd test, and the men with those bags were not allowed to touch their bags to remove their Tefillin, under threat of being removed from the flight.
In all, 4 bags were forced to be checked in.
The employees tried to stop them from taking pictures:
The men explained that they had a separate connecting flight on United from Frankfurt to Newark, but were told that the bags would be checked through to Newark.
Aron Grosz was sitting at the gate by himself when he saw the other Hasidic Jews brought over to the podium. He was wondering what was happening when a female gate agent came for him as well and said he had to go to the podium.
Even before the wheel went into the sizer, he was told it would have to be gate checked, despite it being able to fit by just moving the wheel. He was not allowed to touch his bag after that, even to remove his Tefillin. He has flown with his bag on flights on many airlines without issue and never experienced such rudeness or high tension, but didn’t want to be removed from the flight so he let them take his bag.
Still, he didn’t like what was going on at all. The men all acted respectfully, but were being treated like criminals.
He took out his phone to take pictures of the bags and gate agents, which triggered a gate agent to page for a supervisor. The supervisor demanded that he open his phone and delete any pictures.
When he asked the supervisor why they were being targeted when many people in the boarding area had even larger carry-on bags, the supervisor said if you ask that again, you won’t be boarding this flight.
Aron was shocked that the gate agent didn’t make an effort to hide the fact that they were targeting only the visibly Jewish passengers on the flight. They could have easily called up a few other passengers with even larger carry-ons to the podium, but they didn’t.
On the flight, the men noted many bags that were significantly larger than their carry-ons, had made it onto the flight without issue.
The men had a tight connection in Frankfurt before they boarded United flight 75 to Newark without issue, where they noted the gate agents and flight attendants were much more friendly than on Lufthansa. They didn’t have time to file a complaint in Frankfurt.
Unfortunately, their carry-on bags that were promised to be tagged to Newark never made it, and they left the airport without their bags.
Meyer is a world traveler and is still shocked at the incident. He was part of a group in 2022 that met with Tal Muscal, Lufthansa’s head of Corporate Communications in the Americas, who promised Lufthansa would provide sensitivity training for their employees.
Meyer’s carry-on bag, in Tel Aviv:
Mayer isn’t interested in money. He wants to see Lufthansa investigate and provide an official apology for the profiling. And he wants to know what will change with employee training and how it will differ from the response to the 2022 incident.
He said he has also heard from other visibly Hasidic Jews who have been targeted by Lufthansa gate agents in Prague.
He plans on filing a DOT complaint and hopes to receive an apology from Lufthansa and what they will do so that others aren’t targeted in the future.
DansDeals reached out to Lufthansa earlier today for comment, but we haven’t yet received a response.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Yesterday, Southwest told its loyal customers, "We don't need you."
This runs counter to 60 years of company culture and we have the receipts to prove it. 1/
Herb Kelleher co-founded the airline and was CEO from 1981-2001 and chairman until 2008.
He created much of Southwest’s unique culture, including the refusal to layoff a single employee.
He cared deeply and spoke out often about the airline’s culture and values, I am sure if he was still with us, he'd be wearing a bag on his head...
Last September, Southwest CEO Bob Jordan bowed to pressure from Elliott Investment Management in agreeing to remove open seating and selling extra legroom seats.
However, he stressed that the airline would not give up on free bags, flexible tickets, and other customer-friendly perks that made Southwest unique.
He said that getting rid of free bags on the lowest fares would add $1.5 billion of value while destroying $1.8 billion market share.
He cited free checked bags and flexible changes as the top 2 differentiators for Southwest. 3/
On Sunday, May 5th, @AmericanAir Kicked an orthodox Jewish passenger off a flight due to the actions of an unrelated orthodox Jew.
This story was so outrageous I had to investigate, and after talking to the two passengers involved, the story seems even worse than I thought!
Reuvi Scheinerman is removed from American flight 4447:
On Sunday, May 5th, 17 year old Reuvi Scheinerman was flying back to his yeshiva in Connecticut after Pesach break. There are no nonstop flights between Cleveland and Hartford, so his father booked him on an American flight via Washington DC’s Reagan National Airport.
Cleveland’s TSA lines can run very long these days, especially if you don’t have PreCheck and CLEAR. Reuvi doesn’t drive and has no state ID, which isn’t required if you’re under 18 years old. But that also means he can’t get PreCheck or CLEAR.
American offers unaccompanied minor services for 15-17 year olds, but doesn’t require it. Reuvi is in 11th grade and has flown on his own since 9th grade without incident. The very shy boy was dressed in the yeshiva uniform, a white dress shirt, suit jacket, and a black fedora. He had the yeshiva-required kosher flip phone, without the ability to record what happened.
He was thankful to make it through security and board the plane just a few minutes before boarding was scheduled to end for AA flight 4447, an Embraer E175 operated by Republic Airways for American Airlines. He stopped to help a thankful passenger put their bag in the overhead compartment and then went straight to his window seat in 23A, the very last row of the plane. He took his seat and was happy to see that 23B was empty as boarding concluded.
