Neil Thomas 牛犇 Profile picture
Nov 5 10 tweets 4 min read Read on X
Mao said China would eclipse the US by 2030

In 1955: "Our goal is to catch up with and surpass the US ... it will take at least 50 years, perhaps 75, which is 15 five-year plans"

Xi just outlined China's 15th five-year plan. Can he prove Mao right?

Latest for @AsiaPolicy

1/ Image
Probably not by the numbers—China's nominal GDP was only 64% of the US last year

But perhaps yes in substance—industrial might, tech self-reliance, and export controls helped Xi stare down US pressure this year

Chinese scholars are praising Mao's "strategic foresight"...

2/ Image
But Xi still sees Trump as an agent of chaos and is preparing for a more turbulent world

April 2: 34% tariff on China
April 8: 84%
April 9: 125%

April 10: Beijing holds a "special meeting" to adjust its five-year planning in light of "changes in the external situation"...

3/ Image
Beijing sees a connect between its recent Fourth Plenum on the five-year plan and Trump-Xi

"Major-power relations shape the international situation ... which profoundly influences domestic development"

The summit was a bid to secure strategic breathing room for Xi's agenda

4/ Image
Xi's top goals for the five-year plan for 2026-2030 are "building a modernized industrial system" and "self-strengthening in science and tech"

He wants to ensure China can never again be coerced or contained by the US

With "extraordinary measures" on key core tech below!

5/ Image
China will remain a high-capacity economy that puts producers over consumers

Tensions with other industrial economies—especially in Europe and North America—will intensify

China wants to dominate supply chains for future tech like it does now for EVs, batteries & solar

6/ Image
Xi himself is concerned about overproduction causing ruinous price wars

But the plenum offered few convincing answers (yet) for curbing such "involution"

For Xi, the US is a cautionary tale of deindustrialization, so China's economy "must not shift from real to virtual"

7/ Image
Key to Xi’s domestic agenda and US dealmaking is his political power

The plenum reaffirmed his control despite record purges and further centralization

E.g., share of cadre comments on plenum drafts then incorporated into final docs fell from 35.5% in 2010 to 21.4% in 2025

8/ Image
So what kind of deal does Xi want with Trump?

Shortly after their summit, I went to a conference in NYC where half the room thought there'd be a "comprehensive" US-China trade deal by 2028

I was shocked

Xi wants a truce to buy time and build leverage, not a grand bargain

9/ Image
Much more on the Fourth Plenum and US-China relations in my latest piece for the @AsiaPolicy Center for China Analysis, co-authored with Lobsang Tsering



10/10asiasociety.org/policy-institu…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Neil Thomas 牛犇

Neil Thomas 牛犇 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @neilthomas123

Oct 28
Everyone talks about Cai Qi. Don't forget Wang Huning.

Xi Jinping just made extra space for Wang on the drafting team for his five-year plan proposals

Wang is China's most powerful United Front boss since Deng Xiaoping left the role in 1983

Could stay past retirement age? 1/ Image
This table shows the evolution of drafting teams for plenums about five-year plans

Wang Huning is the first CPPCC Chairman (United Front boss) on such a team

He was also the first CCP Secretariat Head involved when he held that role in 2020

Becoming a constant presence.. 2/ Image
Similar thing happened at the Third Plenum last July, which decided structural reforms for 2029

Per past practice, Xi led the drafting team, with the CCP Secretariat Head (Cai Qi) and Executive Vice Premier (Ding Xuexiang) as deputies

But he added a deputy: Wang Huning.. 3/
Read 6 tweets
Oct 23
China's Fourth Plenum ends:

1. Super-low attendance suggests record purge of Central Committee

2. Near-record discipline of 10 members & 4 alternates

3. Xi affirms PLA purges by promoting discipline boss Zhang Shengmin to replace He Weidong as CMC Vice-Chair

Thoughts..

1/ Image
Communique suggests huge purge of Central Committee members beyond current rumors

Attendance was only 168/205 members and 147/171 alternates for a total of 315/376 (84%)

I believe that's a record low in the post-Mao era

"Empty chairs at empty tables" (h/t @shuizaiping2)

2/ Image
The Central Committee confirmed the expulsion of 10 members and 4 alternates

These were mostly pre-announced by the Politburo or disciplinary organs—e.g., He Weidong, Miao Hua

Almost as many disciplinary actions as the 2017 Seventh Plenum, but a new record for expulsions

3/ Image
Read 8 tweets
Oct 17
Big update! China just confirmed it has fired number-two general He Weidong

9 generals, inc 8 Central Committee members, expelled from the CCP

1 Politburo vacancy, 3 Central Military Commission vacancies, 11 CC vacancies

Will Xi fill them at the Fourth Plenum next week?

1/ Image
Xi may leave the Politburo and CMC depleted

No one replaced Sun Zhengcai when he was purged from the Politburo in 2017

And Xi has repeatedly declined to promote Li Shangfu's successor Dong Jun to the CMC

Absences make it easier for him to dominate and help punish the PLA

2/ Image
Still, He Weidong was the first uniformed CMC vice chair purged since the 1960s

Xi may be fine with ally Zhang Youxia as sole vice chair. Or he may want balance🤷‍♂️

But Miao Hua handled PLA loyalty, a Xi priority. @jonczin suggests some possible replacements for him:

3/ Image
Read 5 tweets
Oct 15
Who has Xi purged from the CCP Central Committee?

Attendance at next week's Fourth Plenum will reveal the extent of his recent "purge surge"

If all rumors are true, only 168/205 members (82%) and 159/171 alternates (93%) will be there

And only 17/44 of PLA members (39%)!

1/ Image
Would be the sparsest plenum in recent memory

Main cause is spate of disappearances and disciplinary campaigns in the People's Liberation Army

Closest comparison I can find is the 2017 Seventh Plenum at the end of Xi's first-term crackdown (191 members and 145 alternates)

2/ Image
This year could be big drop from the 199/205 members and 165/171 alternates at the Third Plenum last July

Illness and travel explain some absences; but political trouble explains more

Some "missing" cadres may resurface, but maximum attendance will be 193/205 and 165/171

3/ Image
Read 10 tweets
Sep 25
"As Xi [Jinping] steps back, Li [Qiang] could emerge as an important interlocutor for governments and companies that want to engage with China, said Neil Thomas, a Chinese politics fellow at @AsiaPolicy."

Great @AP report by @kmorit

1/ Image
"Li has held talks at the U.N. this week with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney and Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker."

2/
"Thomas described Li as 'an incredibly important person' to engage with during the U.N. meeting. 'He’s acting on Xi’s behalf,' he said, 'and will be able to relay messages between Xi and the world.'"

3/
Read 8 tweets
Sep 2
Told @nytimes the Beijing military parade "underscores China’s pull with autocrats as the world’s leading authoritarian power" and illustrated how "China is already a regional superpower."

But we shouldn't get too carried away about a new China-led world order...

1/ Image
As I told @business "this week is a diplomatic triumph for Beijing but China is still years or decades away from neutralizing US power in global finance, security and technology."

2/ Image
China is offering trade, investment, and stability—and that’s a very attractive package right now.

But it’s not yet offering the type of hard security guarantees and open economic architectures provided by the US, even with Trump’s America First policies.

3/
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(