Putrino Lab Profile picture
Jun 13 25 tweets 7 min read Read on X
Ok, so after that (unintentional) cliffhanger, let's talk about energy production infrastructure and post-exertional malaise (PEM) in people with infection- and exposure-associated chronic illnesses (IACIs) such as #LongCOVID, #MECFS, chronic #Lyme and more. Let's start with 1/
how cells produce energy. ATP is the body's energy currency, and we only know how to make this currency from glucose, so our bodies need to turn glucose into ATP. They can do so either aerobically (using oxygen and mitochondria) or anerobically (fast, but inefficient, no 2/
mitochondria). Energy is never free in this universe, so both processes produce both ATP and waste
- Aerobic: 36-38 ATP units per glucose unit, producing reactive oxygen species (ROSs) as waste
- Anerobic: 2 ATP units per glucose unit, producing pyruvate and lactate as waste
3/
Mitochondrial energy is our body's go-to, so dysfunction causes problems. Why are we having problems caused by IACIs?
1) Persistent pathogens, especially viruses: viruses hijack our mitochondria because they don't have their own (rude). So they infect our cells and use them to 4/
produce the energy necessary to replicate. We've all had this experience in acute illness: a viral illness takes us down, then we wake up one morning and feel pretty ok so we push ourselves, crash hard and experience a couple of days of extra illness because we went too hard 5/
too fast. Just like any self-respecting combustion engine, our mitochondria can only produce so much energy before they start to break down, get choked up with waste (ROSs) and start to push us into energy deficit, so if a persistent virus (or host of reactivated viruses) is 6/
making many of our mitochondria produce "energy for two", this is going to cause energetic problems
Targeted antivirals, monoclonals and combinations of monoclonals are the answer here but require careful and strategic research (see our recent paper!).
7/thelancet.com/journals/lanin…
In the meantime, mitochondrial support in the form of things like oxaloacetate, CoQ10, NAD+, mTOR inhibitors, creatine et al may be beneficial to explore in collaboration with your physician.
2) Chronic inflammation: Maybe your body clicked into a chronic inflammatory 8/
state and can't snap out of it? Maybe persistent pathogens are causing chronic inflammation or maybe something environmental (chemical exposure, mold, heavy metals) are keeping you in a chronic inflammatory state after an initial triggering event. Regardless of the cause, 9/
inflammation costs energy and, again, no matter how much I complain to management, in this universe, energy isn't free. So mitochondria need to work overtime. More energy spent creating an inflammatory response means less energy for exertion, and *dire* consequences 10/
(in the form of feeling literally poisoned by reactive oxygen species) if you push beyond that energy envelope.
3) Autoimmunity: Autoimmunity could most definitely be driving some of the symptom burden in a subset of folks with IACIs (see our paper).

11/medrxiv.org/content/10.110…
Autoimmunity leads to chronic inflammation, chronic inflammation is a total energy pig, and here we are again: producing way too much energy per mitochondrion, proliferation of ROSs, damaging mitochondria every time you push beyond your energy envelope and cause a crash. As 12/
we navigate potential cures for chronic inflammatory drivers (heavy metal chelation, mold removal, targeting persistent pathogens, IVIG and FcRn inhibitors for autoimmunity), and try out mitochondrial support strategies, we must also remember the magic word: PACING. If these 13/
mechanisms drive your PEM, pushing through until you crash is going to cause mitochondrial damage and worsening issues. Pacing is an energy management tool that can prevent this. I really love this video from @LongCOVIDPhysio describing pacing:

14/
but in addition to this, we have shown that folks who use technology-assisted pacing may experience an improvement in their ability to manage their energy, as well as identify biomarkers associated with triggering a crash:
researchgate.net/publication/38…

researchgate.net/publication/38…

15/
So we've talked about some of the ways that we can overwork mitochondria, but what if the mitochondria can't get what they need? Mitochondria need glucose and glucose gets to cells via vasculature. Whether it be due to viral antigens like circulating spike, or simply chronic 16/
inflammation causing excessive fibrinogen production, we now know thanks to work led by folks like @resiapretorius, @doctorasadkhan and @dbkell and now replicated by countless others, that IACIs can cause the proliferation of fibrin-rich, amyloid-containing particles (that 17/
the world has nicknamed 'microclots' - see our paper). These microclots can clog up microvasculature and cause all sorts of dysfunction, including inflammation, but also affecting our ability to adequately transport glucose and oxygen into cells for
18/
cell.com/trends/endocri…
our mitochondria. In addition, recent work has also shown that excess sodium and calcium in the intracellular environment is seen in #MECFS and #LongCOVID due to ion channel dysfunction (see paper!).