That joy would be short-lived. The AA gate agent came over to him, tapped on his shoulder, and told him to grab his carry-on bag and follow him off the plane. The shy boy complied without making a scene, his father always told him how important it is for Jews to make a Kiddush Hashem. When he was back at the gate he was told to wait while the gate agent closed the doors and sent the flight off. He asked what happened, to which the gate agent told him that he should know what he did wrong. He had no clue.
However, back at the gate he met 21 year old Yehudah Roffman for the first time, who had also been ordered off of the flight.
Yehudah Roffman is removed from American flight 4447:
Yehudah is also a yeshiva student, dressed in the same standard yeshiva uniform, a white dress shirt, suit jacket, and a black fedora. He was returning to NYC after spending Pesech break in Cleveland and also had the yeshiva-required kosher flip phone instead of a modern smartphone.
Reuvi lives in an older Orthodox Jewish neighborhood in the city of Cleveland Heights, while Yehudah lives in a newer Orthodox Jewish neighborhood in the city of University Heights, and their paths haven’t previously crossed.
Yehudah was originally booked on American flight 4305 from Cleveland to JFK, but along with several other passengers, missed that flight due to the long security lines. He was rebooked to LaGuardia via Reagan National, departing about 90 minutes later.
Yehudah was waiting in the gate area in Cleveland for flight 4447 to Reagan National and noticed before boarding that the tail of the plane appeared to be dented. He called his mother with his concerns, and she told him to let a flight attendant know what he’d seen. When he boarded, he asked the flight attendant if they noticed the dent in the tail, and sat down in 10D, an aisle seat in the 3rd row of the Main Cabin Extra section. He still felt uneasy, so when the gate agent was onboard he went over and once again asked if they noticed the dent on the tail, and sat back down.
Having not received any validation or even response to his previous inquiries and still feeling extremely uneasy, Yehudah noticed the pilot talking to the gate agent at the front of the plane, and asked about the dented tail. The pilot told him to sit down, but Yehudah wanted reassurance that it had been noticed and inspected, so he asked again, and the pilot told him to sit down. Yehudah asked the pilot if he was listening to his concerns, and the pilot told him for a 3rd time to take his seat. After the gate agent said that federal law required that he listen to crew instructions and that he had to take his seat, Yehudah then returned to his seat.
It’s unclear why his concerns were not addressed. Perhaps they didn’t want a situation where passengers all ask to be deboarded due to problems with the left phalange? The plane’s tail number is N123HQ and it appears to have operated many flights successfully since AA4447.
5 mintues later, the gate agent then went to 10D and told Yehudah to take his carry-ons and leave the plane.
An elderly couple that also missed their flight to JFK and had been rebooked with Yehudah to LaGuardia via Reagan National expressed their surprise as Yehudah was led off the plane.
The crew then pointed out Reuvi in the back and the gate agent walked 13 rows back and told 17 year old Reuvi that he was being ordered to leave the flight as well, despite having zero interaction with Yehudah or any cabin crew.
There were no other visibly religious Jews on the flight.
Here is the story of how a passenger avoided flying on the infamous MH370 flight which mysteriously disappeared 10 years ago.
To date there are many theories about what happened to the plane and why it is still missing.
But one thing we do know for sure, if it wasn't for Andy keeping Shabbos, he would have been on that flight.
On 01/13/14, Andy emailed his travel agent his desired itinerary:
The travel agent was an Orthodox Jew, who didn’t practice booking travel for Jews on Shabbos. Instead, he proposed the following business class itinerary, slightly altering the Kuala Lumpur-Beijing Malaysia Airlines flight 370 from Saturday to Friday:
Why have there not been many deals in the past week?
We have been busy, very busy.
Nothing is the same anymore. Hamas has made a generational defining moment when they massacred over 1,000 Jews. And no Jew anywhere in the world can sit still. Everyone is asking what they can do.
This led to us starting a campaign to get 1 pair of tefillin (used by men for prayer) to be put on daily for every soul Hamas has taken from us.
Our goal is that any man that is ready to commit to start putting it on Tefillin every day for life will get a free pair.
Here is some of the progress we've made this week:
-1,500+ Men have committed to start wearing tefillin every day.
-Over 652 pairs have already been sponsored.
-180 pairs of tefillin are headed to the front lines of Gaza for soldiers to share with literally thousands of soldiers requesting to wear daily.
-316 pairs of tefillin are being sent out around Israel to men who committed to wearing them daily for life.
-More pairs are being sourced and ordered literally across the Globe, from Israel, to India, to Argentina, to Australia, to the US, UK, & Canada.
-More pairs will be ordered as soon as we get more donations because all of this is only possible thanks to individual donations from YOU!
Want to signup or donate:
Please meet Barak who is an Elite Egoz Commando in the IDF. He ships out tomorrow night and just took on the commitment to wear tefillin every single day. He will also be sharing them with his unit.
I only spend a short time with Barak, and he already feels like a brother.