Share this page!

Enter URL or ID to Unroll

You can paste full URL like: https://x.com/threadreaderapp/status/1644127596119195649
or just the ID like: 1644127596119195649

How to get URL link on X (Twitter) App

  1. On the Twitter thread, click on or icon on the bottom
  2. Click again on or Share Via icon
  3. Click on Copy Link to Tweet
  4. Paste it above and click "Unroll Thread"!
  5. More info at Twitter Help
Lucy HunterBlackburn Profile picture
Lucy HunterBlackburn
@LucyHunterB
"Woman without certificate" (Scot Govt). Co-editor, The Women Who Wouldn't Wheesht. Freelance HE researcher. Also one of https://t.co/94Wf6ZzlXN.
Mar 29 • 25 tweets • 7 min read
Most recent stories about Stonewall are about what it's been doing. This one - unusually - is about whether it is doing anything in Scotland (that it wouldn't be doing anyway), in exchange for a six-figure annual grant from the Scottish Government. 1/n
thetimes.com/article/08d4dd… Stonewall Scotland gets £106k a year from the Scottish Government. In 2021, this was described, for up to September 2024, as being for a Scottish specific piece of work, called "Free to Be: Advancing LGBTQ+ Equality in Scotland". supported by 3.75 FTE staff, "across 7 roles". 2/n Image
Image
Mar 24 • 4 tweets • 1 min read
I am continuing with my project of testing the development of AI by asking it to write cheese scone recipes in the style of Judith Butler. This remains a reliable source of satirical entertainment. But it always works best if you remind it to remove the quantities, the ingredients, and the instructions. x.com/i/grok/share/B…
Mar 18 • 13 tweets • 3 min read
In a Scottish parliamentary committee today, I discovered that the current most senior civil servant in Scotland does not understand the concept of a policy.



1/however many this needsheraldscotland.com/news/25018496.… At the Finance and Public Administration Committee today, JP Marks, outgoing Permanent Secretary of the Scottish Government, was asked by Michelle Thomson MSP about the SG's "Trans and Non Binary Equality and Inclusion Policy"

Policy. Is the last word there. 2/n
Mar 8 • 5 tweets • 2 min read
International Women’s Day didn’t start as a chance for jolly statements by the comfy. It has radical roots. So in that spirit, these women facing up to power - political, male physical and institutional - today, in Scotland and the North of England are its true inheritors. 1/4 Edinburgh. Protest outside an SNP meeting attended by the current First Minister John Swinney and former First Minister Nicola Sturgeon. 2/4
Mar 6 • 14 tweets • 5 min read
Visual protest has been central to women's recent campaigning in Scotland. It's been organic and creative. So we're truly grateful to our photographers, and to our publishers, Constable, for allowing us to use #WomenWhoWouldntWheesht as a record of that.

A selection below./ Image The first ribbon, tied and photographed by @Dis_Critic, whose words also open the book./ Image
Feb 22 • 4 tweets • 1 min read
It was so good just to sit in a room and have a meeting.

Six years ago, when “no debate” really meant “aggressive harassment of women raising concerns”, one of Lisa, Kath and my aims was to help bring this all back into normal mainstream political debate./ And that’s now happening. Women’s Declarations groups in all the main parties have played a central role in that - often under horrible conditions within their parties that should be a permanent stain on those parties’ histories, with male aggression too often allowed free rein/
Feb 13 • 5 tweets • 1 min read
It wasn't pleasant today to watch a nurse of decades' standing so uncomfortable at being asked questions about the relationship between changing how you dress and your cheek swab result, and the relevance of sex to medical treatment./ For everyone who has done well out of reality denial about sex, there are so many more it chews up and spits out./
Feb 12 • 4 tweets • 1 min read
|An employment tribunal against NHS Fife for its treatment of a nurse who wanted a single-sex changing room is running past the initial allotted fortnight is *because its lawyers are *still* disclosing documents they were under a court order to disclose much earlier*. Whether or not such late disclosure happens routinely at these tribunals (and a couple of people have reported having this experience in other cases), it still ought to be headline news. They are saying they have stuff relevant to *tomorrow's* witness they will produce overnight.
Feb 11 • 5 tweets • 2 min read
Counsel for Sandie Peggie raised this morning how often she'd been interrupted during her cross-examination of Dr Upton yesterday, by counsel for NHS Fife/Dr Upton.

