Systematic Failures in Unaccompanied Children Processing Under the Biden Administration (2021-2024)
This Thread examines systemic failures in the processing of unaccompanied children (UCs) at the U.S. border during the Biden administration (2021-2024), focusing on policies, inter-agency coordination, and oversight gaps that contributed to losing track of over 300,000 UCs. It highlights key structural issues, such as reliance on Department of Homeland Security (DHS)/Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) for Notices to Appear (NTAs), separation of roles under the Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act (TVPRA) of 2008 and the Flores Settlement Agreement, lack of unified tracking, and the termination of the 2018 Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) on information-sharing. All sources, including Office of Inspector General (OIG) reports, case studies, and additional findings, are documented for evidentiary purposes.
This Thread examines systemic failures in the processing of unaccompanied children (UCs) at the U.S. border during the Biden administration (2021-2024), focusing on policies, inter-agency coordination, and oversight gaps that contributed to losing track of over 300,000 UCs. It highlights key structural issues, such as reliance on Department of Homeland Security (DHS)/Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) for Notices to Appear (NTAs), separation of roles under the Trafficking Victims Protection Reauthorization Act (TVPRA) of 2008 and the Flores Settlement Agreement, lack of unified tracking, and the termination of the 2018 Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) on information-sharing. All sources, including Office of Inspector General (OIG) reports, case studies, and additional findings, are documented for evidentiary purposes.
Executive Summary
The Biden administration’s handling of the border crisis resulted in unprecedented surges of UCs, with over 500,000 entering the system from 2021-2024. Systemic failures—rooted in policy reversals, resource shortfalls, and inter-agency silos—led to inadequate vetting, rushed releases, and minimal post-release monitoring, rendering approximately 323,000 UCs untraceable. This includes 291,000+ without NTAs and 32,000 who missed court hearings. oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
Key failures include DHS/ICE’s delays in issuing NTAs, HHS/ORR’s limited follow-up (e.g., undocumented 30-day calls in 22% of cases), and the March 2021 MOA termination under Acting HHS Secretary Norris Cochran and DHS Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas, directed by President Joe Biden, which hindered real-time data sharing on sponsor addresses and safety concerns. congress.gov/118/meeting/ho…
grassley.senate.gov/news/news-rele…
These gaps exposed UCs to risks like trafficking, exploitation, and unknown fates, as evidenced by OIG audits, congressional hearings, and case studies. Recommendations urge restored data-sharing, mandatory NTAs pre-release, and enhanced tracking.
The Biden administration’s handling of the border crisis resulted in unprecedented surges of UCs, with over 500,000 entering the system from 2021-2024. Systemic failures—rooted in policy reversals, resource shortfalls, and inter-agency silos—led to inadequate vetting, rushed releases, and minimal post-release monitoring, rendering approximately 323,000 UCs untraceable. This includes 291,000+ without NTAs and 32,000 who missed court hearings. oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
Key failures include DHS/ICE’s delays in issuing NTAs, HHS/ORR’s limited follow-up (e.g., undocumented 30-day calls in 22% of cases), and the March 2021 MOA termination under Acting HHS Secretary Norris Cochran and DHS Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas, directed by President Joe Biden, which hindered real-time data sharing on sponsor addresses and safety concerns. congress.gov/118/meeting/ho…
grassley.senate.gov/news/news-rele…
These gaps exposed UCs to risks like trafficking, exploitation, and unknown fates, as evidenced by OIG audits, congressional hearings, and case studies. Recommendations urge restored data-sharing, mandatory NTAs pre-release, and enhanced tracking.
Background
Under TVPRA (2008), HHS/ORR assumes custody of UCs within 72 hours of DHS apprehension, prioritizing welfare and release to sponsors without requiring NTAs upfront. The Flores Agreement (1997) mandates quick releases to avoid prolonged detention. From 2021-2024, border encounters surged (e.g., 147,000 UCs in FY2021, peaking at 152,000 in FY2023), overwhelming systems. immigrationforum.org/article/unacco…
newsnationnow.com/us-news/immigr…
Policy shifts, including the MOA termination, aimed to reduce sponsorship barriers but exacerbated tracking failures. congress.gov/118/meeting/ho…
Initial records in ORR’s UC Portal exist, but without enforcement linkages, UCs become uncontactable.
Under TVPRA (2008), HHS/ORR assumes custody of UCs within 72 hours of DHS apprehension, prioritizing welfare and release to sponsors without requiring NTAs upfront. The Flores Agreement (1997) mandates quick releases to avoid prolonged detention. From 2021-2024, border encounters surged (e.g., 147,000 UCs in FY2021, peaking at 152,000 in FY2023), overwhelming systems. immigrationforum.org/article/unacco…
newsnationnow.com/us-news/immigr…
Policy shifts, including the MOA termination, aimed to reduce sponsorship barriers but exacerbated tracking failures. congress.gov/118/meeting/ho…
Initial records in ORR’s UC Portal exist, but without enforcement linkages, UCs become uncontactable.
