Dr. Fundji Benedict Profile picture
Aug 19 12 tweets 7 min read Read on X
🚨 EXPLOSIVE INVESTIGATION: THE MAHER #BITAR FILES 🚨
How did a documented anti-Israel campus radical ascend to America's most sensitive intelligence positions?

This comprehensive investigation reveals a systematic infiltration of anti-Israel activism into the highest levels of U.S. intelligence - a 20-year journey from organizing conferences calling for Israel's destruction to controlling America's most classified national security information. Today, @DNIGabbard finally took action.

What you're about to read is the most complete documentation of how ideological extremism penetrated the heart of American intelligence. From Georgetown University's Students for Justice in Palestine to the National Security Council's most sensitive roles - this is the story they don't want you to know.

A 🧵 based on extensive investigations by @canarymission, @NGOmonitor , Washington Free Beacon, Congressional Reports, and declassified intelligence documents:
@GeraldNGOM @AnneHerzberg14Image
1/30
🚨 BREAKING: Maher Bitar's security clearance REVOKED by @DNIGabbard. This comprehensive investigation reveals how a documented anti-Israel activist ascended to America's most sensitive intelligence positions. A thread based on multiple investigative sources: Image
EARLY RADICALIZATION (2003-2006)

2/30 🎓 CANARY MISSION PROFILE: "Bitar is a senior U.S. intelligence official who spread hatred of Israel and promoted a policy that would result in Israel's destruction." Georgetown University, School of Foreign Service (2003-2006).

3/30 📋 SJP EXECUTIVE LEADERSHIP: According to Washington Free Beacon and Canary Mission reports, Bitar served as executive board member of Georgetown's Students for Justice in Palestine chapter and was "one of the principal organizers" of the 2006 Palestine Solidarity Movement conference.

4/30 📸 DOCUMENTED BDS ACTIVISM: Multiple sources confirm a photograph showing Bitar "wearing a Palestinian keffiyeh and dancing in front of a banner that read: 'DIVEST FROM ISRAEL APARTHEID'" at the 2006 conference he helped organize at Georgetown.

5/30 🎯 CONFERENCE OBJECTIVES: Canary Mission documents that the 2006 PSM conference promoted sessions on "demonizing Israel" and advanced the complete elimination of the Jewish state through BDS tactics.
ACADEMIC EXTREMISM (2006-2012)

6/30 📝 MASTER'S THESIS ANALYSIS: Canary Mission obtained Bitar's 2008 thesis using the term "Nakba" (catastrophe) - "a term used to delegitimize the creation of the State of Israel by drawing a comparison to the Holocaust."

7/30 💭 THESIS ARGUMENTS: The thesis argued "Israel's existence as a state is the cause for Palestinian dispossession" and that "Israel's rejection of their right to return remains the main obstacle to finding a durable solution."

8/30 📰 PUBLISHED ACTIVISM: In 2007, Bitar published articles endorsing Palestinian Student Society missions calling for "participation in the greater Palestinian national movement for self-determination," per Canary Mission research.
EARLY PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATIONS

9/30 🏢 FOUNDATION FOR MIDDLE EAST PEACE: Canary Mission reports Bitar's 2005 internship with FMEP, which "has provided grants to multiple anti-Israel groups such as Jewish Voice for Peace and IfNotNow."

10/30 🌍 UNRWA TERROR CONNECTIONS: Multiple Congressional reports confirm Bitar's 2007 UNRWA internship. JINSA research shows over 70% of UNRWA Gaza staff have Hamas connections, with dozens participating in October 7, 2023 terror attacks.Image
Image
OBAMA ADMINISTRATION - ANTI-ISRAEL POLICIES

11/30 🏛️ NSC APPOINTMENT (2013): Despite documented anti-Israel record, Bitar appointed as Director for Israeli-Palestinian Affairs on Obama's NSC, giving him direct policy influence during a period of unprecedented U.S.-Israel tensions.

