Thread by @HackingButLegal

THREAD: The Trump admin is systematically defying federal court orders at an unprecedented rate. Of 165 cases where judges ruled against Trump, approximately 57 cases (35%) involved the administration defying, ignoring, or circumventing judicial orders.

1/🧵 Unroll at the end👇

VENEZUELAN DEPORTATIONS: Judge Boasberg found probable cause of criminal contempt in April when Trump deported alleged Tren de Aragua gang members w/o due process despite a restraining order. The admin hastily sent them to CECOT prison before they could contest removals in court.

ICE DETENTION: Trump repeatedly violated court orders requiring due process hearings for detained immigrants. Judge William H. Orrick issued directives that the admin circumvented thru procedural delays and maneuvers-denying detained people their constitutional right to hearings.

FEDERAL WORKER REINSTATEMENT: When Judge John McConnell Jr. ordered the admin to reinstate wrongfully terminated federal workers and unfreeze grant programs in February, Trump refused. The White House repeatedly sought SCOTUS emergency stays to override the lower court's orders.

SNAP FOOD BENEFITS: Just this week, a federal judge explicitly ordered Trump to fully fund SNAP benefits for 42 million low-income Americans. Trump responded by posting on Truth Social that SNAP would not be fully restored, directly mocking and defying the court order.

FEDERAL RESERVE REMOVAL: Trump attempted the unprecedented removal of Fed Governor Lisa Cook despite her legal protections. Judge Jia Cobb issued an injunction stopping the removal. Trump's DOJ sought emergency Supreme Court intervention to override the trial judge's order.

FTC COMMISSIONER REMOVAL: On September 22, Trump forcibly removed FTC Commissioner Rebecca Kelly Slaughter despite Judge Rodney Gilstrap's protective order. The admin violated the injunction outright, and SCOTUS later permitted this on its emergency docket.

CONSUMER PROTECTION AGENCY: Trump dismissed three Democratic commissioners from the Consumer Product Safety Commission despite judicial orders protecting their positions. He simply removed them anyway while appealing to higher courts.

LAW FIRM RETALIATION: Starting in March, Trump issued executive orders targeting Perkins Coie, WilmerHale, and Susman Godfrey (firms he believed worked against him). The orders suspended security clearances, terminated contracts, and barred employees from federal buildings.

LAW FIRM ORDERS STRUCK DOWN: Four separate federal judges ruled these executive orders unconstitutional violations of 1A protections for freedom of speech and association. The admin continued implementing them anyway despite the rulings, undeterred by judicial orders.

VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN ACT TERMINATION: The DOJ terminated all American Bar Association grants for the Office on Violence Against Women citing "agency priorities" The ABA sued for retaliation and viewpoint discrimination. The admin ignored court protections against 1A violations.

TRANSGENDER PASSPORT MARKERS: The administration is intentionally non-complying with court orders allowing transgender people to update gender markers on passports. Government sources have confirmed this noncompliance is deliberate stalling while using appeals as cover.

FOREIGN AID WITHHOLDING: The Supreme Court's emergency docket allowed Trump to withhold $4bn in congressionally authorized foreign aid without going through normal judicial review. Lower court injunctions were simply overridden by the conservative majority on the shadow docket.

NIH RESEARCH CUTS: The administration implemented cuts to NIH grants for racial minority and LGBTQ health research despite court orders attempting to block the cuts. The admin disregarded judicial directives to preserve federally mandated programs.

THE ENFORCEMENT CRISIS: The fundamental problem is that courts have no direct enforcement power. They rely on the executive branch, specifically the DOJ and US Marshals Service reporting to Trump, to enforce judicial orders. Trump controls his own enforcement.

CONTEMPT CONSEQUENCES MISSING: While judges technically found probable cause of criminal contempt, none have imposed meaningful penalties. Fines against executive officials are considered ineffective. Criminal charges would require DOJ cooperation, but the DOJ works for Trump.

SCOTUS COMPLICITY: The conservative-majority Supreme Court has repeatedly granted emergency stays on its "shadow docket," overriding trial court injunctions without full briefing. This emboldened the admin to ignore lower court orders because they knew SCOTUS relief would come.

CONGRESSIONAL ABDICATION: House Speaker Mike Johnson suggested judges ruling against Trump could be punished: "We can eliminate an entire district court." Repubs control Congress and have largely enabled Trump's defiance rather than using impeachment or accountability measures.

THE BREAKDOWN: This isn't normal litigation friction! It's systematic, deliberate defiance. The admin delays compliance, uses procedural maneuvers, appeals to higher courts to get stays, ignores rulings outright, and publicly mocks court orders... all while leadership enables it.

CONSTITUTIONAL CRISIS DEFINED: Constitutional scholars term this a "constitutional crisis" because it fundamentally undermines the separation of powers and rule of law. When a POTUS can ignore courts with impunity, the Constitution's checks and balances essentially collapse.

NO PRECEDENT: Presidential defiance of court orders at this scale and frequency is historically unprecedented. Even Nixon ultimately complied with the SCOTUS order to release Watergate tapes. Trump's admin is testing whether judicial authority has any meaning or heft.

THE STAKES: As courts fail to enforce their orders against executive defiance, the entire judicial system becomes ceremonial. Rights become meaningless. Congress needs to act, but it's controlled by Trump's party.

This is the constitutional stress test that could break the entire system. The upcoming 2026 midterm elections provide America another "make or break" moment.

@threadreaderapp Unroll