Key Failures
1. DOJ/EOIR’s Dependence on DHS/ICE for NTAs
DOJ/EOIR schedules court dates only after DHS/ICE files an NTA, initiating removal proceedings. Without DHS input, EOIR cannot act, making it downstream. oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
nypost.com/2024/08/21/us-…
EOIR manages juvenile dockets but relies on DHS data; discrepancies (e.g., 4,000+ mismatches in absence records) arise from DHS’s manual processes and lack of automation. oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
2. Separation of Roles Under TVPRA and Flores
TVPRA mandates HHS/ORR focus on welfare/release without enforcement authority, while DHS handles NTAs (not required pre-release). Flores emphasizes quick releases to prevent “unnecessary detention,” allowing ORR to prioritize sponsor placements over immigration proceedings. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC58…
immigrationforum.org/article/unacco…
This separation, while protective, creates silos: ORR releases UCs without NTAs, shifting tracking to ICE, which often fails due to backlogs.
3. No Unified Tracking System
Initial records in ORR’s UC Portal/UC Path include sponsor details, but no real-time sharing or mandatory long-term monitoring exists. Without NTAs/court dates, ICE cannot enforce appearances, leading to uncontactable UCs (e.g., due to moves or fear of authorities). oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
HHS follow-ups (30-day calls) were undocumented in 22% of cases, and ICE lacked processes for high-risk referrals. congress.gov/118/meeting/ho…
4. Scale Impact During Surges
Surges (e.g., 2021-2023) led to rushed vetting/follow-ups, exacerbating gaps. Structure allows releases without full enforcement linkage, resulting in unknown conditions if post-release contact fails. Over 340 UCs were sent to nonrelatives, raising exploitation concerns. nbcnews.com/politics/immig…
5. Termination of 2018 MOA
In March 2021, Acting HHS Secretary Norris Cochran and DHS Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas jointly terminated the 2018 MOA, under President Joe Biden’s direction, to prioritize child welfare and reduce sponsorship barriers. This hindered real-time updates on sponsor addresses/safety, increasing risks. Operational signatories from ORR, ICE, and CBP are unnamed in public records. oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
1. DOJ/EOIR’s Dependence on DHS/ICE for NTAs
DOJ/EOIR schedules court dates only after DHS/ICE files an NTA, initiating removal proceedings. Without DHS input, EOIR cannot act, making it downstream. oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
nypost.com/2024/08/21/us-…
EOIR manages juvenile dockets but relies on DHS data; discrepancies (e.g., 4,000+ mismatches in absence records) arise from DHS’s manual processes and lack of automation. oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
2. Separation of Roles Under TVPRA and Flores
TVPRA mandates HHS/ORR focus on welfare/release without enforcement authority, while DHS handles NTAs (not required pre-release). Flores emphasizes quick releases to prevent “unnecessary detention,” allowing ORR to prioritize sponsor placements over immigration proceedings. pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC58…
immigrationforum.org/article/unacco…
This separation, while protective, creates silos: ORR releases UCs without NTAs, shifting tracking to ICE, which often fails due to backlogs.
3. No Unified Tracking System
Initial records in ORR’s UC Portal/UC Path include sponsor details, but no real-time sharing or mandatory long-term monitoring exists. Without NTAs/court dates, ICE cannot enforce appearances, leading to uncontactable UCs (e.g., due to moves or fear of authorities). oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
HHS follow-ups (30-day calls) were undocumented in 22% of cases, and ICE lacked processes for high-risk referrals. congress.gov/118/meeting/ho…
4. Scale Impact During Surges
Surges (e.g., 2021-2023) led to rushed vetting/follow-ups, exacerbating gaps. Structure allows releases without full enforcement linkage, resulting in unknown conditions if post-release contact fails. Over 340 UCs were sent to nonrelatives, raising exploitation concerns. nbcnews.com/politics/immig…
5. Termination of 2018 MOA
In March 2021, Acting HHS Secretary Norris Cochran and DHS Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas jointly terminated the 2018 MOA, under President Joe Biden’s direction, to prioritize child welfare and reduce sponsorship barriers. This hindered real-time updates on sponsor addresses/safety, increasing risks. Operational signatories from ORR, ICE, and CBP are unnamed in public records. oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
Sources, Case Studies, and OIG Reports
OIG Reports
• DHS OIG Report OIG-24-46 (August 2024): “ICE Cannot Monitor All Unaccompanied Migrant Children Released.” Details ICE’s inability to track 323,000 UCs due to NTA failures, lack of automation, and data mismatches with DOJ. Recommends improved sharing with HHS. oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/… oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