12/30 ⚠️ OBAMA'S HOSTILE POLICIES: During Bitar's NSC tenure, Obama administration pursued systematically anti-Israel policies including: settlement freeze demands, public confrontations with Netanyahu, and Iran nuclear deal negotiations without Israeli input.

13/30 📊 STRAINED RELATIONS: ABC News documented that "Obama-Netanyahu relationship has been strained from the get-go, fueled by their ideological differences." Obama's popularity in Israel plummeted during this period when Bitar held key Middle East policy roles.

14/30 🇺🇳 UN MISSION ROLE (2015-2017): As deputy to UN Ambassador Samantha Power, Bitar positioned to influence anti-Israel UN resolutions. The Atlantic reported "red-hot anger" at Netanyahu and threats to withdraw diplomatic cover at the UN.Image
Image
15/30 ⚖️ UN RESOLUTION 2334: The Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs documents how during Bitar's UN mission tenure, Obama administration broke decades of U.S. policy by abstaining on UNSC Resolution 2334, condemning Israeli settlements.

16/30 🔍 POLICY COORDINATION: Resolution 2334 passed only because Obama administration "initiated it, stood behind it, coordinated on the wording and demanded that it be passed," according to Israeli intelligence reports cited by Times of Israel.Image
Image
CONGRESSIONAL PERIOD (2017-2021)

17/30 ⚖️ HOUSE INTELLIGENCE COUNSEL: Served as General Counsel to House Intelligence Committee Democrats under Rep. Adam Schiff, coordinating legal strategy during Trump impeachment while maintaining anti-Israel positions.

18/30 📋 RUSSIA INVESTIGATION: According to newly declassified DNI documents released July 2025, Bitar's name appears in materials related to efforts to undermine Trump's 2016 election victory through intelligence politicization.

19/30 🔄 PATTERN OF MANIPULATION: Multiple sources document Bitar's consistent role in weaponizing intelligence and legal processes against administrations that supported stronger U.S.-Israel ties.Image
BIDEN ADMINISTRATION - PEAK INFLUENCE

20/30 🏛️ SENIOR INTELLIGENCE DIRECTOR: Biden appointed Bitar as Senior Director for Intelligence Programs at NSC - among the most sensitive positions in U.S. government, with access to classified intelligence on Israel's security and regional threats.

21/30 🔒 CLASSIFIED ACCESS: In this role, Bitar accessed top-secret intelligence on Israeli operations, Iranian nuclear program, Hamas and Hezbollah capabilities, creating unprecedented security concerns given his documented anti-Israel activism.

22/30 📈 EXPANDED AUTHORITY: By 2024, promoted to Deputy Assistant to the President and Coordinator for Intelligence and Defense Policy, further expanding influence over national security matters affecting Israel and Middle East allies.
CONGRESSIONAL INVESTIGATIONS

23/30 🔍 SJP TERROR FUNDING: ISGAP research shows SJP receives over $3 million annually from Hamas-connected groups. Congressional committees investigating foreign influence operations targeting U.S. campuses through organizations like SJP.

24/30 📋 NGO MONITOR FINDINGS: Documents SJP as "the campus organization most directly responsible for creating a hostile campus environment saturated with anti-Israel events, BDS initiatives" - the organization Bitar helped lead at Georgetown.

25/30 ⚠️ SECURITY IMPLICATIONS: The documented 20-year pattern from organizing conferences calling for Israel's destruction to holding America's most sensitive intelligence positions raised unprecedented national security concerns.
BROADER CONTEXT

26/30 🌐 OBAMA LEGACY ON ISRAEL: Brookings Institution analysis shows Obama administration "consistently worked to block attempts to challenge" anti-Israel positions, while being "the only U.S. administration in nearly half a century to consistently shield Israel from any type of censure" was false - they actively enabled it.