When too much calcium and potassium flood the 19/

onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdfdirect/…
intracellular environment it disrupts mitochondrial function and blocks the ability of the mitochondria to utilize oxygen efficiently, leading to ROS proliferation and PEM. Klaus Wirth and Carmen Scheibenbogen (and many others) are doing important work on this in Berlin. 20/
Finally, the incomparable @RobWust and his brilliant team are also starting to show morphological changes in microvasculature in #LongCOVID and #MECFS that would make it harder for resources to make it to the mitochondria. In a recent poster, they showed changes in vascular 21/ Image
size and structure associated with ppl with #LongCOVID and pre-2020 #MECFS that were CLEARLY different from healthy controls. So. We have under-resourced and overworked, mitochondria - how would that manifest systemically? Well. Obviously, if we actually LISTENED to people, 22/
they would tell us that they have PEM. But also, if you did invasive CPET on them, you might notice that they show impaired oxygen extraction (resources can't get to the cells) when they exert themselves. Thanks for showing it beautifully, Dr Systrom:
23/sciencedirect.com/science/articl…
You might also see that when you force them to exercise, their body produces abnormal waste product associated with altered energy production that CANNOT be explained by deconditioning. Thanks for debunking that, @RobWust. And you might also see that

24/researchgate.net/publication/39…
when you push folks too hard, they have lactic acid build-up because they're now using anerobic energy production almost exclusively:

God. I'm out of space (and time) again, so:
1) QED: PEM is biological.
2) to my haters, see you in hell. ✌️
/endnature.com/articles/s4159…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Putrino Lab

Putrino Lab Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @PutrinoLab

Jun 13
Wanted to put forward a thread about #PEM since there have been some new developments and also because I just need to get some of this out of my head and work through it. Folks with infection- and exposure-associated chronic illnesses (IACIs) like #LongCOVID, #MECFS, 1/
chronic #lyme and other tick- and vector-borne illnesses will often experience post-exertional malaise (PEM). In fact, it is often thought of as a cardinal hallmark of many of these diagnoses. To start, a simple working definition of PEM: it is a condition that emerges when 2/
somebody physically, mentally or emotionally exerts themselves beyond a certain point, causing a delayed worsening of symptoms that can last days, weeks or even months. NB: There is much more to PEM than this definition, and one of my favorite explainers is @LongCOVIDPhysio's 3/
Read 25 tweets
May 17
A few comments that might be helpful after a phenomenal couple of weeks learning from brilliant people in #MECFS, #LongCOVID, chronic #Lyme and infection-associated chronic illness (IACI) communities and still buzzing after yesterday's @polybioRF meeting. These illnesses are 1/
complex and are going to require equally complex science to solve. When it comes to studying and managing these illnesses, I rarely feel sure about anything, but if I'm sure of one thing it is this: anyone telling you that one drug/one approach will solve all cases of an IACI 2/
is probably selling that one drug/one approach. These illnesses are complex: Biomarker-driven, personalized dispensation of combination therapies are going to be crucial to addressing the problem. Let's talk through an example (an example that assumes a perfect world where we 3/
Read 16 tweets
May 15
Quite disheartening to return from 10 days working with some of the most important and relevant #MECFS and #LongCOVID researchers in the world and to read this drivel being allowed through from @bmj_latest. Let's be unambiguous about this: BMJ has 1/

bmj.com/content/389/bm…
allowed an OPINION piece to be published about #MECFS that flies in the face of:
1. current consensus science
2. recent NICE guidelines that were corrected so as to not include recommendations based on fraudulent/discredited data (PACE Trial)
3. voices of ME/CFS patients
2/
Not only should this be a point of shame for @bmj_latest and their editorial team, but we really should be asking about the legal ramifications of continuing to invite researchers to push an agenda that is no longer supported by consensus science and has NEVER been supported 3/
Read 6 tweets
Mar 25
Excerpt of an email received by a mentee of mine who is currently transitioning to independence as a career researcher. This is happening all over the country right now. The “equity research” my mentee was proposing was centered around novel neurotechnologies that increase the 1/ Image
safety, privacy and independence of people with disabilities. Canceling programs like this doesn’t make America great, it makes America weak, behind the times, not at the bleeding edge of innovation and just kinda mean. Canceling programs that uplift early career scientists 2/
doesn’t “cut waste” and put “America first”, it encourages promising scientists to leave because opportunities are better elsewhere and they can more easily do great science in another location. America loses out so that the 1% can thrive further by creating environments that 3/
Read 4 tweets
Mar 15
Two steps forward, one step back. For #LongCOVID awareness day today I had the honor of joining thousands of other New Yorkers in a peaceful protest to stand against many of the current administration’s recent damaging and thoughtless policies and executive orders. Let there 1/
be no misunderstandings here: many of the executive orders and policies being proposed and passed into law will erase entire populations of historically and currently excluded communities. Under the facile goal of “improving efficiency”, decisions are being made that not only 2/
harm the vulnerable, but weaken a nation by taking away its true strengths: diversity, morality and innovation. Today of all days, my ask of the complex chronic illness community to take heart: if it is the wish of this administration to start a constitutional street-fight, 3/
Read 8 tweets
Feb 20
A tumultuous 24-ish hours since our preprint was released yesterday. I mentioned that this was a fraught issue and I genuinely do understand that people have mixed feelings about the work. I wanted to take some time to respond to some of the concerns and comments that have 1/
arisen. First, and most importantly: #LongCOVID (LC) and post-vaccine syndrome (PVS) both exist. Anyone claiming that all LC or even *most* LC is actually PVS is unserious and is making up nonsense that is not supported by the consensus science. I cannot stress this strongly 2/
enough. While we're talking about Long COVID and its clear distinction from PVS, I'd like to remind people that my team was talking about persistent effects of acute COVID in April and May of 2020. By November of 2020, we pre-printed our first LC paper:
3/medrxiv.org/content/10.110…
Read 22 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(