• DHS OIG Report OIG-25-14 (January 2025): “Results of May 2024 Unannounced Inspections of CBP Holding Facilities.” Highlights overcrowding and poor conditions for UCs in Tucson, recommending better management. oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
• DHS OIG Report OIG-24-44 (August 2024): “Results of January 2024 Unannounced Inspections.” Notes coordination issues in UC programs, with facilities exceeding capacity. oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
• DHS OIG Report OIG-24-39 (July 2024): “Results of October 2023 Inspections.” Identifies failures in short-term holding for UCs, including hygiene and transfer delays. oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
• HHS OIG Report (February 2024): On ORR follow-ups, found 19% uncontactable (extrapolated to 85,000), with gaps in safety checks and documentation. publicintegrity.org/inequality-pov…
Case Studies
• House Hearing (November 2024): “Trafficked, Exploited, and Missing: Migrant Children Victims of the Biden-Harris Administration.” Testimony from HHS whistleblowers and experts on systemic neglect, including 233,000+ UCs not enrolled in proceedings. homeland.house.gov/hearing/traffi…
congress.gov/event/118th-co…
homeland.house.gov/2024/11/21/hhs…
homeland.house.gov/2024/11/19/thi…
congress.gov/118/chrg/CHRG-…
• Grassley Report (February 2025): Confirms oversight failures, with 500,000+ UCs entering amid cartel exploitation; highlights DHS non-enrollment of 233,000. grassley.senate.gov/news/news-rele…
• Florida Grand Jury Report (March 2023): Details atrocities against UCs in Florida under federal authority, including trafficking. myfloridalegal.com/newsrelease/21…
• NBC News Audit (June 2023): Over 340 UCs placed with nonrelatives, risking labor exploitation. nbcnews.com/politics/immig…
• CIS Report (April 2023): Analyzes HHS loss of 85,000 UCs, calling for media/government accountability. cis.org/Arthur/Did-Joe…
• PBS Report (February 2023): Hundreds of separated children unreunited despite Biden efforts. pbs.org/newshour/show/…
Conclusion and Recommendations
These failures represent a moral and operational crisis, with unknown outcomes for UCs potentially in trafficking or exploitation. For hearings: Restore 2018 MOA, mandate NTAs pre-release, implement unified tracking databases, increase OIG audits, and hold leaders accountable. Visuals like Vera Institute flowcharts (branching by origin/risks) illustrate gaps.
OIG Reports
• DHS OIG Report OIG-24-46 (August 2024): “ICE Cannot Monitor All Unaccompanied Migrant Children Released.” Details ICE’s inability to track 323,000 UCs due to NTA failures, lack of automation, and data mismatches with DOJ. Recommends improved sharing with HHS. oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/… oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
• DHS OIG Report OIG-25-14 (January 2025): “Results of May 2024 Unannounced Inspections of CBP Holding Facilities.” Highlights overcrowding and poor conditions for UCs in Tucson, recommending better management. oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
• DHS OIG Report OIG-24-44 (August 2024): “Results of January 2024 Unannounced Inspections.” Notes coordination issues in UC programs, with facilities exceeding capacity. oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
• DHS OIG Report OIG-24-39 (July 2024): “Results of October 2023 Inspections.” Identifies failures in short-term holding for UCs, including hygiene and transfer delays. oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
• HHS OIG Report (February 2024): On ORR follow-ups, found 19% uncontactable (extrapolated to 85,000), with gaps in safety checks and documentation. publicintegrity.org/inequality-pov…
Case Studies
• House Hearing (November 2024): “Trafficked, Exploited, and Missing: Migrant Children Victims of the Biden-Harris Administration.” Testimony from HHS whistleblowers and experts on systemic neglect, including 233,000+ UCs not enrolled in proceedings. homeland.house.gov/hearing/traffi…
congress.gov/event/118th-co…
homeland.house.gov/2024/11/21/hhs…
homeland.house.gov/2024/11/19/thi…
congress.gov/118/chrg/CHRG-…
• Grassley Report (February 2025): Confirms oversight failures, with 500,000+ UCs entering amid cartel exploitation; highlights DHS non-enrollment of 233,000. grassley.senate.gov/news/news-rele…
• Florida Grand Jury Report (March 2023): Details atrocities against UCs in Florida under federal authority, including trafficking. myfloridalegal.com/newsrelease/21…
• NBC News Audit (June 2023): Over 340 UCs placed with nonrelatives, risking labor exploitation. nbcnews.com/politics/immig…
• CIS Report (April 2023): Analyzes HHS loss of 85,000 UCs, calling for media/government accountability. cis.org/Arthur/Did-Joe…
• PBS Report (February 2023): Hundreds of separated children unreunited despite Biden efforts. pbs.org/newshour/show/…
Conclusion and Recommendations
These failures represent a moral and operational crisis, with unknown outcomes for UCs potentially in trafficking or exploitation. For hearings: Restore 2018 MOA, mandate NTAs pre-release, implement unified tracking databases, increase OIG audits, and hold leaders accountable. Visuals like Vera Institute flowcharts (branching by origin/risks) illustrate gaps.