27/30 📊 AIPAC CONCERNS: Obama's memoirs confirm systematic efforts to circumvent pro-Israel influence, with officials risking being "tagged as 'anti-Israel'" for supporting traditional U.S.-Israel partnership, creating environment where anti-Israel officials like Bitar could advance.
TODAY'S ACCOUNTABILITY

28/30 🚫 CLEARANCE REVOKED: DNI Gabbard cited "politicization of intelligence" and officials who "put their own interests ahead of the American people" - precisely describing Bitar's documented pattern of advancing anti-Israel agenda through sensitive positions.

29/30 ⚖️ PRECEDENT SET: Today's action demonstrates that documented hostility toward key U.S. allies, combined with intelligence politicization, will no longer be tolerated in America's most sensitive national security positions.

30/30 🇺🇸🇮🇱 ACCOUNTABILITY RESTORED: The US administration's decisive action ensures America's intelligence apparatus serves U.S. national interests and those of our democratic allies, not the agenda of campus radicals turned intelligence officials.

SOURCES: Canary Mission, NGO Monitor, Washington Free Beacon, Congressional Reports, ISGAP, JINSA, Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, ABC News, The Atlantic, Times of Israel, Brookings Institution, DNI Declassified Documents

This comprehensive investigation reveals a systematic infiltration of anti-Israel activism into the highest levels of U.S. intelligence - now finally addressed.

This thread is non partisan. It is documented and shows that democracies can be threatened from the inside. This is a reminder that there are many wolves in sheep clothes waiting in the closet. Liberty, freedom and democracy do not resonate without standing up for Jews worldwide and for the State of Israel.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Dr. Fundji Benedict

Dr. Fundji Benedict Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Fundji3

Feb 8, 2024
#UNRWA| The #Hamas Den

🧶1/6. #defundUNRWA #dismantleUNRWA

Dear @secretary45 @antonioguterres @UNLazzarini ,

Q: What do Suhail Ahmed Hassan Al-Hindi, head of UNRWA #Gaza staff union & boys school, and Muhammad Daoud Ismail al-Jamassi, head UNRWA engineer, central Gaza have in common?

A: Well, in 2017 they were elected to the Hamas politburo which was chaired by the Butcher of Khan Yunis.

Let me detail their resume and refresh your memory!
2/6
📣Dr. Suhail Ahmed Hassan al-Hindi holds a PhD from Cairo University (his thesis dealt with improving the conditions of Palestinians teachers under the Israeli "occupation").

👉🏽Since 2012 he has been the chairman of the UNRWA staff union in the Gaza Strip, controlled by Hamas.

👉🏽In 2015 and 2016 he led demonstrations protesting UNRWA's intention to reduce its activities in Gaza because of budget cutbacks. The protests, which included sanctions and strikes in UNRWA institutions in the Strip, were widely covered by the media.

👉🏽In December 2016 the union reached a fundamental understanding  with UNRWA and ended its protests and sanctions (, December 20, 2016)

👉🏽In addition to his role as union chairman, he is also the principal of the %Palestine Boys' Elementary School, an UNRWA school for refugee children.

👉🏽On February 10, 2017, the school held a ceremony honoring students who excelled in their studies. The ceremony was attended by Bo Schack, director of UNRWA operations in the Gaza Strip, who sat on stage and was photographed with Dr. al-Hindi (Facebook page of Yasser Abu Zakariya, February 10, 2017).gazaonline.netImage
Image
3/6
📣 Dr. Suhail al-Hindi's name appeared on the list of the members of Hamas' newly-elected political bureau published in the Palestinian media.

👉🏽After his election had been publicly announced, Dr. al-Hindi issued a series of vigorous denials, claiming he had not been elected to the bureau. He even claimed he planned to sue those responsible for the reports. So far, Hamas has not formally related to the issue of his election.

📣 The election of Dr. Suhail al-Hindi to Hamas' political bureau in the Gaza Strip is another illustration of Hamas' deep penetration into the Gaza Strip's educational system and of the great power of its activists in UNRWA institutions in the Strip.