I noted 17 times in first session (just over an hour), at which point there was a break at Ms Russell's request. Started keeping track when first one happened 10 mins in, because the contrast with how little Cunningham had interrupted Russell last week was so immediately obvious. It slowed down a bit later, but in the end, there were 34 in just over 3 1/4 hours. May have missed some.
Feb 11 • 4 tweets • 1 min read
With each case you learn something new about the judicial process. With this one, it's how little disincentive there seems to be for the respondents at an ET to mess up the other side's case by being very slow at document production, as well as resistant and apparently confused/ Up to and including telling the court something hasn't happened which late disclosed documents then refer to.
If there are no penalties for this behaviour, justice surely isn't served? (Regardless of the outcome of the case) Image
Feb 11 • 12 tweets • 3 min read
Episode 1. A female nurse tells her manager she is uncomfortable the changing room has become in effect mixed sex. No action is taken./ Image She is the only one who raises it with management, though she is directly aware others also feel uncomfortable about this. / Image
Feb 10 • 5 tweets • 1 min read
A doctor working in the NHS, getting legal support on the NHS, believes that any female member of staff who has a particular difficulty sharing a changing room due to something in her personal history shouldn’t expect a properly managed single sex changing room, but/ should instead have to disclose her personal history to management and have special arrangements made. I’m thinking the woman I know who only in her late 40s disclosed with great difficulty has sexual abuse as a child./
Feb 5 • 7 tweets • 2 min read
Though this does give me an excuse to tell the story of the single funniest result from FoI response we’ve ever received. Needs more than one tweet. 1/n We put in a request for the info held on their consideration of the 2011 article by Dhejne, which had not been mentioned in the EQIA they published in 2019, and was still absent from the revised one in 2022, two years after we (and others) had drawn it to their attention. 2/m
Jan 12 • 10 tweets • 3 min read
Despite being someone of very definite views (you may have noticed), for the 15 years I spent benefitting from the influence, salary and security granted by being in the policy part of the civil service, I left it all at the door when I went to work./ So my attitude to those who want all the personal satisfaction of activism, while enjoying the benefits of being in the civil service, is very very uncharitable.
Dec 21, 2024 • 20 tweets • 6 min read
A 🧵reliving day 2 of Stage 3 of the GRR, two years ago today. The debate began around 2pm.

Important things to remember here, as this was when the Scottish Government went to incredible lengths to side-step discussing the interaction with Equality Act.
A quick reminder in the thread below of how things had ended the night before.
Nov 28, 2024 • 5 tweets • 1 min read
It can take a day for a penny to drop. Something in the final remarks of the EHRC's KC was specifically irking me. Late on, IIRC,, he asked the court to note that if it did not accept that a GRC changes "sex" under the EA, there might be unforeseen consequences for GRC-holders/ in bringing discrimination-related cases (only GRC holders, not everyone with gender reassignment PC). He couldn't say what those were - they would be things nobody had thought of yet was his point, as I recall - although the EHRC has had a very long time to run scenarios here./
Nov 21, 2024 • 6 tweets • 2 min read
This is the final instalment of a story that began almost 6 (*6*) years ago, when Lisa, Kath and I asked SG what it thought the effect of a GRC was under the Equality Act (given they wanted to hand out many more, more easily). Their response was to avoid the question. For years./ And now here we are. The SG is going to the highest court in the land to argue that a GRC changes your sex under the Equality Act. Image
Oct 6, 2024 • 15 tweets • 3 min read
Quick🧵on the FWS case against the SG. It started with SG trying to legislate as if self-ID was already the law (in a way that self-ID supporters no doubt hoped would help create that effect more generally), using a relatively obscure bit of legislation about public boards./ FWS called them out in court and won, in the course of that obtaining a clear statement that sex under the Equality Act meant the characteristic you develop physically in utero (the court talked about "biological" males). (This case I'll shorthand below to FWS1.)
May 20, 2024 • 8 tweets • 5 min read
Important to understand how much the ERCC "heresy hunt" is rooted in the political and civic establishment culture that developed here over the last ten years. The dogmatism and bullying at ERCC was close to our political heart🧵 Maggie Chapman was the COO of ERCC when Mridul Wadwha was appointed. She was deputy convener of the GRR Bill committee, and reprimanded for not declaring her role at ERCC when the Sandy Brindley of Rape Crisis Scotland appeared before it as a witness.
Image
Image
May 19, 2024 • 9 tweets • 3 min read
Last Thursday
@DalgetySusan and I announced the publication on 30 May of #WomenWhoWouldntWheesht.
Nicola Sturgeon attempted to reinvent herself.
The Scottish Greens expelled some members.

Any book about recent campaigning Scotland ends up being about our political culture... 🧵 Sturgeon's attempted reinvention and the latest from the Scottish Greens has provoked a lot of reflection on where we are, how we got here and where we are headed - all themes that run through our book, too.

This thread pulls together various articles from the last few days/
Apr 29, 2024 • 6 tweets • 2 min read
This is the second man in Scotland to be convicted of violent threats against women because they argue that sex cannot be changed and there are times that that matters in policy and law, and we need to be able to talk about that freely in clear language.
This is the other. heraldscotland.com/news/19157798.…