Many whistleblowers came forward to reveal what was taken place only to be retaliated against in an effort to silence them. The USG knew what was going on under the Biden administration. Let’s take a look 👀
@taraleerodas , a federal employee with the Council of the Inspectors General for Integrity and Efficiency (CIGIE) under the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), volunteered in 2021 to assist with the unaccompanied children (UC) border crisis as part of Operation Artemis, a government-wide HHS initiative to recruit federal volunteers for surge support. She was deployed (detailed) to the Pomona Fairplex Emergency Intake Site in California, which was operated by Southwest Key Programs—an NGO contracted by the Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR) to run temporary facilities for UCs. In her role as deputy of the federal case management team at the site, she was involved in assisting with the sponsor vetting and placement process, including reviewing sponsor applications, verifying documents (often via photographs), and helping facilitate releases, though she emphasized in testimony that the vetting was inadequate and lacked investigative rigor. This hands-on involvement aligns with how federal employees are often detailed to NGO-operated sites to provide direct support during crises, under ORR’s oversight framework where NGOs handle day-to-day operations but ORR retains final approval authority on releases.
The root of responsibility here lies in the structured delegation under ORR policies: NGOs like Southwest Key are contractors that operate facilities and support vetting/placement tasks, but they do so with embedded federal personnel (like Rodas) during high-volume periods to ensure compliance and efficiency. This is not independent authority—ORR provides “strict oversight” through federal field specialists who review and approve all final decisions, site visits, and policy adherence, as outlined in ORR’s Unaccompanied Children Program Policy Guide (Section 2). However, Rodas’s testimony reveals systemic gaps where this oversight was insufficient, leading to rushed processes, minimal verification (e.g., no standard law enforcement involvement or full household background checks), and placements with unsafe sponsors, including those tied to MS-13. She described the system as functioning like a “multi-billion-dollar child trafficking operation” due to these flaws, with federal employees like herself embedded to “help” but often pressured to prioritize speed over safety amid surges.
Her assignment was authorized by HHS/ORR leadership as part of the broader Operation Artemis volunteer program, which solicited federal employees government-wide to address the 2021 UC influx. While specific individual authorizers are not named in public records (e.g., testimonies or audits), the program fell under the direction of then-Acting HHS Secretary Norris Cochran (January-March 2021) and incoming Secretary Xavier Becerra (confirmed March 19, 2021), with operational deployment handled by ORR administrators. This detailing practice is standard for emergency responses, allowing federal staff to embed at NGO sites to augment capacity while maintaining ORR’s oversight. Rodas faced retaliation for her whistleblowing (e.g., badge revocation and removal from the site after reporting concerns), underscoring accountability issues at the federal level rather than solely with NGOs.
They knew about all this and did nothing. Let that sink in……youtube.com/live/T5Mkwn2es…
@taraleerodas , a federal employee with the Council of the Inspectors General for Integrity and Efficiency (CIGIE) under the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), volunteered in 2021 to assist with the unaccompanied children (UC) border crisis as part of Operation Artemis, a government-wide HHS initiative to recruit federal volunteers for surge support. She was deployed (detailed) to the Pomona Fairplex Emergency Intake Site in California, which was operated by Southwest Key Programs—an NGO contracted by the Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR) to run temporary facilities for UCs. In her role as deputy of the federal case management team at the site, she was involved in assisting with the sponsor vetting and placement process, including reviewing sponsor applications, verifying documents (often via photographs), and helping facilitate releases, though she emphasized in testimony that the vetting was inadequate and lacked investigative rigor. This hands-on involvement aligns with how federal employees are often detailed to NGO-operated sites to provide direct support during crises, under ORR’s oversight framework where NGOs handle day-to-day operations but ORR retains final approval authority on releases.
The root of responsibility here lies in the structured delegation under ORR policies: NGOs like Southwest Key are contractors that operate facilities and support vetting/placement tasks, but they do so with embedded federal personnel (like Rodas) during high-volume periods to ensure compliance and efficiency. This is not independent authority—ORR provides “strict oversight” through federal field specialists who review and approve all final decisions, site visits, and policy adherence, as outlined in ORR’s Unaccompanied Children Program Policy Guide (Section 2). However, Rodas’s testimony reveals systemic gaps where this oversight was insufficient, leading to rushed processes, minimal verification (e.g., no standard law enforcement involvement or full household background checks), and placements with unsafe sponsors, including those tied to MS-13. She described the system as functioning like a “multi-billion-dollar child trafficking operation” due to these flaws, with federal employees like herself embedded to “help” but often pressured to prioritize speed over safety amid surges.
Her assignment was authorized by HHS/ORR leadership as part of the broader Operation Artemis volunteer program, which solicited federal employees government-wide to address the 2021 UC influx. While specific individual authorizers are not named in public records (e.g., testimonies or audits), the program fell under the direction of then-Acting HHS Secretary Norris Cochran (January-March 2021) and incoming Secretary Xavier Becerra (confirmed March 19, 2021), with operational deployment handled by ORR administrators. This detailing practice is standard for emergency responses, allowing federal staff to embed at NGO sites to augment capacity while maintaining ORR’s oversight. Rodas faced retaliation for her whistleblowing (e.g., badge revocation and removal from the site after reporting concerns), underscoring accountability issues at the federal level rather than solely with NGOs.