👉🏽That allows Hamas to systematically indoctrinate Gazan school children with its extremist Islamist ideology. In addition, Hamas' great influence on the educational system in the Gaza Strip enables it to hold paramilitary activities within schools, training young children to join Hamas and the ranks of its military wing.

📣Since Hamas is the power ruling the Gaza Strip, its ideological and military activities in the educational system are not curbed either by UNRWA(which operates many educational and social institutions in the Gaza Strip) or by the Palestinian Authority(which is formally responsible for the educational system in the Gaza Strip, but as in many other governmental areas, its actual influence is limited).Image
Read 6 tweets
Jan 8, 2024
BREAKING | #SouthAfrica -“Blood, Bodies and Bullets"
South Africa has brought genocide charges against Israel in the ICJ.

Julius #Malema and other political leaders have threatened to prosecute South Africans who serve in the IDF. They have also welcomed a Hamas leader for an official visit since #Hamas attacked #Israel on Oct. 7.🧶 7/7

🚨Have South African leaders lost their minds? Fix the country first!

1/7
South Africa has one of the highest murder rate of the planet: women account for just 14 % of murder victims, and children account for 5%. But it is men, 81%, who mostly lose their lives to killers. With millions unemployed, breaches of the law have become so common that assaults and even murders often fail to make the news.

South African Jews are leaving South Africa and it has nothing to do with South Africa ranking as the world’s country with the third-highest murder rate, behind only Jamaica and Honduras and six times the U.S. average, with no other African nation even close. Polls show public support for life imprisonment and even for the restoration of the death penalty — scrapped in 1995 — to try to curb the mayhem. Fewer than one in 10 of the more than 23,000 murders committed annually across the country result in an arrest and conviction.
In fact, South African Jews are leaving the country because of its stance toward Israel and also because of a lack of opportunities for their future and

Overwhelmingly, Jews have huge safety concerns about being Jews in South Africa.Image
2/7
Migrants attacked
In recent years there have been attacks on migrants from the rest of the continent, vast numbers of whom have entered illegally over South Africa’s 2,900-mile land border that stretches from the Atlantic to the Indian Ocean.Image
3/7
Enough is Enough!

White victims
Attacks on white-owned farms happen almost daily — more than 300 in 2022 with 50 farmers killed — and can be equally grisly. Rape is common and bodies are sometimes left dismembered.
In July, Pretoria-born Elon Musk went on this platform to post his concern about a “genocide of white people” in his home country.

Black victims
Despite the outcry, the murder crisis is even more acute for the country’s black majority, where homicides are more frequent but attract far less media coverage.

Research shows that white South Africans make up around 8% of the population and account for less than 2% of murder victims. Crimes are opportunistic, white farmers are often vulnerable, living on isolated properties far from neighbors or the police. Often the attackers are high on drugs and alcohol, almost always armed with guns, and won't hesitate to kill if they are challenged.Image
Read 7 tweets
Dec 26, 2023
BREAKING | Antisemitisme à l’ULB

📣Il était temps! Une carte blanche signée par 4 éminents professeurs de l’ULB dénonce l‘antisemitisme qui y règne et le dévoiement au libre examen.

🗣️Dans une précédente lettre par de 700 collaborateurs et étudiants de 5 universités flamandes (dont 67 professeurs) ont appelé au boycott d’Israel, demandant aux recteurs une prise de position claire, l’annulation de la collaboration avec les universités israéliennes ainsi que les entreprises et autorités . Cependant le recteur de l’université d’Anvers, Herman Van Goethem, a clairement déclaré qu’une université ne pouvait pas se comporter comme un parti politique ou un groupe de pression. Luc Sels, le recteur de la KULeuven, a également indiqué qu’une université n’est pas une institution politisée. (Source: Hypatia)
🧶

📣J’en avais fait l’écho sur cette plateforme et certains ont tenté de me faire taire en me discréditant ou en me menaçant. Je remercie d’ailleurs @joelrubinfeld d’avoir complété ce que j’avais écrit ainsi que @Ed_Brainis @NoMoreSmoke1 et tous ceux qui ont effectivement déploré cette dérive.

