@_lliesl_ @sharrond62 @cajardineMP
1. The clinical treatment of children & adolescents is not relevant to the need to reduce the growing harassment, discrimination & hate crime targeted at individuals trans people.

A key tenet of GC theory & ideology is…
2. … that Trans people should not face discrimination

@Docstockk & @MForstater of @SexMattersOrg have both reiterated that point

A call by @cajardineMP for action on growing anti-trans hate crime should therefore be welcomed by GC activists as well as by Trans people. …
3. But to respond to the claims made by @_lliesl_ & @sharrond62

Only 8% of GIDS clinic attendees received PBs. Yes, 97-99% went on to take cross sex hormones & transition as adults

That demonstrates the exceptional abilities of clinicians to determine which children are trans.
4. To reiterate, >50% of trans adults do not identify as heterosexual.

Our self understanding as we wait many years for genital reconstruction, often means we conclude, as do many disabled people, that some aspects of body shape has little to do with how we are accepted .,,.
5. … by friends & colleagues, and least of all by partners & lovers

Many TP learn to live for years with a body, particularly, genitals, which do not match how we identify

Unfortunately the exceptionally long NHS waiting lists for assessment, & the minimal numbers…
6. … of surgical teams providing genital reconstruction in the UK, is now being weaponised against TP.

Further I encourage TP to apply for gender recognition- but that cannot be done until after assessment & diagnosis. The lists are so long that most service clients …
7. .,. will have been socially transitioned (& also medically albeit with unsafe, occasional, access to hormones) for several years before diagnosis

Our right to be, is now being constantly undermined.

In the end TP ask why go through the hard work of …
8. … applying for a GRC thar might end up being a useless paper, all about our right to privacy, when our rights to privacy are being stripped by Senior Courts & Government agencies who claim an ability to ride roughshod over out rights

We’ve fought this battle once already.
9. We will again

Government is failing us, & those failings are then weaponised eg. GCs claim the non-surgical status of many TP invalidated their lives

Not requiring genital reconstruction in both the Gender Recognition Act & the Equality Act, was the…
10. … Labour government (in 2004 & 2020) acknowledgment of

a) Excessive NHS waiting lists for assessment, diagnosis & surgery

.b) Those TP with disabilities or clinical conditions who were unable to under major surgical reconstruction

c) That in the UK we have too …
11. … few surgical teams to meet need, & that is unlikely to change

The weaponisation of these issues is grossly misleading

The issues raised about PBs are gross ignorance, or lies

GCs say they cannot have a discussion with us

Of course we can’t, not until GCs read…
12…., alternative views, & try stepping into our shoes.

Being trans is an experience that is very difficult to understand if you haven’t personally had it or known a TP as a very close friend

Since the Supreme Ct judgment, like most TP I have given extensive thought to...
13. … who/what I am

I knew as a 4yr old that there had been a ‘serious mistake’. Something had gone wrong in the mix, for I had no doubt that people should see me as the boy I was

Transitioned for 50yrs, i have extensively questioned, I realise that some will never ….
14. … accept my word for it, but I have absolutely no doubt that I am a man, & am recognised as such, by those who work with me. know. & love me

I cannot in anyway think of myself other than as a man who has lived a long, and good life with my wife and family …
15. I recognise that is a stretch for some, but it never is for those who meet me.

I want to go out & neither be questioned as I go to the loo, or see my friends questioned, or heat someone complaining because all the loos have. ‘Anyone’ signs on the doors.
16. We want constructive discussion, not about our right to exist, our treatment, or our medical status, but how we can work towards accessibility safe from predators in all facilities

But 1st accept us as fellow humans, be respectful & most T people will respond with the same
@threadreaderapp unroll

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Prof. Stephen Whittle OBE, PhD, DLaws, FAcSS,

Prof. Stephen Whittle OBE, PhD, DLaws, FAcSS, Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @stephenwhittle

Jun 17
1. Let me be clear -

I abhor all predatory sexual behaviours, & violence, whoever it victimises.

The grooming gangs saga & the failure of the state to recognise girls as victims has become a deep stain on our criminal justice system

But despite her real work experience …
2. … of pimped girls in care, @suzanne_moore can’t resist the temptation to imply certain groups are more predatory

As the week heats up it’s
as if she has set out to provoke the right wing led riots & assaults, we saw this summer in Ballymena & numerous cities last summer…
3. … With glee she heaps blame on the innocent alongside the guilty. Whose homes will now be 🔥 out?