They knew about all this and did nothing. Let that sink in……youtube.com/live/T5Mkwn2es…
Source: congress.gov/118/chrg/CHRG-…
@taraleerodas full testimony : docs.house.gov/meetings/JU/JU…
grassley.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/…
congress.gov/event/118th-co…
Full video to Grassley Senate hearing: grassley.senate.gov/news/news-rele…
homeland.house.gov/2024/11/21/hhs…
sgp.fas.org/crs/homesec/R4…
@taraleerodas full testimony : docs.house.gov/meetings/JU/JU…
grassley.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/…
congress.gov/event/118th-co…
Full video to Grassley Senate hearing: grassley.senate.gov/news/news-rele…
homeland.house.gov/2024/11/21/hhs…
sgp.fas.org/crs/homesec/R4…
Clarification on NGO Involvement in UC Sponsor Vetting and Placement (Focusing on Aaron Stevenson who went public in August of 2021)
youtu.be/Lnesw0NguKI?si…
@JamesOKeefeIII
Based on whistleblower accounts from @DHSAaron and official documentation from the Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR) under HHS, NGOs are involved in operational support for sponsor vetting and placement of unaccompanied children (UCs), but as contractors under ORR oversight without independent authority for final decisions, court scheduling, or enforcement. Stevenson, a former DHS intelligence official and Transnational Organized Crime (TOC) Mission expert, highlighted these roles in his whistleblowing, exposing how relaxed federal policies allowed dangerous placements (e.g., with MS-13 gang members) despite NGO-facilitated vetting. His revelations complement Tara Rodas’s testimony, emphasizing systemic failures where NGOs like Endeavors and Southwest Key handle day-to-day tasks but federal pressures for speed undermine thorough checks, leading to trafficking risks. homeland.house.gov/2024/11/21/hhs…
Watch this full interview with @DHSAaron @taraleerodas @MaryFlynnONeil1
youtu.be/HohyZZ3erao?si…
This fits the broader critique that while NGOs support processes, accountability lies with federal agencies (DHS/HHS/ORR) for policy and oversight lapses contributing to 300,000+ untraceable UCs.
To address your concern: Prior analyses did not claim NGOs have no role; they clarified delegated tasks under federal control. Stevenson’s case shows how DHS intel (his domain) intersected with ORR/NGO operations, revealing gaps like unvetted sponsors. Below, I’ll break it down with details from his whistleblowing and sources.
Aaron Stevenson’s Whistleblower Testimony and Key Revelations
Aaron Stevenson, a former DHS intelligence official specializing in transnational organized crime, came forward in February 2021 (public in August 2021) to expose flaws in the UC sponsor vetting process. He lost his job for whistleblowing and has testified in interviews, podcasts, and congressional contexts about government-facilitated child trafficking via inadequate checks.
homeland.house.gov/wp-content/upl…
• His Role and Observations: Stevenson worked in DHS’s TOC Mission, analyzing threats like gang involvement in migration. He identified the first known case of a TOC Watchlisted individual (e.g., MS-13 member) sponsoring a UC due to relaxed vetting post-2021 policy changes (e.g., no full household fingerprints). He reviewed sponsor data and flagged issues like repeated addresses linked to gangs or traffickers, but DHS/HHS failed to act comprehensively. Unlike Rodas (embedded at NGO sites), Stevenson focused on intelligence analysis, collaborating with ORR data to spot patterns. He co-authored solutions like a “PACE-like” entity for cross-agency data sharing to detect trafficking.
• Specific Failures Leading to MS-13 Placements: Stevenson reported gang members on the TOC Watchlist sponsoring UCs, with fake documents and shared addresses indicating trafficking rings. He noted relaxed vetting (e.g., phone-based checks only) allowed this, and HHS ignored flags. In Central American prison interviews, he uncovered organ harvesting tied to cartels exploiting UCs. Children were often unescorted post-release, dropped at airports without sponsors. He criticized HHS for denying law enforcement access to UC Portal data.
youtu.be/Lnesw0NguKI?si…
@JamesOKeefeIII
Based on whistleblower accounts from @DHSAaron and official documentation from the Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR) under HHS, NGOs are involved in operational support for sponsor vetting and placement of unaccompanied children (UCs), but as contractors under ORR oversight without independent authority for final decisions, court scheduling, or enforcement. Stevenson, a former DHS intelligence official and Transnational Organized Crime (TOC) Mission expert, highlighted these roles in his whistleblowing, exposing how relaxed federal policies allowed dangerous placements (e.g., with MS-13 gang members) despite NGO-facilitated vetting. His revelations complement Tara Rodas’s testimony, emphasizing systemic failures where NGOs like Endeavors and Southwest Key handle day-to-day tasks but federal pressures for speed undermine thorough checks, leading to trafficking risks. homeland.house.gov/2024/11/21/hhs…
Watch this full interview with @DHSAaron @taraleerodas @MaryFlynnONeil1
youtu.be/HohyZZ3erao?si…
This fits the broader critique that while NGOs support processes, accountability lies with federal agencies (DHS/HHS/ORR) for policy and oversight lapses contributing to 300,000+ untraceable UCs.