🗣️En octobre, j’écrivais à la rectrice pour dénoncer l’anti sémitisme sur le campus de l’ULB et lui demandais un rdv pour exprimer l’inquiétude croissante des étudiants juifs. Il lui a fallu 14 jours pour

-ne pas me recevoir
- envoyer un courriel laconique soi-disant neutre et qui en réalité tentait de noyer le poisson

🗣️Pourtant, les manifestations pro-palestiniennes organisées par les étudiants @Ecolo @PS Comac se sont succédées sur le campus, toujours plus violentes dans les slogans et à l’égard des étudiants juifs, les traitant de terroristes.

🗣️Il faut attendre le 9 novembre 2023 pour que la rectrice envoie un e-mail à la communauté universitaire. Dans cet e-mail, elle
met en avant le libre examen mais précise aussi ce qui suit:
“(…) il nous est important de rassurer les uns et les autres sur l’engagement très ferme des autorités de l’Université à les soutenir. Chacun doit pouvoir vivre sa vie universitaire en toute sérénité et pouvoir exprimer ses opinions dans le respect des autres, sans subir une quelconque intimidation. Nous appelons fortement notre communauté universitaire à faire en sorte que nos campus, heureusement préservés jusqu’ici, demeurent à la fois des lieux de débat et de controverse, mais aussi des espaces à tout prix préservés de toute forme de haine ou d’intolérance.”

Pourtant

🗣️Des affiches d’otages ont été arrachées, le drapeau palestinien trône devant la porte d’accès à la cafétéria du Solbosch

🗣️Plus grave encore, l’Union des étudiants juifs de de l’ULB a dénoncé ce qui se passe sur le campus et dans les amphis lors d’une réunion avec les autorités académiques sans être écoutés. (Voir à ce titre le reportage de i24news réalisé sur le campus de l’ULB).

🗣️Que dire encore de la présence et de l’influence du Comité BDS ULB qui est très actif, et invite très souvent pour des conférences le Professeur Dubuisson, chantre du narratif pro-palestinien et de sa propagande, tristement célèbre pour avoir tordu le cou au DIU et à l’histoire sur le plateau de la @RTBF 👇🏽



📣L’ULB organise avec la Haute École Francisco Ferrer de Bruxelles (HEFF) un Certificat inter universitaire “Complexités, nuances et regards croisés : Israël-Palestine” avec entre autres comme intervenants
☑️Baudouin Loos,
☑️François Dubuisson,
☑️Sylvain Cypel,
☑️Younes El Montasser, Simone Susskind, Hassan Ahmaidouch de AIM

🗣️Cette formation a été annulée cette année en raison de l’actualité. Toutefois la composition de l’équipe encadrante pose question.

🗣️Il est par ailleurs étonnant de ne pas retrouver dans le corps enseignant le Professeur Joël Kotek.
Parti pris ?!
Joël Kotek en avait par ailleurs dressé le portrait ici:
“50 nuances de gris… antisioniste.
Sans contester la qualité de certains intervenants, on doit s’interroger sur l’étonnante asymétrie du programme.7sur7.be/belgique/franc…Image
Image
Mis à part Élie Barnavi (le meilleur d’entre nous !), on chercherait en vain un autre intervenant à même d’éclairer objectivement les participants sur les positions israéliennes.

