Long ago, I managed people. If I'd thought of making a 20-something carry the can for a serious organisational failure, I'd have been too ashamed to look in the mirror. So I hope NHS Fife top brass aren't planning that.
The one to start with is the Chief Executive of NHS Scotland, who's also the Director-General in the Scottish Govt for Health and Social Care. The NHS Scotland Central Legal Office, which provides legal services to all NHS Boards, reports ultimately to her. /
NHS Fife's Board has seven members who are there as part of their job in the NHS. Carol Potter is the CEO.
Janette Keenan is the Director of Nursing.
Christopher McKenna is the Medical Director.
Susan Dunsmuir is the Director of Finance.
Joy Tomlinson is the Director of Public Health.
Lynne Parsons is the Employee Director.
Nicola Robertson is Chair of the Area Clinical Forum.
Then there are 11 "non-executive" board members. Their job (broadly) is to make sure NHS Fife does it job properly; non-execs are the first line of accountability. They are part-time (I think) and paid a day rate for their input (2024-25 figs below). publications.scot.nhs.uk/files/dl-2024-…
The most important of the non-execs is the chair, Pat Kilpatrick. That her name is not familiar after all these months of coverage of the Peggie case is very surprising.
The vice-chair, Alistair Morris, is the next most important.
Cllr Mary Lockhart represents Fife Council on the Board.
Professor Deborah Williamson represents the University of St Andrews.
Jo Bennett is another non-exec.
Sinead Braiden is another (and is the Equality and Diversity Champion on the Board).
Alastair Grant is another non-exec.
Colin Grieve is another non-exec.
Ann Haston is another non-exec.
John Kemp is another non-exec.
Arlene Wood is another non-exec.
There is a vacancy for the Whistle-blowing Champion.
"The overall purpose of the Board is to ensure the efficient, effective, and accountable governance of NHS Fife and to provide strategic leadership and direction for the system as a whole, focussing on agreed outcomes." ()/nhsfife.org/about-us/nhs-f…
Every person in this thread has years more professional experience (many more in most cases) than Ms Bumba, and is likely to hold, or have held if retired, more highly paid jobs. They are ultimately accountable for every decision taken in this case./
In addition there is a senior management team, whose collective role in decision-making relation to this case will depend on how this structure is used by the Chief Exec. Some posts will be directly involved, some possibly not at all./ nhsfife.org/about-us/senio…
These people are responsible for high-level decisions in NHS Fife. Staff who have already taken the witness stand, or will take it over the next two weeks, are seeing their names and faces all over the media. But the thread above is full of people who ought be even better known.
@threadreaderapp please unroll.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
It would be crazy (and improper, in my strong view) if MPs and/or MSPs to set off on an inquiry without first commissioning the EC to do a full investigation both into (a) how Murrell was able to do what he did, at that scale, for so long and also
3/n
.@ForWomenScot have done a thorough job on the candidates. I'll just highlight one I'd very much like to see back at Holyrood who has no party machine behind her.
Ash Regan is standing as an independent on the regional list for Edinburgh and Lothians East - these places. 1/7
I want to see Ash back because she is will be a tough, articulate and principled voice for the reality of women's lives, and safeguarding generally, in a place that will badly need that. She remains the only government Minister to resign on principle in 20 years, over the GRR./
Over the next 5 years, we're going to need brave and intelligent scrutiny and challenge of government generally, and esp on (what should be) sex-based laws and policies. At a practical level, I expect this to matter much more than anything where I take a different view from Ash/
Compare and contrast @STVNews attributing this sexual offending against girls to a woman (left - a 'lesbian' even), never mentioning the offender is male, with careful reporting in @courier_dundee (right), which at no point calls him a woman or she (right - link in next tweet)/
The Court Service told the Petitions Committee last month that they are recording sex as per the police, and the police say they now use (actual) sex, so all those involved knew this was not a woman. How far STV knew, is another question. thecourier.co.uk/fp/news/courts…
When people wonder why Sturgeon can't bring herself to say that Bryson is a man, I'm sure it's partly because Connolly and others have told her so often how upsetting they'd find it if she did. He put turned ordinary pictures of real little girls into private porn. #NotOurCrimes
We'll never know how many girls have been used as - deliberately targeted to be - props in confusing an unknown number of boys, and for adult male validation. Mixed-sex Scouts was always available.
As @prof_curiosity1 keeps pointing out, treating a little boy as a girl has no basis in decades and decades of careful child development literature. A parent deliberately choosing a girls' organisation for their male child was asking guide leaders and girls in membership to/
@prof_curiosity1 become involved in a complex psychological intervention none of them were qualified for *for that child*, on top of removing the rights of girls to a properly single-sex organisation, and safeguarding issues round males of all ages. An organisation for children failed to see that
Spending today (yet again) sitting in the court of session listening to the Scottish government discuss its determination that some men should be treated by like women, in one way or another. This time - prisons. I expect to hear much talk “balancing of rights”. But/
As others said, this is a case where an attractive-sounding concept has been introduced into a context where it simply does not belong. Whether we’re talking about rights as moral/ethical, protected in domestic law or international human rights standards…/
there are plenty of times where I don’t have a right to something and “balancing” simply doesn’t come into it. As a trivial example, I don’t have the right to…./