To address your concern: Prior analyses did not claim NGOs have no role; they clarified delegated tasks under federal control. Stevenson’s case shows how DHS intel (his domain) intersected with ORR/NGO operations, revealing gaps like unvetted sponsors. Below, I’ll break it down with details from his whistleblowing and sources.
Aaron Stevenson’s Whistleblower Testimony and Key Revelations
Aaron Stevenson, a former DHS intelligence official specializing in transnational organized crime, came forward in February 2021 (public in August 2021) to expose flaws in the UC sponsor vetting process. He lost his job for whistleblowing and has testified in interviews, podcasts, and congressional contexts about government-facilitated child trafficking via inadequate checks.
homeland.house.gov/wp-content/upl…
• His Role and Observations: Stevenson worked in DHS’s TOC Mission, analyzing threats like gang involvement in migration. He identified the first known case of a TOC Watchlisted individual (e.g., MS-13 member) sponsoring a UC due to relaxed vetting post-2021 policy changes (e.g., no full household fingerprints). He reviewed sponsor data and flagged issues like repeated addresses linked to gangs or traffickers, but DHS/HHS failed to act comprehensively. Unlike Rodas (embedded at NGO sites), Stevenson focused on intelligence analysis, collaborating with ORR data to spot patterns. He co-authored solutions like a “PACE-like” entity for cross-agency data sharing to detect trafficking.
• Specific Failures Leading to MS-13 Placements: Stevenson reported gang members on the TOC Watchlist sponsoring UCs, with fake documents and shared addresses indicating trafficking rings. He noted relaxed vetting (e.g., phone-based checks only) allowed this, and HHS ignored flags. In Central American prison interviews, he uncovered organ harvesting tied to cartels exploiting UCs. Children were often unescorted post-release, dropped at airports without sponsors. He criticized HHS for denying law enforcement access to UC Portal data.
• Testimony Dates and Contexts:
• August 2021: Went public on MS-13 sponsorships. homeland.house.gov/2024/11/21/hhs…
congress.gov/event/118th-co…
• December 2023: Kyle Seraphin Show with Rodas on government child trafficking. orthochristian.com/157682.html
• July 2024: Senate Roundtable – “The Exploitation Crisis.” facebook.com/NTDTelevision/…
homeland.house.gov/wp-content/upl…
• November 2024: House Homeland Security Committee – Referenced in Rodas’s testimony on Biden-Harris failures.
Official Role of NGOs in the Vetting Process (As Related to Stevenson’s Concerns)
NGOs like Endeavors (Pecos, TX facility) support ORR by collecting applications, verifying identities, and conducting checks, but ORR approves releases. Stevenson criticized NGO opacity (e.g., filtered info to monitors, delayed staff background checks) and how this enabled gang sponsorships.
• NGO Tasks: Similar to Rodas’s experience, NGOs handle initial vetting but under ORR guidelines.
• Limits: No final authority; ORR oversees via specialists.
Why the Discrepancy Feels “Off” and Systemic Implications
Stevenson’s DHS intel role exposed how NGO-supported vetting failed under federal relaxation (e.g., 2021 MOA termination), allowing TOC infiltration. The “missing” element is federal accountability—DHS/HHS policies prioritized releases, overriding thorough NGO checks. This led to 85,000+ uncontactable UCs and trafficking. For your project, his story (with Rodas) underscores bipartisan reform needs, like better data sharing.
• August 2021: Went public on MS-13 sponsorships. homeland.house.gov/2024/11/21/hhs…
congress.gov/event/118th-co…
• December 2023: Kyle Seraphin Show with Rodas on government child trafficking. orthochristian.com/157682.html
• July 2024: Senate Roundtable – “The Exploitation Crisis.” facebook.com/NTDTelevision/…
homeland.house.gov/wp-content/upl…
• November 2024: House Homeland Security Committee – Referenced in Rodas’s testimony on Biden-Harris failures.
Official Role of NGOs in the Vetting Process (As Related to Stevenson’s Concerns)
NGOs like Endeavors (Pecos, TX facility) support ORR by collecting applications, verifying identities, and conducting checks, but ORR approves releases. Stevenson criticized NGO opacity (e.g., filtered info to monitors, delayed staff background checks) and how this enabled gang sponsorships.
• NGO Tasks: Similar to Rodas’s experience, NGOs handle initial vetting but under ORR guidelines.
• Limits: No final authority; ORR oversees via specialists.
Why the Discrepancy Feels “Off” and Systemic Implications
Stevenson’s DHS intel role exposed how NGO-supported vetting failed under federal relaxation (e.g., 2021 MOA termination), allowing TOC infiltration. The “missing” element is federal accountability—DHS/HHS policies prioritized releases, overriding thorough NGO checks. This led to 85,000+ uncontactable UCs and trafficking. For your project, his story (with Rodas) underscores bipartisan reform needs, like better data sharing.
We have proven that this is criminal wouldn’t you say?
