François Valentin Profile picture
Sep 22 • 27 tweets • 9 min read • Read on X
Is Catholicism making a revival in France?

Latin masses, baptisms, pilgrimages, Catholicism seems hip again!

But behind the vibes, what do the stats and maps show?

A đź§µ on the decline and transformation of Catholicism in post-Catholic France Image
France is historically one of the most important Catholic countries in Europe

To this day the trace of Catholicism can be found everywhere in France

Here's a map of France with all the towns with "Catholic" names (with Saint or trinity in it for example) Image
But since around the mid 18th century, Catholicism stops being a mass phenomenon and is instead much more geographically polarised

Here's the map of practicing Catholics in 1965. Big contrasts. Alsace, Brittany, the SW and the south-center are very pious Image
This map is remarkably similar to the number of priests who refused to swear allegiance to the Republican constitution in 1791 showing long established divides Image
In fact the left-right divide in France from the French revolution until quite recently was a pretty good proxy for Catholicism

Look at the 1974 presidential electoral map for the center-right candidate Valéry Giscard, rings a bell? Image
But today France is no longer polarised among Catholics vs non-Catholic lines.

France has been a for a little while now a post-Catholic country

Here's the map of practicing Catholics in 2012, looks very similar to the previous ones

But now look at the percentages on the left...Image
Catholicism was also the social matrix, even for those who weren't big pillars of the church:

From the cradle to the grave, Catholicism would likely be part of your life from start to finish
Cradle? Fewer kids than ever are getting baptised in France. It used to be 76% in the 70s, we now around a quarter Image
What about the number of Catholic weddings?

Massively collapsed in the last 2 decades Image
Divorces have stalled in France... but that's largely because fewer people are getting married Image
Grave?

Increasingly people in France prefer to get cremated instead Image
The number of priests in France also dropped massively in the early 2000S and very few were ordained to make up for it Image
You still see moments of Zombie Catholicism that pop up in French politics, a reminder of old divides

Take the 2005 referendum on the EU constitution, the old Catholic bastions overwhelmingly backed the EU sideImage
But France is now decisively a post-Catholic country.

To be sure those trends are happening in many other European countries, but this statement is more true than in most EU countries Image
So has French Catholicism hit rock bottom?

There are some early signs of a transformation.

For years Catholicism survived thanks to its elders who were born in a Catholic world

Now it is transforming under pressure from the generation born in a post-catholic world Image
The number of baptisms of young children has continued to decline, but in large part because France's birth rate has collapsed.

Meanwhile the number of adults and adolescents getting baptised has surged 3 to 4X in 12 years Image
After decades of sex scandals, the Church's image was very damaged.

But young people in France overwhelmingly have a positive image of Catholicism Image
Signs of this youthful revival can be seen in pilgrimages such as the one in Chartres that attracted 19,000 pilgrims this year, an all-time record after having beaten the previous record from... 2024 Image
Talk to priests across France and they are clearly starting to see something different.

In a post-Catholic world, many young Catholics have a sense of rebecoming missionaries once again
And among young people "traditional" forms of Catholicism, have been especially popular

But also with the influence of evangelical movements, many young Catholics simultaneously tend to adopt more spiritual forms of Catholicism Image
Does this make this burgeoning revival a reactionary movement?

For many the starting point of this turn traces back to 2013 and the mass demonstrations against the legalisation of gay marriage. Up to 1.4 million people demonstrated. Image
What do the polls say? It's mixed.

Practicing Catholic tend to be more right-wing than the French average

But the more practicing you are the less right-wing you are Image
Within French Catholic intellectual circles you do get a dynamic staunchly conservative ecosystem, but also interesting Catholic-environmental movements bolstered by pope Francis and his Laudato Si encyclical Image
On social media, since Covid there's been the emergence remarkably dymanic Cathosphere.

Soeur Albertine has 336K follower on IG, 200K on tiktok

Abbé Raffray has 168K on IG with a mix of theological and (conservative) political takesImage
For further reading on these topics I have to recommend the brilliant books from J. Fourquet who has created many of historic maps I used in this thread

I also used some charts from this article lepoint.fr/societe/les-ra…Image
If you liked this thread, I'd greatly appreciate if you could retweet the first post so others can read it.

