A friend told me I needed to simplify my articles and produce a Net Zero for Dummies. Well, here goes, the folly of Net Zero in eight charts (1/12)
Net Zero is sold as a climate fix, but it’s ineffective. UK’s 0.8% of global emissions means our cuts barely dent the climate (2/12)
CO2 isn’t the only climate driver—ice cores show temp swings with stable CO2. Net Zero is a futile gesture (3/12)
Net Zero spikes energy costs. UK had the priciest industrial & domestic electricity in 2023 (IEA data). EU 2024 stats confirm UK’s industrial power is the most expensive in Europe. Renewables aren’t cheap—they’re driving the surge (4/12)
Renewables like wind & solar aren’t the bargain they’re claimed to be. Renewables cost more than gas-fired power (with carbon tax). Grid balancing & backup costs make them pricier still (5/12)
Some new renewable projects got “cheap” contracts, but many, like Norfolk Boreas & Hornsea 4, were cancelled or rebid higher. Add grid & backup costs, and they’re still more expensive than gas. Claims of cheap renewables don’t hold up (6/12)
Net Zero is tanking the UK economy. High energy prices cut consumption & emissions & stagnated growth. No rich nation thrives with low per-capita energy. We’re exporting jobs to China & the US, fuelling unemployment & poverty (7/12)
“Green jobs” in wind & solar sound nice but cost £220K/year in subsidies per job. We’re swapping market-driven jobs for subsidized ones—a recipe for economic disaster. Net Zero’s job promises are a costly mirage (8/12)
Renewables aren’t green. Wind & solar use huge amounts of land & ocean, scar the environment, and rely on critical minerals mined with child/slave labor. Their energy return is low compared to production & backup needs. (9/12)
Net Zero curbs freedom. Gov advisors push propaganda, urge meat cuts, limit driving & flying, and control products like cement & steel. The Energy Act 2023 lets them manage your EV charger, appliances, even your fridge. Non-compliance? Jail. It’s a power grab (10/12)
Summary: Net Zero won’t change the weather, jacks up bills, kills jobs, and relies on unsustainable renewables. It’s a costly, controlling policy that harms the economy and personal freedom. A dumb plan pushed by dummies. (11/12)
If you enjoyed this thread please like and share. You can sign up for free to read the full article on the link below (12/12): open.substack.com/pub/davidturve…
HI @threadreaderapp unroll please.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Net Zero is a far-left tyrannical Death Star, cloaking state control as climate action. It crushes free markets with subsidies & bans. Time to fight for freedom! #NetZeroTyranny (1/11)
On the Political Compass, Net Zero is far-left: massive subsidies for renewables, bans on oil/gas, & Soviet-style plans like Miliband’s Clean Power 2030. No free market here! #NetZero (2/11)
Net Zero is peak authoritarianism. The Climate Change Committee (CCC) overrides Parliament, mandating how we heat homes, drive, & eat. Tyranny, not progress! #FreedomVsNetZero (3/11)
Late last month, the CCC released their Methodology Report that gave a little more insight into their thinking, or lack thereof, when they produced the 7th Carbon Budget. How did they get it so wrong. A thread 🧵(1/n)
First up, they assume even lower costs for fixed-bottom offshore wind than the Government's woeful Generation Cost report from 2023. The CCC's assumed costs for 2030 are less than half the value of contract awards in last year's AR6 auction. (2/n)
Floating offshore wind is even more expensive and being offered £245/MWh in AR7, some six times more than the CCC's estimate for 2030 delivery. Worse, the CCC shows a declining cost trend, whereas recent auctions have shown an upward trend in prices (3/n)
Last week, the Government released new data about energy costs in the UK & EU, and by extension the developed world. The bad news is that the UK still has the highest industrial electricity prices in Europe. But what else is going on in the data? A thread 🧵(1/n)
The chart above is for medium consumers, where UK prices are 89% higher than EU14 median. Large & v. large UK user prices are 132% & 113% respectively higher than the EU14 median. Very large UK users pay 22.32p/kWh compared to the lowest Finland with just 4.19p/kWh (2/n)
But it can't be gas driving these eyewatering electricity costs because UK industrial gas prices are below the EU14 median (3/n)
The data is in for CfD subsidies in April 2025. Overall subsidies are down from April last year, but subsidies per MWH are up. What is going on? A thread 🧵(1/n)
Overall subsidies for April 2025 came in at £155m across all technologies. This is slightly up on March 2025 (£152m) but much lower than April 2024 (£270m) (2/n)
Sounds like a move in the right direction until you look at generation. The fall in subsidies was mostly driven by a big drop in offshore wind generation. April 2025 delivered 1,263GWh, down form 2,237GWh in 2024 and lower than April 2023's 1,287GWh (3/n)
Ofgem just cut the price cap for Jul-Sep 2025. What's been driving our electricity bills since the price cap came into force? Mostly Net Zero stuff. A thread 🧵(1/n)
Overall bills (including VAT) including both gas and electricity have fallen by £129 or 7%. Interestingly, those on prepayment meters pay less than those on direct debit (2/n)
However, gas-bills fell by 9.3%, or £81 which is more than the average cut for the whole bill. Of the ex-VAT total of £797, about £408 is the price of gas with most of the rest being gas network costs, supplier operating costs & profit (3/n)
The institutions were out in force claiming renewables are cheap in their evidence to the ESNZ Cost of Energy Inquiry. This amounts to an industrial-scale effort to gaslight the public and mislead Parliament because renewables are much more expensive than gas. A thread 🧵(1/n)