On ne pourra guère compter sur Sylvain Cypel, pressenti pour coprésenter « le récit national juif ». Ses articles comme ses ouvrages (L’État d’Israël contre les Juifs, Éditions La Découverte, 2020) témoignent d’un évident parti-pris antisioniste.
De même, comment ne pas s’interroger sur le fait de confier à Baudouin Loos (Le Soir) les trois heures de cours consacrées à « la situation politique actuelle » et à Dubuisson, deux cours de trois heures, le premier sur « le droit international et la question israélo-palestinienne » et le second sur « la représentation du conflit ». On rappellera que ce militant/enseignant qui prône activement le boycott d’Israël qualifie le seul État démocratique de la région, d’État d’apartheid. François Dubuisson n’aime guère Israël (et c’est son droit) comme en témoigna sa maladroite, mais révélatrice « contextualisation » de l’attaque « des combattants du Hamas » au JT de la RTBF, le soir même des événements.
Évidemment, je n’ai pas été sollicité pour participer à la formation ; une précédente intervention ayant été jugée trop partisane, trop sioniste !”

cclj.be/plaire-a-tout-…
Read 16 tweets
Nov 24, 2023
🚨Illégal- les communes n’ont pas de compétence en matière de relations internationales .

Molenbeek vient de jouer sa partition de “mini-ONU” sur la question de la guerre contre les groupes terroristes palestiniens.

J’oubliais que le député @ikazban est un grand soutien de Gaza et des palestiniens (voir mes précédentes publications); il fait la promotion de ses participations aux manifestations organisées par Samidoun, réseau de soutien du FPLP, aime faire le geste de ralliement aux FM, etc etc

#antisemitisme
#idiotutile
#gauchepogrom
#HamasisISIS
Une commune ne possède aucune compétence même accessoire pour ce type de sujet.. Il s’agit d’une posture et propagande politiques; le @PSofficiel utilise donc cette guerre pour se positionner politiquement face au @MR_officiel qui a le portefeuille des Affaires Étrangères. Image
Je rappelle qu’un député belge se doit de travailler sur les sujets qui impactent la vie des Belges en Belgique comme la mobilité, le logement, l’emploi, la sécurité, l’accès aux soins de santé etc. Je ne vois pas cela dans les communications du député Ikazban . Image
Read 11 tweets
Nov 22, 2023
@djemilaben place sur le meme plan les fondamentalistes du Hamas et les partis religieux d’extrême-droite israéliens qui sont au pouvoir avec la droite israélienne classique.

Je m’inscris en faux avec cette analyse .

Je rappelle que 62% des Israéliens votent à droite.
Cette guerre contre les groupes terroristes palestiniens et le Hezbollah bénéficie d’une analyse importante sur le plan de la politique extérieure (et les analyses sont pertinentes lorsqu’elles sont explicitées par des experts tels que George Bensoussan, Gilles Kepel, Frédéric Encel). Il n’en reste pas moins que la coalition au pouvoir, imaginée par Netanyahu pour rester premier ministre, doit s’examiner également au regard de la politique intérieure sur le temps long.
La surenchère de Amichai Eliyahu, Itamar Ben-Gvir masque le recul de l’influence des partis religieux extrémistes au sein du gouvernement de Netanyahu. En effet, Benny Gantz est monté au gouvernement de crise . Et on sait que Gantz est depuis toujours un farouche opposant des partis d’extrême-droite, notamment religieux.
Read 15 tweets
Nov 20, 2023
🚨Le terrorisme palestinien est un business lucratif 🚨

🧵Les civils palestiniens ne sont pas que des victimes innocentes. Le terrorisme paie bien, mieux qu’un cadre moyen de l’AP

Explications 11/11
1/11
En 2017, l’Autorite palestinienne a versé la somme totale de 199 millions au fond des familles de martyrs et 160 millions de dollars au Collectif des prisonniers palestiniens -cela représentait 7% du budget global de l’autorité palestinienne.
2/11
🎯Les prisonniers palestiniens condamnés à des peines de 20-30 ans pour avoir perpétré des attaques terroristes reçoivent donc une rente mensuelle à vie de 3500 dollars.
🎯Les prisonniers palestiniens condamnés à 2-3 ans reçoivent une rente mensuelle de 1200 dollars.
Read 13 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(