Thanks for taking the time to read this thread!

Errare humanum est: a fantastic resource I forgot to link

jean-jaures.org/wp-content/upl…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with François Valentin

François Valentin Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Valen10Francois

Sep 8
French PM François Bayrou has been ousted by parliament. Macron's 3rd PM to lose his job in 18 months

The stakes are huge:

Will Macron dissolve parliament? Will the left take over? What about the IMF?

A đź§µon what happened and what happens next Image
What happened?

Ever since Macron's snap election last july, his coalition has shrunk into a small minority government

Last December his previous PM Michel Barnier was deposed by parliament after 3 months.

Bayrou took over facing similarly impossible parliamentary arithmetics Image
On top of that his government had to deal with possibly the most toxic fiscal situation in a decade

France's deficit is well above the 3% EU target

Bayrou was aiming for 43 bn in savings!

A recipe for disaster with roughly 3 equal parliamentary blocks unwilling to compromise Image
Read 24 tweets
Sep 7
Portugal being the first modern European colonial empire despite having a population of 1 million is seriously impressive. Image
And then at a similarly impressive pace becoming a secondary political player for the five centuries that followed.
Fun fact on the Portuguese empire: after decades of negotiations to try to get Goa peacefully, India just sent in the army in 1961

Portuguese dictator Salazar ordered for the completely outgunned defenders to fight to the last man

The prudent governor surrendered 36 hours after Image
Read 5 tweets
Aug 6
In 1582 Jesuit missionaries entered China

They could have been killed!

And yet in a few years they became the Emperor’s top advisors, brokering diplomatic deals and moving their pawns

This is a đź§µon how the Jesuits infiltrated China...

And how it all came crashing down! Image
The Society of Jesus was founded in Paris in 1534 by students.

It rapidly grew and recognised by the Pope in 1540

They were big on missionary work and wanted to convert the world before the protestants

Here's a map of their colleges founded in the 220 years that followed Image
In that global vision China was key. Since Marco Polo it was the land of fantasies.

One of the order's cofounder Francis Xavier died on the shores of China without being able to enter. Image
Read 26 tweets
Jul 4
China's biggest threat isn't Trump... but its explosive local debt

After decades of relying on land sales and the real estate market the music has stopped with huge consequences.

A đź§µ on China's biggest and underreported economic challenge Image
It might come as a surprise but China is in some ways very decentralised!

85-90% of all public spending is done at subnational level.

Even the US with its Federal model is at 50% Image
The debate about centralisation in communist regimes is an old one.

Leninists wanted a strong centralised state to push industrialisation, but there's a long anti-bureaucratic tradition in Marxism

Mao made fun of the USSR's bureaucracy but himself oscillated on centralisation Image
Read 14 tweets
Apr 20
Americans have a unique superpower:

They naturally know how to dig entrenched political cleavages overnight to stick to their political tribe.

Even on issues where they previously didn't disagree much!

Some samples of America's hyper-tribalism Image
This might come as a surprise but free trade has been unpopular on both parties for a while.

Until Trump's tariffs and now all of the sudden the Left are rediscovering the virtues of free trade

Basically overnight Image
I gave the example of Canada. All of the sudden many conservative have decided that Canada was an enemy.

But it's also true of Ukraine.

All of the sudden Republicans have decided that Ukraine was an unfriendly nation because Putin said so/Biden was helping Ukraine Image
Read 7 tweets
Apr 5
Who are China's political elites?

What is the equivalent of their Ivy Leagues or the Oxbridge?

A thread on the (mostly) old men who run the People's Republic of China Image
Here's how I define the Chinese political elites:

It's the 812 people who serve in China's top political bodies from Xi Jinping at the top all the way to provincial standing committee.

Most of them are provincial officials (61%) Image
Image
They are overwhelmingly male.

The higher you go, the fewer women you get:

There is 1/25 in the Politburo, 0/7 in the Politburo's Standing Committee Image
Read 10 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(