@suzanne_moore implies grooming gangs happened because of failed safeguarding, due to fears amongst authorities of being branded racist and - surprise, surprise, transphobic. From Suzanne Moore article in the Telegraph:  “ "Progressives" who ran several of the councils involved are clueless about safeguarding. We have seen it around the trans issue, where any notion of safeguarding of children or vulnerable women has gone out of the window. Not all trans people are predatory, we are told. Well, of course not, but a few are.”
Read 9 tweets
Jun 11
1. I don’t think the T community should be blaming self-ID (or perhaps better put as self -declaration) for its current woes

It is worth once again looking at the actual events that took place in 2016-2024 to understand today’s anger, from pro & anti self-dec, in context …
2. a. 2015 HofCommons Women’s & Equality Cttee investigated Trans Equalities, making 30 recommendations incl. calling for reform of the GRA & better NHS access to gender affirming services. L
Read their report conclusions again publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201516/cm…
3. b. Nicky Morgan, Minister for Equalities said Govt would look at
- reforming the GRA
- reviewing unnecessary requests for gender info, &
- improving access to NHS Services, see assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/upl…
Read 20 tweets
May 31
1. This is what the Supreme Court did not decide & it is still the law:

Service providers (& not the @EHRC / @SexMattersOrg ) decide for themselves what services to provide, how they are provided
incl. whether single or separate sex services , and to who they provide them...
2. … Service Providers decide whether it is legitimate AND proportionate to exclude anyone from their services.

Employers must provide single sex bathrooms - at least 1 each for males & females unless seperate rooms (which can all be unisex).

Handwashing can be shared

BUT …
3. … Employers become service providers the minute they let staff use the toilets

As Service providers, Employers get to
decide to whom & how they give access to those services

Neither Sex Matters nor the EHRC can dictate how services are provided & to whom they are provided
Read 4 tweets
May 27
1. Trans broken arm syndrome is when any & every health issue is seen & overshadowed by a person being trans

I lived & worked with a broken shoulder from 1976 - 2016.

40 yrs in pain despite repeatedly stating I had fallen from a 1st floor window ledge (whilst painting windows)
2. I was ignored, referred to a psychologist (I didn’t go), told it was migraine related pain, offered anti-anxiety medicines

Then in 2016 a physiotherapist said “Do you know your shoulder is broken?”

Yes, Yes,YES

She got a surgeon to see me who operated. He said …
3. … the normally 15min op took almost 3hrs

He shaved off a piece of broken bone still attached & growing. The lump on the rear of my shoulder was the bone about to break through my skin

He also found I had snapped my bicep.

2 screws, 78 stitches, 3 tubes of superglue…
Read 12 tweets
May 22
1. Ok - Stephen for 50yrs
Prior to 1996
- I lost many jobs. The advice was that if an employer would also sack a trans women that was being treated equally.
So TP who have the human right not to experience discrimination (art 13 ECHR) had less rights than none TP
.,,
2. Prior the the GRAct:
- my wife & I couldn’t foster, or adopt, & was refused fertility treatment because I am trans (art 12 ECHR)
- if my wife had died, Soc services told us they would put the kids in foster care whilst deciding if I could look after them (Art 12 & 13 ECHR)
3. When we had 1st child we asked if I could be registered as a parent (nb not as a father)
It as refused - so our children lost any privacy as to their conception solely (Art 13 & 8 ECHR) ..,
Read 4 tweets
May 17
1. Can using pronouns to misgender a person, including a Trans person, constitute unlawful harassment?

The law does not as a rule regulate pronoun use. There are a few: e.g. Lord , Lady, Sit which carry legal constrsints in very limited settings…. 1/13
2. … But he/him, she/her, they/their are just matters of social convention, used by people to categorise individuals & to be polite.

There are 2 types of unlawful harassment:
- Criminal (The Protection from Harassment Act 1997)
- Civil (The Equslity Act 2010 s. 26)…
3. … CRIMINAL: the Protection from Harassment Act s.1. states a person must not pursue a course of conduct which

- amounts to harassment of another,
- which they know or ought to know amounts to harassment of the other.
Or
- that involves harassment of 2 or more people ….,
Read 15 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(