I’m kind of tired of people talking about “revolution, not [material improvement short of revolution]!” unless they’re actually out there successfully building institutions/organizations which might plausibly be able to mobilize the working class for revolution
In my experience, 99% of the time the people who say stuff like this mean “refuse to participate in the existing struggles of the working class, at the level of workers’ current political consciousness” with no serious effort to do anything else besides publish zines
When we say “meet the masses where they’re at” that means aiding our fellow workers in struggles—even liberal struggles—against material inequalities so that we can better recognize ourselves as a unified class.
Helping workers remove the barriers of bigotry, while sharing the message of class unity, will go a lot further than telling people they’re a bunch of incremental liberal morons who should accept material divisions until The Rapture—sorry, I mean, until The Revolution—comes
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Honestly the easiest thing to do immediately and by executive authority, as a left-populist president, would be to punish/imprison *different* symbolic targets. Instead of immigrants, bankers. Instead of homeless people, slumlords. Health insurance CEOs. Etc.
But Dems generally refuse to punish elites even when there’s legitimate grounds to punish actual crimes, with full due process. They couldn’t even punish their political opponents who attempted a coup!
I still think back to Obama’s “I’m standing between you and the pitchforks” speech to bankers after the 08 financial collapse. They bitched about it at the time, but he really burned a ton of political capital to let the entire financial industry off the hook
While this is articulated in MAGA-coded grievance language, there’s a related truth.
I’ve talked before about how liberal experts are often blind to their own values, because they approach society as a math problem to solve. Goodness is something to be Efficiently Optimized
It’s not truly sneaky, in the sense that this blindness is totally sincere. They really think everyone wants the same things—that there just is an objective definition of The Good, and that the job of the state is to maximize Goodness Production. It all seems obvious to them
They can’t talk to voters very well because of this; they think voters are basically idiots who need to be led by the nose to their own self-interest—by the enlightened experts, obviously
This is the lib version of Trumpism and it is present in some of the Abundance types—specifically, we’re seeing a nationwide exhaustion with self-regulation and compassion, and a desire to just throw up your hands, and do what’s easy even if it leaves others behind
I have a family friend who was a really volatile and narcissistic 20-year old, who worked on herself over the years, went to therapy, grew up, and became infinitely more conscientious and regulated in her 30s. She fell down the Trump pipeline this election, and has regressed
It’s not *just* that she’s become angry and paranoid and delusional about politics—she’s also re-embraced all her old psychopathologies, too. She’s angry, narcissistic, and paranoid interpersonally in a way she hasn’t been in a decade
I will keep begging leftists to have some humility about praxis. We act like politics has been solved, Correct Praxis is already known, and we just have to implement it. But we keep losing. So how can we possibly have the right praxis?
If the American left already had the answers for how to Do The Work correctly, then why did we fail when 2 million people in Gaza needed us to win? We failed so comprehensively it’s totally broken all my faith and trust in our received wisdom about strategy and tactics
Our failure to arrest the genocide in Gaza has been so thoroughgoing in such a critical moment where failure is intolerable that I can’t imagine how any of us feel like we already have the answers. Clearly we don’t, or the world wouldn’t be this way
I maintain my belief that one of the great virtues and unique strengths of socialism/socialists is that we’re *right* more than anyone else. We’re materialists, we’re critical, and that counts for a lot. But we’ve also gotten kind of high off that rightness.
Social media has driven every political tendency that exists to become more insular, less forgiving, more disciplinary, and more in-group directed. Leftists aren’t alone in this. The incentives for this are baked into the infrastructure. But it hurts us more than most
It’s actually imperative liberals and leftists learn how this works: only a tiny minority of Americans actually care about literal deficits. No one really cares about “fiscal responsibility.” These are symbols; they signify “taking resources away from the Undeserving and Cheats.”
The GOP is the party of “fiscal responsibility” because “fiscal responsibility” means “taking money away from poor people, single mothers, the homeless, immigrants, and minorities.” They can take out infinite debt and give it to billionaires and be totally consistent
No one that votes for them will ever see this as hypocritical—they believe rich people are Righteous and deserve Rewards; their success and wealth is proof of an inherent moral goodness, a spiritual essence of purity & righteousness. They deserve more.