1. I provide country reports for the courts

After a 4 to 6 year wait, approx 75% of people seeking asylum will be given temporary leave to remain as they are found to be genuinely at risk of persecution in their home country

This might be because they are from a war zone, or…
2. … because they have certain political or religious beliefs, or they are disabled, LGBT*, or have a mental health condition.

When writing a country report I read the statements the asylum seeker has provided to the home office.
I then read …
3. …. The HO assessment, then newspapers local to the country, national & local government documents, get reports from lawyers on the ground & anything else I can get my hands on.

I set out to show objectively what would happen to the particular person if returned. I ask…
4. … could they go to another part of that country & be safe, & whether or not they will be allowed to work.

Sometimes I write
“This person (TP) is unlikely to leave the airport & their body may never be found”, or I say
“TP has an illness that will lead to them being…
5. … “targeted & killed by members of their community, even their family” or
“TP will not be allowed to be economically active, & within a few weeks will be destitute, & in 6 months probably be dead from malnutrition, physical or sexual abuse, and/or torture by the state” …
6. … In 23 years, after reading the Home office documents I have only once said “No, I can see no basis for a claim”
After doing the research I have only once said
“whilst life will be difficult if TP is returned, I believe those difficulties will be nothing more …
7. … “than the ordinary travails of life, in what are the usual (though very difficult) circumstances in which many people find themselves in that country”

No one makes the journeys people seeking asylum take without very good reason.

The rhetoric distorts.

There is a …
8. … solution.

After 6 to 12 months in a hostel, & an initial evaluation, provide basic accommodation for a further 6 to 12 months & Let them work, pay their own way, pay taxation, etc.

That way if they are found not to have a valid claim we will have their details, find …
9. … them & return them

We could offer a voluntary repatriation scheme, incl. free flight & a small sum of money

Many of the 25% failed asylum seekers would take that rather than face a yr in s detention centre.

Just an idea for a solutions but remember 9/10 people…
10. … who immigrate into the UK come as invited workers (without whom care homes. & the NHS would collapse), family dependants (kids or the elderly), & students (without whom our Uni system would collapse).

They are required to be completely financially independent. …
11. People seeking asylum must have no money £0 before they receive £49.18 voucher weekly to pay for food, toiletries etc. Shopd cannot give change as cash if the voucher is not completely spent.

If they are in hostel/hotel & receive breakfast £3/day is taken to pay for …
13. … 1/2pt milk, a mini box of cereal & a tea bag.

Economic migration is 99% right wing rhetoric, & has no bearing on the reality for most people seeking asylum

@threadreaderapp unroll

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Prof. Stephen Whittle OBE, PhD, DLaws, FAcSS,

Prof. Stephen Whittle OBE, PhD, DLaws, FAcSS, Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @stephenwhittle

Sep 7
1. Oh dear - Pure 1980s homophobia as well as being transphobia now

That is an awful lot of teaching staff, scout leaders, football club volunteers, ministers, choir masters, and Dads etc who will
“need to be able to explain the nature of their relationship”.,,
2. … And once explained just tell me how that will prevent any abuse of any child

Total bonkers overreach assuming all men are predatory … but wait, something like 10% of c-is heterosexual men will admit to having not properly gained a woman or girl’s consent at some time ..,
3. So l tell me instead what you are suggesting to protect the 98% of people who report SA/Rape each year

Let’s make boyfriends, husbands, guys out in the make, or in a nightclub, or teen boys at school, explain & justify the nature of their relationships with girls & women .,,
Read 4 tweets
Sep 7
1. Neither gender nor sex trumps the other, each case stands on its own merit

The law is an empathic instrument & is designed to re-balance the scales, not to create unwarranted burdens

When revisited it will become clear that they manner in which the SCt judgment was …
2. … presented, not its central decision, has allowed a level of
- unwarranted triumphalism,
- gross over-misinterpretation &
- the spreading of a great deal of misinformation.

It will be revisited as soon as with a Gender recognition certificate challenges ..
3. … an instance of unwarranted & unreasonable segregation (as suggested by the EHRC)

At that point l, by distinguishing the facts eg. s11 of the EqAct & statutory interpretation will be found to be irrelevant to where a tennis player changes, or whether a Sunday morning …
Read 5 tweets
Sep 5
1. Might be worth considering what Helena Kennedy said of the FWS decision in debate in the House of Lords on Thursday 1 May 2025
You can search in in Hansard under
NHS: Single-sex Spaces for Staff, Vol 845 … Quote: Dame Helena Kennedy KC in the House of Lords; “The judgment makes it clear that the decision was limited to the question of statutory interpretation and that it was not involved in making policy—so the difficult business of policy follows. But the judgment also made it clear, and it was emphasised - although unfortunately this has been lost in some of the utterances by people who should have known better-that its conclusion "does not remove or diminish the important protections" that there have to be for trans people and which are available to them under our own legislative...
2. Look at the next para in the decision in P v S & CCC [1996] ECJ

“22 To tolerate such discrimination would be tantamount, as regards such a person, to a failure to respect the dignity and freedom to which he or she is entitled, and which the Court has a duty to safeguard.” …
3. It smacks of sheer desperation or pure ignorance to revert to the very first decision EVER to acknowledge TP had any rights at all

& then to not bother reading the entire decision

As if nothing hasn’t happened between 1996 & now - 30 yrs later …
Read 5 tweets
Aug 28
1. Indeed, in 1990 I sat down & read 201 ‘trans’ related papers by a lawyer/legal academic, or another discipline when they purported to discuss TP & law

Every paper stated TP wanted to change their birth registration & ‘disappear’ into the anonymity of successful passing.
2. Notably, not 1 of the lawyers/legal academics/ philosophers or sociologists had spoken to a TP when doing their ‘research’. Few in medical disciplines had

These academic papers were not based on research but would be better described as ‘sexy’ one offs, reviewing …
3. … legal concepts & how they ‘might’ impact on the lives of TP

In 1990 Trans people were still referred to as transsexuals, or in the popular media as sex swaps, sex changers, and in the Red Tops, especially the Sunday people, & Murdoch’s News of the world, as perverts. …
Read 12 tweets
Aug 27
1. Andrew @AusPsychReview I have no desire to get into long but pointless conversations

I believe your starting point - your fundamental assumption - is incorrect

The question then becomes should I waste my time trying to explain why to someone who is not open to listening. …
2. But I will give you some benefit, not of doubt, but of hope.

Can we agree that Mental ill health refers to a range of conditions that affect a person's thinking, feeling, or behavior, causing distress & impairing their ability to function in daily life? …
3. Nb: ‘causing distress & impairing their ability to function in daily life’

I was extremely distressed throughout childhood & teen yrs because people expected me to be a girl.

I am not talking expectations of behaviour, or clothing. I am talking about being invisible. …’
Read 20 tweets
Aug 25
1. All law is a response of those in governance to a social concern

In any society those who live within it, agree to abide by the rules created by those we have voted for - that’s democracy

In contemporary society it is usual to consult society’s members. …
2. Legal gender recognition came about as a result numerous court cases, & several consultative processes, which ultimately led to the GRAct 2004.

Theresa May’s proposed reform of the GRA had so many - a national consultation found 70% of 140k people favoured the reforms. …
3. In Scotland the Gender Recognition Reform Bill had a total of 6 consultations, and was reviewed by 2 Scottish Parliament Cttees

The Cttee on Human Rights, despite numerous assertions by GC Activists that the reform into a self-declaratory process would …
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(