Based on the extensive evidence we’ve discussed—from whistleblower testimonies (e.g., Tara Rodas and Aaron Stevenson), OIG audits, congressional hearings, and official referrals—there are clear indications of systemic negligence, policy failures, and potential exploitation in the handling of unaccompanied children (UCs) by agencies like HHS/ORR and DHS/ICE. These issues have led to risks like trafficking, abuse, and over 300,000 UCs becoming untraceable, as detailed in reports extrapolating from unissued NTAs (Notice To Appear), missed court dates, and failed follow-ups.
However, while these point to moral, operational, and possibly ethical crimes against vulnerable children, “proven criminality” in a legal sense requires formal charges, convictions, or court rulings—none of which have been widespread or conclusively established as of mid-2025. @AGPamBondi @POTUS @VP
Evidence Supporting Potential Criminality
• Allegations of Facilitated Trafficking: Whistleblowers like Rodas and Stevenson have described the UC program as enabling “government-sponsored child trafficking,” with UCs placed with MS-13 gang members, traffickers, or exploitative sponsors using fake documents. Stevenson flagged the first TOC Watchlisted sponsor in 2021, and Rodas reported over 100 concerns ignored by HHS. Senate referrals (e.g., by Sen. Grassley) to FBI/DHS in 2024 cited HHS records of UCs sent to MS-13-linked households or trafficking rings, with over 50 UCs to one address. As of 2025, DHS’s Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) has launched welfare checks uncovering abuse/exploitation, with interagency probes into 65,605 backlogged reports from prior years.
ice.gov/news/releases/…
• OIG and Audit Findings: DHS OIG reports (e.g., OIG-24-46, August 2024; OIG-25-21, March 2025) confirm ICE’s inability to monitor UCs due to unissued NTAs and data mismatches, with HHS OIG noting incomplete vetting (e.g., 1/6 cases lacking safety checks) and ignored exploitation signs. HHS audits highlight failures to probe 7,300+ trafficking reports, with children in hazardous labor or abuse. These are framed as “widespread abuse” but not yet prosecuted as crimes.
• Ongoing Investigations and Actions: In 2025, HHS Secretary RFK Jr. launched a task force for 500 criminal investigations into ORR’s alleged trafficking facilitation, claiming 80 cases to court and interagency probes with DHS/ICE targeting sponsors. A Guatemalan man was indicted in April 2025 for smuggling a UC for trafficking. Grassley’s referrals to FBI/DHS (e.g., 2024-2025) cite potential crimes, with HSI identifying 100+ targets. Contractors like Cherokee Federal face scrutiny for non-compliance in probes.
ocpathink.org/post/independe…
grassley.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/…
justice.gov/opa/pr/guatema…
federalregister.gov/documents/2025…
• Congressional and Legal Scrutiny: Hearings (e.g., November 2024 House, 2023 Oversight) label it a “crisis” with “willful ignorance,” demanding accountability for lost UCs and exploitation. Lawsuits (e.g., March 2025 by legal groups) challenge HHS cuts to UC aid, citing trafficking risks.
Based on the extensive evidence we’ve discussed—from whistleblower testimonies (e.g., Tara Rodas and Aaron Stevenson), OIG audits, congressional hearings, and official referrals—there are clear indications of systemic negligence, policy failures, and potential exploitation in the handling of unaccompanied children (UCs) by agencies like HHS/ORR and DHS/ICE. These issues have led to risks like trafficking, abuse, and over 300,000 UCs becoming untraceable, as detailed in reports extrapolating from unissued NTAs (Notice To Appear), missed court dates, and failed follow-ups.
However, while these point to moral, operational, and possibly ethical crimes against vulnerable children, “proven criminality” in a legal sense requires formal charges, convictions, or court rulings—none of which have been widespread or conclusively established as of mid-2025. @AGPamBondi @POTUS @VP
Evidence Supporting Potential Criminality
• Allegations of Facilitated Trafficking: Whistleblowers like Rodas and Stevenson have described the UC program as enabling “government-sponsored child trafficking,” with UCs placed with MS-13 gang members, traffickers, or exploitative sponsors using fake documents. Stevenson flagged the first TOC Watchlisted sponsor in 2021, and Rodas reported over 100 concerns ignored by HHS. Senate referrals (e.g., by Sen. Grassley) to FBI/DHS in 2024 cited HHS records of UCs sent to MS-13-linked households or trafficking rings, with over 50 UCs to one address. As of 2025, DHS’s Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) has launched welfare checks uncovering abuse/exploitation, with interagency probes into 65,605 backlogged reports from prior years.
ice.gov/news/releases/…
• OIG and Audit Findings: DHS OIG reports (e.g., OIG-24-46, August 2024; OIG-25-21, March 2025) confirm ICE’s inability to monitor UCs due to unissued NTAs and data mismatches, with HHS OIG noting incomplete vetting (e.g., 1/6 cases lacking safety checks) and ignored exploitation signs. HHS audits highlight failures to probe 7,300+ trafficking reports, with children in hazardous labor or abuse. These are framed as “widespread abuse” but not yet prosecuted as crimes.
• Ongoing Investigations and Actions: In 2025, HHS Secretary RFK Jr. launched a task force for 500 criminal investigations into ORR’s alleged trafficking facilitation, claiming 80 cases to court and interagency probes with DHS/ICE targeting sponsors. A Guatemalan man was indicted in April 2025 for smuggling a UC for trafficking. Grassley’s referrals to FBI/DHS (e.g., 2024-2025) cite potential crimes, with HSI identifying 100+ targets. Contractors like Cherokee Federal face scrutiny for non-compliance in probes.
ocpathink.org/post/independe…
grassley.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/…
justice.gov/opa/pr/guatema…
federalregister.gov/documents/2025…
• Congressional and Legal Scrutiny: Hearings (e.g., November 2024 House, 2023 Oversight) label it a “crisis” with “willful ignorance,” demanding accountability for lost UCs and exploitation. Lawsuits (e.g., March 2025 by legal groups) challenge HHS cuts to UC aid, citing trafficking risks.
Why It’s Not Fully “Proven” Criminal Yet
Criminality requires proving intent (e.g., willful endangerment under 18 U.S.C. § 1591 for trafficking) or violations like fraud/negligence. Current evidence shows:
• Negligence vs. Intent: Audits cite “failures” (e.g., incomplete checks in 1/5 cases) but not deliberate crimes. Whistleblowers allege complicity, but no indictments of officials. oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
nypost.com/2025/05/29/us-…
nipnlg.org/sites/default/…
• Ongoing Probes: RFK Jr.’s task force and DHS initiatives are active, but results are preliminary (e.g., “handful” of cases uncovered). FBI/DHS referrals remain under review. notus.org/health-science…
federalregister.gov/documents/2025…
immpolicytracking.org/policies/repor…
justice.gov/opa/pr/guatema…
grassley.senate.gov/news/news-rele…
In summary, the failures are egregious and demand justice—potentially rising to criminal levels if intent or cover-ups are proven—but as of now, they’re mostly documented as administrative breakdowns with active probes. This warrants deeper congressional/FBI scrutiny to establish criminal accountability. @FBIDirectorKash @FBIDDBongino
• Rep. Mark Green (R-TN), Committee Chairman: @RepMarkGreen
• Rep. Michael McCaul (R-TX): @RepMcCaul
• Rep. Clay Higgins (R-LA): @RepClayHiggins
• Rep. Andrew Garbarino (R-NY): @RepGarbarino
• Rep. August Pfluger (R-TX): @RepPfluger
• Rep. Michael Guest (R-MS), who led the hearing: @RepMichaelGuest
• Rep. Josh Brecheen (R-OK): @RepBrecheen
• Rep. Morgan Luttrell (R-TX): @RepLuttrell
@HHSGov
@DHSgov
@OIGatHHS
@StateOIG
I am going to add my last Thread involving testimony from @ali_hopper @JarrodSadulski @GUARDATOfficial
@P_MilkCarton @SpartanX_Ray
We Demand Accountability!!!
Criminality requires proving intent (e.g., willful endangerment under 18 U.S.C. § 1591 for trafficking) or violations like fraud/negligence. Current evidence shows:
• Negligence vs. Intent: Audits cite “failures” (e.g., incomplete checks in 1/5 cases) but not deliberate crimes. Whistleblowers allege complicity, but no indictments of officials. oig.dhs.gov/sites/default/…
nypost.com/2025/05/29/us-…
nipnlg.org/sites/default/…
• Ongoing Probes: RFK Jr.’s task force and DHS initiatives are active, but results are preliminary (e.g., “handful” of cases uncovered). FBI/DHS referrals remain under review. notus.org/health-science…
federalregister.gov/documents/2025…
immpolicytracking.org/policies/repor…
justice.gov/opa/pr/guatema…
grassley.senate.gov/news/news-rele…
In summary, the failures are egregious and demand justice—potentially rising to criminal levels if intent or cover-ups are proven—but as of now, they’re mostly documented as administrative breakdowns with active probes. This warrants deeper congressional/FBI scrutiny to establish criminal accountability. @FBIDirectorKash @FBIDDBongino
• Rep. Mark Green (R-TN), Committee Chairman: @RepMarkGreen
• Rep. Michael McCaul (R-TX): @RepMcCaul
• Rep. Clay Higgins (R-LA): @RepClayHiggins
• Rep. Andrew Garbarino (R-NY): @RepGarbarino
• Rep. August Pfluger (R-TX): @RepPfluger
• Rep. Michael Guest (R-MS), who led the hearing: @RepMichaelGuest
• Rep. Josh Brecheen (R-OK): @RepBrecheen
• Rep. Morgan Luttrell (R-TX): @RepLuttrell
@HHSGov
@DHSgov
@OIGatHHS
@StateOIG
I am going to add my last Thread involving testimony from @ali_hopper @JarrodSadulski @GUARDATOfficial
@P_MilkCarton @SpartanX_Ray
We Demand Accountability!!!
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
